Software Patents in Europe Are Still Promoted by the EPO, Even in Defiance of the Ban

Dr. Roy Schestowitz

2017-06-15 10:06:16 UTC
Modified: 2017-06-15 10:06:16 UTC

CII at EPO
This EPO presentation from just months ago spoke of software patents ("CII"). Photo credit: EPO Patent Information Conference 2016 (Grant Philpott)

Summary: The European Patent Office continues to ignore the directive on the patentability of computer-implemented inventions, which had software patents disallowed with an overwhelming majority of 648 to 14 votes at the European Parliament

THE patentability of software in the US patent system, or at least the enforceability of such patents in courts, is in a sharp decline. We have a lot of articles about that coming (several dozens of drafts), but EPO is a priority for now.

"Has it been privately decided in Battistelli's secret penthouse that patent quality no longer matters, only the perception/illusion thereof?"Software patents are not permitted in Europe, yet in public events the EPO's spokespeople have the audacity to repeatedly defend and promote these. It pushes in a similar direction in India, which has similar laws for similar exclusions (athough India's patent office actually obeys these exclusions, unlike the EPO).

The EPO further expanded to patents on life and genome (not a joke!) and days ago we saw some press release and coverage about Transgenomic. How far will the EPO go? Has it been privately decided in Battistelli's secret penthouse that patent quality no longer matters, only the perception/illusion thereof? Stakeholders were not consulted about this and many holders of EPs will inevitably see the value of their patent/s perish.

"Software patents are not allowed in Europe."The EPO is pushing software patents again, in defiance of the law (see paragraph 3 in this epo.org Web page) that EPO promoted here and also (about a day later) here. To quote the relevant part: "The consequences for the patent system are potentially tremendous, and they challenge some of the fundamental concepts of the system, such as the definition of "industry" and "inventor". There will be a greater overlap and interplay between the types of rights, and as software pervades through all technologies a greater debate on the patentability of software."

There was already a debate and it was concluded. Software patents are not allowed in Europe. We wrote about the above, "Industry 4.0", several months ago, and particularly about how it was used by the EPO to promote software patents, not just in the past but also at present.

"...Siemens had a lot to do with the push for software patents in Europe, not just in Germany..."This report which the EPO is promoting this week was quoted as saying that "They [presumably those who actually produce software] feel that software patents must be abolished or greatly restricted."

Attributed to Siemens, a top patentor at the EPO, is this quote: "novel hardware in order to be patentable is “an alarming development”..."

As we wrote here a very long time ago, Siemens had a lot to do with the push for software patents in Europe, not just in Germany [1, 2]. ⬆

