08.18.20

EPO Censorship Rebuked by Former UK Human Rights Judge

Posted in Courtroom, Europe, Patents at 1:18 pm by Guest Editorial Team

The EPO still censors every single page in Techrights, which it also threatened using several law firms

EPO IAC
Former UK Judge at the European Court of Human Rights, Sir Paul Mahoney:
Now head of the EPO’s Internal Appeals Committee

Summary: The European Patent Office (EPO) under the leadership (maladministration) of António Campinos and Benoît Battistelli is in noncompliance with international standards of law

In 2017 (warning: epo.org link) following an unrelenting stream of adverse publicity both inside the EPO and outside, Battistelli was forced by the Administrative Council to reform the EPO’s internal justice system.

Since then the Internal Appeals Committee (IAC) has been headed by Sir Paul Mahoney, a distinguished British legal scholar who previously served as first President of the European Union Civil Service Tribunal (2005 to 2011) and as the UK’s judge on the European Court of Human Rights from 2012 to 2016.

Somewhat belatedly the Mahoney-led IAC is getting around to dealing with the massive backlog of internal appeal cases that built up during the Battistelli era at the EPO.

It’s an unenviable task that could be compared with the fifth labour of Hercules, cleaning out the large volumes of manure that have accumulated in the Augean stables of the Battistelli regime.

Augean
The IAC has the unenviable task of cleaning out the Augean stables of the Battistelli era

The role of the IAC is to issue opinions to the EPO’s two appointing authorities, the President and the Administrative Council, who then take a final decision which can be appealed to the ILOAT.

“Somewhat belatedly the Mahoney-led IAC is getting around to dealing with the massive backlog of internal appeal cases that built up during the Battistelli era at the EPO.”The system is far from ideal because the opinions issued by the IAC are only non-binding advisory opinions and the appointing authority is free to depart from them.

Also following a “reform” introduced by Battistelli which remains in force long after his departure, the appellant no longer receives an advance copy of the IAC’s opinion when it is issued to the appointing authority as was the long-established practice prior to Battistelli. Nowadays a copy of the opinion is only provided to the appellant after the appointing authority has issued its decision.

“In a recent landmark case, the IAC issued an opinion belatedly excoriating an arbitrary and unprincipled act of censorship by Elodie Bergot which occurred almost four years ago in 2016.”Strictly speaking any departure from the IAC’s opinion by the appointing authority should be justified by reasons. But, hey, this is EPOnia where anything goes and where – to borrow a phrase from the ILOAT – “arbitrary, unprincipled or even irrational decision-making” was the ordre du jour under Battistelli.

Nevertheless it seems that the current EPO management under Campinos is generally more inclined to follow the opinions of the IAC than was the case under Battistelli.

In a recent landmark case, the IAC issued an opinion belatedly excoriating an arbitrary and unprincipled act of censorship by Elodie Bergot which occurred almost four years ago in 2016.

Bergot censorship
Sir Paul and his Committee were not amused by Bergot’s censorship

The background to this case is that in October 2016 the EPO Central Staff Committee (CSC) tried to publish two documents relating to the internal justice system of the EPO, namely a presentation criticising the operation of the system under Battistelli’s management and an open letter to the Principal Director of the Human Resources Department (Dir 4.3), Ms Elodie Bergot.

But Bergot was having none of this and – presumably with the backing of Battistelli and her hubby Gilles Requena – she spiked the publication.

Four years down the road, in a unanimous opinion the IAC has found that the Office was wrong in refusing the publication of the two documents.

“Four years down the road, in a unanimous opinion the IAC has found that the Office was wrong in refusing the publication of the two documents.”The IAC confirmed that freedom of speech is part and parcel of freedom of association. Those freedoms are not absolute or unconditional and an organisation may take steps to prevent publications containing incorrect information, or statements impairing the dignity of international civil service or grossly abusing freedom of speech. However, such interferences by an organisation are subject to limits.

The IAC found it impossible to accept that two minor statistical deviations from actual official figures in the presentation objected to by Bergot were grave enough to justify the refusal to allow publication.

The IAC also confirmed that staff representatives are at liberty to criticise the EPO’s policies and actions, even sharply and robustly, as long as the language used is not injurious or defamatory. This is a perfectly legitimate manifestation of the political jousting between management and staff bodies that is part and parcel of the life of a healthy International Organisation.

“The IAC unanimously concluded that the censorship imposed by Bergot was neither appropriate nor proportionate and that the refusal to publish both documents was tainted by illegality.”The IAC took the position that it is essential for staff members to have knowledge of the various positions discussed between EPO management and the Staff Committee on matters of general interest for staff. This ensures that EPO management can be exposed to a degree of accountability to staff in relation to policy decisions affecting them.

