Bonum Certa Men Certa

The ILO Tribunal:€ Is It Still Worthy of Our Trust?

The latest EPO FLIER (No. 38), published by staff from the EPO on 22 June 2018 (source: www.epostaff4rights.org), has the title "The ILO Tribunal: Is it still worthy of our trust?"

We reproduce its content here in order to give our readers direct access to it.

Trust



Summary: Trusting ILO-AT has become a lot harder in light of its handling of EPO scandals

 



The Administrative Tribunal (AT) of the International Labour Organization (ILO) is the successor of the League of Nations Administrative Tribunal, created as a judicial tribunal to ensure to officials the firm conviction of safety and security emanating from justice, provide a judge for internal disputes, and preclude the possibility of one of the parties being a judge in his own cause.

For European Patent Office (EPO) labour disputes, the ILO-AT is the only external legal instance.

Extent of jurisdiction

The applicable law, under the ILO-AT Statute1, is formally limited to the terms of appointment and service conditions of the organisation concerned. But the ILO-AT’s case law on this point has been inconsistent; in some judgments, general principles of law and human rights have been considered as additional sources of law, in others they have been excluded2. The Tribunal does not order interim relief. Witnesses can give written statements but their cross-examination is not possible. Since 1989, the ILO-AT has declined to hold any oral hearings. The Tribunal has no means of enforcing judgments.

The Tribunal has recently changed its approach concerning general decisions. While Staff Committee members could, in the past, challenge general decisions directly, it now seems that general decisions (legislative decisions) may no longer be challengeable at all. Concerned employees must now wait until an administrative decision implementing a general decision, eg a career reform, produces a direct adverse effect on them,3 eg through a missed promotion that was due, visible on a payslip. This has as a consequence that every staff member must file an individual appeal instead of a staff committee member filing a model appeal for all. The number of internal appeals has thus since exploded.3 Another consequence is that many general decisions, eg decisions changing governance rules, may no longer be challengeable, even if they are presumably illegal.

Workload issues

The ILO-AT struggles to meet its caseload2,4. In 2015, the Tribunal said: “It is the number of complaints filed against a single organization, the EPO, rather than the rise in the overall number of organizations having accepted its jurisdiction, that represents the main challenge for its effective functioning.”5 At the same time, the Tribunal has made it clear that it has “reached its limits in terms of output” and that it cannot increase it any further “without compromising the quality of its services.”

The Tribunal has recently reasserted that the main challenge to its functioning is the large number of EPO cases4,6. Robin Silverstein reports that the chosen approach to reducing the backlog has affected the quality of the judgments being delivered: “ILOAT staff rush through records of pending cases, and draft hundreds of judgments, dismissing as many cases as possible on technicalities, and glossing over the finer points of those appellant submissions that it accepts.It is a common gripe among appellants that the judgments finally rendered contain anomalies, mischaracterizations and factual errors, and fail to address key claims and legal arguments.”2,7

Until 2014, the Article 7 “summary dismissal procedure” was only rarely used8: Sessions 1-116 (3305 judgments) saw only 19 summary dismissals (0.65%). The Tribunal changed its approach, leading to a rapid processing of a large number of complaints and a corresponding reduction in the size of the backlog. This was achieved without increasing the number of judges or Registry staff4. The report4 of the 332nd Session of the ILO Governing Body is a little ambiguous in its wording, but it gives the impression that it was the goal of the new approach to reduce the case backlog. Sessions 117-125 (676 judgments) saw a striking increase: 124 summary dismissals (15%), 74 of them concern EPO complaints (32%). Summary dismissal denies in fact access to justice.

Independence and impartiality

It has been the subject of some debate whether the ILO-AT is truly independent.2 The Tribunal’s seven judges are appointed on three-year renewable contracts.2 Renewable contracts for judges cast doubt on their independence9. The appointment of the ILO-AT judges is not transparent and there are no clear standards for their minimum professional qualifications3. The Tribunal is financed through fees paid by the defendant organisations on a per-dispute basis10,11. About 60% of the ILO’s caseload comes from just six organisations, about 20% from the EPO alone.

