EditorsAbout the SiteComes vs. MicrosoftUsing This Web SiteSite ArchivesCredibility IndexOOXMLOpenDocumentPatentsNovellNews DigestSite NewsRSS

03.23.17

Nepotism at the European Patent Office and Suspicious Absence of Tenders for Big Projects

Posted in Europe, Patents at 1:09 pm by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

We know who’s laughing all the way to the bank, but we don’t know why

Man laughing

Summary: Carte blanche is a French term which now perfectly describes the symptoms encountered in the European Patent Office, more so once led by a lot of French people (Battistelli and his friends)

Battistelli has turned the EPO into a laughing stock and he too seems to realise it (albeit still trying to shift the blame for it). Comments in The Register, for instance, already joke about the EPO’s apparent transparency, saying that it’s about transparency in the windows and in the panorama sense (alluding to Battistelli's secretive palace at the top floor).

“Battistelli still seems ever so eager to yank out lots of crappy patents, demonstrating his utter lack of real understanding of the process involved.”Why was Team Battistelli trying so hard to hide what had happened there at the top floor? Why was it so concerned about photographs showing up in a Web site (concerned enough to demand that they should be taken down immediately)? See, Battistelli does not really like transparency. Battistelli just likes publishing/composing (perhaps merely signing) so-called ‘blogs’ about “transparency”. It’s like those speeches where George Bush speaks about freedom and democracy. Nobody should take these words seriously.

Battistelli, along with the docile EPO management, continues to lie to the staff (example from last night), just like he lies to journalists. It’s utterly disturbing that he keeps getting away with it. Lying is a much lesser offense than those other things Battistelli can be accused of (his immunity from prosecution notwithstanding). Battistelli still seems ever so eager to yank out lots of crappy patents, demonstrating his utter lack of real understanding of the process involved. In France they don't do any of this and he seems to believe that computers can replace humans for such a monumental, complex task.

“If Battistelli has any dignity (an unrealistic expectation, no doubt!), he would have resigned and then publicly apologised.”Due to this reckless policy of Battistelli, the EPO will probably have many layoffs and decades of great pain ahead, having to ‘clean up’ (i.e. flush down erroneously-granted EPs). Expect a growing need for oppositions/appeals; it takes a lot of work and even more resources than ordinary examination. It’s very expensive to do all this and there are ramifications like refunds after licensing deals, which may or may not have already destroyed products if not companies (injunctions, bankruptcies and so on).

If Battistelli has any dignity (an unrealistic expectation, no doubt!), he would have resigned and then publicly apologised. He should give his new penthouse to the Boards of Appeal (BoA), then quietly walk away to exile in some fine Haar hospital. That in its own right would not fix the Office, but it would at least be a start. Here is a sarcastic new comment which we caught yesterday:

Don’t forget that the President and his friends earn considerably more for a work which, at best, can be described as mediocre.

“But is this really what the economy needs, as the EPO claims?”

Now we know what the economy needs.
New public-private partnership construction projects to kick-start the recovery …

King Battistelli’s swish penthouse office the Euro Patent Office doesn’t want you to see

Some readers of ours seem to believe that Team Battistelli foresees its end and hence tries to claw money from the future. In any other, i.e. accountable, patent office this would be a scandal so big that the media would be all over it. But not in Europe; certainly not in Germany, which seems to be gaining by turning a blind eye to it.

“Sometimes it’s depressing to see what people like Battistelli can get away with.”For all we know, the contractors chosen to design and build Battistelli’s palace could be nothing more than old friends of Lutz or whoever else guards Team Battistelli while milking the Office. There’s no way of telling when procurement is so obscure, especially in recent years. Judging by the lack of updates in the report from the The Register*, the Office never got back with any details about the costs associated with construction, design etc. And yet, the EPO keeps bragging about tenders recently, especially in Twitter (almost half a dozen times in the past month alone). Maybe they just try to proactively distract from something.

“You’ll understand the key aspects of patent litigation better after this free online class,” the EPO wrote the other day.

“With UPC,” I responded, “the EPO wants lots of litigation using bogus patents (EPs are BS now, due to Battistelli)…”

Sometimes it’s depressing to see what people like Battistelli can get away with. All of us — myself included — will suffer from this in the long run. Battistelli will have stashed millions of Euros and probably retire peacefully in Corsica, where the name Battistelli may be already associated with a Mafia.
_____
* The article says: “We have asked the EPO if it will break out the cost of Battistelli’s office, and we will update this story if it responds.” But a day and a half later there is no update.

Share this post: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
  • co.mments
  • DZone
  • email
  • Google Bookmarks
  • LinkedIn
  • NewsVine
  • Print
  • Technorati
  • TwitThis
  • Facebook

If you liked this post, consider subscribing to the RSS feed or join us now at the IRC channels.