The IAC unanimously concluded that the censorship imposed by Bergot was neither appropriate nor proportionate and that the refusal to publish both documents was tainted by illegality.

In addition, it also found aggravating circumstances in the way that the EPO handled the CSC requests, by delaying a response and then failing to respond altogether.

The IAC also had “some difficulty in understanding” the EPO when it raised a receivability objection with no serious arguments at the appeal stage.

“So after almost four years of waiting the CSC has had a small taste of justice.”The good news is that the new President of the Office, António Campinos, has decided to follow the opinion of the IAC. As a result, the CSC is finally allowed to publish the documents from October 2016 on the EPO Intranet!

So after almost four years of waiting the CSC has had a small taste of justice.

But what is even more remarkable about this case, is that the person responsible for trampling on the CSC’s fundamental right to freedom of speech still remains in her position.

Back in June 2018, the ILOAT found Bergot guilty of masterminding a witch-hunt conducted against two SUEPO officials, one of whom was unlawfully dismissed from his position and the other who was unlawfully downgraded.

Bergot mugshot
Fit for purpose as head of the EPO’s HR department?
Some think not… but Madame Bergot still enjoys António’s support

To her officially documented record as a union-basher, Bergot can now add the distinction of an official rebuke for unlawful acts of censorship.

Campinos Battistelli
Why does Campinos continue to protect Bergot?

It’s a mystery how someone with such an egregious track record of trampling on the fundamental rights of staff can be allowed to remain in a senior managerial post at an international organisation like the EPO.

“It’s a mystery how someone with such an egregious track record of trampling on the fundamental rights of staff can be allowed to remain in a senior managerial post at an international organisation like the EPO.”What many people at the EPO are wondering is why Campinos is still protecting Bergot whose “fitness for purpose” as a principal director of the EPO’s human resources department is clearly open to question. Some suspect that it is part of a secret unwritten deal with his predecessor Battistelli.

Over to you on that one, António… anything to say?

Or has the cat got your tongue?

Share in other sites/networks: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Reddit
  • email

This post is also available in Gemini over at:

gemini://gemini.techrights.org/2020/08/18/epo-censorship-rebuked-sir-paul-mahoney/

If you liked this post, consider subscribing to the RSS feed or join us now at the IRC channels.

Pages that cross-reference this one

What Else is New


  1. Freenode is IRC... in Collapse

    Freenode is now down to just 13,194 online users, which makes it the 6th biggest IRC network. Months ago it was #1 with almost 6 times as many users as those below it. The graph above shows what the latest blunder has done (another massive drop in less than a week, with a poem and the all-time chart at the very bottom).



  2. Barrier and Synergy Can Work Together, Connecting Lots of Different Machines

    Barrier and Synergy can be configured to work properly in conjunction, though only provided different port numbers (non-default) are specified; in my current setup I have two computers to my right, working over Barrier, and two older ones on the left, working over Synergy; the video explains the setup and the underlying concepts



  3. Links 2/8/2021: Open Science in France and Zoom Pays to Settle Privacy Violations

    Links for the day



  4. It Almost Feels Like Battistelli Still Runs the EPO (by Extension/Proxy)

    The "Mafia" that destroyed the EPO is still being put in charge and is using the EPO for shameless self-promotion; it is never being held accountable, not even when courts demand remediatory action and staff seeks reparations



  5. [Meme] Vichyite Battistelli Committed Crimes and His Buddy António Snubs Courts That Confirm These Are Crimes

    Staff of the EPO is coming to realise (or reaching acceptance of the fact) that the spirit of Battistelli — not just people he left in charge of the EPO — dooms the Office and there’s no way out of this mess



  6. Links 2/8/2021: Linux 5.14 RC4 and 20% Growth in Steam

    Links for the day



  7. IRC Proceedings: Sunday, August 01, 2021

    IRC logs for Sunday, August 01, 2021



  8. Links 1/8/2021: LibreOffice 7.2 RC2 and Lakka 3.3

    Links for the day



  9. Was Microsoft Ever First in the Market?

    Confronting the false belief that Microsoft ever innovates anything of significance or is "first" in some market/s



  10. Links 1/8/2021: 4MLinux 37.0, IBM Fluff, and USMCA Update

    Links for the day



  11. Microsoft Knows That When Shareholders Realise Azure Has Failed the Whole Boat Will Sink

    The paranoia at Microsoft is well justified; they've been lying to shareholders to inflate share prices and they don't really deliver the goods, just false hopes and unfulfilled promises