The ILO-AT has had several bilateral talks with the EPO administration – a party in the dispute – without informing or inviting representatives of the appellants8. A March 2016 ILO report12 mentions that two video conferences were held in 2015, “with senior officials from the legal and human resources services” of the EPO, who “highlighted the internal challenges faced by the EPO in a context of ongoing reforms, called for improvements in the Tribunal’s case management in general, and appealed to the understanding of the Tribunal offering financial support if needed.” Written requests13 to involve staff representatives in these talks have apparently been to no avail8. Considering “the functioning and credibility of the Tribunal … at risk”, the ILO’s Director-General arranged a meeting with the EPO President12. To this meeting, which took place in April 2016, he (apparently) also invited the President of the Administrative Tribunal14. But when the Tribunal‘s credibility is at risk, does it help to organise bi-lateral talks with one party to a dispute - while excluding the other party?

The EPO administration informed the Director-General about its “targeted communication campaigns on the Tribunal’s case law, as statistics show that a considerable number of complaints against the EPO are dismissed.”12,15 This measure was positively received at the ILO since it was expected to help reducing the number of complaints filed by EPO staff12. But how can a Tribunal, whose task is to establish justice in labour disputes, welcome measures aiming at discouraging staff members from claiming their rights?

The March 2016 ILO report12 further mentions several communications to the Director-Generalin which president Battistelli gives “an overview of recent disciplinary cases involving staff representatives of the European Patent Office, some of which had resulted in the dismissal of the individuals concerned”, and that “the analysis of the cases referred to the Tribunal indicates that a significant number of complaints stem from strained relations between staff representatives and management.”

A March 2017 ILO report14 lays out that in its March 2016 Resolution16, the Administrative Council had “noted that disciplinary sanctions against staff or trade union representatives were widely questioned in the public opinion”, and that during a meeting in April 2016, the Director-General, the EPO President and the President of the Tribunal had “exchanged views on the situation created by the high number of complaints against the EPO, the root causes of the backlog and possible solutions.” An agreement on certain points “prompted the Director-General’s optimism that real progress could be made in the coming months so as to alleviate the Tribunal’s workload ...”.

The drafting of judgements

For the Tribunal to work efficiently, the cases are prepared by the Registry: “The Registry is tasked with providing technical, factual and legal support to the judges, thus requiring its staff in effect to draft judgments.”2 In 2010, the Registry was staffed by the Registrar and a part-time secretary10. Its current staff also comprises a “small team of legal officers.”17The Tribunal has recently reformed the work of the Registry, so that it is now even “better focused on assisting the judges.”4 The seven judges themselves are generally not familiar with the defendant organisation’s own and very specific sets of rules since they “do no work for the Tribunal on a full-time basis, but usually sit only twice a year for three to four weeks each time,” and “some of them have extremely busy schedules as they are still serving in the supreme courts of their respective countries.”5 The judges will thus not study the full set of submissions but rather rely on the work done by the Registry. The preparatory work of the Registry has thus a significant impact on the decision which will be taken by the judges.

Personal ties

The ILO-AT has issued publications with contributions from members of its member organisations. For example, Laurent Germond, “Director Employment Law” at the EPO, and responsible for legal disputes of staff members with the European Patent Organisation, was invited to make a speech at a symposium18 to celebrate the Tribunal’s 90th anniversary in 2017. His speech can be found in a recent ILO publication19, edited by Mr Dražen Petrović, the Registrar of the Tribunal. Mr Petrović and Mr Germond have been personal friends for a long time20. It may not be a coincidence that Mr Petrović joined the ILO on 1 December 2013 while Mr Germond joined the EPO at the end of 2013. Under the circumstances, the Registrar could naturally have more understanding for the arguments of the defendant organisation than for those of the appellants.

The 126th session

The ILO-AT judges met again from 23 April to 18 May 2018 at the International Labour Office in Geneva. The judgments will be delivered in public on Tuesday, 26 June 2018 at 3 p.m. and published on the Tribunal's website shortly thereafter.

Among the EPO cases judged are those of Elizabeth Hardon, Ion Brumme and Malika Weaver, at the time chair, vice-chair and treasurer respectively of the Munich branch of the EPO’s largest staff union SUEPO. They were collectively suspended (on the same day!). The SUEPO chair and vice-chair were then dismissed, and the treasurer down-graded by president Battistelli – officially for reasons that had nothing to do with their work as staff representatives.

