Bonum Certa Men Certa

European Patent Institute (EPI) Not Happy With the EPO's Terrible Treatment of the Boards of Appeal

EPI letter



Summary: The European Patent Institute, or epi (all lowercase) as it prefers to refer to itself, opposes many of the suggestions made by the EPO, which effectively weakens the boards and wants them sent to exile

Not only AIPPI is upset at the EPO's attacks on the independent boards. Another letter, formally sent several days ago, expresses similar concerns but does so a lot more gently and politely (starts with positives, followed by negatives). Here it is in full. We have highlighted some key sentences in larger fonts.



epi

European Patent Institute ● Bayerstrasse 83 ● 80335 Munich ● Germany

Administrative Council of the EPO Bob-van-Benthem-Platz 1 80469 Munich

11th December, 2015

epi comments on CA/98/15 - Orientations for the Structural Reform of the EPO Boards of Appeal

Dear Members of the Administrative Council,

"We are disappointed to see that CA/98/15 does not address the urgent issue of the unfilled posts in the BoA."epi has had an opportunity to study CA/98/15 as part of its continuing effort to assist the Administrative Council (AC) in considering the status of the Boards of Appeal (BoA) at the EPO. epi provided a detailed response to the consultation from the Office and wishes to continue to contribute to the process. This is of particular importance to epi’s members as the vast majority of representatives who appear before the BoA are epi members.

Unfilled Posts in the BoA

We are disappointed to see that CA/98/15 does not address the urgent issue of the unfilled posts in the BoA. epi is aware that according to the Business Distribution Scheme for 2016, there are 30 unfilled posts, 23 for technical members and 7 for legal members, and that this is affecting both the timeliness and quality of the decisions of the BoA. Some of the BoA have had to issue communications indicating that they are unable to process some appeals because they lack technical members with appropriate technical skills. The general length of appeal proceedings is rising because of the shortage of staff, epi therefore considers that the AC should take immediate action to fill the unfilled posts as soon as possible.

"In particular, epi considers that the Office should not be involved in appointing or re-appointing members of the BoA or the EBoA."There may be a belief that there will be less need for the BoA once the UPC comes into force. However, epi considers that this belief is misplaced, certainly in the short term and even in the long term for appeals relating to applications. As appointments to the BoA are only for 5 years, it would be possible to reduce the number of appointments and/or re-appointments if the UPC does draw work away from the BoA.

General Comments on CA/98/15

epi was sent and has had access to many of the responses to the EPO’s consultation and, from studying these, it appears that the degree of acceptance of the original proposals in CA/16/15 may have been overstated. For instance, epi agreed that reform of the BoA was welcomed and that CA/16/15 was a good basis for further work. However, epi, and many others, did not agree that CA/16/15 was a sound proposal. Rather, epi, and others, suggested that the proposal needed changes before it would become “sound”. It is suggested that the members of the AC should study all the responses and come to their own conclusions.




Legal Basis

It is clear that the Office has seen that there may be legal problems with its proposal, epi appreciates the fact that the Office has asked for independent legal advice from an expert on the potential legal problems. However, epi considers that it is essential for the members of the AC and interested parties to see not just the advice but the instructions on the basis of which the advice was prepared. If you do not know the question, you cannot tell whether the answer is useful.

"The BoA and the EBoA will be making decisions regarding the operation of the Office or on references from the President of the Office."As epi noted in its response to the consultation, it is essential for there to be a proper legal basis for “attributing” the powers for dealing with the BoA to the proposed new President of the BoA. It is clear that, at present, in many of the functions performed by the AC in connection with the BoA, the EPC specifies that the AC must consult the President of the Office. However, if the BoA are to be truly independent of the Office, then the requirement for consulting with the President of the Office should no longer apply, epi would favour any solution to this problem which does not require amendment of the EPC.

It appears that consideration should be given not only to the "attribution" of the powers of the President of the Office but also to the effect of Articles 6 and 7 EPC and the Protocol on Centralisation (see below).

External Members of the Enlarged Board of Appeal

epi supports the proposal that there should be external members of the Enlarged Board of Appeal (EBoA) when the EBoA is considering petitions under Article 112a EPC. These external members should be present in both 3- and 5-membered panels.

Unit Headed bv the President of the BoA

epi considers that the creation of a President of the BoA and the removal of the office of Vice-President of DG3 is a positive move. However, epi does not see the need for a completely new “unit” as epi considers that the existing Presidium of the BoA, with suitable alterations in composition, would function effectively, epi suggests that the Presidium should include external members of the EBoA and observers.