  12. [Meme] Nobody and Nothing Harms Europe's Reputation Like the EPO Does

    Europe’s second-largest institution, the EPO, has caused severe harm/damage to Europe’s economy and reputation; its attacks on the courts and on justice itself (even on constitutions in the case of UPC — another attempt to override the law and introduce European software patents) won’t be easily forgotten; SUEPO has meanwhile (on Saturday, link at the bottom in German) reminded people that Benoît Battistelli and António Campinos have driven away the EPO’s most valuable workers or moral compass



  13. IRC Proceedings: Saturday, July 31, 2021

    IRC logs for Saturday, July 31, 2021



  14. [Meme] When it Comes to Server Share, Microsoft Azure is Minuscule (But Faking It)

    Don't believe the lies told by Microsoft's charlatans and frauds; Azure has been a total failure and that's why there are layoffs as well



  15. [Meme] Mozilla Has Turned From Technical to Marketing

    Way back, long before Mozilla and Firefox got hijacked by politics (turning Mozilla into a VPN reseller that lies about its stance on privacy), geeks were driving the company, not corporate lawyers and spying/marketing people



  16. Over 1,500 (Known/Unorphaned) Gemini Capsules and Over 160,000 Page Requests in gemini.techrights.org During July

    Techrights is expanding at gemini:// (Gemini space) and over 1,500 capsules are reported to have been found (less than 4 months ago it was about 1,000)



  17. Links 31/7/2021: Kernel Additions and Linux Mint 20.3 Release Date

    Links for the day



  18. Microsoft Azure Stagnating

    Reprinted with permission from Mitchel Lewis, former Microsoft employee



  19. For 17 Days (and Counting) António Campinos Has Failed to Respond to Call for Compliance With the Law

    Team Campinos has been so arrogant and so evasive that there’s no indication (yet) that it will follow court orders (Willy ‘Guillaume’ Minnoye openly bragged about ignoring court orders and he's still cheering for the EPO's abuses); therefore, staff of the EPO takes collective action



  20. Raw: Elodie Bergot Breaking the Law by Threatening Against the Exercise of Fundamental Rights

    Over the years we saw a number of rude letters from Elodie Bergot, the grossly under-qualified spouse of a friend of Vichyite Benoît Battistelli; most of these we never published (we already have these and can always publish if the need arises), but those paranoid and insecure “Mafia”-like ‘cabal’ need to be exposed for the mobsters they are; for nearly a decade they’ve illegally bullied EPO staff in clear violation of the law (and for over 3 years António Campinos has kept those bullies on board); why does Europe do nothing and why is it never holding high-profile abusers accountable (only low-level facilitators)? Is it because the EU too is being infiltrated by them?



  21. Linspire Should Be Avoided in 2021 Just Like It Was Avoided 14 Years Ago

    The brand "Linspire" was brought back, but the agenda seems to be more or less the same, namely pushing proprietary software and serving Microsoft's commercial agenda (in 'Linux' clothing)



  22. The Death of Freenode Would Be Freenode's Own Fault

    Freenode is going dark and now it’s asking people to create accounts at IRC.com (just to get back into the network that they may have already occupied for decades) as if Freenode owns “IRC” as a whole



  23. Links 31/7/2021: KDE Progress and Activision Catastrophe

    Links for the day



  24. IRC Proceedings: Friday, July 30, 2021

    IRC logs for Friday, July 30, 2021



  25. The Smartest Meter of All

    Yesterday a lady came over to take our power readings (electric/gas meter); secure these people's jobs as they help protect people's privacy (dignity) at home



  26. [Meme] A Web of False Dichotomies

    A reminder that Techrights is fully available (all blog posts and wiki pages) in gemini://



  27. Freenode Shrinks by Another Quarter and Gemini Continues to Grow (For Techrights at Least)

    Freenode continues to perish faster than we've imagined; it's a good thing that we've had contingencies set up; regarding the monopolised and increasingly centralised Web, we're still making baby steps towards weaning ourselves off it



  28. Links 31/7/2021: Wine 6.14 and Chrome 93 Beta

    Links for the day



  29. European Media Does Not Care About Europe's Second-Largest Institution Crushing Basic Laws and Fundamental Rights

    New video about the latest publication from SUEPO (the EPO’s staff union); it was published yesterday, seeing that the “Mafia” (what EPO staff actually calls the management!) hasn’t done anything to comply with a wide-ranging set of court rulings from ILO-AT; why has the media said nothing about this and what does that say about today’s media? The material is all in the public domain, in widely understood languages, and SUEPO spoke about it more than 3 weeks ago.



  30. Links 30/7/2021: Distro Comparisons and Tootle Introduced

    Links for the day


RSS 64x64RSS Feed: subscribe to the RSS feed for regular updates

Home iconSite Wiki: You can improve this site by helping the extension of the site's content

Home iconSite Home: Background about the site and some key features in the front page

Chat iconIRC Channel: Come and chat with us in real time

Recent Posts