Bonum Certa Men Certa

Judges at the EPO (Boards of Appeal) Can Still be Punished for Ruling 'Unfavourably' on Patent Maximalism

When judges are appointed or reappointed for loyalty/agenda things are bound to go south, with decisions acutely distressing

Roland Freisler
His Master's Voice Roland Freisler, Germany's own William Barr



Summary: The EPO follows juridical standards reminiscent of 'third-world countries' and even the German Constitutional Court is raising concerns about it, perhaps recalling a harrowing past of judges as mere extension of the executive (and executing) branch

THE EPO's Central Staff Committee has been very busy during the lock-downs. It wrote a large number of internal publications and circulated letters; while staff was besieged at home the representatives sought to guard the rights of staff. We applaud them for this; the same people who risked firing/defamation from António Campinos had also done that in the Benoît Battistelli era; we see many of the same names (staff trusts these people and re-elects them).



We have not heard about the Boards of Appeal's (BoA) Presidium for a very long time. Years in fact. It's still there, however, along with AMBA and other key bodies which lashed out at Battistelli and Kongstad (the corrupt slaughterer of chinchillas).

Roland Freisler, Franz Schlegelberger, Otto Georg Thierack and Curt Rothenberger"Career System for the Boards of Appeal," as the Central Staff Committee put it, was also discussed. "Consultation in the Presidium" was done as the "Administrative Council ha[d] decided in 2019 that the Presidium of the Boards of Appeal (BoA) should be consulted on any proposal which concerns the conditions of employment of the members and chairs of the Boards, instead of the GCC. The Presidium has now given its (quite interesting) opinion on the Performance Evaluation Guidelines and the Career System for the BoA."

For the uninitiated, every BoA deals with matters of law and compliance (like the EPC), unlike the EPO's examiners, accountable directly to the Office. It's very important that BoA members are well compensated (to attract suitable and competent candidates) and also independent, which they still aren't. We occasionally see the Office meddling in their affairs. This harms their ability to judge independently, so impartiality can no longer be presumed.

Here's what the publication from the Organisation says:

4 May 2020

Presidium’s Opinion on the Performance Evaluation Guidelines and the Career System



Dear Members of the BoAC,

The President of the Boards of Appeal asked the elected members of the Presidium to provide you with advice on the amended performance evaluation guidelines. While the elected members do not have major problems with the few editorial changes with respect to the previous version, they find it appropriate to provide their opinion on the whole document in the broader context of a discussion on amendments to the career system and to the performance evaluation guidelines. We note that Article 9 of the proposed guidelines provides a link between evaluation reports and the career system. In our view, the issues are also so inextricably linked that our main comments belong in a single document.

Summary

We generally welcome a fair and transparent Performance Evaluation System for certain purposes, however we think that the current career system in combination with its Performance Evaluation Guidelines are not suitable for the career development and re-appointment of members of the Boards of Appeal with judicial, in particular final instance judicial functions.

Career System

Although it is hard to explain all the principles, history, issues and problems in a short text, in the following, we try to give a comprehensible summary.

Before the introduction of the new career system, board members were in the A5 grade scale and chairs (then called chairmen) in the A6 grade scale. Step advancement within the grades was automatic (i.e. based on experience), yearly or two-yearly. There was some overlap between the grades. Moving from the post of member (A5) to chair (A6) required a new appointment based on a selection procedure that included a performance assessment and an assessment of the candidate’s suitability for the new post. The functions of members and chairs were clearly separated.

The new Office career system introduced “technical” and a “managerial” career paths, each with a hierarchy of job groups and a corresponding range of non-overlapping grades. Step progression is performance-based, and grade advancement is via a promotion.