Transfer of Powers

epi also supports the “attribution" of powers from the President of the Office to the President of the BoA. However, epi considers that, for this to be effective, the Office should not be involved in matters related to the BoA at any level below the level of the AC.

In particular, epi considers that the Office should not be involved in appointing or re-appointing members of the BoA or the EBoA. The BoA and the EBoA will be making decisions regarding the operation of the Office or on references from the President of the Office. If the Office is involved in the appointment and re€­appointment of members, then there will remain a perception that the BoA are not independent of the Office. It is for this reason that epi suggested that there should be a Judiciary Committee (see below).




Boards of Appeal Committee

Although epi is in principle in favour of a Boards of Appeal Committee (BoAC), epi considers that the structure for the BoAC proposed in CA/98/15 is not properly balanced. In particular, the only person on the BoAC from the BoA is the President of the BoA (without a voting right), epi considers that there should be more members of the BoA on the BoAC. As explained in epi's response to the consultation, epi considers that there should be less representation from the AC and a chair who is not a member of the AC. Also, for the reasons explained above, epi considers that the Office should not be represented at meetings of the BoAC. The AC will still have overall decision-making power as any proposal from the BoAC must be decided on by the AC.

"Also, for the reasons explained above, epi considers that the Office should not be represented at meetings of the BoAC."epi still considers that there should be a Judiciary Committee, as explained in epi’s response to the consultation, as well as the BoAC. The Judiciary Committee should be responsible for appointments and re€­appointments to the BoA.

epi considers that the composition of the BoAC is especially important if, contrary to epi’s suggestion, the BoAC is solely responsible for providing recommendations to the AC regarding appointments and re€­appointments. epi considers that it is essential for the appearance of independence that the appointments and re-appointments are made on objective grounds of competence and having independent members and BoA members on the BoAC will ensure that it is seen that such competence is independently assessed.

"epi considers that it is essential for the appearance of independence that the appointments and re-appointments are made on objective grounds of competence and having independent members and BoA members on the BoAC will ensure that it is seen that such competence is independently assessed."Paragraph 13 of CA/98/15 refers to the BoAC working on a "general level", epi agrees that this should be the case but considers that it will be necessary for there to be clear terms of reference for the BoAC to ensure that it only works at the “general" level.

epi appreciates the proposal that there should be observers from Business Europe and epi on the BoAC.

Rules of Procedure

epi also agrees that the BoAC, in a suitable composition, could be responsible for drafting the Rules of Procedure (RoP) for the BoA and the EBoA. However, epi considers that proposals for the RoP should not be made by the Office, contrary to the suggestion in paragraph 17 of CA/98/15. Since the BoA and the EBoA decide on the actions of the Office, any involvement of the Office in providing the RoP would be seen as significantly reducing the independence of the BoA.

"Since the BoA and the EBoA decide on the actions of the Office, any involvement of the Office in providing the RoP would be seen as significantly reducing the independence of the BoA."It is epi’s view that the BoAC should consult widely about any proposed amendments to the RoP and, in particular, should consult the Presidium and users before any amendment is presented to the AC for approval.

The second half of paragraph 15 of CA/98/15 indicates that users would like to see a change in the RoP to ensure better predictability and consistency of proceedings, epi agrees that measures should be taken to ensure better predictability and consistency of proceedings. However, epi considers that this does not require only an amendment to the RoP. Predictability and consistency also depends on the attitudes to the individual Boards, not on the RoP.

Human Resources

epi considers that it will be essential to have appropriate contractual arrangements for the BoA but, apart from the following, has no comment on the present proposals. The only comment relates to the point in paragraph 26 of CA/98/15 about “budgetary constraints”. Again, in order to ensure the independence from the Office, epi considers that any budgetary constraints should be determined solely by the AC. It will be necessary for the AC to instruct the Office to make appropriate contributions from the Office’s revenues to the BoA as the level of the appeal fee will not cover the operational costs of the BoA.




Conflict of Interest

"The location of the BoA will have no impact on the perception of independence."epi is concerned that CA/98/15 appears to be arguing for overly onerous rules on conflicts of interest. If such rules are too onerous, they will deter people from outside the Office applying for positions in the BoA, especially if there are onerous restrictions on what such a person can do after leaving the BoA. epi is therefore in favour of a principles-based code of conduct rather than a prescriptive set of rules.