Pages that cross-reference this one

7 Comments

  1. john said,

    March 24, 2017 at 9:26 am

    Gravatar

    I don’t know how much the renovation of the 10th floor was, but I know that no structural work was really needed. I know how the building is built and it was always designed to allow this kind of open floor plan. The walls separating the offices bear no structural load and can be removed easily. The building was famous amongst architects when it was built originally.

  2. Anton_P said,

    March 24, 2017 at 10:33 am

    Gravatar

    Hi, the IPKat ran a short article about EP patents being “printed” by Jouve. Didn’t you run a story about this firm a few months ago? From recollection, you pointed out that the firm which got the contract was essentially a shell company.

    Dr. Roy Schestowitz Reply:

    I think you might be mistaking it for, e.g., Europatis. I never wrote about Jouve.

    Honest question: do you think the Jouve story merits coverage here? Didn’t look like a huge deal.

    john Reply:

    Jouve is a big fish as far as the EPO is concerned. They built the main part of the EPO database system and related systems and that is a contract that was not cheap. They are also still deeply involved and you should thank ipkat for pointing that out. Europatis is comparatively small (and indeed linked to Jacques Michel).

    The story started in 1990 and is described in that book, page 38:
    https://books.google.de/books?id=wovsCgAAQBAJ

    Other key players were active at the time, particularly Bertelsmann. How the whole European patent database activity managed to end up concentrated in the hand of a single private player would be a very interesting story, even more so when you realize that this single player is French.

    Dr. Roy Schestowitz Reply:

    If it started in the 1990s (or prior to that), then it’s hard to demonstrate French nepotism.

    Presidents of the European Patent Office:

    1. Johannes Bob van Benthem (1 November 1977 – 30 April 1985), Dutch.
    2. Paul Braendli (1 May 1985 – 31 December 1995), Swiss.
    3. Ingo Kober (1 January 1996 – 30 June 2004), German.
    4. Alain Pompidou (1 July 2004 – 30 June 2007), French.
    5. Alison Brimelow (1 July 2007 – 30 June 2010), British.
    6. Benoît Battistelli (from 1 July 2010), French.

  3. john said,

    March 25, 2017 at 4:46 pm

    Gravatar

    About tenders and control: there is absolutely no, nada, zilch control on how Battistelli spends the EPO money. People don’t realize that and don’t even believe it when faced with the facts, but it is true:
    1: for “moderate” sums, there is a placement procedure, meaning the EPO management chooses absolutely freely. Except that the sum is not that “moderate” and that management are allowed to split a large project into smaller chunks
    2: for larger sums (think about a project like, the MOST EXPENSIVE building in the Netherlands, presently under construction), there is internal audit. Except that the head of that department is a personal friend that Battistelli hired from the INPI. That person has functional immunity and is only responsible to the EPO president.
    3: France’s minister of industry, who is responsible for Patents, aware of what is going on and of a different political side as Battistelli, instructed France’s representative to vote against the budget in 2015. Before the session, Battistelli talked to that person in private and the person did not vote. He said his voting key did not work. It is a unique event in the history of the budget committee and demonstrated that national delegations can do nothing when Battistelli can talk in private to the representative.

    I think that with all your efforts and your stream of articles you are still severely underestimating the magnitude of the EPO’s problem.

    Dr. Roy Schestowitz Reply:

    The tendering problems were covered quite recently. If you have additional information (like the above), please do share. It helps with future articles. Evidence of some kind would help too, in the face of expected denials or the EPO taking actions in an effort to rewrite history (happened several times before, always as a reaction to something we had leaked).

What Else is New


  1. A Month After One OSI Co-Founder Resigns in the Mailing Lists Over OSI's Attacks on Software Freedom the Other OSI Co-Founder Gets Kicked Out for Speaking About It

    The 'cancel culture' seems to be canceling people who speak about software freedom, under the guise of the real motivation being manners (when one lashes out at those who attack Free software and free speech)



  2. Links 27/2/2020: LibreOffice 6.4.1, Collabora Office for Phones and Latte Dock 0.9.9

    Links for the day



  3. The Linux Foundation is Deeply Committed to Diversity and Inclusiveness (as Long as You Have Perfect Vision and Use 'Big Browsers' That Spy)

    The Linux Foundation's message of inclusiveness refers only to a particular kind of inclusiveness



  4. Inside the Free Software Foundation (FSF) - Part I: Year Zero

    People behind the ousting of Richard Stallman (or 'leaders of the coup' as some call them) want a fresh start; but they aren't starting what most FSF supporters have been led to believe



  5. Alexandre Oliva on Diversity Hypocrites

    "Some of them purport to be for inclusion and diversity, but won't hesitate to make fun of someone's poorly-disguised handicap."



  6. IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, February 26, 2020

    IRC logs for Wednesday, February 26, 2020



  7. Alexandre Oliva: Courage is Contagious

    Having a proposal rejected at a conference is nothing unusual, but the surrounding circumstances and the conflicting versions are.



