Bonum Certa Men Certa

Gervase Markham Outlines the Case Against Software Patents

Gervase Markham
By Didyktile, licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International license.



Summary: "Innovation in software proceeds at a rapid pace, and does not need the “encouragement” of patents," explains Markham

The former Governator at the Mozilla Corporation, Gervase Markham (the programmer, not the poet), has something to say about software patents. "In 2006," according to Wikipedia, "he won a Google-O'Reilly Open Source Award as "Best Community Activist" [...] and has been undergoing treatment for metastatic adenoid cystic carcinoma."

"As we have stressed so many times before, almost every software developer is against software patents."We were very saddened to learn some months ago that his time alive might be very limited. His words about software patents are therefore more critical/important to preserve.

Spotted via the blog (in Planet Mozilla) of the developer, Gervase Markham, was this piece titled "A Case for the Total Abolition of Software Patents" (later mentioned in Soylent News as well). "A little while back," it says, "I wrote a piece outlining the case for the total abolition (or non-introduction) of software patents, as seen through the lens of “promoting innovation”. Few of the arguments are new, but the “Narrow Road to Patent Goodness” presentation of the information is quite novel as far as I know, and may form a good basis for anyone trying to explain all the possible problems with software (or other) patents."

From the introduction:

Very few software patents make it down the road to patent goodness. The vast majority cost the company money to file and then lie gathering dust, acting only to provide a vague chilling effect on innovation in that area for those brave enough to do a patent search. A few become famous and tie up an enormous amount of industry and lawyer time and money. And almost none achieve that fabled goal of protecting the small inventor from the large rapacious company which wants to “steal his idea” and leave him penniless. If you add to that poor hit-rate the negative systemic effects from having a software patent system, it seems to me that the conclusion becomes obvious. Innovation in software proceeds at a rapid pace, and does not need the “encouragement” of patents. Software patents are a problem for the industry now, and will only be a bigger one in the future. We should work to end them.


We are going to keep this archived in case the domain expires in the future. As we have stressed so many times before, almost every software developer is against software patents. Patent law firms don't like to talk about it.

Recent Techrights' Posts

Claim That Finance and HR at IBM Already Work on the Next Wave of IBM Layoffs, Media Silence Persists
The media is still telling misleading nonsense about IBM layoffs (like some fantasy about 'rehiring' thousands for "AI")
Claims of More IBM Layoffs a Week Before 'Christmas Week'
Of course, as usual, nobody in the media says anything
 
