04.03.19

The EPO Continues Granting Bogus Patents on Mathematics and Nature, But There’s Hope Over the Horizon

Posted in Europe, Patents at 3:19 am by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

Summary: Pressure is growing for the EPO to actually comply with the law and obey the European Patent Convention (EPC); the judges who look into these matters, however, lack the independence which the EPC sought to guarantee

THE European Patent Office (EPO) may hopefully invalidate European software patents some time soon. This will have to come from a court rather than the Office itself. As Jan Wildeboer (Red Hat, soon IBM) put it in this tweet yesterday: “The EUCJ never pulled an ALICE AFAICS. I hope they do soon.”

We remain concerned that António Campinos is friends with Iancu, whose attitude towards the law has just come under scrutiny from a high court. Will Campinos even allow judges to deal with the relevant issues? Judges that exercise true independence? We think not.

“Will Campinos even allow judges to deal with the relevant issues? Judges that exercise true independence? We think not.”On Tuesday the EPO wrote about opposition procedures as follows: “Patent administrators in Helsinki are invited to this event to learn about fee payment, opposition procedures and other related matters…”

But the EPO is still a very unjust place where people responsible for oppositions can be arbitrarily ‘disciplined’ and dismissed under false pretexts/fabricated circumstances. This apparently happens also under Campinos, not just Battistelli. SUEPO wrote about it.

“Our hope is that the Boards will rediscover or recover their independence; then and only then do we expect them to rule out software patents and patents on life, in lieu (shall we say “harmonisation”?) with Alice and Mayo, respectively, in the US.”What if the EPO’s staff says “no!” to a big “client”/”customer” (what EPO management calls applicants)? Or to a partner of the EPO (like Judge Corcoran did Baxter)? Can the examiners in Oppositions be fired? Demoted? Reprimanded? We have mentioned this the other day, maybe before the press release even came out.

Here is the official press release and Globes coverage from yesterday:

Teva Pharmaceutical Industries Ltd. (NYSE and TASE: TEVA) today announced that a three-member panel of the European Patent Office’s (EPO) Opposition Division upheld patent EP 2 949 335 covering Teva’s COPAXONE® 40mg product in Europe. The Opposition Division will issue its written underlying rationale on the decision within a few months.

And the financial media in Teva’s home country:

While in the US, Teva Pharmaceutical Industries Ltd.’s (NYSE: TEVA; TASE: TEVA) original multiple sclerosis treatment Copaxone is already battling it out with generic competitors with its main dosage (40mg), in Europe there is still no generic competition, and a decision by the European Patent Office (EPO) should delay it further. Teva announce today that a three-member panel of the EPO Opposition Division upheld the patent (EP 2 949 335) covering its Copaxone 40mg product in Europe. The Opposition Division will issue its written underlying rationale on the decision within a few months.

Should this take months? Longer than the decision took to be reached perhaps?

An advocacy site of patents on life, Life Sciences Intellectual Property Review, has meanwhile written about the EPO merely considering obeying a law — another subject we last touched yesterday. To quote:

European Patent Office (EPO) president António Campinos will refer a recent decision on the patentability of plants exclusively obtained by essentially biological processes to the office’s Enlarged Board of Appeal (EBA).

The news follows long-running legal confusion over whether plant products produced by essential biological processes are patentable.

Last December, the EPO’s Technical Board of Appeal 3.3.04 issued decision T 1063/18, which ruled that rule 28(2) of the European Patent Convention (EPC) is incompatible with Article 53(b) of the same convention.

This neglects to take account of the European authorities’ position and the fact that in defiance of the European Patent Convention (EPC) these Boards no longer enjoy freedom and independence to rule as they see fit.

As European Patents now exceed 3 million in number we’re seeing yet more press releases about them, such as this one from yesterday:

Also, SANUWAVE received European Patent EP 3,117,784 on December 26, 2018 entitled “Usage of Intracorporeal Pressure Shock Waves in Medicine”, which has an expiration date in July 2030 from the European Patent Office (EPO). This patent is validated in designated countries including Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Great Britain, Holland, Ireland, Italy, Norway, Spain, and Sweden. The European patent includes fifteen (15) claims related to the special construction of the intracorporeal shockwave devices/systems comprising of a catheter size fit within at least one of a blood vessel, graft, or artificial blood vessel, with at least one balloon, and at least one or multiple shockwave generation sources coupled to the catheter. The intracorporeal shockwave device/system can be used to treat plaques and obstructions together with distal protection devices, to protect the flowing of dislodged plaque particles to the heart or brain. The shockwave generation sources can be electrohydraulic, laser-based, electromagnetic, or piezoelectric.

This isn’t my field and the above is a promotional press release, but this one too seemingly relates to health. The EPO used the term “medtech” yesterday — a term it nowadays uses to refer to algorithms (i.e. software) in a medical context.

