Bonum Certa Men Certa

“EPO Enlarged Board of Appeal Has Brought an Unprecedented Level of Certainty to the Law,” But Benoît Battistelli Crushes It

A shocked Battistelli
Context: The Boards of Appeal Openly Complain (in the EPO's Web Site) About Battistelli, But Don't Tell Battistelli About It...



Summary: The systematic erosion of patent quality at the EPO, including attacks on the appeal boards, means less patent justice in the rest of Europe, even in the Supreme Court of Britain

YESTERDAY, only a few days after shaming strikers, the EPO released a pile of lies (warning: epo.org link) that we already debunked in many articles several months ago. These were paid-for lies -- a hallmark of the Battistelli regime. They try to pretend that everything is OK and that things are improving. The reality is, many people are leaving (management also) and patent quality declined so fast that even applications the USPTO would reject are being accepted by the EPO.



"They try to pretend that everything is OK and that things are improving. The reality is, many people are leaving (management also) and patent quality declined so fast that even applications the USPTO would reject are being accepted by the EPO."Yesterday morning we used the term "Gold Standard" and someone later used it as well, essentially by asking, "where is the EPO's Gold Standard now?" As Mr. Battistelli basically turned the EPO into rubbish (in many respects, ranging from working conditions to patent quality), calling the EPO "gold" anything would make no sense, except maybe the gold diggers that Team Battistelli became.

We've gone though the comments thread at IP Kat and highlighted the relevant bits below:



I too am worried about the Art 54(3) point. If a claim defining "sodium" now encompasses in its scope "potassium", how should an applicant formulate his claim to be clear of Art 54(3) art disclosing potassium, but not sodium? Or now does the test of "disclosure" have now to encompass that which is directly and unambiguously disclosed and also Improver equivalents thereto? Or, put another way, where is the EPO's Gold Standard now?

How do the Germans sort this out, with their DoE?

MaxDrei?


I would agree with LordBeefBurger and the GuestKat that this judgement is quite surprising.

When considering that the original disclosure only relates to disodium, stating that dipotassium also falls under the scope of the claims, would mean that actually in such a situation the applicant/proprietor could amend its specification after filing in order to envisage any other salts which were not specifically disclosed in the original application.

Even if one would not adopt the strict approach of the BA of the EPO, there is no doubt that such an amendment would plainly offend Art 123(2) EPC.

When one looks at the contribution to the art, the proprietor has only disclosed the association of permetrexed disodium with vitamin B12 or a pharmaceutical derivative thereof, and nothing else. There is well a general statement in €§ [0005] and [0022] of the patent referring to antifolates as a class associated with a methylmalonic acid lowering agent as vitamin B12. But that’s it.

All further statements in the patent refer exclusively to permetrexed disodium. See for example €§ [0010], [0011], [0016], [0034], [0039], [0045] or [0047] of the patent specification. The judgement refers to some of those €§, but then takes a different route.

The limitation to permetrexed disodium is thus a clear choice of the proprietor. Why the proprietor should then be allowed to obtain protection for something he has not invented? I fully agree with LordBeefBurger “that "disodium" is not a term amenable to variation in practice”. It cannot be compared with “vertical” in Catnic.

The problem with Art 2 of the Protocol on Art 69 in EPC 2000 is that, although it mentions equivalents, the diplomatic conference was not able to reach an agreement on the definition of what is an equivalent. The EPO had made proposals to this effect, but no agreement could be reached. Taking pretext of this new article in the Protocol to go as far as here is quite daring and certainly not enhancing certainty in UK.

One gets the feeling that the mistake done in the Epilady case had to be corrected and a more lenient stance adopted. And for this it was convenient to rely on Art 2 of the Protocol.

The judgement might look interesting, but it should remain a one-off, as in my opinion it totally disregards the actual contribution to art by the proprietor.


I think that now we are Brexiting we can return to formulating our own unique case law and making our purposive construction doctrine broader, without needing to worry about the way Europe or the EPO look at claim language.

The EPO have increasingly viewed the 'invention' as the literal claim scope since getting rid of the Snackfood test (https://www.epo.org/law-practice/case-law-appeals/recent/t880073ep1.html)

At least the UK can now go back to reconsidering claims and inventions based on essential and non-essential features, and not let limitations relating to non-essential features get in the way of catching infringers using the same the invention.


Still not had time to read through the decision but let that not stop me indulging myself with a rant.

Through the second half of my long career as a patent agent/attorney, I have defended "purposive construction" against the notion of "infringement by equivalent". The notion that the claim means the same, whether for validity or infringement, is precious to me. You know, the notion that "What comes after, and infringes, if coming before, anticipates". You know, the notion that the Act provides only one sort of infringement and there is no justification to debate whether any given act of infringement is "direct" infringement or infringement "by equivalent".