The Register MS Does the "AI" Keyword Stuffing Because It Gets Paid to Do "AI" Keyword Stuffing
They are in effect profiting from legitimisation and promotion of a Ponzi scheme
Blogs to Read (or Even Binge on) When You Look for a Daring and Different Perspective
If you have free time and want to check out interesting old articles/posts, consider these people
Paying the Price for IBM's Leadership Buying Worthless Companies With Capital It Doesn't Have
For some people the last day at the company is Christmas Eve
When Malformed RSS or Atom Feeds Clog Up (or Even Crash) Programs
RSS readers are an excellent way to keep on top of news online
Publication Plans for the Coming Weeks
We've begun this week with many articles and plan to carry on until tomorrow
EPO People Power - Part XIV - EPO Management Living in Fantasy Land
wrongly assumes that any crime committed by the EPO will always be brushed aside
Secret Code is Undesirable
If someone wants you to use proprietary software, say no. Secret code is even worse.
Google News Still Has an LLM Slop Problem (With Slop Images Too), But Google Itself is a Pusher of Slop
If Google keeps shilling and selling slop as "AI", and moreover if people keep hating slop (there's growing awareness of this problem), then at the end Google will suffer greatly
Gemini Links 16/12/2025: Bingo Card and i586 in 2025
Links for the day
Links 16/12/2025: Security and Conflict (No Territorial Concessions in Ukraine)
Links for the day
With Half of December Over, FSF Two-Thirds of the Way Towards Funding Goal
If you can share some money this month, the FSF should be a priority
A Lot of People Don't Want "Smart" (Things That Spy, Stop Working, Cannot be Repaired Easily)
They also don't want slop disguised as "intelligence"
Links 16/12/2025: More GAFAM (Now Amazon) Layoffs and iRobot Chapter 11
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Monday, December 15, 2025
IRC logs for Monday, December 15, 2025
Wrapping Up and Ending "Slopwatch"
An "end-of-life" improvement
Gemini Links 15/12/2025: How We Lost Communication to Entertainment, Dichotomy Between the Real and the Digital
Links for the day
The New Chief Editor at The Register MS is a Microsofter, Now They Increase Microsoft Coverage and Add Microsoft Slant to 'Linux' Coverage
Did Microsoft pay some more?
GAFAM "doesn't depend on any sort of lock-in, humans just don't want to be free anymore," according to MinceR
As many readers are aware, our criticism of UEFI (restricted boot in particular) attracted a lot of online harassment against us, including stalking and libel
IBM Layoffs in India and IBM's CEO Spins His Lack of Market Share as a Strength
If this leadership carries on, the only red left at IBM won't be Red Hat but a red stain
Links 15/12/2025: "Life in Prison" for Criticising China, Tikhanovskaya Says 'Pressure Works'
Links for the day
Due to 'Secure Boot' (An Anti-Security Measure, a Kill Switch) Computer Users Are Afraid of GNU/Linux
This is what Microsoft wanted
'Crypto' 'Currencies' Are a Ponzi Scheme. So Is "AI". Both Destroy the Planet, Not Just the Economy.
Believe it or not, millions of these GPUs just sit there boxed, unopened, unconnected, unused
The Register MS Has Just Been Paid to Promote the Ponzi Scheme Some More ("AI" Keyword Stuffing)
This won't end well for The Register MS
Microsoft Colonialism in Africa is Not Sustainable
Microsoft's situation in Nigeria is not
Perpetuating the Lie of "No Red Hat Layoffs" Because of the Bluewashing (Red Hat Became Just "IBM")
Many Red Hat employees were pushed out and/or removed lately
EPO People Power - Part XIII - If the EPO's Chief Propagandist (Berenguer) Told the Police He Was a Spanish Tourist (or Similar) or That He Does Not Reside in Munich, Then He May Have Lied to the Police (in Addition to Doing Cocaine in Public)
Lying to the police in Germany is a criminal offense
Links 15/12/2025: Chromebooks as Work Machines, "Americans [Who] Moved to Australia" to Avoid Cheeto
Links for the day
Breaking Your Proprietary Router in the Name of "Security"
Each time they "patch" the router something that previously worked OK is likely to just break
IBM May be Breaking the Law to Silence Staff It Laid Off
Observation to add regarding IBM layoffs
Demonisation Attacks on Richard Matthew Stallman (RMS) - Including Antisemitic Attacks - Have Not Worked
Name-calling doesn't work
Slop ("AI") Will Replace People and Take Away Jobs, Say the Slopfarms With Fake (LLM-Generated) Text and Slop Images
"AI" often means slave labour in a poor country
More Than a Million Bytes Should be Enough for Most Computer Programs
Who said computing would improve over time?
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, December 14, 2025
IRC logs for Sunday, December 14, 2025
Another "AI" (Slop) Use Cases Turns Out to be a Fraud
Those who talk about this fraud get SLAPPed
They Say Rules Are Made to be Broken, at Microsoft That Became an Imperative (e.g. Accounting Fraud, Bribery and So on)
Its biggest client is itself
In Russia, Microsoft is Already a Dying Breed Online
A lot of Europe also dumps Microsoft. Europe is a big revenue source of Microsoft.
The Future of News on the World Wide Web
No "greener pastures" on the Web
𝐈𝐁𝐌 𝐂𝐄𝐎 𝐀𝐫𝐯𝐢𝐧𝐝 𝐊𝐫𝐢𝐬𝐡𝐧𝐚: Proof That at IBM People Fall Upwards
IBM is collapsing
EPO People Power - Part XII - The Mobbing Got So Bad People Were Unable to Work
What's at stake here isn't just the EPO or the patent system
Links 14/12/2025: "Chile to ban smartphones in classroom" and "Portugal updates cybercrime law to exempt security researchers"
Links for the day
Gemini Links 14/12/2025: "GUI TUI CLI" and EmacsConf 2025 Video
Links for the day
Links 14/12/2025: Tensions in Asia, US Making Deals With Belarus
Links for the day
A Utopian and Very Dumb Vision of Technology, Based on Accounting Fraud
the "industry" has become insane and a lot of "the media" is going along with it
Links 14/12/2025: "The Slop of Things to Come", Goldman Sachs Nervous About Slop Bubble
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Saturday, December 13, 2025
IRC logs for Saturday, December 13, 2025