01.11.22

Gemini version available ♊︎

Microsoft GitHub, DRM Enforcer, Bans Free Software

Posted in DRM, Free/Libre Software, Microsoft at 7:08 am by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

Reproduced from Mobileread, as can be seen here:

Initially, I didn’t want create an account on this site and keep all discussion on GitHub (the fewer accounts one has, the easier it is to stay anonymous …), but I guess with the GitHub being gone, it’s about time to answer some of the questions here …

Maybe GitHub hasn’t been the best choice for a platform, but I didn’t expect there to be DMCA claims when there have been none over the recent years in Apprentice Harper’s repository. I guess, in the long term, I should move to another platform.

I received the first message from Github about the DMCA claim on January 4th in the late evening, with a time line of 24h to remove the “offending” content. Of course that deadline is rather short – I am obviously not using my “main” mail address for stuff like this, so I didn’t check this account every single day, and only found out the repository was blocked (some time on January 6th) when I checked this forum thread and saw the discussion on January 7th.

The GitHub FAQ states that when one misses the 1-day window to make requested changes, one can request an additional time of 1 day to perform the changes. I requested that by mail on January 7th, but so far the GitHub support hasn’t gotten back to me yet. Right now, I see the same page that you all see – repo unavailable due to DMCA. They could have at least given the repo owner access to update the code, but they didn’t.

Rather disturbing that they are allowed to block a repo after just one day of no response (they could have given me a notification on the Github page itself, in addition to the mail, then I would have seen it before the deadline was over …), and then don’t respond to the topic for multiple days, but maybe their support doesn’t work on weekends and they don’t consider stuff like this urgent now that the repo’s down and they did what they legally have to do …

The goal is to hopefully get Github to restore the repository once they finally read my mail, then remove the offending code from the repository, and have the plugin no longer contain the offending LCP code on Github to comply with the DMCA request.

The DMCA request mentions nothing about the difference between library books and bought books. The request states that the original repositories (apprentice harper and so on) are not part of the takedown – not because they have blocks for library books, but because they don’t support LCP at all. So I doubt adding a block for library books would have prevented this takedown (or, would be an acceptable solution to get the repository back). The guys behind LCP know how easy it is to edit Python code to remove such blocks, and I think with this plugin being the first public solution for LCP DRM removal, I guess they are more concerned with people knowing the algorithm, and they think that with a DMCA request for this repo they can remove that from the entire internet.

I don’t want to piss off GitHub (and Readium?) even more by now creating a new account or repository. Even though it’s probably fine as far as the DMCA goes (if there’s no LCP code in the new repo), it certainly violates Github TOS to just make a new repo when there’s a pending takedown. So I’m going to wait for the support to respond, which they are supposed to according to their own FAQ. If they don’t, I guess the plugin moves to another platform.

As for the other topics being discussed here in the last couple days:

- Someone mentioned that based on the description of LCP in the takedown notice, this DRM doesn’t sound so bad – maybe it doesn’t, but there’s one thing they are purposefully omitting in that description, and one they either deliberately or accidentally explained wrong. They are claiming that LCP is oh-so-open and doesn’t lock the user into a proprietary environment.
Yeah, LCP is not as proprietary as Adobe or Amazon, but it’s still proprietary. Yes, they have the source code available on their GitHub, but still require you to pay huge amounts for licenses if you want to use the code. A critical piece of source code for the project is missing on their Github, and you only get this code (with a very restrictive license) if you pay them. So, the code on the GitHub is useless, as if you forked it and built the code yourself, it wouldn’t work.
And the other thing they omitted is the fact that there’s (almost) no reader support. They claim the DRM doesn’t hurt content accessibility, it lets users share content with friends, and so on. But that’s only true if you’re reading on a phone or computer, or if you have a very new eReader from particular vendors.
If the codebase would have *really* been open-source (meaning, I take the source code, built it, and get a 1:1 100% identical binary to the one they give to users, without paying for a license), AND Readium had support on all eReaders, I doubt I would have deemed it necessary to add LCP support. The main reason I added this support was not to “crack” books and share them with the world, it was getting them to work on MY readers …

- The latest release of the plugin (10.0.2) does not yet support QT 6 / Calibre 6, but the latest commit on master already does. I doubt there’s many people that have that downloaded, with the repo now gone. Though, even if GitHub decides to block the repo permanently and I don’t find any other useful hosting, the plugin only required very small changes in two or three places that became apparent when reading the error messages, so it should be easy for others to fix that, if needed.