The Register MS is Profiting From Pyramid Schemes Run by Americans: We cannot help but feel disgusted by what this publisher became
IBM: Hiring, Then Disposing of, Unpaid or Low-Paid European Staff to Spread or Play Up Buzzwords and Hype: Like Google With "Summer of Code", this seems like a low-cost marketing stunt more than anything substantial
The Europe Conversation: The EPO Has Cocaine at the High-Level Management and Isn't Denying It: Now we plan to ensure the matter is properly documented in European press
Links 15/11/2025: Science, Conflicts, and International Politics: Links for the day
Annus Horribilis at the European Patent Office (EPO): The article explains how the EPO "Cocainegate" scandal is turning 2025 into an Annus Horribilis for Campinos
Links 15/11/2025: Latest in "Component Abuse Challenge" and Qt Keeps Promoting LLM Slop: Links for the day
Gemini Links 15/11/2025: Egoism, Misunderstood Universe, DeX, and "Why desktop Linux is growing": Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Friday, November 14, 2025: IRC logs for Friday, November 14, 2025
Richard Stallman Talk Tomorrow in Ethereum Cypherpunk Congress 2: It's not clear if a livestream of some kind will exist
Many "Last Days" at IBM on Allegedly the "Last Day" for IBM to RA People This Quarter: "Last day" is "social media code" for "got laid off", more so at IBM because they compel people to act like it's a happy departure with gratitude, photos and so on
Slopwatch: Almost a Majority of Google News is Now Slopfarms (Fake Sites, Fake Articles): Google News is noise
Gemini Links 14/11/2025: Boredom, "Twenty Percent Cooler", and Moving From Windows to Artix: Links for the day
Links 14/11/2025: YouTube's Trap for Publishers, Lack of Accountability a Growing Legal Matter/Concern: Links for the day
Many Times in the Past We Said That Microsoft Lunduke Was Becoming a Spokesperson/Voice for - and Occasionally Weaponising - 4Chan. He's Proving Us Right This Week.: Stay away
Casual Reminder That We Also Publish GNU/Linux Stories and News Coverage in Tux Machines: Without trust in our robustness (including fearlessness, not just success in protecting stories and sources) we'd not have come this far, nor would I devote my life to it
Links 14/11/2025: Goddard Space Center Abused by the White House, Jeffrey Epstein Scandal Expands (Cheetos Need Distraction): Links for the day
Corporate Media Helps IBM Relay Vapourware (Misinformation/Fake News): They compensate with words for a lack of compelling products
Hacking on Recipes: Maybe, in due course perhaps, we can also release some of our own cooking recipes or "forks"
Web Searches Far Too Polluted, Gamed by LLM Slop and "Plagiarised Information Synthesis Systems" (PISS): old articles are already getting difficult to find in mainstream search engines, even if they are still online
Privacy-respecting Metasearch Engine SearX/SearXNG Still Jailed by Microsoft: The official site and code still sadly controlled by Microsoft
"AI" is a Lie. It Always Was. What They Call "AI" Is Not.: This MSM does no favours to the economy
Our First Week of Our Twentieth Year: My wife and I have had a very productive week here and in Tux Machines
Links 14/11/2025: Sleep Research, France to Suspend Pension 'Reform' Law, and Linux Foundation's Latest Openwashing: Links for the day
Gemini Links 14/11/2025: KDE vs XFCE and Leaving the Web: Links for the day
Google Admits It Lost Control of Slop (While Google Itself is Selling Slop, Currently Under the Name "Gemini" Instead of "Bard"): Slop is nothing to be celebrated
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Thursday, November 13, 2025: IRC logs for Thursday, November 13, 2025
Mozilla Handed Over Control Over Firefox to Microsoft, Now Firefox is Preloaded With Microsoft Spyware and It's Proprietary: Who would still want to download Firefox?
Slopwatch: LinuxSecurity, Brian Fagioli, and WebProNews: becoming a slopfarm is a site's suicide
"Sponsored Posts" in The Register MS: That's The Register MS in 2025
IBM RAs in India (Apparently): IBM is a bad place to work
Another Richard Stallman Talk in Two Days: His talk will be a remote talk, as he won't be travelling to Argentina
Links 13/11/2025: "Fight for Control Over In-Car Technology" and "Climate Crisis is a Health Crisis": Links for the day
Gemini Links 13/11/2025: Disbelief in the Moon Landings and Doom That Came to Scrolling: Links for the day
A Month After "End of 10" analytics.usa.gov Says More People Use Vista 7 Than Use Vista 11: Does it get any more pathetic than this?
Links 13/11/2025: Ghost (E-mails) of Jeffrey Epstein Chases Cheeto, Uproar Over SLAPP Threats Against British Broadcasters: Links for the day
IBM Layoffs Seem to Have Reached Europe: Is it Europe's turn to fall on its sword?
A Lot of What's Left of the Online "Media" is Paid-for SPAM: How much of online media can people still trust?
Synopsys, Which Controls a Microsoft FUD Operation (Black Duck), to Lay Off Hundreds of Workers: Microsoft had plenty of layoffs this year, well over 30,000 in total, including at least two waves of layoffs last month
The EPO Has Spent Years Attacking European Media, Led by a Cocaine Addict (the EPO's Spokesperson): The EPO silences critics
Prominent German Media Dares Not Mention Cocaine at the European Patent Office, Germany's "Cash Cow" (Seller of Monopolies for the Whole of Europe): It seems like a case of the corrupt hiring the corrupt to bully those who speak about the corruption
Techrights Protects Against Collective Amnesia (Forgetting History the Rich and Powerful Want Us to Forget or be Misled About): Keeping full access to our material with a good search facility is a priority for us
Mainstream Media Compliments Techrights on Its Work: Google isn't "the Web" and this site isn't "the Web" either
Microsoft-Sponsored FSFE is Exploiting the Success of Jean-Baptiste Kempf to Market Itself and Its GAFAM-Funded Messaging (While Pretending to be "FSF" Europe): No doubt Jean-Baptiste Kempf accomplished a lot (not limited to VLC) in not so many years
A Week of Techrights Search: Tomorrow it'll be one week since we turned 19
LLMs Will Never Work, You Need to Type What You Know: Voice recognition is too imprecise to be practical or really save any time if you can type fast
Your Computers Are Work and Entertainment Tools, Not a Fashion Statement: If you're into fashion, find another job or keep cruft out of the workplace
The Federation? Almost 90% of Its Users Have Quit Participating.: If one counts offline (historic) instances, it's even worse than this
Under IBM, Red Hat Isn't a Linux Company, It's Sold to Clients as "AI Company": IBM is sacrificing Red Hat for Wall Street (share price)
IBM Will Carry on or Carry Out Mass Layoffs Until Tomorrow, Based on Unverified Claim (Silent Layoffs Under Secrecy Clauses/Deals): Red Hat (as a "company" with a Web site) will probably never announce layoffs again
It Looks Like Microsoft is Really Abandoning XBox (the Brand "XBox" Means Just an Online "Games Store" or Streaming): Published last night
The Register MS Has Just Taken Money to Promote Microsoft Windows Under the Guise of "HEY HI" (AI): Just 'consume' the ads disguised as "journalism" at The Register MS
Apple is Waning, Shows Data (Web Stats): Is Apple doing as well as Apple-sponsored (paid to run Apple ads) claims?
IBM is a Buzzwords Vendor: Does anyone even pay attention to anything IBM promises these days?
It's Patently False That Apple Has Avoided Layoffs: be sceptical of people who say Apple hasn't got layoffs
IRC.com is Vendor-Locked (Freenode): Web client
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, November 12, 2025: IRC logs for Wednesday, November 12, 2025
Slopwatch: Spam, Scams, and Plagiarised Information Synthesis Systems (LLMs): The way things are going, LinuxSecurity might become entirely inactive
IBM "Trying to Memory Hole the RA With Positive News.": it's clear they have no real plan, just vapourware
Gemini Links 13/11/2025: Pictures From the Aurora and Cryptography of the Internet: Links for the day

Software Patents in Europe Are Still Promoted by the EPO, Even in Defiance of the Ban

Recent Techrights' Posts