I remember at a Seminar about 20 years ago, when discussing not Improver but HILTI, speaker Nick Pumfrey cautioned me that such a notion might seem to me unassailable while being simultaneously given no houseroom at all, on The Continent.

What chance does the UK SC have, of getting to the right result, when both sides are represented by professional litigators for whom, the more legal uncertainty there is, the more money they can make? Who is there to point out to the judges the perils and unwisdom of overturning a century of established patent law? One would like to think that the wisdom of the vastly experienced patent judges in the High Court and Court of Appeal would carry more weight. But no, weight is instead given to the jurisprudence of non-specialist, indeed generalist, judges in the civil law jurisdictions of Continental Europe, for whom Binding Precedent is what you find on a Different Planet, but not on grounded Earth.

There are ways and means, in civil law jurisdictions, to live with legal uncertainty. See how the EPO Enlarged Board of Appeal has brought an unprecedented level of certainty to the law of novelty, obviousness, clarity, added matter, sufficiency, Convention priority. Poisoning an English law jurisdiction with a near fatal dose of it though and what do you get? Litigate like in America? Do you know over there how to construe a claim, or what is or is not definite, enabled, enjoys sufficient written description, entitled to priority, old or obvious?

Somebody asked me about Germany. I'm not qualified to advise. But here is a thought to play with, nevertheless. Take the claim, construe it (purposively, if you will) assess validity, assess if there is "direct" infringement. You are nearly done.

Just one more thing, equivalence. Is it "fair" to go outside the claim scope, to nail the infringer? Would it do un"reasonable" damage to "legal certainty" so to nail the infringer? If not, nail him.

But what if he has a Gillette Defence, that his act, whether or not it touches validity of the claim as you have construed it, is nevertheless no more than an obvious variant of the prior art. In Germany, it works. They call it their "Formstein" defence.

HILTI by the way was the case in which a Swiss patentee litigated its patent all over EPC-land. It lost in every jurisdiction bar one. But the reasons were different in each jurisdiction. Which was the one jurisdiction in which it prevailed. Go on, you can probably guess: their home jurisdiction CH.

There is a lot wrong with Europe. We should harmonise. I suppose that's what the SC in this case has in mind. but was the sacrifice worth it?

BTW, does any reader remember the Chef America case about the bread-making oven. The claim recited heating the dough "to" 400€°F when they meant baking it "at" 400€°F, that is, an oven temperature of 400€°F. How to construe that claim then, to be "fair" to its owner. With purposive construction, no problem. But how does one apply a "Doctrine of Equivalents" to such a claim element? I for one lament the sacrifice of purposive construction on the international altar of the appalling DoE.


It needs to be remembered that one purpose of Supreme Court decisions in all jurisdictions is for basic principles of case law to be invented or substantially changed, and then the lower courts and patent offices need to deal with the fallout on individual future cases. The take home message here is that it is time to reconsider how we are going to deal with equivalents.

As the previous comments have pointed out the present decision will cause issues in validity, and the next 10 years will be a sort of experiment as to how the patent system deals with that. Perhaps validity does need to get stricter in some way, and if that leads to narrower (literal) claim scope on granted patents that might benefit the system in the long run.


This means that the scope of protection for infringement goes beyond the meaning of the claim, but the test for novelty uses only the meaning of the claim without the extra scope provided for infringement. So a granted patent covers more than what it had to overcome in order to be granted.

It's not the judgement's fault - the problem is with paragraph 2 of the Protocol to Art 69 which sets up this situation. The judge has simply applied what it says rather than trying to come up with a way to ignore it (as in Kirin Amgen).

I would argue that "a fair protection for the patent proprietor with a reasonable degree of legal certainty for third parties" (from paragraph 1 of the Protocol) can only be achieved by NOT having a doctrine of equivalents, as having a different scope of protection for infringement than for interpretation of novelty is not fair. But that makes the "due account" to be taken of equivalents from paragraph 2 of the Protocol be "no account" of equivalents! That interpretation is clearly unreasonable so we must take some account of equivalents when considering infringement and must therefore allow patents to cover more than what the claims state.

It's a sad place to be but that's the law our country has signed up to with EPC 2000.


The Protocol only relates to the scope of protection conferred by the claims, and it does not apply to the issue of validity. The law therefore accepts that a patent claim may encompass what has gone before. It is valid, but infringed.

