EditorsAbout the SiteComes vs. MicrosoftUsing This Web SiteSite ArchivesCredibility IndexOOXMLOpenDocumentPatentsNovellNews DigestSite NewsRSS

10.29.17

Large US Companies Continue to Stockpile Patents, But US Courts Have Learned to Repel Patent Maximalism

Posted in America, Apple, IBM, Patents at 7:49 pm by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

Patents on software are just about as inane and worthless as patents on musical notes

Papers with musical notes

Summary: In spite of misguided campaigns to accumulate/hoard tens of thousands of patents and then cross-license these, courts do not see the legitimacy of most of these patents

SEVERAL days ago someone pointed out this case of a lawyer who had been fired for being ethical. It’s not too shocking; lawyers aren’t expected to be honest, only to maximise profit. To quote:

The Third Circuit reversed the grant of the dismissal of a lawsuit by in-house counsel who sued because, he alleged, he was forced to choose between complying with an application filing quota or complying with his ethical obligations to the USPTO. The case, Trzaska v. L’Oreal USA, INc., (3rd Cir. July 25, 2017), is here.

“The complaint alleged that complying with the quota meant filing “frivolous” patent applications,” Generare Oy Ltd. told me about this. The situation may seem familiar to some.

What’s with all the stockpiling? Why has this become so normal? Yesterday we saw blind acceptance of patents and endless admiration of Apple/Steve Jobs, leading to this kind of terrible Web site which equates/conflates patents with innovation and celebrates accumulation of patents based on quantity alone (because large companies just cross-license a massive number of patents without even assessing these individually).

“What’s with all the stockpiling? Why has this become so normal?”The above is about Apple, but IBM too plays that game and IBM is far too proud of software patents that are likely invalid (it still uses these to bully rivals). See this press release [1, 2, 3] which said “IBM leadership in storage systems and software is based upon more than 380 system patents, including IBM FlashCore technology and more than 700 patents for IBM Spectrum Storage software.”

Around the same time (as this press release) we saw IBM’s patents chief gloating that “Snap-On gets hammered” by patents, having just been judged by a jury that probably does not understand what patents are. The report in question says this:

The Journal Sentinel reports Snap-on’s Rick Secor says the company strongly disagrees with the jury’s verdict and will “vigorously appeal.”

In the lawsuit, the Brookfield-based Milwaukee Tool says the lithium-ion battery packs it invented revolutionized the industry after the technology was introduced in 2005. It replaced packs that used nickel-cadmium batteries.

This particular case is not about software patents, but it’s interesting that IBM is keen to promote it. The patents chief has also just linked to a patent troll’s site (Dominion Harbor) in support of software patents. “The sad, confused state of US #patent eligible subject matter described here,” he said in relation to a patent troll known as Secured Mail Solutions (SMS) — a troll we just mentioned here the other day. To quote:

Because I believe that everyone, as a means of self-improvement, should occasionally test their patience and evaluate their ability to manage pain, I was reading the Federal Circuit’s recent decision in Secured Mail Solutions, LLC v. Universal Wilde Inc., upholding the district court’s ruling on the pleadings that Secured Mail’s seven asserted patents were all ineligible under 35 USC § 101. These patents all address tracking mail through an encoded marking, e.g., a barcode, QR code or URL, on the outside of a mailer which is intended to provide information to the recipient about the contents and the sender. Setting aside that when you see a panel of Prost, Clevenger and Reyna you know the patent’s dead, it’s just a matter of how they will craft the language to that desired effect, let’s just look at how the famed Alice test was handled in this case in general.

It’s safe to say that almost every such case now yields invalidity. Courts understand, in light of Alice, that it’s a matter of great certainty. Software patents are out.

“Software patents are out.”If the rumours are true, the USPTO‘s patent examiners too will soon follow suit. Maybe the EPO‘s also?

The EPO mentioned PCT applications a few days ago and so did Patently-O (compare China to Korea in this graph). PCT is the Patent Cooperation Treaty and if one nation abandons software patents, we can expect others to follow the lead.

