Bonum Certa Men Certa

The EPO, Europe's Largest Patent Office, Admits Outsourcing to Microsoft Slop

posted by Roy Schestowitz on Jun 16, 2025,
updated Jun 16, 2025

An EPO Boards of Appeal paper

The Local Staff Committee Munich (LSCMN) at the EPO has a new report about a recent meeting with the appointee of Benoît Battistelli - meant to serve him and his other crony, António Campinos, surely under the guise of "appeals" inside the EPO. As it turns out, software patents came up. Remember that European software patents are both illegal and undesirable, but the EPO's unaccountable tribunal and the illegal kangaroo courts (also unconstitutional) don't care about either legality or constitutionality. Their sole goal is to make more money. At whose expense? Europe. Who stands to benefit? Not Europe.

LSCMN wrote to colleagues:

Dear Colleagues,

The Local Staff Committee Munich met with the Boards of Appeal (BoA) on 4 June 2025.

In the meeting, we addressed the declining workload, the upcoming relocation and the use of AI.

The Management Report of the BoA for 2024 (CA/9/25) mentions that “[t]here has been a decrease of 31% in new inter partes cases because, as foreseen, opposition divisions have eased production. Ex parte cases have shown a decrease of 11.3% (from 2023 to 2024), partly due to a significant decline in a particular technical field (IPC class G06Q, business methods) of over 90% since 2022. The incoming workload decreased across all technical fields, although more markedly in the field of mechanics.”

Notice in the above "business methods", which are closely related to software patents i.e. patents which are granted illegally (and consciously so). The Office is so unhinged that even its own tribunals just play along with deliberate violations of the European Patent Convention. From the 3-page report dated 4 days ago:

Örtlicher Personalausschuss München Innenstadt, Haar und Brüssel
Local Staff Committee Munich City, Haar and Brussels
Le Comité local du Personnel de Munich Ville, Haar et Bruxelles

Munich, 12-06-2025
sc25004mp

Report on the meeting between the EPO Boards of Appeal
and the Local Staff Committee Munich
on 4 June 2025

On 4 June 2025 members of the Local Staff Committee Munich met online with the Boards of Appeal, as represented by the President of the EPO Boards of Appeal (BoA) Carl Josefsson; Director Administrative Services BoA Philippe Lahorte; Advisor to the President of the BoA Marielle Piana, Lawyer Judith Soentgen, and HR Administrator BoA Katja Warneck.

Meeting opened: 15:00

Opening of the meeting

Mr. Josefsson opened the meeting by welcoming Staff Representation and introducing the other EPO Boards of Appeal meeting participants.

State of Play in BoA

Mr. Josefsson summarised the state of play in the BoA. The objective for the end of 2025 was to have no more than 10% of cases being older than 24 months, and the BoA were on target to achieve this. The trend was for less incoming cases, with a yearly reduction of 500 cases, and the backlog of pending cases continued to steeply decrease with currently less than 3000 cases pending. The main reason for the decline was a decline in the number of oppositions and a consequent decline in the number of appeals1. The BoA would be working with the Office to investigate why the number of oppositions was decreasing, which might involve a user satisfaction survey.

3.000 cases were completed last year, with 1.600 oral proceedings. Of these, 60% were carried out by video conference and 40% in person, a stable situation over the last years. The number of BoA members was decreasing and would be down from 230 to 225 by the end of the year, with retiring colleagues not being replaced.

______

1 “Management Report of the BoA”, CA/9/25, p. 4, “There has been a decrease of 31% in new inter partes cases because, as foreseen, opposition divisions have eased production. Ex parte cases have shown a decrease of 11.3% (from 2023 to 2024), partly due to a significant decline in a particular technical field (IPC class G06Q, business methods) of over 90% since 2022. The incoming workload decreased across all technical fields, although more markedly in the field of mechanics.”


Staff Representation asked why clearing the backlog was a priority when the amount of incoming work was decreasing. Mr. Josefsson explained that it was important to users that pendency time was reduced as much as possible, and courts should aim to work on cases as they come in. Any extra capacity would allow the BoA to focus on non-core work and quality. Examples of quality were that decision abstracts were being provided externally, a European judges’ conference was held annually in Vienna, and workshops were held jointly with national judges, including those of the UPC.

Staff Representation asked if this would mean a change in targets for the BoA members. Mr. Josefsson answered that there used to be productivity and number objectives, but now there were solely timeliness objectives. However, members were never asked to achieve the impossible. Workload was allocated as evenly as possible, although this needed more flexibility from members as the cases were reallocated. The career system for members had been amended two years ago. In the new system there was the possibility to be promoted after the first reappointment, and then one chance to get to G15/4 after ten years. For Chairmen there was a chance to get to G16/4 after ten years. It was too early to say what effect the change to the career system had had.

Relocation - Update

Mr. Josefsson was not able to say what was discussed in the closed session of the administrative council. All he could say was there was not a concrete date for the move, but the BoA was looking forward to moving. BoA staff had inspected the building and were apparently satisfied.

Staff Representation noted that after the closure of the large canteen in PH 1-4 the next largest would be in PH VII, and so the reopening of PH VII was of interest to all staff.