As noted in Mastodon: “RIAA showed that it was acceptable to use GitHub’s (legally mandated) DMCA process for DMCA section 1201… Any tool like this should probably self-host their code repository at this point… Can we please kill these anticircumvention laws? Maybe then we won’t need tools like DeDRM?”

Related:

Share in other sites/networks: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Reddit
  • email

Decor ᶃ Gemini Space

Below is a Web proxy. We recommend getting a Gemini client/browser.

Black/white/grey bullet button This post is also available in Gemini over at this address (requires a Gemini client/browser to open).

Decor ✐ Cross-references

Black/white/grey bullet button Pages that cross-reference this one, if any exist, are listed below or will be listed below over time.

Decor ▢ Respond and Discuss

Black/white/grey bullet button If you liked this post, consider subscribing to the RSS feed or join us now at the IRC channels.

DecorWhat Else is New


  1. Jim Zemlin: Chief Revenue Officer in 'Linux' Seat-Selling Foundation

    Board seats in the Linux Foundation are basically a product on sale, based internal documents



  2. Reminder: Linux Foundation's Last IRS Filing is Very Old (Same Year the CFO Left)

    People really need to ask the Linux Foundation, directly, why its filings are years behind; this seems like a sensitive subject



  3. Linux Foundation Does Not Speak for GNU/Linux Users

    There's a serious problem in the "Linux" world as the so-called 'Linux' Foundation claims to speak for us (the GNU/Linux community) while in fact speaking against us (on the payroll of those looking to extinguish us)



  4. IBM's Lennart Poettering on Breaking Software for Pseudo Novelty

    Recently-uploaded ELCE 2011 clip shows a panel with Linus Torvalds, Alan Cox, Thomas Gleixner, Paul McKenney, and Lennart Poettering (relevant to novelty or perceived novelty that mostly degrades the experience of longtime users, e.g. Wayland and systemd)



  5. IRC Proceedings: Sunday, May 15, 2022

    IRC logs for Sunday, May 15, 2022



  6. Links 15/05/2022: Linux 5.18 RC7 and Calls for More Mass Surveillance

    Links for the day



  7. Audio: Mark Shuttleworth Marketed to Young Males, With Sexy Pictures

    The Web is rotting away, old links become broken links within months or years, so I’ve decided to encode a 3-minute segment of the whole as Ogg



  8. What a Difference Half a Decade Makes (When Linux Foundation is 'Having Fun')

    Media shaming campaigns may have taken their toll on the founder of Linux, who is now bossed by someone who rejects Linux and is married to a Microsoft booster. Like Richard Stallman under FSF guidance (and conditions for return, mostly for fear of further media assaults and attack dogs), he has become a more publicity-shy and private person. The Linux Foundation has in effect reduced the founder of what it’s called after (Linux) into a weekly release manager and mascot, whose brand it is gradually diluting/cheapening.



  9. Links 15/05/2022: GNU libiconv 1.17

    Links for the day



  10. [Meme] Unitary Patent and Unified Patent Court (UPC) Cannot Be Reconciled With the Law

    Unitary Patent and Unified Patent Court (UPC)? Impossible. But Team UPC counts on an endless torrent of fake news managing to convince you (and more importantly politicians) otherwise.



  11. Even Team Battistelli is Sometimes Admitting -- Out in Public! -- That Unified Patent Court (UPC) is Neither Legal Nor Desirable

    Daniel X. Thomas and other people who are “too old to punish” (consequences to their career profoundly minimised owing to seniority) are among those who push back against the Unitary Patent or Unified Patent Court (UPC); any sane person — not a career-climbing litigation zealot — can identify the pertinent facts and realise that what’s going on here is an injustice of unprecedented proportions in the patent discipline



  12. [Meme] Common Sense at EPO

    The European examiners who deal with patents prefer a system that works for science, for Europe, not for foreign megacorporations that amass millions of low-quality patents and weaponise these to discourage competition