It will be another test of the ILO-AT’s independence. It will show whether the Tribunal will recognise this amazing “coincidence” for what it really is – an attempt to get rid of pesky opponents and to suppress any meaningful dialogue.21

The ILO-AT has the mandate to guarantee that the over 60,000 international civil servants of more than 60 international organisations over which it has jurisdiction can enjoy protection against arbitrary acts committed against them by their employer.17 We fervently hope that it takes its duties seriously. If it does not, the entire legal framework for thousands of staff falls apart. ⬆

__________



2€ Robin Silverstein, REVISITING THE LEGAL BASIS TO DENY INTERNATIONAL CIVIL SERVANTS ACCESS TO A FUNDAMENTAL HUMAN RIGHT, Michigan State International Law Review, Vol. 25.2 (2017)



4€ Functioning of the Administrative Tribunal of the ILO – An update, ILO Governing Body, Programme of the 332nd Session in March 2018



5€ Matters relating to the Administrative Tribunal of the ILO - Workload and effectiveness of the Tribunal, Programme of the 325th Session of the ILO Governing Body (from 29 October to 12 November 2015)



6€ The ILO is working on an amendment to the Tribunal's statute and rules of procedure, apparently with the aim of improving the backlog situation (see B28/6/18), but we are not aware of any details of that on-going process



9€ In a recent decision, the Federal Constitutional Court clarified that the nomination of qualified judges to first instance administrative tribunals for a fixed term is in line with the German constitution, but under the condition that contract renewal is excluded



10€ Matters relating to the Administrative Tribunal of the ILO: Financing of the Tribunal, Programme of the 309th Session of the ILO Governing Body (November 2010)



11€ The costs per case, which vary roughly between 15.000 Euros and 25.000 Euros, are calculated by dividing the “session costs”, which cover expenses for the judges, legal services and translations, by the number of cases dealt with during the session. The major share of the Tribunal’s “overhead costs”, which include the office space and the operational costs of the Registry including staff salaries, have, at least until 2010, been borne by the ILO.



13€ Letter, on behalf of SUEPO, from Schwab, Flaherty & Associés to Guy Ryder, ILO Director-General (23.02.2016)



15€ The glowing reports on ILO-AT sessions by VP5 or the Director Employment Law, which are published in the EPO intranet and in the Gazette, form presumably part of these “targeted campaigns”. You can find an example here.



18€ Symposium in honour of the ILO’s Administrative Tribunal (5 May 2017)



20€ Also “Märpel” has reported about this personal connection; see The best friend of a key man on the R.I.P. Kat blog



 

 

Recent Techrights' Posts

IBM "Efficiency" is Working One's Way to the Bottom of the Remuneration Scale While Hiding the Stealth Layoffs
People still leaving
Forbes Already Stopped Being a News Site. Now It's a Spam and Propaganda Platform for "Paying Partners" (Companies).
news from Forbes became very scarce
Soap Opera of NVIDIA Marketing in Mainstream Media (Overhyped GPUs and Mindless Buzzwords)
NVIDIA's shares lost about $100 in "value" (or 40% "market cap" decline) in 6-7 weeks
The Boss of Linus Torvalds Has Bad Taste, Takes More Money Connected to Traffickers of Underage Girls for Sexual Exploitation Under the Guise of "Tackling Fraud"
Nothing will ever teach Jim Zemlin that Jeffrey Epstein is bad [...] Even the wife of Mr. Epsteingate was wise enough to keep a distance from it. But not Mr. Zemlin, who profits from rehabilitating abusers.
 