Premises

It appears to epi that the discussion of moving the BoA to different premises should be treated separately from any discussion on institutional reform. The location of the BoA will have no impact on the perception of independence. CA/98/15 refers in paragraph 58 to the perception of independence being lower if the BoA remain in Munich. However, there does not seem to be any problem with having the DPMA and the Bundespatentgericht in Munich or the Dutch Patent Office and the Dutch Courts in The Hague. The UK Intellectual Property Office was not moved to Newport because of any perceived lack of independence of the UK Court. Also, the branch of the Office in The Hague is physically remote from the seat of the Office in Munich but there is no perception that the branch at The Hague is independent of the seat in Munich. It is the institutional legal arrangements which will make the BoA independent of the Office, not any possible physical separation.

"It is the institutional legal arrangements which will make the BoA independent of the Office, not any possible physical separation."Before a decision is taken on premises, as noted above, epi would also suggest that the AC should have a sound view on the legal basis for moving the BoA to a different location, without the need to change either Articles 6 and 7 EPC or the Protocol on Centralisation, epi notes that CA/98/15 does not give any cost estimate for the option of not moving the BoA at all.

Summary

epi continues to support the AC and the Office in their considerations of the structural reform of the BoA and considers that CA/98/15 is a helpful contribution. However, as noted above, epi considers that there are still areas where further detailed analysis is needed, epi looks forward to contributing further to the analysis at the forthcoming AC meeting.

epi repeats that, in the medium term, the way to improve the situation of the BoA is to fill the unfilled posts so that the BoA have the appropriate technical skills to decide on the large backlog of cases it already has.

Yours sincerely,

Tony Tangena

President



Will the EPO and its AC buddies (often acting more like the President's lapdogs) take this letter seriously or will they continue to disregard input even from the stakeholders who pay the EPO? This is getting serious and rapidly becoming too much to be bearable. ⬆

Recent Techrights' Posts

IBM "Efficiency" is Working One's Way to the Bottom of the Remuneration Scale While Hiding the Stealth Layoffs
People still leaving
Forbes Already Stopped Being a News Site. Now It's a Spam and Propaganda Platform for "Paying Partners" (Companies).
news from Forbes became very scarce
Soap Opera of NVIDIA Marketing in Mainstream Media (Overhyped GPUs and Mindless Buzzwords)
NVIDIA's shares lost about $100 in "value" (or 40% "market cap" decline) in 6-7 weeks
The Boss of Linus Torvalds Has Bad Taste, Takes More Money Connected to Traffickers of Underage Girls for Sexual Exploitation Under the Guise of "Tackling Fraud"
Nothing will ever teach Jim Zemlin that Jeffrey Epstein is bad [...] Even the wife of Mr. Epsteingate was wise enough to keep a distance from it. But not Mr. Zemlin, who profits from rehabilitating abusers.
 
