Bonum Certa Men Certa

Yes, You Can Love and Adore Things Whilst Also Criticising Them

posted by Roy Schestowitz on Jul 31, 2025

BSD and UNIX

Criticising something and disliking some things aren't opposites (as concepts/attitudes). There are famous sayings along the lines of, when you stop criticising something or give up offering ways to improve, then that means you've given up on that something (or someone, sometimes). The idea that you're attached to something is key. If you care about something or someone, then you'll very much care about the destination of that something or someone, right? If you quit caring, and thus quit criticising, that's not the same as acceptance. It might even be a sign of apathy, maybe rejection.

There are all sorts of projects and companies that we criticise here all the time. Criticising is OK. It ought to be welcomed sometimes. I too read criticisms of myself, my sites, my articles. I view some of those as constructive and some as mean-spirited attacks, depending on who or what does the criticism (which implies the "whys").

Decades ago (maybe too much yearning for the 1990s, that's a giveaway) we were able to disagree with people, even in the open. Even with employers! On many occasions I openly criticised my bosses, sometimes to their face (even as a teenager). Before I quit Sirius I confronted my bosses for a number of years, preferably over the phone (where making excuses and preparing carefully-crafted lies would be harder). E-mail criticism was easier to deflect, in my experience.

By 2022 it was already becoming very hard to criticise bosses. Doing so was feasible, but they would just not listen. Lots of that foolish, infantile, "either you're with us, or..."

Regarding politics, which isn't our focus in this site, back in the old days we could argue with people - even close colleagues - without words like "Woke" or "communist" or "fascist" being tossed around.

Is society being divided and groomed/primed to be resistant to constructive criticism?

For what it's worth, it's OK to argue with BSD folks (the operating systems or the licences); it's like brothers and sisters having arguments. Our overall goals are pretty much the same, even if not 100% overlapping. A lot of our "blood" (code) is also overlapping, as we stand to benefit from kinship. Opinionated people can have fierce arguments with siblings and parents and still love them deeply.

Other Recent Techrights' Posts

Web Developers in the US Can Already Disregard Mozilla, Firefox, and Firefox Users
"Last month, Firefox turned 21"
 
Upgrading the Site
Debugging might be needed, so feedback helps
Why Microsoft is Panicking
Keep advocating (or "marketing") GNU/Linux to Vista 10 (or Vista 7) users... there are still over a billion of them "out there".
The Fate of "Blockchains" and "Metaverse" as a Sign of Things to Come for Slop ("AI")
Doesn't that tell us a lot about the modus operandi of these companies?
A Year After the Owner of X (Twitter) Performed Several Nazi Salutes on Stage the Germany-Based and Microsoft-Funded 'FSFE' Decides to Exit X (Twitter)
Will the real Free Software Foundation (FSF) follow suit?
EPO: What Comes Next
European media seems to have been sedated by soft bribes from cocaine addicts
Slopwatch: The Volume of Slop Has Certainly Gone Down a Lot Lately, Slop Image Providers Abandoned/Changed
It's a big improvement compared to past months
Thousands Laid Off at IBM, "Last Day" Yesterday
IBM is a dying company. This is a problem for Red Hat.
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Thursday, December 04, 2025
IRC logs for Thursday, December 04, 2025
Gemini Links 05/12/2025: Espressif ESP32-C5 UEXT Module, Pixelfed, and the Web Getting Much Worse
Links for the day
Links 04/12/2025: "People Hooked on [Slop] Far Are More Likely to Experience Mental Distress", Monopolies in Europe, and "Blogging Makes Me Feel Like A Worse Writer"
Links for the day
Dr. Andy Farnell: Can we regain control (of technology)?
"Technology as spiralling mass hysteria has the unsettling potential to draw even rational sceptics like myself into disaffection"
Links 04/12/2025: "Hey Hi" Implosion and Half of Europeans See Cheeto Trump as Enemy of Europe
Links for the day
Communication Needs Open Standards and Open Data
Standards are imperative
The "Hey Hi" House of Cards
The "Hey Hi" bubble is living on borrowed time (days or weeks) and it can implode any time now
Supporting the Free Software Foundation (FSF) Also Supports GNU Development
The FSF is mostly raising money to pay salaries
IBM's "AK Sez" Campaign
In today's media, to be characterised as important and smart one needn't be important and smart
Microsoft's Vista 11 Not Gaining, Just Plateauing or Even Going Down (Over Time)
"Desktop Windows version Market Share Worldwide"
Bubbles Popping, "Hey Hi" (AI) a Passing Fad
"Microsoft slides amid report it's cutting software sales quotas tied to AI"
At The Register MS, "Exclusive Webinar" Means Sponsored Video Ad Disguised as an Article
Why would one choose to watch these?
IBM Forces Staff to Sign an NDA If They Want Severance Package, in Effect Bribing Them or Denying Them Money They're Entitled to If They 'Disparage' IBM
We wrote about the legality or illegality of this in relation to Microsoft two years ago
IBM and Red Hat Not Done With 2025 Layoffs ("RAs") Yet
IBM isn't quite done laying off people this year, with only 3 weeks till Christmas
Gemini Links 04/12/2025: Christmas Looms, Devuan, and Programming
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, December 03, 2025
IRC logs for Wednesday, December 03, 2025
Loads of People Exit IBM Tomorrow
Way to slam the door on on those who march or walk on
Slopwatch: It's Blowing, Jim (Gym), the Bubble is Blowing Up
Let's race to "zero GPT"
At IBM, "Last Day" Can be Same as Layoffs ("RAs"), Might be Euphemism Advanced by PR/HR Under NDA-Tied Conditions
They try to act all happy cheerful (in public) about becoming unemployed
Links 03/12/2025: "Disastrous Hey Hi (AI)", Breaches of Confidentiality, and "Global Democratic Recession"
Links for the day
Fake Security and 'Free' Certificates as a Trap of Planned Obsolescence and Top-Down Centralisation
The boiling frogs
Links 03/12/2025: UK Budget Leak and Criticism of Peace Posturing Over Ukraine
Links for the day
So Far Rust in Ubuntu Has Turned Out to be an Expensive Mistake
it is certainly seeming or feeling like the wrong people are in charge and they make bad decisions based on false reasoning
Gemini Links 03/12/2025: Obsession, Ubuntu, and Programming With Scheme
Links for the day
The Next Stages of EPO Coverage (and Why That Matters)
What's at stake here?
Wayland Rejection Is Not Racist
We need to collectively reject that
Reflections on a Month of Techrights Search
it looks like we've survived nearly a month without the search functionality being leveraged to stage DDoS attacks
New Year's Resolutions 4 Weeks Ahead of 2026
the main New Year's Resolution was... sleep
IBM Layoffs: It's Like They Read From a Script, Like They've Signed a Non-Disparagement Agreement/Clause
Some new departures
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, December 02, 2025
IRC logs for Tuesday, December 02, 2025