Moreover, as Patently-O pointed out a few days ago, better examiners will result in fewer incorrect patent grants. The research explores the “[r]elationship between examiner specialization and examination outcomes.”

“So it shows empirically that “specialization is associated with a more stringent examination process,” as one might expect. Lack of knowledge (or ignorance) in the problem domain leads to more patents.”The summary says, “we find a significant degree of technological specialization among patent examiners working in the same art-unit. This specialization is less pronounced in some of the computer-related technology centers. We found no evidence that examiners specialize in handling important or controversial applications. And it seems that specialization is associated with a more stringent examination process, perhaps because it allows examiners to more easily identify relevant prior art.”

So it shows empirically that “specialization is associated with a more stringent examination process,” as one might expect. Lack of knowledge (or ignorance) in the problem domain leads to more patents. Here we see the importance of the recruitment process, or the ability to attract top talent. It’s hard to mislead examiners who assess patents in their own field of expertise. Consider for instance this new example that says: “The court found the defendant’s argument “not unreasonable,” but nonetheless rejected it. The “great weight of the case law” made clear that the duty to “disclose all material information to the patent examiner” did not extend to ensuring that “the patent examiner understands that information.””

Sadly, if the examiners don’t understand, they often just grant patents. It should be the exact opposite. If the applicant cannot properly explain to the examiners what is being claimed, then the examiner should assume it’s likely intentional. “If you can’t explain it simply, you don’t understand it well enough,” Albert Einstein famously said. He too was a patent clerk (before becoming famous).

Share this post: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
  • co.mments
  • DZone
  • email
  • Google Bookmarks
  • LinkedIn
  • NewsVine
  • Print
  • Technorati
  • TwitThis
  • Facebook

If you liked this post, consider subscribing to the RSS feed or join us now at the IRC channels.

Pages that cross-reference this one

What Else is New


  1. Links 30/3/2020: Linux 5.6, Nitrux 1.2.7, Sparky 2020.03.1

    Links for the day



  2. The Fall of the UPC - Part IX: Campinos Opens His Mouth One Week Later (and It's That Hilarious Delusion Again)

    Team Campinos said nothing whatsoever about the decision of the FCC until one week later, whereupon Campinos leveraged some words from Christine Lambrecht to mislead everybody in the EPO's official "news" section



  3. Pretending EPO Corruption Stopped Under António Campinos When It is in Fact a Lot Worse in Several Respects/Aspects (Than It Was Under Benoît Battistelli)

    Germany's eagerness to keep Europe's central patent office in Munich (and to a lesser degree in Berlin) means that politicians in the capital and in Bavaria turn a blind eye to abuses, corruption and even serious crimes; this won't help Germany's image in the long run



  4. IRC Proceedings: Saturday, March 28, 2020

    IRC logs for Saturday, March 28, 2020



  5. Links 28/3/2020: Wine 5.5 Released, EasyPup 2.2.14, WordPress 5.4 RC5 and End of Truthdig

    Links for the day



  6. IRC Proceedings: Friday, March 27, 2020

    IRC logs for Friday, March 27, 2020



  7. The Fall of the UPC - Part VIII: Team UPC Celebrates Death, Not Life

    Team UPC plays psychological games now; it is trying to twist or spin its defeat as good news and something to be almost celebrated; it is really as illogical (and pathetic) as that sounds



  8. Links 27/3/2020: GNU/Linux Versus COVID-19 and Release of GNU Guile 3.0.2

    Links for the day



  9. When Your 'Business' is Just 'Patent Portfolio'

    Hoarding loads of patents may seem impressive, but eating them to survive is impossible if not impermissible



  10. LOT Network is a One-Man (Millionaire's) Operation and Why This Should Alarm You

    The ugly story of Open Invention Network (OIN) and LOT; today we take a closer look at LOT and highlight a pattern of 'cross-pollination' (people in both OIN and LOT, even at the same time)



  11. Faking Production With Fake Patents on Software

    The EPO with its illegal guidelines (in violation of the EPC) can carry on churning out millions of fake patents that European courts would only waste time on and small companies be blackmailed with (they cannot afford legal battles)