We continue to worry that nobody seems to care — let alone intervene — in EPO affairs. Commenting on the patent troll Unwired Planet as recently as yesterday (it operates in Europe, even in London), Florian Müller wrote that “[s]tatistics show that most patents are invalid as granted, and even those that are valid rarely involve an inventive step of the impressive kind…”

Here’s the part about EPO and then some more about FRAND/SEP:

The patent system is prone to abuse because, contrary to widespread misconception, the commercial value of patents lies in legal uncertainty, and patent offices around the globe prioritize quantity over quality (institutionalized excess and race to the bottom, especially with leaders such as USPTO Director Andrew Iancu or the current president of the EPO and his predecessor). Statistics show that most patents are invalid as granted, and even those that are valid rarely involve an inventive step of the impressive kind–and reasonable people can disagree on claim construction, which is why a fairly high percentage of all claim constructions are reversed on appeal.

Patent judges are increasingly aware of the issues, and it depends on each judge’s style how they try to address the problem (such as by being ever more inclined to stay cases when the validity of a patent-in-suit is doubtful)–but the root cause (the aforementioned institutionalized excess) can’t be addressed by them, so it all comes down to purely symptomatic treatment.

One form of abuse that constitutes a systemic threat is privateering: the practice of transferring patents to patent assertion entities whose business is to bring extortionate litigation. A few years ago I made a public call to “name and shame companies that feed patent trolls,” and I’d like to refer you to such previous statements (you can find far better explanations of the privateering problem from others to be honest) rather than elaborate on this again.

[...]

To give you an idea of how novel and unorthodox that approach is, it may help to remind you of the fact that Germany is a jurisdiction that doesn’t even enable third-party beneficiaries (such as companies that are entitled to a FRAND license because of a FRAND promise made by a participant in a standard-setting process to a standard-setting organization) to enforce their rights like a direct contract. So even if Ericsson had never sold those patents to anyone, Huawei couldn’t simply enforce third-party beneficiary rights to a FRAND license from Ericsson. But Judge Dr. Kuehnen’s decision comes down to restricting Unwired Planet’s rights vis-à-vis Huawei. So we’re not talking about a third-party, but partically fourth-party, beneficiary rights.

It’s not just about the FRAND commitment at an abstract level. It’s that specific licensing terms could be deemed discriminatory based on what the previous patent holder did. (It would, of course, make sense to consider a previous patent holder’s licensing terms in a FRAND analysis, but just an indication of what terms might have been agreed upon by parties.)

Our hope is that the Boards will rediscover or recover their independence; then and only then do we expect them to rule out software patents and patents on life, in lieu (shall we say “harmonisation”?) with Alice and Mayo, respectively, in the US.

Share in other sites/networks: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Reddit
  • email

This post is also available in Gemini over at:

gemini://gemini.techrights.org/2019/04/03/european-patents-on-mathematics-and-nature/

If you liked this post, consider subscribing to the RSS feed or join us now at the IRC channels.

Pages that cross-reference this one

What Else is New


  1. [Meme] Nobody and Nothing Harms Europe's Reputation Like the EPO Does

    Europe’s second-largest institution, the EPO, has caused severe harm/damage to Europe’s economy and reputation; its attacks on the courts and on justice itself (even on constitutions in the case of UPC — another attempt to override the law and introduce European software patents) won’t be easily forgotten; SUEPO has meanwhile (on Saturday, link at the bottom in German) reminded people that Benoît Battistelli and António Campinos have driven away the EPO’s most valuable workers or moral compass



  2. IRC Proceedings: Saturday, July 31, 2021

    IRC logs for Saturday, July 31, 2021



  3. [Meme] When it Comes to Server Share, Microsoft Azure is Minuscule (But Faking It)

    Don't believe the lies told by Microsoft's charlatans and frauds; Azure has been a total failure and that's why there are layoffs as well



  4. [Meme] Mozilla Has Turned From Technical to Marketing

    Way back, long before Mozilla and Firefox got hijacked by politics (turning Mozilla into a VPN reseller that lies about its stance on privacy), geeks were driving the company, not corporate lawyers and spying/marketing people



  5. Over 1,500 (Known/Unorphaned) Gemini Capsules and Over 160,000 Page Requests in gemini.techrights.org During July

    Techrights is expanding at gemini:// (Gemini space) and over 1,500 capsules are reported to have been found (less than 4 months ago it was about 1,000)



  6. Links 31/7/2021: Kernel Additions and Linux Mint 20.3 Release Date

    Links for the day



  7. Microsoft Azure Stagnating

    Reprinted with permission from Mitchel Lewis, former Microsoft employee



  8. For 17 Days (and Counting) António Campinos Has Failed to Respond to Call for Compliance With the Law

    Team Campinos has been so arrogant and so evasive that there’s no indication (yet) that it will follow court orders (Willy ‘Guillaume’ Minnoye openly bragged about ignoring court orders and he's still cheering for the EPO's abuses); therefore, staff of the EPO takes collective action



  9. Raw: Elodie Bergot Breaking the Law by Threatening Against the Exercise of Fundamental Rights

    Over the years we saw a number of rude letters from Elodie Bergot, the grossly under-qualified spouse of a friend of Vichyite Benoît Battistelli; most of these we never published (we already have these and can always publish if the need arises), but those paranoid and insecure “Mafia”-like ‘cabal’ need to be exposed for the mobsters they are; for nearly a decade they’ve illegally bullied EPO staff in clear violation of the law (and for over 3 years António Campinos has kept those bullies on board); why does Europe do nothing and why is it never holding high-profile abusers accountable (only low-level facilitators)? Is it because the EU too is being infiltrated by them?