Job groupTechnical pathManagerial pathGrade rangeOld grade
Job group 2Principal advisor
Board of appeal chairman
Principal directorG15, step1 –
G16, step 4
A6
Job group 3Senior expert
Board of appeal member
DirectorG13, step 3 –
G15, step 4
A5


All members of the Boards are in the “technical” career path. Members are in job group 3 and chairs in group 2. The previous grades (A5/A6) corresponded to these job groups, but the relevant new grades (G13-G16) are more fine-grained. As a result, there was more than one new grade in each job group and hence a possible promotion within each job group. This still applies to members (see below).

In its December 2014 meeting, the Council approved the new system “on the understanding that the provisions regarding appraisal, performance, step advancement, bonus, promotion and all career-related elements for Council appointees as members of the boards of appeal will not apply until specific provisions have been included in documents concerning the organisation and functioning of DG 3...” (OJ 2015, page 4)

In May 2015, the Presidium and the committee of the Association of the Members of the Boards of Appeal (AMBA) noted this in a letter to the joint DG3/Office Task Force responsible for the institutional reform of the Boards of Appeal. They also offered their view that the provisions presented to the Council should be appropriate for persons exercising a judicial function and should have inter alia:

- No performance-related pay (Nr. 55 of CM/Rec(2010)12), which implies: ● A third career path “Boards of Appeal” with a single grade per function; ● Job profiles with core competencies which are specific to the BoA; ● Seniority based step in grade advancement; ● No bonuses; ● A salary package which will allow the BOA to recruit competent members bothfrom inside and outside the Office.

In September 2015, the Presidium/AMBA met with the Task Force and presented further considerations for an appropriate career system (see Annex 1).

The Office subsequently submitted an orientation paper CA/98/15 on the structural reform. AMBA commented on it in a position paper in December 2015 inter alia as follows:

7. The proposal puts the Boards back in the Office’s “technical” career path (as defined in Art. 47 ServRegs) [24]. The Council recognised this as inappropriate for the Boards, which is why a transitional system was adopted. Not mentioned is the Boards’ paper regarding a career system. The main points were that the principles of judicial independence and security of tenure require that re-appointment should not be based on performance and that all board members (or chairs) do the same job so that proficiency levels and promotion within a job level make no sense and would give a strange impression to the parties. The paper also proposed various scenarios to address these problems, by having grade advancement at re-appointment.

In June 2016, the Council approved the reform of the Boards of Appeal (CA/43/16 Rev.1), which put the members and chairs in the same “technical” career system as examiners, but with a modified progression (paragraphs [31-42] and the changes to the ServRegs in CA/D 8/16). Essentially, members and chairs were assigned the fixed grades G14 step 1 and G16 step 1, respectively. There was no possibility of step advancement and the promotion of members from G14/1 to G15/1 (there is no corresponding provision for chairs) was dependent on a recommendation by the President of the BoA at the same time as reappointment (i.e. once every five years).

This structure was favourable for new members, who would start in the Boards on the grade of G14/1, which corresponded to the old grade of around A5/9, i.e. up to nine years ahead of where they would have been previously. However, it was not so good for experienced members who, being at the same grade, effectively lost around nine years in comparison to new colleagues. Moreover, the only available further advancement was the “promotion” to G15/1, which was conditional on a recommendation determined solely by the President of the BoA.

In July 2016, AMBA commented on this as follows:

Instead of a providing a career system appropriate to a judicial body, the link between grade and performance evaluation for the Technical and Legal members may result in substantial differences in remuneration for members doing essentially the same work. This sort of substantial monetary reward for productivity is unknown in Member States (two or three do have a very small fraction of judges’ salary dependent on appraisal, and they are strongly criticised for it by the CCEJ).

Recently, Germany’s Federal Constitutional Court held, in their decision BVerfG, 2 BvR 780/16, Rdnr. 59 (unofficial translation from the German original) that:

Measures concerning the status of the judge may also be indirect influences on the judicial decision. By limiting such possibilities of influence, the danger of "rewarding" or "punishing" for a certain decision-making behaviour is to be countered....