Had the Lilly case been an example of such a situation (i.e. the prior art disclosed the potassium salt) the judges may have been more aware of the implications of their poor judgement, and may have tread more wearily. In the present case, a claim literally covering the potassium salt (i.e. the claim used the word 'potassium' in big bold letters with flashing lights and dancing nubile naked dancers pointing at it) would have been valid on the grounds of novelty and inventive step and sufficiency, but such a claim would have been rejected for added matter.

When watching sections of the Supreme Court hearing, I got the impression that most of the judges had no grasp of the issues or understanding of patent law. A couple of judges, including Neuberger, fared better, but still they showed a dangerous ignorance in many of their questions.

Re Snackfood's comment: Brexit doesn't come into it. You sound like one of the Supreme Court judges.

I am, myself, looking forward to some more original insight from the Beefburger. Copy and Paste, M'Lud? Can you advise us to follow the US attorney strategy in future? "Draft narrow, claim broad"? Is 'Observer' correct that the judgement should remain a one-off? Or would my Learned Friend advise that a decision of the Supreme Court is no such thing? Pray tell!


I am going to go against the grain of the earlier comments and say that this decision seems to make sense. There has long been a disconnect between Article 69 and UK law. This decision seems to address it, without going through the intellectual hooplah of Kirin-Amgen. While Kirin-Amgen is superficially beautifully simple as Lord Neuberger says here, it does not answer the question of equivalents which fall outside any reasonable interpretation of the claim.

As for "file wrapper estoppel" (note, it isn't even called that) the judgement is clear: it can only be useful when it is useful.


We expect a lot more to be said about this decision in the coming days. We wrote about it yesterday and not so many people have read the decision yet. ⬆

Recent Techrights' Posts

IBM "Efficiency" is Working One's Way to the Bottom of the Remuneration Scale While Hiding the Stealth Layoffs
People still leaving
Forbes Already Stopped Being a News Site. Now It's a Spam and Propaganda Platform for "Paying Partners" (Companies).
news from Forbes became very scarce
Soap Opera of NVIDIA Marketing in Mainstream Media (Overhyped GPUs and Mindless Buzzwords)
NVIDIA's shares lost about $100 in "value" (or 40% "market cap" decline) in 6-7 weeks
The Boss of Linus Torvalds Has Bad Taste, Takes More Money Connected to Traffickers of Underage Girls for Sexual Exploitation Under the Guise of "Tackling Fraud"
Nothing will ever teach Jim Zemlin that Jeffrey Epstein is bad [...] Even the wife of Mr. Epsteingate was wise enough to keep a distance from it. But not Mr. Zemlin, who profits from rehabilitating abusers.
 