Links 20/11/2026: "Anthropic IPO [Shows] the AI Bubble Finally Popping" and New Problems With Slop Copyright Infringement
Links for the day
Richard Stallman, Founder of the GNU Project and a Co-founder of the FSF, Still Working With the FSF to Abolish Microsoft's Restricted Boot
Jack M. Germain has just published a lengthy article about GNU Boot
GNU/Linux Has Gained a Lot in Western Europe
Eastern Europe is another matter
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Thursday, November 19, 2026
IRC logs for Thursday, November 19, 2026
It's All About Restricted Boot and Microsoft
Garrett is working with Microsoft staff towards Microsoft agenda
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXXVII - UK Isn't Part of the US or Russia
We have plenty to cover in the coming years
Update on Pocock v. Software in the Public Interest, Inc. (26-1766)
Case reassigned
Calling Frauds "Frauds" is Not Illegal
We are still getting the same vibe; Americans do not understand free speech, even if their country has a First Amendment
Everything is "AI" Now
"More Open Than Open [...] I am constantly amazed at the flexibility of this single word.”
Microsoft Web Sites Paint Mass Layoffs as Opportunities for Those Impacted, Mass Layoffs Alleged to Follow in January (to 'Kill Off' Survivors)
Keeping Up Appearances
Microsoft Outages Accelerate Migrations to Free Software
More than one major outage lately
Richard Stallman's Talks Next Month (Tech de Ciudad de México)
Right now is a very good time to promote Software Freedom because of recent world events
WSJ Leadership Institute as Marketing Spam for Slop and GAFAM/IBM PR
What the heck is "WSJ Leadership Institute"?
Links 19/11/2026: "So Many Crucial Services Are Going Down" and "Government Tech Debt is a National Security Risk" (Outages Blamed on Slop Frenzy)
Links for the day
Gemini Links 19/11/2026: Friends, Slop Harms Learning, and IBM Plex Lagrange Fontpacks
Links for the day
Links 19/11/2026: "Ignorance Has Taken Over" and "Apocalypse Now, Again"
Links for the day
Richard Stallman Still Insists "They" is Plural, Suggests "Perse" Instead
this week
New Video Explains Why Software Patents Are Evil ("Why Software Patents Spark So Much Frustration")
Maybe some patent examiners (who don't mind a Facebook URL) can take a look
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXXVI - Never Showing Up for Their Own Hearings, Just Paying Hired Guns in London to Act as Fall Guys and Proxies With No Comprehension of the Technical Issues (and Sometimes by Bullying Our Lawyers)
Without any qualifications in the subject at hand
Compatible With Software of 30 Years Ago
Old is not bad, sometimes old is better
NVIDIA Corporation Does Not Look Healthy
The bubble will be hard to re-inflate
Gemini Links 19/11/2026: Thinking About Thinking and Discord
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, November 18, 2026
IRC logs for Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Lots of IBM Layoffs in Slovakia This Year
Slovakia and Europe at large
There May be Little or No Future for IBM Consulting
IBM is believed to be run by parasites
At Least Three RMS Talks Next Month in Mexico (Richard Stallman Has 8+ Talks in a Month)
And also - possibly with slop - in social control media
Mass Layoffs at Salesforce Foretold by Techrights
Salesforce is dead meat and it's not alone
Gemini Links 18/11/2026: Creativity, MFA Hype, and Presto Music
Links for the day
Links 18/11/2026: More GAFAM/Apple 'Clown Computing' Outages and Deutsche Bank Leak, Banks' Downtimes
Links for the day
Today The Register MS Showed Loyalty to the Pyramid Scheme With Homage of Paid Spam About "AI"
The Register MS is disavowed by its founder, who died a few years ago (The Register MS didn't even mention this)
Staff Union of the European Patent Office (SUEPO) Plans General Assembly Next Week, Vote Planned to Approve 7+ More Months of Strikes
The "Agenda" is the same as what we showed yesterday, but the pattern of the actions varies somewhat
IBM's Red Hat a Microsoft Reseller (Second Day in a Row)
If you want a replacement for Microsoft, look somewhere other than Red Hat
After the Bubble Pops the "AI Experts" (Formerly "Data Scientists" or Whatever) Will Rebrand Themselves Again
Remember blockchains and metaverse?
Links 18/11/2026: "Fossil Fuel Companies Are Undermining Democracy" and "Lawyer Up, Elon"
Links for the day
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXXV - Acts of Hypocrisy (Doing What You Accuse Others of Doing)
connected to my criticism of "Restricted Boot"
Mainstream and Establishment Media Trying to Connect "Open Source" to White-Collar Crimes and Scandals at Fraudulent NVIDIA
An associate us said that "MIT lies to smear OSS"
Lawfare Will Continue in 2027
We're dealing with defiant Microsofters who wrongly assume that accurate reporting that causes them distress somehow makes them entitled to money
On the Concept of Moral Obligations to Make the World a Better Place for Everybody
The world generally becomes better when more people challenge the status quo rather than bow down to masters
Nadella Talks About 60,000 Microsoft Workers Having to Decide Whether to Leave (in the Next 2-3 Weeks), They've Been Put on Notice
Some parts of Microsoft are poised for severe cuts
IBM Moved From Selling Technology to Selling Its Buildings
IBM is trying very hard to silence/crush critics
Staff Union of the European Patent Office (SUEPO) Looking to Extend Industrial Actions and Strikes to Almost 1.5 Years
It says a lot about the media that for 1.5 years staff is on strike in the second-largest organisation in Europe and the media pretends it's not happening
Richard Stallman's Talk in Quito This Week (At Least 5 Talks After That)
He's having a busy end of year
Gemini Links 18/11/2026: "Love For Old Devices" and New Software/Slop-ware Releases
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, November 17, 2026
IRC logs for Tuesday, November 17, 2026