Bonum Certa Men Certa

The four freedoms and GNU/Linux naming controversy, by Akira Urushibata

posted by Roy Schestowitz on Jan 07, 2026,
updated Jan 07, 2026

Spongebob nametag: GNU/Linux

Akira Urushibata recently wrote to libreplanet-discuss, which hadn't been active for 2 months (he was the last person to write to it back in November). His latest message is a bit like an article and it was approved by moderators about 4 days after it had posted to the mailing list.

Today we reproduce it:

The four freedoms and GNU/Linux naming controversy
In the book "Just for Fun: The Story of an Accidental Revolutionary"
which describes the creation of Linux, Linus Torvalds claims Richard
Stallman caused him trouble by demanding credit on the grounds that
GNU tools were used to develop Linux [1].

We members of the Libreplanet mailing list know the difference between the kernel and the OS. It appears to me that many people - not only ordinary folk but also professional engineers - are not aware of the distinction.
Torvalds claimed that he had developed a UNIX-like operating system [2]. Stallman reasoned that the OS needed a separate, distinct name and he desired one that reflected the fact that many of the crucial components were from the GNU project. But to people unaware of the fact that a kernel is not an OS, it appeared that after Torvalds had decided upon the name for his creation [3], a guy called Stallman came up and tried to force him into changing that. If it were true, I'd consider that extremely rude.
This is an important point. If I am mistaken, please tell me so [4].
Although most everybody nowadays has heard the word "OS", few actually know what an OS actually does. People know that Microsoft has a product called "Windows" and that it is an "OS." But few can explain what it accomplishes beyond providing a standard which developers and consumers recognize. I believe that this condition is mostly a product of Microsoft's marketing strategy.
Try to tell someone with but a hazy grasp of the "operating system" to distinguish between the entire system and a component thereof. The likely outcome is that shoulders are shrugged and the request is ignored. To make matters worse, among educators and technology writers who need to make the distinction to do their jobs, there are many who can't. The issue betrays their ignorance and makes them uncomfortable. When one discovers one's own shortcomings the right thing to do is to take remedial action, in this case by investigating the issue. In reality many fail to do so and at worst, feign knowledge by parroting phrases which spread confusion [5].
Failure on the part of Stallman and his supporters to recognize the widespread ignorance, the associated uncomfortable feelings, and the response created thereby contributed to failure in getting people accept "GNU/Linux." I think we should recognize this.
Why do we GNU/Linux supporters know about the difference between the kernel and the OS? That is because we understand the four freedoms promoted by Richard Stallman.
Linux kernel development began as a student's hobby. In contrast GNU was created with an intent to help society by making available an OS which provides the four freedoms.
When Stallman told people to call the entire OS "GNU/Linux" the reason he gave was that the GNU project contributed greatly to the system's realization. An quantitative analysis of the contribution appeared among the GNU philosophy articles but its effect was limited [6]. Instead he should have brought up the four freedoms [7]. Getting facts wrong is detrimental to one's own freedom. An engineer with insufficient freedom tasked with solving a problem runs the risk of implementing a solution which is not ideal: it may turn out to be ineffective, costly, hazardous or all three at once. Stallman should have said: "I'm telling you to use the right term because I care about you and wish that you do your job well."
I recognize another issue. Many people do not have the freedom to modify programs simply because they can't read computer code. Even experienced programmers cannot read all of the code with so many programming languages in existence: one can modify some programs, but not all. GNU/Linux is based on UNIX. To be proficient in UNIX one has to master several languages including c, shell, awk and make. There is much to learn. Some people consider this beyond their means and give up before getting an idea of how UNIX really works [8]. Thus even among programmers, educators and journalists there are many who fail to understand the functions of kernel. A clear picture of the boundaries is not easy to attain.
Stallman has not been helpful in this regard. I have not once seen him encouraging students to patiently study UNIX until a firm grasp of its design principles is acquired. Instead he has been telling students to study Lisp [9]. He has also instructed users to keep the Emacs editor running throughout the session and has vented frustration toward those who failed to obey. It is true that Emacs is rich in functionality and can do a great many things, but that is the exact opposite of the UNIX principle of "Do one thing and do it well."
Because I am aware of the above, I can suggest some measures which would serve as antidotes.
One path to people's enlightenment is to remind them that the language of the computer is important, and proceed with the question:
Do you know the language of Linux? Maybe you know that "Linux" belongs to the UNIX family. What is the language of UNIX? What are the features of the language?
Another approach is stating the four freedoms, and discussing what the Linux kernel does in their regard:
How much freedom does one get with just the Linux kernel? Suppose the kernel and nothing else is written in binary in a hard disk device of a typical PC. Can one get the program running?
(The answer is no.)
Suppose that somehow one can get Linux running in the above setup. Can one instruct Linux to make a copy of Linux?
(Also no.) Can you modify the program?
(No again.)
With GNU/Linux the user has the four freedoms. He can do any of the above.
Whether the four freedoms are put in context or not makes a big difference in how the fundamentals are perceived.
And perhaps we should try to get more people know basic facts like this:
The Linux kernel is one program. It is a "monolithic" design. UNIX is composed of many programs. So are MS-DOS and Windows.
I also believe that it is important to remind people that they are getting something useful for free. When you get something good for free, you say thanks. Gratitude is important. In its absence bad things happen [10]. For one thing men lose track of what they are capable of and what they aren't.
I notice that there is increased awareness of the functions of the OS. This is happening because people are urged to upgrade to Windows 11 but it comes with several features that make the upgrade not desirable. There are concerns that certain programs may become impossible to execute because of an accident [11] or perhaps through deliberate policy. Ordinary people are now speaking about this. People are realizing that ignorance comes at a cost [12].
I believe people who want to make better choices would be pleased to learn that someone has been preaching about software freedom for decades and there exists a body of thought that anyone interested is welcome to study.
---
[1] Just for Fun: The Story of an Accidental Revolutionary Linus Torvalds, David Diamond First published January 1, 2001
https://goodreads.com/book/show/160171.Just_for_Fun
[2] "Wikinomics" by D. Tapscott and A.D. Williams says so. This highly influential book work does not mention GNU.
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/154341.Wikinomics http://www.wikinomics.com/
In some contexts the kernel is the operating system. This position is not widely supported and ordinary computers would have a hard time accepting the idea because the "OS" as such is very different from MS Windows and Mac OS.
[3] I've read that Torvalds had plans to develop a complete OS on his own, one not as sophisticated as GNU. But this project did not get very far largely because within a few years personal computers became powerful enough to run GNU systems. One episode symbolic of the attempt to make Linux a full-fledged OS was the libc fork.
[4] To list members who wish to discuss this: please clarify whether you have actually read "Just for Fun." If any evidence to the contrary of my position on the matter exists, please provide the source.
[5] The calculation that an enthusiast's hobby OS would never be the equal of proprietary products considering the vast resources spent developing the latter may be the reason for this lax attitude.
[6] I can't locate this article. I'd like to know if it is still available.
I understand that this is an attempt to measure something that is difficult to measure. The result will vary depending on whether Emacs is considered a standard OS component or not. Similarly, nowadays the default kernels of popular distros are bloated with device drivers of rare hardware, support for exotic file systems, etc.
[7] Stallman spoke in length on this point. One example: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/linux-gnu-freedom.html
Unfortunately, at least some people perceived it to be an effort to make people give credit to him by promoting the name "GNU/Linux". In a way the efforts to justify promoting the name worked against him.
[8] One can learn the basic features of Awk in a weekend. Make takes much effort to learn because GNU's implementation added many features. The basics of the popular Bash shell can be mastered within weeks but it too has many additional features which may require some time to learn. With GNU make and Bash an important skill is understanding what features are GNU extensions.
[9] I have observed that a common question is: "What language should we study?"
[10] "The Analects" Taibo 2 https://ctext.org/analects/tai-bo#n1290
When one observes the kind of misfortune that Stallman has experienced the above passage come to mind.
[11] See for example the following article, by a publication for the commons:
Microsoft Teams down LIVE as Office 365 platform suffers major outage - World News - Mirror Online https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/microsoft-teams-down-live-office-36431910
[12] See for example the following article on the "rental economy":
Nothing Is Ours Anymore: Is the "Rental Economy" the Most Destructive Scam in US Capitalism? https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2025/12/29/2360514/-Nothing-Is-Ours-Anymore-Is-the-Rental-Economy-the-Most-Destructive-Scam-in-US-Capitalism
---
Thank you for reading.
Akira Urushibata

