Bonum Certa Men Certa

What is Doctor of Philosophy (Ph.D.)

posted by Roy Schestowitz on Jul 25, 2026

"Doctor of Philosophy" typically has nothing to do with philosophy

The man who created GNU/Linux or GNU-plus-Linux (MCC) is a Doctor of Philosophy. Philosophy, literally. I took a look at his thesis over two decades ago when I worked on mine (he generated an online version of it around 1998). The founder of GNU (RMS) is a "doctor", but not of the same kind. All of those are honorary. My own doctorate is in Medical Biophysics, but my supervisor was the head of the Computer Science Department and at the time I did a lot of my work at the Computer Science Department, where I had also studied software engineering. Not "Medical", nothing "Biophysics" (neither biology nor physics).

Computer Science is not "Philosophy", it is a science. It's more like mathematics, which helps formally explain various phenomena (temperatures, distances, and so on). Computer Scientists or software engineers know how to leverage physics (gate-level logic) to create complicated programs that work reliably, typically without having to know much about the chemistry or the physical components that make it all possible.

"Philosophy" is something many scientists can relate to and write about, even without a Doctor of Philosophy (Ph.D.) honorific/acronym. Similarly, in Britain, many people can be taken seriously without some acronym like OBE (like my supervisor's) added/appended to their name.

The term Doctor of Philosophy has become quite misleading. In the case of Owen, the first man to combine GNU and Linux (in 1992), his thesis was completed in "the Faculty of Arts" a year earlier (1991):

COMPUTATIVE PROTOTHETIC

Scroll down a bit:

Department of Philosophy

System C mentioned a lot:

Le´sniewski’s deductive theories

The abstract:

Abstract of thesis submitted by A. O. V. Le Blanc for the Degree of Doctor of Philosphy, and entitled Le´sniewski’s Computative Protothetic. Submitted January, 1991.

The logician StanisÃlaw Le´sniewski devoted most of his academic life to the development of a system of foundations of mathematics, which consists of three deductive theories: protothetic, ontology, and mereology. Protothetic is the most general of these theories, logically prior to the others; it has been described by its creator as a unique extension of the classical ‘theory of deduction’ or ‘propositional calculus’, though this theory differs from more usual versions in many respects. The ‘standard’ system of protothetic is developed by a rule of procedure corresponding to the traditional style of development incorporating substitution and detachment, but including directives for definition and extensionality.

Le´sniewski also developed systems of protothetic whose rule of procedure does not contain directives for substitution or detachment, and whose style of development has been described as ‘computative’ or as involving ‘automatic verification’. The directives may be said to resemble Peirce’s zero/one verification method, though they are extended to allow verification and rejection of expressions containing variables in all semantic categories, and having various numbers of possible ‘values’. Only an informal summary of Le´sniewski’s work on these systems survives.

This thesis examines computative protothetic historically, informally, and formally. It contains a set of directives for a system of computative protothetic which is as close as possible to the lost directives of Le´sniewski’s own systems.

Owen was a "proper" philosophy doctor, even based on his prior record as outlined in page 9 of his thesis.

Philosophy

So sometimes a Ph.D. is really about philosophy (same for D.Phil.). Usually, however, it is not. As Wikipedia puts it, "[i]n the context of the Doctor of Philosophy and other similarly titled degrees, the term "philosophy" does not refer to the field or academic discipline of philosophy, but is used in a broader sense in accordance with its original Greek meaning, which is "love of wisdom"."

In many cases, the acronym became a misnomer.

Owen, a former colleague of mine, was a "proper" Ph.D. because the "Ph" meant something and it wasn't about water/liquid acidity. █

Other Recent Techrights' Posts

Linux Kernel Needs Diversity and Diversity of Good Code, Not LLM Slop
Linux (and Linus) are kicking a can down the road
Techrights Was Right About a Fake Security Model Built Around Lies or Built Upon Trust in "Certificates" and "Authorities" (like Microsoft)
We have begun to amass some media reports and blog posts from technical sites
 