Staff Representation commented that PH VII would be too large for just the BoA. Mr. Josefsson said that it would be up to the Office what the rest of the building would be used for, but it would not be used for patent examiners as a clear separation between the first and second instances was needed.

Use of AI in the BoA

Mr. Lahorte stated that AI was a topic of keen interest, and the BoA might work with BIT to develop internal AI tools. Mr. Lahorte explained that Mr. Josefsson had set up an AI working group which was tracking developments in AI. Corporate AI tools were being tested, such as CoPilot. There was, as yet, no operational use of AI. The AI working group had been mandated by Mr. Josefsson to develop guidance on the use of AI, including the benefits, risks, reliability and safeguards. This guidance was a working document. Mr.


Josefsson added that although this document was not available outside the BoA the core of it was in the BoA management report.

Staff Representation referred to their intervention in the recent BFC meeting regarding AI classification and autoclosure of circulation. It was pointed out that CPC classification typically determined IPC classification at the EPO, hence AI classification would have an effect on the business distribution plan at the BoA. Staff Representation asked if the BoA had noticed any problems resulting from poor AI classification. Mr. Josefsson replied that he had not heard of any, although there had not been any systematic monitoring.

AOB

Staff Representation asked if there were any interesting enlarged BoA cases pending. Mr. Josefsson replied that there were three – G1/23, G1/24 and G2/24. Of these, G1/24 was of most interest to the public, it concerned taking account of the description when interpreting the claims. Hearings had been heard for G1/23, this concerned the enablement requirement when judging novelty. No hearings had as yet been held for G2/24, which concerned interventions.

Staff Representation asked whether examiners were able to discuss cases they had worked on which had reached the appeal stage. Mr. Josefsson replied that pending cases could not be discussed at all, and the best approach would be to ask for a presentation after deliberations had closed. This was a useful and productive exercise for both examiners and BoA members.

Closing of the meeting

Staff Representation thanked Mr. Josefsson for the meeting.

Meeting closed: 15:50

Your representatives of the Local Staff Committee Munich (LSCMN)

When they speak about CoPilot they speak about: 1) slop (typically associated with illegal things in the legal context). 2) sending sensitive data to Microsoft, which can use it to further perturb Office affairs. This is related to other ongoing EPO scandals. Maybe the EPO should speak to Denmark, but the EPO is not accountable to anyone. █

Other Recent Techrights' Posts

Digitalisation Is Not Inevitable or Unavoidable
Nor inescapable
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXIV - Why the Swatting Failed
After that we only ever heard from or spoke to cops when we invited them to our home to collect evidence
 