Links 20/11/2026: "Anthropic IPO [Shows] the AI Bubble Finally Popping" and New Problems With Slop Copyright Infringement
Links for the day
Richard Stallman, Founder of the GNU Project and a Co-founder of the FSF, Still Working With the FSF to Abolish Microsoft's Restricted Boot
Jack M. Germain has just published a lengthy article about GNU Boot
GNU/Linux Has Gained a Lot in Western Europe
Eastern Europe is another matter
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Thursday, November 19, 2026
IRC logs for Thursday, November 19, 2026
It's All About Restricted Boot and Microsoft
Garrett is working with Microsoft staff towards Microsoft agenda
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXXVII - UK Isn't Part of the US or Russia
We have plenty to cover in the coming years
Update on Pocock v. Software in the Public Interest, Inc. (26-1766)
Case reassigned
Calling Frauds "Frauds" is Not Illegal
We are still getting the same vibe; Americans do not understand free speech, even if their country has a First Amendment
Everything is "AI" Now
"More Open Than Open [...] I am constantly amazed at the flexibility of this single word.”
Microsoft Web Sites Paint Mass Layoffs as Opportunities for Those Impacted, Mass Layoffs Alleged to Follow in January (to 'Kill Off' Survivors)
Keeping Up Appearances
Microsoft Outages Accelerate Migrations to Free Software
More than one major outage lately
Richard Stallman's Talks Next Month (Tech de Ciudad de México)
Right now is a very good time to promote Software Freedom because of recent world events
WSJ Leadership Institute as Marketing Spam for Slop and GAFAM/IBM PR
What the heck is "WSJ Leadership Institute"?
Links 19/11/2026: "So Many Crucial Services Are Going Down" and "Government Tech Debt is a National Security Risk" (Outages Blamed on Slop Frenzy)
Links for the day
Gemini Links 19/11/2026: Friends, Slop Harms Learning, and IBM Plex Lagrange Fontpacks
Links for the day
Links 19/11/2026: "Ignorance Has Taken Over" and "Apocalypse Now, Again"
Links for the day
Richard Stallman Still Insists "They" is Plural, Suggests "Perse" Instead
this week
New Video Explains Why Software Patents Are Evil ("Why Software Patents Spark So Much Frustration")
Maybe some patent examiners (who don't mind a Facebook URL) can take a look
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXXVI - Never Showing Up for Their Own Hearings, Just Paying Hired Guns in London to Act as Fall Guys and Proxies With No Comprehension of the Technical Issues (and Sometimes by Bullying Our Lawyers)
Without any qualifications in the subject at hand
Compatible With Software of 30 Years Ago
Old is not bad, sometimes old is better
NVIDIA Corporation Does Not Look Healthy
The bubble will be hard to re-inflate
Gemini Links 19/11/2026: Thinking About Thinking and Discord
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, November 18, 2026
IRC logs for Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Lots of IBM Layoffs in Slovakia This Year
Slovakia and Europe at large
There May be Little or No Future for IBM Consulting
IBM is believed to be run by parasites
At Least Three RMS Talks Next Month in Mexico (Richard Stallman Has 8+ Talks in a Month)
And also - possibly with slop - in social control media
Mass Layoffs at Salesforce Foretold by Techrights
Salesforce is dead meat and it's not alone
Gemini Links 18/11/2026: Creativity, MFA Hype, and Presto Music
Links for the day
Links 18/11/2026: More GAFAM/Apple 'Clown Computing' Outages and Deutsche Bank Leak, Banks' Downtimes
Links for the day
Today The Register MS Showed Loyalty to the Pyramid Scheme With Homage of Paid Spam About "AI"
The Register MS is disavowed by its founder, who died a few years ago (The Register MS didn't even mention this)
Staff Union of the European Patent Office (SUEPO) Plans General Assembly Next Week, Vote Planned to Approve 7+ More Months of Strikes
The "Agenda" is the same as what we showed yesterday, but the pattern of the actions varies somewhat
IBM's Red Hat a Microsoft Reseller (Second Day in a Row)
If you want a replacement for Microsoft, look somewhere other than Red Hat
After the Bubble Pops the "AI Experts" (Formerly "Data Scientists" or Whatever) Will Rebrand Themselves Again
Remember blockchains and metaverse?
Links 18/11/2026: "Fossil Fuel Companies Are Undermining Democracy" and "Lawyer Up, Elon"
Links for the day
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXXV - Acts of Hypocrisy (Doing What You Accuse Others of Doing)
connected to my criticism of "Restricted Boot"
Mainstream and Establishment Media Trying to Connect "Open Source" to White-Collar Crimes and Scandals at Fraudulent NVIDIA
An associate us said that "MIT lies to smear OSS"
Lawfare Will Continue in 2027
We're dealing with defiant Microsofters who wrongly assume that accurate reporting that causes them distress somehow makes them entitled to money
On the Concept of Moral Obligations to Make the World a Better Place for Everybody
The world generally becomes better when more people challenge the status quo rather than bow down to masters
Nadella Talks About 60,000 Microsoft Workers Having to Decide Whether to Leave (in the Next 2-3 Weeks), They've Been Put on Notice
Some parts of Microsoft are poised for severe cuts
IBM Moved From Selling Technology to Selling Its Buildings
IBM is trying very hard to silence/crush critics
Staff Union of the European Patent Office (SUEPO) Looking to Extend Industrial Actions and Strikes to Almost 1.5 Years
It says a lot about the media that for 1.5 years staff is on strike in the second-largest organisation in Europe and the media pretends it's not happening
Richard Stallman's Talk in Quito This Week (At Least 5 Talks After That)
He's having a busy end of year
Gemini Links 18/11/2026: "Love For Old Devices" and New Software/Slop-ware Releases
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, November 17, 2026
IRC logs for Tuesday, November 17, 2026