  8. Links 26/2/2020: Cosmo Communicator 2-in-1, FSF Outlines Plans for Code Hosting

    Links for the day



  9. Reminder: At Linux Foundation in 2020 Three Board Members, Including the Vice Chair and Director at Large, Are Current or Past Microsoft Employees

    Sometimes the facts speak for themselves (or pictures speak louder than words)



  10. IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, February 25, 2020

    IRC logs for Tuesday, February 25, 2020



  11. Links 25/2/2020: MakuluLinux LinDoz and Manjaro 19.0 Released

    Links for the day



  12. FSF's Interim Co-President Alexandre Oliva on FSF Communication Policies

    Surely I, being acting president and then half-acting president, must suck as a manager. I probably do indeed, but it's not so simple.



  13. The EU's EUIPO Will Later Today Help the EPO (Run by EUIPO's Former Chief) Promote Illegal Software Patents

    Propaganda terms such as "intellectual property rights" and meaningless concepts like "technical effect" are being used to promote so-called 'computer-implemented inventions' (software patents by another name)



  14. Growing Acceptance That There's No Future to the UPC System and the Unitary Patent

    There are growing pains and more signs that even key elements of Team UPC move on, accepting the demise of the UPC



  15. Emulating the Linux Foundation's Business Model (Selling Influence)

    LibrePlanet sponsors are presented with benefits of offering money to the event (or to the FSF)



  16. Guest Article: LibrePlanet Attendees Should Demand a Partial Refund

    What we do know is — that the FSF is no longer “Free as in Speech!”



  17. IRC Proceedings: Monday, February 24, 2020

    IRC logs for Monday, February 24, 2020



  18. An FSF That Rejects Its Founder Would Not Remain FSF As We Once Knew It

    It's important to keep the FSF focused on its goals; that won't be achieved by expelling those who insist on these goals



  19. Links 24/2/2020: Linux 5.6 RC3, Netrunner 20.01, Google Summer of Code 2020 Mentoring Organisations Announced

    Links for the day



  20. Alexandre Oliva's New Article About a Coup

    Some people try to tell me that the criticism I've got, inside the FSF and outside, since the Free Software Sept 11, are not about my being supportive of RMS, but about my making public statements referencing him at all.



  21. Debian Leadership Should Not be 'Shy' of Politics (and It's OK to Admit Palestinians Are Human Beings Too)

    The contemporary tendency to limit people's freedom of speech (e.g. permission to express political views) means that while people may find software freedom they will lose other essential freedoms



  22. New Series: Inside the Free Software Foundation (FSF)

    In the interest and motivation of exposing the true nature of things, Techrights will turn its attention to internal affairs at the higher echelons of the FSF, founded more than three and a half decades ago in MIT (where Stallman launched the GNU Project, developed the GNU Compiler Collection and a lot more foundational Free software)



  23. IRC Proceedings: Sunday, February 23, 2020

    IRC logs for Sunday, February 23, 2020



  24. Links 23/2/2020: PipeWire 0.3 and Osu!

    Links for the day



  25. FSF's Interim Co-President Alexandre Oliva on Being Cancelled

    It was reading this that I realized I’d been cancelled myself. In my case, I was painted misogynist and transphobic, and for a post in which I supported women but denounced a crowd of men twisting the feminist cause, that I share, to attack rms, as if he wasn’t a feminist himself; and in which I express curiosity as to what pronoun to use to refer to zero women to paint me as someone who disregards gender identities and their pronouns.



  26. Good People Need to Run for Free Software Foundation (FSF) Board Positions After an FSF Coup Threw in the Towel, Pushing Out the Founder

    "I have been hit, but not knocked out, and my campaign for free software is not over." --Richard Stallman, October 2019



  27. IRC Proceedings: Saturday, February 22, 2020

    IRC logs for Saturday, February 22, 2020



  28. Alexandre Oliva's Message About Cancel Culture at the FSF

    Being cancelled is no fun. In my case, it was for standing for a friend who got canceled for defending someone else from an accusation that was later proven false.



  29. Links 22/2/2020: Polish Government Increases GNU/Linux Use, Samza 1.3.1

    Links for the day



  30. Being Rich Does Not Imply Being Smart (Especially When One is Born Into Wealth)

    Presenting the 'genius' (college dropout, but that does not matter when the yardstick of wisdom is wealth alone), with his own predictions overlaid on top of his photo from the show of Bloomberg (another 'genius' whose supposed brilliance is measured using money alone)


RSS 64x64RSS Feed: subscribe to the RSS feed for regular updates

Home iconSite Wiki: You can improve this site by helping the extension of the site's content

Home iconSite Home: Background about the site and some key features in the front page

Chat iconIRC Channel: Come and chat with us in real time

Recent Posts