EditorsAbout the SiteComes vs. MicrosoftUsing This Web SiteSite ArchivesCredibility IndexOOXMLOpenDocumentPatentsNovellNews DigestSite NewsRSS

01.11.19

The EPO’s Low Patent Quality Can Kill the European Software Industry and Kill People Too

Posted in Europe, Patents at 5:43 am by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

This isn’t just some game or competition between brands (as human rights and lives are at stake)

Office Life

Summary: The patents granted by the EPO are often invalid as per courts’ decisions, which means that fake/illegitimate European Patents saturate the market and discourage development (e.g. of software and life-saving drugs)

Yesterday, for whatever reason, the European Patent Office (EPO) tweeted almost nothing, but it then — later on — it retweeted the following:

The @EPOorg has opened its consultation on a postponed examination system. The consultation can be found at https://www.epo.org/law-practice/consultation/ongoing.html …, and will remain open until tomorrow, 11 January 2019

That’s today. This does nothing for patent quality, reinforcing the false impression that speed is the same as quality (by that definition, optimal quality would mean all decisions are made on the spot within one minute of application/submission). António Campinos follows Battistelli’s yardstick for “quality”. They conflate that with timeliness. It’s really that laughable and nowadays they pretend that giving applicants more control over timeliness (e.g. imposed delays/procrastination) is giving them “quality”. What about public interests?

“…they pretend that giving applicants more control over timeliness (e.g. imposed delays/procrastination) is giving them “quality”.”How about European software patents disguised as “AI”? Or as the headline from Paweł Kocańda (JWP Patent & Trademark Attorneys) has just put it, “Artificial Intelligence Patent?”

“EPO Gives The Green Light!”

To quote an example put forth by Kocańda (just algorithms, obviously, based on maths/statistics):

An example of an artificial-intelligence and machine-learning solution that would be patented by the EPO is the use of a neural network in a heart-monitoring apparatus designed to identify irregular heartbeats. Examples of technical character may also include classification of speech signals, digital audio or video, or digital images. It is important that patent applications directly or indirectly indicate a close link between the technical objective and the stages of a given method. A general objective, such as “control of the technical system”, will not be sufficient.

The next step after establishing the technical nature of the solution is to verify whether the solution is new and has an inventive step. If all the necessary conditions for considering the solution as an invention are met, we can start the patenting procedure.

So “technical effect” became (above) “technical character”, “technical system” and “technical nature” (in just the above two paragraphs), conjoined with “inventive step”. It’s that typical semantic nonsense to get around common sense.

Sandeep Basra (Haseltine Lake LLP) has also just posted this article about a case where the “first instance decision went in favour of the generic companies.” Generics save lives. Everyone knows that. Watch what had happened at the EPO though:

After surviving opposition proceedings at the EPO, the validity of the patent in Germany has been challenged, and the first instance decision went in favour of the generic companies. The EPO found that the skilled person would have no motivation to use pemetrexed in combination with vitamin B12 to reduce the toxic effects of pemetrexed. The judges at the German Federal Patent Court saw things differently and concluded that there are ample pointers in the prior art to arrive at the claimed combination. In particular, the skilled person would have known that homocysteine elevation is a sign of folic acid deficiency that can inter alia be caused by a vitamin B12 deficiency. As such, the claims were found to be obvious to the skilled person.

The judges emphasised that the conclusion reached is not in direct contradiction to the EPO decision due to the extensive prior art filed by the parties during the proceedings in Germany. Based on these documents, the first instance decision was reached without the use of expert witnesses.

This is why there are protests outside the EPO (not just staff’s). People’s lives are at risk when patents get granted in error. Policy can kill. The policymakers are then culpable. Sure, those who manage the EPO enjoy both immunity and impunity, but that’s another matter…

“UPC was an attempt to get around national courts and national patent law (scope), but that didn’t work out.”At the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO), which we don’t cover much anymore (by choice), there’s a widening gap between examiners’ decisions and courts’ decisions. This reduces confidence in US patents and discourages legal action. Is the same happening to European Patents now? If so, it’s unlikely that law firms will publicly talk about it because their biggest ‘product’ is lawsuits and they don’t wish to discourage that. The same goes for patent applications at the EPO. They worry that applicants will find out what’s going on. UPC was an attempt to get around national courts and national patent law (scope), but that didn’t work out. Nor should it.

Share in other sites/networks: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Reddit
  • email
  • Slashdot

If you liked this post, consider subscribing to the RSS feed or join us now at the IRC channels.

Pages that cross-reference this one

What Else is New


  1. Links 25/10/2020: GNU Taler's IETF Milestone, RISC OS 5.28 and New Ubuntu Community Council

    Links for the day



  2. IRC Proceedings: Saturday, October 24, 2020

    IRC logs for Saturday, October 24, 2020



  3. Links 24/10/2020: GDB 10.1, Kodachi 7.4, Wine 5.20

    Links for the day



  4. Celebrating Code of Conduct Violations

    Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock



  5. The Militarised Elephant in the Room Still Commands a Lot of Free Software Development

    We take a difficult (albeit in-depth and perfectly factual) look at IBM's past and present; considering this is the company that controls Red Hat (which in turn controls many key projects in GNU/Linux) we need a better understanding of the real context, not PR fluff and marketing



  6. Juve Patent's Love of Patent Trolls and Their Misinformation

    The press 'gutter' known as Juve (basically propaganda disguised as 'news' since years ago) has gotten to the point where the publisher is just an extension of lawyers and liars



  7. IRC Proceedings: Friday, October 23, 2020

    IRC logs for Friday, October 23, 2020



  8. Look How Many Tux I Give!

    "Long live rms, long live (Hyperbola) GNU/BSD, and happy hacking."



