Bonum Certa Men Certa

An Uphill Battle for Software Patents in the United States, Except When Catchphrases and Buzzwords Are Used

20 Buzzwords you have to know in Artificial Intelligence
Reference: 20 Buzzwords you have to know in Artificial Intelligence



Summary: Barring or excepting misuse of buzzwords such as Artificial Intelligence, software patents have become incredibly hard to assert in the United States, albeit they're possible to sneak past examiners and then license without any legal challenge

THIS summer, i.e. several months from now, Alice will turn four. The USPTO is still granting some software patents (that ought to have stopped), but the courts as well as PTAB barely tolerate any of that.



"The USPTO is still granting some software patents (that ought to have stopped), but the courts as well as PTAB barely tolerate any of that."Watchtroll is still overtly promoting software patents, even in a so-called 'webiner'. It's like a front group. But worry not, they're not getting their way.

One way remains to get software patents past examiners and sometimes judges too. It boils down to semantics; they just try to make software patents sound like something they're not. They use all sorts of catchphrases and buzzwords -- many of which we have named here before. That includes, more recently, artificial intelligence (AI).

"They use all sorts of catchphrases and buzzwords -- many of which we have named here before. That includes, more recently, artificial intelligence (AI)."It has been particularly hard to overlook or ignore the "AI" buzzword (and media hype) this month. Everywhere one looks in the news -- not just science news -- it's "AI", "AI", "AI"... it's not even a new concept.

Wayne Ramsay, Chief Strategy Officer at Exigent, wrote about "AI" some days ago in relation to law firms. It's time for law firms which neither understand "AI" nor care about "AI" to just say "AI" all the time:

Instead, alternative providers have taken a multifaceted approach to innovation: still applying the FTE billable hour model while slowly shifting to the faster, better quality, fixed-fee model enabled by Artificial Intelligence. [AI]


"We previously hypothesised and showed evidence for "AI" as a buzzword of choice for software patents, along with "machine learning" (ML) and other related terms."All this hype about artificial intelligence has even reached IAM some days ago ("Patent search: the evolution from manual to artificial intelligence"), not to mention Lexology ("Artificial Intelligence: All Our Patent Are Belong to You 3.0"). This nearly sickening media hype around "Artificial Intelligence" (especially over the past month) is mystifying. Who is pushing this? The concept is many decades old. Why is it all of a sudden like the "next best thing"? We previously hypothesised and showed evidence for "AI" as a buzzword of choice for software patents, along with "machine learning" (ML) and other related terms. A lot of examiners might not be familiar with these concepts, which can make any old idea sound more novel/innovative. I actually implemented "AI" more than 15 years ago when I wrote game engines and wrote papers about machine learning about 15 years ago when working on my Ph.D. Even back then those things weren't particularly cutting-edge. It's statistics. It's mathematics.

We kindly ask examiners as well as other readers not to be misled by buzzwords. They're like fashion.

"We kindly ask examiners as well as other readers not to be misled by buzzwords. They're like fashion."Why does the US still grant some software patents on what's clearly not eligible under Alice? A few days ago I saw this new press release about 4 newly-granted patents on computer vision (my research discipline). Do they really not know that it's just mathematics (matrices)?

How about Walmart applying for a 3D image patent for online grocery? This too was in the news some days ago and again it's computer vision, i.e. software/geometry. Stop granting monopolies on maths...

"As it's a blanket/bulk licence, they might be paying for patents that aren't even eligible."To name one last example, Aterica licenses mMed patents [1, 2] on a "hardware and software platform," which we assume means that some of these patents simply cover software. As it's a blanket/bulk licence, they might be paying for patents that aren't even eligible. This kind of bundling of decent patents with dubious ones has become so common. It's one way to drive up the price of licensing or litigation (for instance, suing or threatening to sue a company with 100 patents, only a handful of which are decent). Patent maximalism is quite a disease and it's antithetical to the theory of incentive.