IBM 'Robbery': No More Car Allowance in the UK, Severance Shredded, CEO Pay Up 51% in One Year While Thousands Laid Off in Secret
Why does a CEO reward himself so much when the company does so badly?
Gemini Links 08/11/2026: "Back", Zot, and Information Overload
Links for the day
“Concerned Microsoft Workers” Say “Working at Microsoft Has Become Joyless and Demoralizing.” (That's What Microsoft Wants, More Will Leave That Way)
Many Microsoft employees are going to leave
The Register MS is Losing Hundreds of Thousands of Pounds a Year While Directors Pay Themselves Hundreds of Thousands of Pounds a Year in Dividends
they take money from slop pushers and have clearly compromised some journalistic standards in the process
GNU/Linux Measured at 7.4% in the UK This Weekend: Clownflare Radar
I hope that one day GNU/Linux will be everywhere here
Never a One-Person Project
Just because I'm the main "public face" of the site (who takes all the insults and SLAPPs) doesn't mean I deserve all the credit
“I Always Expect to Lose. I Fight Anyway, and Sometimes I Win.” — Richard Stallman
To change the world meaningfully people must think big
Stop Looking for News About "Layoffs", Layoffs Are Over (They've Been Rebranded)
To properly assess the status quo we need other yardsticks
Links 08/11/2026: Bosses Who Were Forcing Their Workers to Use Slop Change Mind, "Rapper RBX Files Ninth Circuit Appeal in Fraud-Focused Class Action Lawsuit Against Spotify"
Links for the day
Links 08/11/2026: Why Vikings Stayed in Iceland and "TikTok Accused Of Promoting Sex Industry To Young Girls"
Links for the day
Gemini Links 08/11/2026: "Before Sunrise" and LLM Scrapers Versus Self-Hosting (or Web in General)
Links for the day
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXIII - Weaponising Cops in Another Continent (Europe), Knowing They Cannot Come to Your Home in America, While Threatening Women
This year it culminated in death threats
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Saturday, November 07, 2026
IRC logs for Saturday, November 07, 2026
The Decade Ahead, a Decade of Suppressed Stories
Our stories aren't discouraged or considered taboo because of racism or "toxic politics" or anything like that; they just hurt powerful people and corporations
Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) Inaction and Incompetence - Part V - "Reports Closed Without the Evidence Being Examined."
Totally what the SRA did regarding Brett Wilson LLP
Gemini Links 07/11/2026: Illusion Garden and Lagrange 2
Links for the day
Complexity is the Tyrant's Friend
Slop is for feeble minds and cheaters
IBM Firings (or Silent Layoffs) After Bluewashing; "IBM’s Employment History is More Troubling Than its Patriotic Marketing Suggests"
"It has zip to do with race but everything to do with the greed of the 1% who have been doing all they can to destroy the middle class..."
“Week van de Werkstress” and Work-Related Stress at the EPO, Where Staff is Bullied Into Granting Illegal Patents for Foreign Monopolists
"poor working environments, including discrimination and inequality, excessive workloads, low job control and job insecurity pose a risk to mental health"
Czech Republic: GNU/Linux Rises Above 5% in Desktops and Laptops
A year ago it was somewhere around 4%
EPO's Local Staff Committee The Hague Says Almost or About a Third of Staff Assembled to Organise at "a Time of Continued Social Unrest"
They speak of "circa 850 staff members in attendance" (in The Netherlands there are about a couple thousand)
Suggestions That XBox Will be Offloaded by Microsoft, Rather Than Shut Down, Make the False Assumption XBox is Profitable (It's Not, It's a Liability)
Microsoft has serious financial troubles
Which "Smart" "Phone", Which "Social" "Media", and Which "Cloud" "Storage"?
Let's take back control of the language
State of the (Linux) Slop, Late 2026 Edition
Google News (Gulag Noise) is a plagiarism booster
Year 21
It's 5PM here
Links 07/11/2026: "Flock Cameras Got Eviscerated by the Midterms" and Joshua Wong Shows China is Highly Repressive and Fully Controls Hong Kong
Links for the day
At The Register MS the Net Liabilities Doubled in One Year, Tangible Assets Down About 35% in One Year
signed off in 2026
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXII - Running One's Mouth
British Police told me "making a false complaint to police is a crime" in relation to Lozza
Another 20 Years of Exposing Corruption
We'll focus on carrying on what we do
EPO Budget and Finance Committee (in Very Recent Meeting) Increases Bribes to People Who Vote on Campinos Reappointment ("Cooperation Activities")
Buying 'elections' to protect the cocaine-stained regime in Europe's second-largest institution
Links 07/11/2026: London's SLAPP Industry Now Targets Kirkenes (Northern Norway) at the Behest of Corrupt Thieves in Russia and Microsoft’s 'Buyout' Offer Crashes Microsoft Systems
Links for the day
Links 07/11/2026: "The Moon is Waning Crescent", Homeworlds, and "Can't Handle The AVIF!"
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Friday, November 06, 2026
IRC logs for Friday, November 06, 2026
IBM Compels Workers - Even at Red Hat - to Become "Retired-ish"
Who needs RAs (layoffs, which have been rebranded as "buyouts" like pink slips are generous "gifts") when workers can have their butts kicked every day and WARN Act reporting thresholds are never approached?
Links 06/11/2026: "XBox Is Closer Than Ever to Being Sold Off" and "BuzzFeed Stock in Free Fall"
Links for the day
Gemini Links 06/11/2026: Dao and Dreams
Links for the day
20 Years of Techrights
Celebrating 2 decades of abuses of power being watched (and looking back at key changes)
Linux (and Linus Torvalds) Sleepwalking Into a Binance-Level Catastrophe With Slop 'Code'
Someone should ask Linus Torvalds or his boss (Linux Foundation) if they deem slop, which nobody audits, trustworthy enough to add to every computer out there running the Linux kernel
Vitaly Orlov Weaponises Deep Pockets to Leverage High Court of Justice in London for Censorship and Punishment of Critics
reproduced in full for more exposure and to make censorship harder
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXI - What I Told British Police About Lozza the Same Month Garrett Was Preparing His First Nastygram From 'Hired Guns' Brett Wilson LLP
Lozza and Garrett
Outsourcing at IBM
Cheapening of the workforce is hardly a new problem
The Register MS: Turnover Fell by Over a Million Pounds (About 20%) in One Year, Administrative Expenses Rose by Almost Half a Million Pounds, The Register MS Operates at a Loss
This is not a (commercially) healthy publisher
Links 06/11/2026: Slop "Companies Race to Lock Down Oil Clients" and Salon Shuts Down
Links for the day
Our Third Decade
Our anniversary is tonight at midnight
Freedom Is Not Free of Charge, Freedom Can be Very Expensive
Being someone's "slave" is the "default" when no resistance exists
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXX - Swatting by Proxy
Using imbeciles who lie to cops and then dox cops (and already have arrest record and court documents wherein they admit being stoned in front of the cops)
Intel Craters at Taxpayers' Expense (Bailouts for Failing Companies Simple Don't Work)
GOP, which did this, has lost many seats
Mass Layoffs at IBM, Also Outsourcing to India
What IBM does to itself it is doing to other entities as well
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Thursday, November 05, 2026
IRC logs for Thursday, November 05, 2026
During Strikes and Industrial Actions Lots of EPO Staff Organised Yesterday and Will Do the Same Next Week
There really needs to be a genuine election, not a reappointment
Gemini Links 06/11/2026: Hadestown and "Where Has the Electronics Shop Gone?"
Links for the day