  9. Embrace, Extend, and Extensions: Two New Reasons to Delete GitHub, Which Microsoft Ruined for Everyone (Except the Copyright Cartel and Other Censors)

    GitHub is being turned into a garbage dump with malicious masters (or monsters, or mobsters); many people are denied access for using the 'wrong' browser and developers/projects are being censored (not for doing anything wrong or illegal, either)



  10. [Meme] When EPO Staff Claims to be 'Ill' or 'Sick'... During a Pandemic's European Peak

    Gotta check and verify that those 'lazy' EPO examiners aren't just faking being ill (in order to not meet "production" targets)



  11. The EPO Has Relegated or Lowered Itself to Extremely Poor Standards

    Today's EPO continues to reaffirm the image of global weakness; having failed to improve the working conditions and quality of the work (its actions did the exact opposite), it's nowadays begging China to send over lots of workload irrespective of quality or merit and it is outsourcing the functions of the Office to the United States



  12. Links 23/10/2020: Turing Pi 2, GNU Parallel 20201022

    Links for the day



  13. IRC Proceedings: Thursday, October 22, 2020

    IRC logs for Thursday, October 22, 2020



  14. Links 23/10/2020: 'Groovy Gorilla' Everywhere in the News

    Links for the day



  15. For Better 'Tech Rights' in the United States (and the World at Large) the 'Orange Man' Needs to Go

    With less than a fortnight before election day we explain our stance from a purely tech-related rationale



  16. [Meme] Microsoft Never 'Brought' Skype to GNU/Linux (It Just Bought Skype) and It Never 'Brought' Edge to GNU/Linux Either (Google Did)

    Foolish media or gullible 'journalists' are giving Microsoft credit for other people's work; this isn't the first time either, but it helps perpetuate lies such as "Microsoft loves Linux" (so who cares about facts anyway?)



  17. It's Going to be a Long, Long Winter

    Today we revert back to lock-down mode; we're reflecting and pondering what comes next



  18. TechRadar is an Irresponsible Clickbait and Misinformation Site Disguised as 'News'

    TechRadar is no tech and no radar, either. It's just an opportunistic click-harvesting machine, disguised as a source of "news"; today we deal with the latest example (among many).



  19. Links 22/10/2020: LibreOffice 6.4.7, Septor 2020.5, Ubuntu 20.10 Released, FreeBSD Quarterly Status Report

    Links for the day



  20. IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, October 21, 2020

    IRC logs for Wednesday, October 21, 2020



  21. Living Humbly (With Older Technology or None) is More Compatible With Privacy- and Freedom-Respecting Technological Lifestyle

    Simplicity sometimes trumps so-called 'novelty', especially when it comes to human rights and users' freedom



  22. Reasons Why You (and Everybody Else) Should Join the Fight for Software Freedom

    Society is being closely watched and controlled (more so during/after the latest pandemic) and people must carefully consider the true importance of resisting proprietary technology (controlled remotely by state actors)



  23. Ways and Means to Reduce One's Dependency on Google's Various Monopolies and Near-Monopolies

    Getting rid of Google means a lot more than embracing DumbDumbGo (DDG) or some other sites that spy just like Google; we're taking stock of some options



  24. The European Commission is Still M.I.A. Regarding EPO Corruption (and the EPO's Management Plays Dirty, as Always)

    There's no change in the EU; the EUIPO and EPO enjoy complete and total immunity/impunity, with the Commission being manned by those who are deeply complicit



  25. 10 Reasons Why All This 'Edge for Linux' Coverage is a Total Farce

    The fake hype surrounding "Edge" is an inauthentic hype/buzz campaign made to coincide with anti-Google sentiments spread by Microsoft front/pressure groups



  26. Microsoft's IIS Has Collapsed Again This Past Month (and IIS Will Not and Cannot Survive This Way)

    Netcraft shows that Microsoft's decline further accelerates in the Web servers space; IIS is becoming financially unviable



  27. Links 21/10/2020: Alpine 3.12.1, Tor Browser 10.0.2

    Links for the day



  28. [Meme] US Department of Justice Should Have Taken on Microsoft Again, Not Google

    When lobbying, connections and political sway determine the actions of the American government it's hardly surprising that Bill Gates gets the Trump administration to fight for him (to make him even richer)



  29. [Meme] Banning Words, Gaslighting Volunteers

    What happens when institutions are themselves in violation of a CoC (institutional violation) and massive corporations that fund such institutional violations are defending demonisation of the individual (squashing ‘uncomfortable’ voices, even volunteers’)



  30. IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, October 20, 2020

    IRC logs for Tuesday, October 20, 2020


RSS 64x64RSS Feed: subscribe to the RSS feed for regular updates

Home iconSite Wiki: You can improve this site by helping the extension of the site's content

Home iconSite Home: Background about the site and some key features in the front page

Chat iconIRC Channel: Come and chat with us in real time

Recent Posts