For this reason, the advancement of judges in the pay grades must be standardised by law and must not be left to the discretion of the executive.

It would be unconstitutional for the administration of justice to have discretion to assign judges with the same office and the same judicial function to posts of different grades.

Furthermore, in order to protect the independence of judges, Article 97 paragraph 1 German constitution (Grundgesetz) contains the fundamental obligation to avoid a hierarchical structuring of the judiciary by creating “Beförderungsämter” (loosely: promotion positions) along the lines of the career development principle under civil service law and to provide for as few promotion positions as possible.

It is our view that the present career system does not respect these basic principles; the advancement is not standardised by law, but is at the sole discretion of the President of the BoA based on his evaluation of performance, there is assignment of members with the same functions to different grades (G14/1 and G15/1), which is a hierarchical structure that follows the Office’s “technical” career path.

The fact that, unlike others in the same job group, members and chairs have no possibility of reaching the final grade and step is a further cause for concern, but is left aside for the purposes of this paper.

Evaluation Guidelines

The President of the BoA has drafted guidelines for the evaluation of the performance of members and chairs (chairmen) of the Boards of Appeal.

However, these do not remove the “discretion on the part of the judicial administration to appoint [Board members] with the same office and the same judicial function to posts of different grades” as objected to in the above noted German constitutional court decision. Rather, they retain the President of the BoA’s sole authority over such discretion. This amounts to what is often referred to as a lack of “internal” independence.

Although the Presidium objects to this lack of internal independence as such, the current system would already be improved if the Guidelines specified how the discretion was to be exercised. This would go some way towards the “standardis[ation] by law” of the advancement in grade. It is regrettable that the Guidelines give no guidance at all, but only refer to the evaluation reports in Article 9(1) and need for at least one assessment of very good in Article 9(3).

The evaluation report templates in the Annex to the Guidelines, in turn, give no guidance in this respect, since, in the definition of the overall grades 1 and 2, there is no explanation of what is meant by contributes greatly or significantly to the performance and functioning of the board (see the explanations under “Overall grade”, Grade 1 and Grade 2 in item 4 of the Annex), or how any objective judgment of this can be made; moreover, in plain English, they are synonymous. As will be recognised, it is the overall grade, and that alone, which is of importance and which determines possible advancement, and this is entirely at the discretion of the President of the BoA.

Further, it will be noted that, in the Annex to the Guidelines, before point 1 (Objectives), the introduction states that the “focus of the performance evaluation shall lie on quality”, and indeed many of the competencies refer to aspects attributable to quality. However, the overall grade which “shall depend on how the individual competencies have been evaluated”, is not based on this, but on unstated criteria concerning the contribution to the performance and functioning of the Board, leading to an unpredictable result. An example of this is the inexplicable discrepancy in the promotion rate of legally and technically qualified members.

It should also be understood that the President of the BoA, who exercises discretion on the overall grade, is faced with input from chairs who each evaluate their own Board members without knowing what standard other chairs are using in their evaluations. Simply put, one chair might evaluate their members as “very good” while another chair might evaluate their members as “sufficient”, although performance is essentially equal. Thus, even the evaluations provided by the individual chairs will not provide the President of the BoA with the information needed to exercise discretion in an objective manner.

Conclusion

The elected members of the Presidium, the autonomous authority within the Boards of Appeal Unit under R. 12(b)(1) EPC, welcome the opportunity of presenting our view on the career system and its application.

In our view, the present career system and its guidelines are not suitable for the promotion and re-appointment of members of the Boards of Appeal with judicial, in particular final instance judicial functions.

We would respectfully ask that you recognise this and consider initiating improvements.

Alternatively, and as a preliminary step, we would invite you, as the Administrative Council’s advisory body in respect of its supervisory duties relating to the BoA (CA/D 7/16, Article 4, paragraph 1), to advise the AC to have an independent review of the system carried out by an appropriate internationally recognised body such as the European Network of Councils for the Judiciary (ENCJ).