  10. Linspire Should Be Avoided in 2021 Just Like It Was Avoided 14 Years Ago

    The brand "Linspire" was brought back, but the agenda seems to be more or less the same, namely pushing proprietary software and serving Microsoft's commercial agenda (in 'Linux' clothing)



  11. The Death of Freenode Would Be Freenode's Own Fault

    Freenode is going dark and now it’s asking people to create accounts at IRC.com (just to get back into the network that they may have already occupied for decades) as if Freenode owns “IRC” as a whole



  12. Links 31/7/2021: KDE Progress and Activision Catastrophe

    Links for the day



  13. IRC Proceedings: Friday, July 30, 2021

    IRC logs for Friday, July 30, 2021



  14. The Smartest Meter of All

    Yesterday a lady came over to take our power readings (electric/gas meter); secure these people's jobs as they help protect people's privacy (dignity) at home



  15. [Meme] A Web of False Dichotomies

    A reminder that Techrights is fully available (all blog posts and wiki pages) in gemini://



  16. Freenode Shrinks by Another Quarter and Gemini Continues to Grow (For Techrights at Least)

    Freenode continues to perish faster than we've imagined; it's a good thing that we've had contingencies set up; regarding the monopolised and increasingly centralised Web, we're still making baby steps towards weaning ourselves off it



  17. Links 31/7/2021: Wine 6.14 and Chrome 93 Beta

    Links for the day



  18. European Media Does Not Care About Europe's Second-Largest Institution Crushing Basic Laws and Fundamental Rights

    New video about the latest publication from SUEPO (the EPO’s staff union); it was published yesterday, seeing that the “Mafia” (what EPO staff actually calls the management!) hasn’t done anything to comply with a wide-ranging set of court rulings from ILO-AT; why has the media said nothing about this and what does that say about today’s media? The material is all in the public domain, in widely understood languages, and SUEPO spoke about it more than 3 weeks ago.



  19. Links 30/7/2021: Distro Comparisons and Tootle Introduced

    Links for the day



  20. [Meme] Enforcing ILO-AT Rulings...

    We’re still waiting for a statement — any statement (direct or indirect) — from EPO management, seeing that almost a month has passed



  21. 'Open Source' as a Failed Initiative

    A closer look at the dire state of the Open Source Initiative, or OSI, which no longer protects Open Source (let alone software freedom) but instead helps openwashing, Microsoft entrapment, and a coup against the FSF



  22. [Meme] Rowan and António Sittin' on a Tree...

    How much longer can Team Campinos keep issuing tons of noisy and self-congratulatory puff pieces to (perhaps) distract from the elephant in the 10th floor of the Isar building (EPO HQ)? Staff won't wait for eternity.



  23. IRC Proceedings: Thursday, July 29, 2021

    IRC logs for Thursday, July 29, 2021



  24. Half the People in This Letter Are IBM Employees

    IBM seems to be continuing its war on the FSF because IBM wants to own everything (CentOS being ‘canned’ was just part of the plan)



  25. The OSI Song

    The sad demise of OSI, which has become little but a front group of proprietary software companies in pursuit of openwashing services (and outsourcing to proprietary disservices looking to eradicate copyleft)



  26. [Meme] OSI is Doing Just Fine

    So what if OSI is run by someone who raised money from Microsoft (to sell Microsoft a keynote slot in a copyleft event — the thing that Microsoft attacks through GitHub!) while funnelling the OSI's funds to a serial GPL violator?



  27. The OSI's Defunct Elections (Privacy Breach), Conflict of Interest (Nicholson), and Other Lingering Problems

    The above, together with an email from the OSI below, serves to show they’re re-running a bad election and — yet worse! — there appears to be a conflict of interest implicating the OSI’s sole member of staff!



  28. Links 30/7/2021: Audacity 3.0.3 and KD Chart 2.8.0

    Links for the day



  29. Links 29/7/2021: siduction 2021.2 and Xubuntu 21.10 Dev Update

    Links for the day



  30. GitHub is Racism

    Microsoft has the world's most racist code hosting repository; it wasn't like this when Microsoft took over as the racist policies were added to impress Donald Trump, who would later rig a procurement/tendering process to bail out Microsoft (10 billion dollars from the Pentagon, i.e. taxpayers)


RSS 64x64RSS Feed: subscribe to the RSS feed for regular updates

Home iconSite Wiki: You can improve this site by helping the extension of the site's content

Home iconSite Home: Background about the site and some key features in the front page

Chat iconIRC Channel: Come and chat with us in real time

Recent Posts