KDE is Good for Everybody
If Plasma isn't for "beginners", then why does does Valve made it the sole default in SteamOS/Steam Deck and why is it still around after 30+ years without any major controversy?
US Office of Government Ethics: NVIDIA Insider Trading by the Dictator of the US, Stock Soon 50% Below Its Value in October
It's just a rigged market, taxpayers are forced to pay for it (to bail out 'shy' billionaires)
Microsoft Morale Low, Drives Workers Crazy
Only a total moron with no grasp of technology would believe the catch-all excuse
No, IBM Didn't Lay Off Just "Hundreds" in 2026
These companies are rapidly shrinking. They just know how to hide what's really going on.
Slopapers: The Issue of Slop 'Wallpapers' Flooding the Repository in KDE and More
it's just an excuse that calls fusion (without attribution or any mention of a licence) "training" or "hey hi" or "fair use" or "superintelligence"
Links 20/11/2026: "Anthropic IPO [Shows] the AI Bubble Finally Popping" and New Problems With Slop Copyright Infringement
Links for the day
Richard Stallman, Founder of the GNU Project and a Co-founder of the FSF, Still Working With the FSF to Abolish Microsoft's Restricted Boot
Jack M. Germain has just published a lengthy article about GNU Boot
GNU/Linux Has Gained a Lot in Western Europe
Eastern Europe is another matter
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Thursday, November 19, 2026
IRC logs for Thursday, November 19, 2026
It's All About Restricted Boot and Microsoft
Garrett is working with Microsoft staff towards Microsoft agenda
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXXVII - UK Isn't Part of the US or Russia
We have plenty to cover in the coming years
Update on Pocock v. Software in the Public Interest, Inc. (26-1766)
Case reassigned
Calling Frauds "Frauds" is Not Illegal
We are still getting the same vibe; Americans do not understand free speech, even if their country has a First Amendment
Everything is "AI" Now
"More Open Than Open [...] I am constantly amazed at the flexibility of this single word.”
Microsoft Web Sites Paint Mass Layoffs as Opportunities for Those Impacted, Mass Layoffs Alleged to Follow in January (to 'Kill Off' Survivors)
Keeping Up Appearances
Microsoft Outages Accelerate Migrations to Free Software
More than one major outage lately
Richard Stallman's Talks Next Month (Tech de Ciudad de México)
Right now is a very good time to promote Software Freedom because of recent world events
WSJ Leadership Institute as Marketing Spam for Slop and GAFAM/IBM PR
What the heck is "WSJ Leadership Institute"?
Links 19/11/2026: "So Many Crucial Services Are Going Down" and "Government Tech Debt is a National Security Risk" (Outages Blamed on Slop Frenzy)
Links for the day
Gemini Links 19/11/2026: Friends, Slop Harms Learning, and IBM Plex Lagrange Fontpacks
Links for the day
Links 19/11/2026: "Ignorance Has Taken Over" and "Apocalypse Now, Again"
Links for the day
Richard Stallman Still Insists "They" is Plural, Suggests "Perse" Instead
this week
New Video Explains Why Software Patents Are Evil ("Why Software Patents Spark So Much Frustration")
Maybe some patent examiners (who don't mind a Facebook URL) can take a look
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXXVI - Never Showing Up for Their Own Hearings, Just Paying Hired Guns in London to Act as Fall Guys and Proxies With No Comprehension of the Technical Issues (and Sometimes by Bullying Our Lawyers)
Without any qualifications in the subject at hand
Compatible With Software of 30 Years Ago
Old is not bad, sometimes old is better
NVIDIA Corporation Does Not Look Healthy
The bubble will be hard to re-inflate
Gemini Links 19/11/2026: Thinking About Thinking and Discord
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, November 18, 2026
IRC logs for Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Lots of IBM Layoffs in Slovakia This Year
Slovakia and Europe at large
There May be Little or No Future for IBM Consulting
IBM is believed to be run by parasites
At Least Three RMS Talks Next Month in Mexico (Richard Stallman Has 8+ Talks in a Month)
And also - possibly with slop - in social control media
Mass Layoffs at Salesforce Foretold by Techrights
Salesforce is dead meat and it's not alone
Gemini Links 18/11/2026: Creativity, MFA Hype, and Presto Music
Links for the day
Links 18/11/2026: More GAFAM/Apple 'Clown Computing' Outages and Deutsche Bank Leak, Banks' Downtimes
Links for the day
Today The Register MS Showed Loyalty to the Pyramid Scheme With Homage of Paid Spam About "AI"
The Register MS is disavowed by its founder, who died a few years ago (The Register MS didn't even mention this)
Staff Union of the European Patent Office (SUEPO) Plans General Assembly Next Week, Vote Planned to Approve 7+ More Months of Strikes
The "Agenda" is the same as what we showed yesterday, but the pattern of the actions varies somewhat
IBM's Red Hat a Microsoft Reseller (Second Day in a Row)
If you want a replacement for Microsoft, look somewhere other than Red Hat
After the Bubble Pops the "AI Experts" (Formerly "Data Scientists" or Whatever) Will Rebrand Themselves Again
Remember blockchains and metaverse?
Links 18/11/2026: "Fossil Fuel Companies Are Undermining Democracy" and "Lawyer Up, Elon"
Links for the day
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXXV - Acts of Hypocrisy (Doing What You Accuse Others of Doing)
connected to my criticism of "Restricted Boot"
Mainstream and Establishment Media Trying to Connect "Open Source" to White-Collar Crimes and Scandals at Fraudulent NVIDIA
An associate us said that "MIT lies to smear OSS"
Lawfare Will Continue in 2027
We're dealing with defiant Microsofters who wrongly assume that accurate reporting that causes them distress somehow makes them entitled to money
On the Concept of Moral Obligations to Make the World a Better Place for Everybody
The world generally becomes better when more people challenge the status quo rather than bow down to masters
Nadella Talks About 60,000 Microsoft Workers Having to Decide Whether to Leave (in the Next 2-3 Weeks), They've Been Put on Notice
Some parts of Microsoft are poised for severe cuts
IBM Moved From Selling Technology to Selling Its Buildings
IBM is trying very hard to silence/crush critics
Staff Union of the European Patent Office (SUEPO) Looking to Extend Industrial Actions and Strikes to Almost 1.5 Years
It says a lot about the media that for 1.5 years staff is on strike in the second-largest organisation in Europe and the media pretends it's not happening
Richard Stallman's Talk in Quito This Week (At Least 5 Talks After That)
He's having a busy end of year
Gemini Links 18/11/2026: "Love For Old Devices" and New Software/Slop-ware Releases
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, November 17, 2026
IRC logs for Tuesday, November 17, 2026