Finally, in analogy with the Administrative Council’s rules for staff representatives at council meetings, we would request that two members of the Presidium be present at BoAC meetings to discuss this matter (see Rules of Procedure of the AC, Article 7, paragraph 4.1 and Article 14, paragraph 5, which also applies to the meetings of the BoAC, see CA/D 7/16, Article 3, paragraph 4).

Yours sincerely,

The elected members of the Presidium.


This shows that in legal and practical terms little has improved; Campinos squashed the 'Haar question' and judges never regained their autonomy/independence. Now, as it turns out, the system for promotion (or demotion in the sense of lack of promotion as per a fixed scale, set aside re-appointments) is another way to 'punish' judges who rule the 'wrong' way. This is the pattern of judgments we're accustomed to seeing in primitive nations where law is tied to religion, monarchy, cults and superstitions. ⬆

Recent Techrights' Posts

IBM "Efficiency" is Working One's Way to the Bottom of the Remuneration Scale While Hiding the Stealth Layoffs
People still leaving
Forbes Already Stopped Being a News Site. Now It's a Spam and Propaganda Platform for "Paying Partners" (Companies).
news from Forbes became very scarce
Soap Opera of NVIDIA Marketing in Mainstream Media (Overhyped GPUs and Mindless Buzzwords)
NVIDIA's shares lost about $100 in "value" (or 40% "market cap" decline) in 6-7 weeks
The Boss of Linus Torvalds Has Bad Taste, Takes More Money Connected to Traffickers of Underage Girls for Sexual Exploitation Under the Guise of "Tackling Fraud"
Nothing will ever teach Jim Zemlin that Jeffrey Epstein is bad [...] Even the wife of Mr. Epsteingate was wise enough to keep a distance from it. But not Mr. Zemlin, who profits from rehabilitating abusers.
 