  13. Patent Granting at the EPO Has Collapsed by 24% Owing to Much-Needed Industrial Action

    Seeing that the EPO’s management routinely violates the law and even the very legal basis of the EPO’s existence (it is a monopoly in Europe; no body has the authority to compete against it), the EPO’s examiners have embarked on a ‘Work-to-Rule’ campaign — working in compliance with the rules as defined 49 years ago and revised over the decades — and the European Patent Convention (EPC) takes priority over unlawful demands from middle and upper management; this is proving highly effective so far and it will carry on until demands are met, i.e. until the law is obeyed and staff is treated with respect/dignity



  14. [Meme] Milan is a Suburb in London

    As long as Italy is not the UK and London means London “proper” (not the French town called London) the UPCA is invalid and no matter how much Team UPC (and its puppets in EPO management) may plead, this whole system is bound to implode



  15. The Latest Propaganda Tactics of Team UPC: Pretending Unified Patent Court Already Exists and Unitary Patents Are Default When If Fact None Even Exists

    8 years ago Benoît Battistelli said that the UPC was imminent; now, after 4 years of António Campinos, it’s still not here and Team UPC speculators say it won’t happen this year, either; just like the EPO constantly lies (both to the public and to its very own staff) Team UPC continues to lie to itself (self-delusion) and to us; both also routinely break the law, engage in deliberate violations of longstanding conventions, and scrap constitutions, which in turn becomes a breaking point for the EU’s credibility and the legal profession



  16. Links 15/05/2022: More Azure Shutdowns and Windows Security Blunders Aplenty

    Links for the day



  17. IRC Proceedings: Saturday, May 14, 2022

    IRC logs for Saturday, May 14, 2022



  18. Links 15/05/2022: Pika Backup 0.4

    Links for the day



  19. Changes in the Site and the Capsule

    A 10-minute explanation of what we've been up to lately and what's changing; hopefully I'll have a lot more free time in months to come and we'll be able to produce about a dozen posts per day



  20. Links 14/05/2022: Alt Linux 10.0 Released

    Links for the day



  21. Links 14/05/2022: Builder GTK 4 Porting and Raspberry Pi Matrix Dashboard

    Links for the day



  22. Elon Musk is Right About Twitter Faking Its Importance and Using Doctored, Manipulated 'Stats' (or Bots) to Boost Valuation Based on Lies

    Today’s empirical proof that Twitter is totally faking its relevance and reach/influence, based on “Analytics” of my long-inactive account; the SEC will once again — quite likely as usual — let Musk get away with it, killing a company for personal gain as a temporary shareholder who amassed a ton of free publicity (he paid nothing at all and sent the company into a death spiral, pretty much in the same way Microsoft and Icahn did Yahoo! or Microsoft and Elop did Nokia)



  23. Who Brings Home the Bacon (Revenue), Sheela or James (Jim)?

    Sheela (yes, wife of the nontechnical Linux Foundation chief, who equates Microsoft critics with people who kick puppies) has a history working with several companies that are closely connected to Microsoft (not just Bakkt); can that be reconciled as not a conflict of interest?



  24. The 'Original' Linus Torvalds on Self-Hosting

    The fast-aging founder of Linux spoke as shown above (2005); so much has changed since then…



  25. IRC Proceedings: Friday, May 13, 2022

    IRC logs for Friday, May 13, 2022



  26. Links 13/05/2022: NetworkManager 1.38 and Pseudo-Security

    Links for the day



  27. Links 13/05/2022: GCC 12 Becoming Default Compiler in Tumbleweed

    Links for the day



  28. Links 13/05/2022: End of 'About BSD'

    Links for the day



  29. IRC Proceedings: Thursday, May 12, 2022

    IRC logs for Thursday, May 12, 2022



  30. Links 12/05/2022: AlmaLinux OS 8.6 and LibreOffice 7.2.7

    Links for the day


RSS 64x64RSS Feed: subscribe to the RSS feed for regular updates

Home iconSite Wiki: You can improve this site by helping the extension of the site's content

Home iconSite Home: Background about the site and some key features in the front page

Chat iconIRC Channel: Come and chat with us in real time

Recent Posts