Recent Techrights' Posts

China's Oceans of Fake Patents on Buzzwords and Hype Reinforce the Widespread Belief That Some Patent Systems Go Astray
They're conflating patents, which are immaterial, with something else, possibly to reinvigorate the old "GAI" hype bubble
GNU/Linux Up to 4.4%, But Let's Think Beyond the Numbers
GNU/Linux growing is a good thing, but we need to look beyond the brand if not dogma
Labour Party Should Transfer Its Web Site and Communications Back to the United Kingdom
The "take back control" (Brexit) rhetoric overlooks the real issues.
Microsoft-, IBM-, and Google-Funded 'FSFE' Don't Follow Their Own Inclusive Language Guidelines
They've deposited that in more official sites
Software In The Public Interest Inc. Turned Against The Public Interest and Turned Into "Red" (Heavy Losses)
Censoring the community
 
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, July 07, 2024
IRC logs for Sunday, July 07, 2024
OSI is Microsoft Front Group, Sponsored by Microsoft
They're hardly even good at pretending anymore!
The World of "Linux", According to Microsoft
You look for Linux news and this is what you get instead
Noam Chomsky Apparently Does Not Understand or Care for Software Freedom
Looking a decade back
[Video] Stella Assange Encourages Citizens or Citizen-Journalists to Put in a Freedom of Information Request Regarding Julian Assange Case
After pleading guilty he is not eligible to do so (at FOIA capacity)
Some GNU/Linux News Sites Are Still Doing OK (But Many Perish)
Today, or overnight, we shall take stock of which sites are still active
Back in the Flow
We're still hoping for a "proper" Wikileaks comeback
Links 07/07/2024: Science and War Updates
Links for the day
Gemini Links 07/07/2024: Candyfloss and GOWIN Chinese FPGAs
Links for the day
Asia is Moving to GNU/Linux, 6% Already Estimated to be on GNU/Linux "Proper" (Not Chromebooks, Steam Deck Etc.)
Isn't it interesting that the so-called 'tech media' never really covers this and barely mentions this?
Links 07/07/2024: Music Getting Objectively Worse, Software Patents Bubble in China
Links for the day
Gemini Links 07/07/2024: Coolness of Geekdom and UPS Story
Links for the day
More Cybercrimes Committed Today by the Misogynists Who Attack My Family and Myself
These people openly boast about avoiding arrest
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Saturday, July 06, 2024
IRC logs for Saturday, July 06, 2024
Just Say the Truth, People Will Come
Uttering lies is a short-term "strategy" (like social control media clickbaiting), it won't last
Microsoft Windows in the Bolivarian Republic Of Venezuela: From Almost 98% (2010) to Just 28% (This Summer), Android Reaches New Highs
the Bolivarian Republic Of Venezuela is gradually exiting Microsoft, even faster than its neighbours, maybe for political reasons
[Meme] Not Winning Arguments and Not Winning Allies, Either
Misusing civil rights causes to censor people for billionaires is basically an attack on these civil rights causes
Microsofters and Their Chaos Theory
censorship is not the way to go
Love Always Wins (Truth Also)
I am still working on lengthy bodies of text
"Streamline Workforce" is the Same as Mass Layoffs, Apparently
we deserve better media than this
Back on the Saddle, Good News
Justices Jeremy Johnson and Victoria Sharp can focus on "real" cases instead
Truth is Not a Crime
They try to censor, not to correct, rebut etc.
Maldives: Estimates of GNU/Linux Userbase Rose From Less Than 1% Last Year to 4% This Month
Desktop Operating System Market Share Maldives
New DW Documentary on Julian Assange (After Release From Prison)
By Turkish journalist Can Dündar
[Meme] A Diversity of Options: YouTube (Proprietary) or YouTube (Proprietary)
Rikard Grossman-Nielsen: 'will there be some online streaming of it?'
Android on 9 Out of 20 Web-Connected Devices for First Time Ever?
According to statCounter, Android has just topped 45%
Wryl Explains the Software Crisis or Why "Counterculture Movements are Health Signals, and a Fever is Brewing"
"(the software crisis)"
Move to Microsoft Because... Bribes (to FreeBSD Developers)?
Don't do drugs, kids, even if the first sample is 'free'
[Meme] [Teaser] Microsoft's Covert Control of the British Government
Coming soon...
statCounter: GNU/Linux Now at 4.3%
statCounter isn't a gold(en) measure, the ground truth or a perfect yardstick, it's just an approximation, which may or may not tell us many people move from Vista 11 to GNU/Linux
Larissa Brown Shapiro & Mozilla concerned other organizations taking advantage of kids in open source
Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
Links 06/07/2024: More on Microsoft Layoffs
Links for the day
Gemini Links 06/07/2024: Usenet Comeback, Web Economics
Links for the day
The Paradoxical State of GNU/Linux Coverage
so much happening, so little reporting
Links 06/07/2024: Shapeways Files For Bankruptcy, Cloudflare Subpoena Emerges
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Friday, July 05, 2024
IRC logs for Friday, July 05, 2024