Links 20/11/2026: "Anthropic IPO [Shows] the AI Bubble Finally Popping" and New Problems With Slop Copyright Infringement
Links for the day
Richard Stallman, Founder of the GNU Project and a Co-founder of the FSF, Still Working With the FSF to Abolish Microsoft's Restricted Boot
Jack M. Germain has just published a lengthy article about GNU Boot
GNU/Linux Has Gained a Lot in Western Europe
Eastern Europe is another matter
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Thursday, November 19, 2026
IRC logs for Thursday, November 19, 2026
It's All About Restricted Boot and Microsoft
Garrett is working with Microsoft staff towards Microsoft agenda
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXXVII - UK Isn't Part of the US or Russia
We have plenty to cover in the coming years
Update on Pocock v. Software in the Public Interest, Inc. (26-1766)
Case reassigned
Calling Frauds "Frauds" is Not Illegal
We are still getting the same vibe; Americans do not understand free speech, even if their country has a First Amendment
Everything is "AI" Now
"More Open Than Open [...] I am constantly amazed at the flexibility of this single word.”
Microsoft Web Sites Paint Mass Layoffs as Opportunities for Those Impacted, Mass Layoffs Alleged to Follow in January (to 'Kill Off' Survivors)
Keeping Up Appearances
Microsoft Outages Accelerate Migrations to Free Software
More than one major outage lately
Richard Stallman's Talks Next Month (Tech de Ciudad de México)
Right now is a very good time to promote Software Freedom because of recent world events
WSJ Leadership Institute as Marketing Spam for Slop and GAFAM/IBM PR
What the heck is "WSJ Leadership Institute"?
Links 19/11/2026: "So Many Crucial Services Are Going Down" and "Government Tech Debt is a National Security Risk" (Outages Blamed on Slop Frenzy)
Links for the day
Gemini Links 19/11/2026: Friends, Slop Harms Learning, and IBM Plex Lagrange Fontpacks
Links for the day
Links 19/11/2026: "Ignorance Has Taken Over" and "Apocalypse Now, Again"
Links for the day
Richard Stallman Still Insists "They" is Plural, Suggests "Perse" Instead
this week
New Video Explains Why Software Patents Are Evil ("Why Software Patents Spark So Much Frustration")
Maybe some patent examiners (who don't mind a Facebook URL) can take a look
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXXVI - Never Showing Up for Their Own Hearings, Just Paying Hired Guns in London to Act as Fall Guys and Proxies With No Comprehension of the Technical Issues (and Sometimes by Bullying Our Lawyers)
Without any qualifications in the subject at hand
Compatible With Software of 30 Years Ago
Old is not bad, sometimes old is better
NVIDIA Corporation Does Not Look Healthy
The bubble will be hard to re-inflate
Gemini Links 19/11/2026: Thinking About Thinking and Discord
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, November 18, 2026
IRC logs for Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Lots of IBM Layoffs in Slovakia This Year
Slovakia and Europe at large
There May be Little or No Future for IBM Consulting
IBM is believed to be run by parasites
At Least Three RMS Talks Next Month in Mexico (Richard Stallman Has 8+ Talks in a Month)
And also - possibly with slop - in social control media
Mass Layoffs at Salesforce Foretold by Techrights
Salesforce is dead meat and it's not alone
Gemini Links 18/11/2026: Creativity, MFA Hype, and Presto Music
Links for the day
Links 18/11/2026: More GAFAM/Apple 'Clown Computing' Outages and Deutsche Bank Leak, Banks' Downtimes
Links for the day
Today The Register MS Showed Loyalty to the Pyramid Scheme With Homage of Paid Spam About "AI"
The Register MS is disavowed by its founder, who died a few years ago (The Register MS didn't even mention this)
Staff Union of the European Patent Office (SUEPO) Plans General Assembly Next Week, Vote Planned to Approve 7+ More Months of Strikes
The "Agenda" is the same as what we showed yesterday, but the pattern of the actions varies somewhat
IBM's Red Hat a Microsoft Reseller (Second Day in a Row)
If you want a replacement for Microsoft, look somewhere other than Red Hat
After the Bubble Pops the "AI Experts" (Formerly "Data Scientists" or Whatever) Will Rebrand Themselves Again
Remember blockchains and metaverse?
Links 18/11/2026: "Fossil Fuel Companies Are Undermining Democracy" and "Lawyer Up, Elon"
Links for the day
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXXV - Acts of Hypocrisy (Doing What You Accuse Others of Doing)
connected to my criticism of "Restricted Boot"
Mainstream and Establishment Media Trying to Connect "Open Source" to White-Collar Crimes and Scandals at Fraudulent NVIDIA
An associate us said that "MIT lies to smear OSS"
Lawfare Will Continue in 2027
We're dealing with defiant Microsofters who wrongly assume that accurate reporting that causes them distress somehow makes them entitled to money
On the Concept of Moral Obligations to Make the World a Better Place for Everybody
The world generally becomes better when more people challenge the status quo rather than bow down to masters
Nadella Talks About 60,000 Microsoft Workers Having to Decide Whether to Leave (in the Next 2-3 Weeks), They've Been Put on Notice
Some parts of Microsoft are poised for severe cuts
IBM Moved From Selling Technology to Selling Its Buildings
IBM is trying very hard to silence/crush critics
Staff Union of the European Patent Office (SUEPO) Looking to Extend Industrial Actions and Strikes to Almost 1.5 Years
It says a lot about the media that for 1.5 years staff is on strike in the second-largest organisation in Europe and the media pretends it's not happening
Richard Stallman's Talk in Quito This Week (At Least 5 Talks After That)
He's having a busy end of year
Gemini Links 18/11/2026: "Love For Old Devices" and New Software/Slop-ware Releases
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, November 17, 2026
IRC logs for Tuesday, November 17, 2026