Social control media owned and run by 'broligarchs' keeps attacking RMS for insisting on names that include GNU, but we won't link to these, only make this observation. Follow the money. █

Other Recent Techrights' Posts

Links 09/11/2026: Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang Cheats on Wife With A Suspected Chinese Spy, "400,000 Russians Killed in Battle Since 2022 Invasion"
Links for the day
Digitalisation Is Not Inevitable or Unavoidable
Nor inescapable
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXIV - Why the Swatting Failed
After that we only ever heard from or spoke to cops when we invited them to our home to collect evidence
 
The Register MS is Not Objective Regarding "AI", It's Paid by Pushers of the Pyramid Scheme (including Nvidia)
Some time soon we'll name some companies that pay millions to The Register MS in order to cement their role in the house of cards (while it lasts)
GAFAM Moribund
A lot of what we say about Microsoft in respect to debt is equally applicable to the rest of GAFAM
NVIDIA as a Scam Company Run by Scammers Who Fake Demand for Their Waste of Energy (Subsidising GPU Sales for Use Cases That Don't Exist)
First they targeted gamers, then fake 'currencies' (which turned out to be a bust), now it's slop (obfuscation of plagiarism using brute force and fusion) [...] We're quite glad that Huang publicly broadcasts how untrustworthy he is
Zero Tolerance for Slop
very few sites that dabbled in slop ended up well off (for it)
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, November 08, 2026
IRC logs for Sunday, November 08, 2026
Gemini Links 09/11/2026: "The Blue Wave Won't Save Us" and "Discoverability Is Only Solved If You Can Be Discovered"
Links for the day
IBM 'Robbery': No More Car Allowance in the UK, Severance Shredded, CEO Pay Up 51% in One Year While Thousands Laid Off in Secret
Why does a CEO reward himself so much when the company does so badly?
Gemini Links 08/11/2026: "Back", Zot, and Information Overload
Links for the day
“Concerned Microsoft Workers” Say “Working at Microsoft Has Become Joyless and Demoralizing.” (That's What Microsoft Wants, More Will Leave That Way)
Many Microsoft employees are going to leave
The Register MS is Losing Hundreds of Thousands of Pounds a Year While Directors Pay Themselves Hundreds of Thousands of Pounds a Year in Dividends
they take money from slop pushers and have clearly compromised some journalistic standards in the process
GNU/Linux Measured at 7.4% in the UK This Weekend: Clownflare Radar
I hope that one day GNU/Linux will be everywhere here
Never a One-Person Project
Just because I'm the main "public face" of the site (who takes all the insults and SLAPPs) doesn't mean I deserve all the credit
“I Always Expect to Lose. I Fight Anyway, and Sometimes I Win.” — Richard Stallman
To change the world meaningfully people must think big
Stop Looking for News About "Layoffs", Layoffs Are Over (They've Been Rebranded)
To properly assess the status quo we need other yardsticks
Links 08/11/2026: Bosses Who Were Forcing Their Workers to Use Slop Change Mind, "Rapper RBX Files Ninth Circuit Appeal in Fraud-Focused Class Action Lawsuit Against Spotify"
Links for the day
Links 08/11/2026: Why Vikings Stayed in Iceland and "TikTok Accused Of Promoting Sex Industry To Young Girls"
Links for the day
Gemini Links 08/11/2026: "Before Sunrise" and LLM Scrapers Versus Self-Hosting (or Web in General)
Links for the day
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXIII - Weaponising Cops in Another Continent (Europe), Knowing They Cannot Come to Your Home in America, While Threatening Women
This year it culminated in death threats
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Saturday, November 07, 2026
IRC logs for Saturday, November 07, 2026
The Decade Ahead, a Decade of Suppressed Stories
Our stories aren't discouraged or considered taboo because of racism or "toxic politics" or anything like that; they just hurt powerful people and corporations
Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) Inaction and Incompetence - Part V - "Reports Closed Without the Evidence Being Examined."
Totally what the SRA did regarding Brett Wilson LLP
Gemini Links 07/11/2026: Illusion Garden and Lagrange 2
Links for the day
Complexity is the Tyrant's Friend
Slop is for feeble minds and cheaters
IBM Firings (or Silent Layoffs) After Bluewashing; "IBM’s Employment History is More Troubling Than its Patriotic Marketing Suggests"
"It has zip to do with race but everything to do with the greed of the 1% who have been doing all they can to destroy the middle class..."
“Week van de Werkstress” and Work-Related Stress at the EPO, Where Staff is Bullied Into Granting Illegal Patents for Foreign Monopolists
"poor working environments, including discrimination and inequality, excessive workloads, low job control and job insecurity pose a risk to mental health"
Czech Republic: GNU/Linux Rises Above 5% in Desktops and Laptops
A year ago it was somewhere around 4%
EPO's Local Staff Committee The Hague Says Almost or About a Third of Staff Assembled to Organise at "a Time of Continued Social Unrest"
They speak of "circa 850 staff members in attendance" (in The Netherlands there are about a couple thousand)
Suggestions That XBox Will be Offloaded by Microsoft, Rather Than Shut Down, Make the False Assumption XBox is Profitable (It's Not, It's a Liability)
Microsoft has serious financial troubles
Which "Smart" "Phone", Which "Social" "Media", and Which "Cloud" "Storage"?
Let's take back control of the language
State of the (Linux) Slop, Late 2026 Edition
Google News (Gulag Noise) is a plagiarism booster
Year 21
It's 5PM here
Links 07/11/2026: "Flock Cameras Got Eviscerated by the Midterms" and Joshua Wong Shows China is Highly Repressive and Fully Controls Hong Kong
Links for the day
At The Register MS the Net Liabilities Doubled in One Year, Tangible Assets Down About 35% in One Year
signed off in 2026
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXII - Running One's Mouth
British Police told me "making a false complaint to police is a crime" in relation to Lozza
Another 20 Years of Exposing Corruption
We'll focus on carrying on what we do
EPO Budget and Finance Committee (in Very Recent Meeting) Increases Bribes to People Who Vote on Campinos Reappointment ("Cooperation Activities")
Buying 'elections' to protect the cocaine-stained regime in Europe's second-largest institution
Links 07/11/2026: London's SLAPP Industry Now Targets Kirkenes (Northern Norway) at the Behest of Corrupt Thieves in Russia and Microsoft’s 'Buyout' Offer Crashes Microsoft Systems
Links for the day
Links 07/11/2026: "The Moon is Waning Crescent", Homeworlds, and "Can't Handle The AVIF!"
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Friday, November 06, 2026
IRC logs for Friday, November 06, 2026