  12. With the Unified Patent Court (UPC) Out of the Way Focus Will Return to EPO Corruption

    Expect the European Patent Office (EPO) to receive more negative attention now that the ’cause’ of UPC is lost and there’s no point pretending things are rosy



  13. IRC Proceedings: Thursday, March 26, 2020

    IRC logs for Thursday, March 26, 2020



  14. Links 27/3/2020: qBittorrent 4.2.2, Krita 4.2.9, pfSense 2.4, Bodhi Linux 5

    Links for the day



  15. IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, March 25, 2020

    IRC logs for Wednesday, March 25, 2020



  16. Still Work in Progress: Getting Those 2,851 Pages of Police Report About Arrest for Pedophilia in Home of Bill Gates

    It’s extremely difficult to get those police records, which were requested exactly one day before the media started attacking Richard Stallman (associating him with pedophiles based on a deliberate distortion)



  17. Links 26/3/2020: Plasma Bigscreen, New Kubernetes, Fedora's New Identity and Bodhi Linux 5.1.0

    Links for the day



  18. Guest Article: Window Managers, Github and Software Disobedience

    "Walking away from monopolies is the essence of freedom"



  19. Links 25/3/2020: LLVM 10.0.0 and UCS 4.4-4 Released, WordPress 5.4 RC4

    Links for the day



  20. 'Team UPC' Last Week

    The looks on Team UPC's faces 5 days ago (before and after the 9:30AM announcement)



  21. The Fall of the UPC - Part VII: Lies and Revisionism About the Reasons for the UPC's Ultimate Demise (to Leave the Door Open for More Failed Attempts)

    The media was lying in a hurry, in a coordinated effort to distort the meaning of the FCC's decision or belittle the impact of this decision; Techrights will carefully watch and respond to these lies



  22. IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, March 24, 2020

    IRC logs for Tuesday, March 24, 2020



  23. Linux Foundation Became Anti-Linux, Run by Microsoft People to Serve Microsoft's Agenda

    Microsoft is taking over the bodies of healthy projects, infecting the hosts in order for them to become slaves of the proprietary parasite; there's still no (known) cure, but we're familiar with the symptoms



  24. Microsoft Continues to Attack and Steal From the Open Source/Free Software Communities

    Microsoft cannot be trusted and there's no "new Microsoft," as another fairly new story serves to show



  25. Targeted Attack Leveraging FSF Servers

    Targeted by a determined and persist perpetrator, I've received over 20,000 E-mails. And the weapon of choice was the FSF's infrastructure, remotely misused against yours truly.



  26. If We Weren't Silencing Founders, Critics and People We Just Don't Like

    "In the long run, history is rarely very kind to tyrants, especially the ones who did little more than lie to people and demand things that served no real purpose."



  27. The Fall of the UPC - Part VI: Drowning in Material

    We're starting to see few good reports on the subject of UPC being rejected by the constitutional court of Germany; we also have a rapidly-growing 'buffer' of rather blatant examples of disinformation (which we'll tackle as best we can)



  28. FFII: EU Software Patent Court Stopped by Constitutional Court, Patent Industry Will Try Again

    The third attempt to validate software patents in Europe via a central patent court (UPC) has been stopped by the German Constitutional Court. The Unified Patent Court (UPC) would have given the keys of the kingdoms to the patent industry, and the last word over software patentability. FFII predict that the patent industry will continue to push for an UPC v2.0.



  29. Links 24/3/2020: Alpine 3.11.5, MythTV 31.0 and Tails 4.4.1

    Links for the day



  30. IRC Proceedings: Monday, March 23, 2020

    IRC logs for Monday, March 23, 2020


RSS 64x64RSS Feed: subscribe to the RSS feed for regular updates

Home iconSite Wiki: You can improve this site by helping the extension of the site's content

Home iconSite Home: Background about the site and some key features in the front page

Chat iconIRC Channel: Come and chat with us in real time

Recent Posts