Both Developers and Users Are Not Interested in Mono

Dr. Roy Schestowitz

2009-08-26 15:30:46 UTC
Modified: 2009-08-26 15:30:46 UTC

"I hereby demand Microsoft in my Linux"

Summary: The Mono riddle begs for source of the claims of "demand"

ABOUT A week ago we showed that Mono was largely rejected by the Free software development community. There is another article on the subject right now. It says about C#:

Its use stands at - hold your breath - 1.24 percent, just one-hundredths of a percent more than assembly language.

Mono, for the uninitiated, is an attempt by Miguel de Icaza, the co-founder of the GNOME desktop project and currently vice-president of Novell, to replicate parts of Microsoft's .NET development environment as an open source project.

Novell is the same company that signed a patent indemnification deal with Microsoft in November 2006, which gave the latter opportunities to spread FUD about Linux. The charges which were levelled have remained just that - unproven charges.

It is not only developers who neglect Mono and C#. Users too are seemingly fed up with it. Even before the FSF expressed its opposition, about three quarters of the readers of TuxMachines said "No" to Mono. Here is another sole voice responding to the issue:

GNOME in .NET? – Not on my desktop!

[...]

I believe the weapon of Mono is to “get Linux users hooked” to the .net environment, always offering the superior and more mature version on the Windows platform. Just like when you first tried alcohol you would probably start off on lighter products until you acquired a taste for it, progressing later in life to liking stronger spirits. With Windows having the “definitive version” and users hooked or caught in the .net, Microsoft could effectively remove or hold to ransom the addiction of using .net from non-Windows users. Just an idea, but from a PR standpoint IMO it would seem far more viable than MONO being used to trick people into installing Microsoft patent infested code.

Novell's Visual Studio copycat proceeds to embracing other languages and as we explained here before, MonoDevelop helps Windows [1, 2]. ⬆

Comments

Charles Oliver

2009-08-26 17:05:46

Gnome going mono at it's core has been talked about for a while. I really hope it doesn't come to pass.

I don't have a real issue with having mono around for people who want to use it. If it actually lived up to the hype that it would allow Windows developers to move to Linux, then maybe there would be a point to it.

Having now gone mono free on my desktop, I don't much want to have to change desktop environments.

If Miguel really wanted to do something good, he'd look at what's good in .net, java, python, perl etc. and then get some guys together to develop something better. Isn't that what the best of FOSS software is, better than that which surrounds it.

Roy Schestowitz

2009-08-26 18:14:01

See the MCP. It's not allowed.

Charles Oliver

2009-08-26 21:45:05

What's not allowed? Encouraging windows users to Linux? Making something better than c# and .net?

Roy Schestowitz

2009-08-26 23:36:27

Deviating from ECMA.

Charles Oliver

2009-08-27 00:03:57

I was actually suggesting the creation of a new language, nothing c#, nothing .net, a community developed language.

That way you aren't three steps behind the monopolist player's variant.

IBM Stock Collapses and It's Only the Beginning: Will GAFAM soon follow and will any executives be arrested for the accounting fraud insiders have long cautioned about?
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, July 14, 2026: IRC logs for Tuesday, July 14, 2026
Heshan de Silva-Weeramuni Becomes Program Manager at the Free Software Foundation (FSF): Heshan's addition means that the FSF is growing after a solid financial year (best in years)
Michael McMahon Explains Distributed Denial of Service (DDoS) Attacks on the Free Software Foundation (FSF): The real solution is a curb on botnets. A mitigation strategy, however, would involve going static.
Matters of Public Safety: "Police say Ann Widdecombe killed in 'targeted attack' as motive investigated"
The Register MS and Its Promotional Microsoft Content: It's not too hard to see what the business model of The Register MS is
IBM: From $306 to $212 in 7 Days, IBM Won't Go Up More Than 50% to Where It Was at 'Peak Vapourware': There's a limit to how much or how long a company can fake its performance and its potential [...] Early this morning a few insiders ("traders") cashed in on their "pump-n-dump"
Red Hat Staff Needs to Start Looking for the Next Job: Workers can conveniently lie or deny it to themselves, but waves of PIPs ("silent layoffs") will sweep over more and more units or teams as the company runs out of money to play with
IBM the Next Bear Stearns: IBM cannot recover if all it has to show is vapourware
I'll Be Extremely Difficult for Microsoft to Sell Any XBox Consoles Now: Microsoft understands this
How Software Freedom Would Benefit Everybody: A society that denies control by greedy companies would do a disservice to monopolies and improve all services to citizens
Links 14/07/2026: Harsh But Also Fair Criticism of Hey Hi (AI) Slop, 'Open' AI Shuts Down Its Own Products as Funds Run Out: Links for the day
Gemini Links 14/07/2026: Old CD Binder and AWK: Links for the day
In Defence of Physical Tickets: Tickets are not some "app" and not some "code" on some "screen"
Microsoft Layoffs Not Limited to XBox (False Narrative in the Mainstream Media): Microsoft is becoming less relevant and workforce reductions won't end any time soon
Links 14/07/2026: Plagiarism Spun as "Training", Zelensky Announces Leadership Shuffle: Links for the day
The Register MS Has Just Published "AI" Webspam That Mentions "AI" 54 Times. It Was Paid to Do This.: Who pays for all this "AI" hype or "buzz"?
Gemini Links 14/07/2026: Self-Advocacy Online; "The Internet Is Dead: How the Web Lost Its Human Soul": Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Monday, July 13, 2026: IRC logs for Monday, July 13, 2026
Modern Technology Harms Women More Than Men (Because the 'Tech Bros' Who Dominate STEM Have a Poor View of Women): “Privacy protects us from abuses by those in power, even if we're doing nothing wrong at the time of surveillance.”
Internet Relay Chat Trolls Are Not Expressing Opinions, They Are Saboteurs: For the record
Links 14/07/2026: "The Freedom of Information Act Is in Serious Trouble"; Irish Datacenters Use Up Almost 25% of Total Energy: Links for the day
The Register MS: "AI" Puff Pieces for Sale, Not Journalism at All, Just "Webspam": The Register MS isn't the sole culprit
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, July 12, 2026: IRC logs for Sunday, July 12, 2026
How We Do Techrights (and What's Changing Next Week): Many former news sites no longer yield much non-meaningless news (not anymore); there's a gap to be filled

Both Developers and Users Are Not Interested in Mono

GNOME in .NET? – Not on my desktop!

Comments

Recent Techrights' Posts