Links 22/10/2026: eBay to Lay Off a Tenth of Staff (Again), Node.js and PHP Security Crises, Climate News
Links for the day
Red Hat Layoffs Still Going on This Week (Whilst IBM's Debt Grows in Spite of Mass Layoffs)
IBM is bluffing/cheating the shareholders again
IBM's Debt Continues to Increase While the Company Rapidly Shrinks
This is what a dying company looks like
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XI - Losing Over a Million Pounds (Borrowed Money) to Try to Silence Critics of Restricted Boot With Microsoft-Controlled "Certificates"
Garrett is also very jealous of Daniel Pocock
Microsoft Shrinks Every Year
Microsoft will try to spin or twist this as "efficiency"
Gemini Links 22/10/2026: Holiday Inn and Emacs
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, October 21, 2026
IRC logs for Wednesday, October 21, 2026
Windows Monopoly is No Longer Sustainable (the Case of Oceania)
This is why Microsoft layoffs are happening all the time
Some Downtime Possible Shortly (Router Work)
We don't use PHP in the site anymore
Mass Layoffs at Microsoft This Week and/or Next Week
Cannot pull a bunny out of some hat
With Its Future on the Line, EPO Management (Dictatorship) Resorts to Further Escalations to Fake 'Production' and Curtail Industrial Actions
It's clear that with a yearlong campaign of industrial actions - including strikes - Campinos cannot save face anymore
Gemini Links 21/10/2026: Summer Day in Tokyo (30c in Late October) and Whole Food for the Whole World
Links for the day
Links 21/10/2026: "Zelensky Took the Gloves Off This Time With Convicted Felon" and "Cellebrite iPhone Radio Zero-Day"
Links for the day
Reuters is Becoming Slop, Not a News Agency (Treat Reports From Reuters Sceptically)
In their own words
Disclosure/s Crisis at The Register MS (Promoting a Ponzi Scheme for Money)
So now they sell several schemes/scams at the same time, not limited to the slop
Links 21/10/2026: "The Tragic Death of the Republican Party" and "No War But Data Center War"
Links for the day
Internet Relay Chat Still Growing
The numbers go up, not down [...] Don't believe the doomers
Intercontinental Brigading - Part X - American Back Doors Inside Our Computers, With Transatlantic Swatting Against Critics Thrown 'Into the Mix'
"If your Windows PC's Secure Boot certificates are out of date, your system is vulnerable to malware like rootkits."
Gemini Links 21/10/2026: A Walk Through Amsterdam and Pythagorean Theorem
Links for the day
More Mass Layoffs at Microsoft Weeks From Now, Then Again Months From Now
Microsoft's crisis is not limited to XBox
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, October 20, 2026
IRC logs for Tuesday, October 20, 2026
Gemini Links 20/10/2026: The Brothers Who Fought Mussolini and a Dying Main Laptop
Links for the day
Brett Wilson LLP Has Almost Zero Litigation Clients This Year (in the Area They Specialise in)
The silence on the financial front, combined with the lack of new clients, is deafening
Where to Celebrate the 20-Year Anniversary
let us know in IRC
Cheapening of the Workforce at IBM and Microsoft, Typically Without Even Announcing Any Layoffs
from leadership to compelled "retirement"
Help Us Improve Techrights
The site relies on teamwork in a growing community; even readers are part of it
Links 20/10/2026: $100 Million ICE “Intelligence” Program and France Riots
Links for the day
Gemini Links 20/10/2026: GAFAM GCP Outage in the UK and New Oddμ Release
Links for the day
Articles in The Register MS Composed by Employees of the Companies They're About
The Register MS is the place to be
Intercontinental Brigading - Part IX - Swatting is Not Funny, Swatting is a Murder Attempt
“Swatting is not harmless. It is a serious crime that can lead to dangerous situations and divert law enforcement away from someone facing an actual emergency. What callers may believe to be a ‘joke’ actually risks the public safety of our communities and can carry lifelong consequences for those responsible”
Links 20/10/2026: Facebook Scraping and Plagiarising News Sites, Copyright Act Turns 50
Links for the day
Microsoft's XBox Leadership and Strategy is Slop
XBox sales are already worst in the entire history of XBox
81% Voted in Favour of EPO Strikes Until End of This Year
Who's in the line of succession at EPO?
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Monday, October 19, 2026
IRC logs for Monday, October 19, 2026
Gemini Links 20/10/2026: Old Movies, Bandera Hike, and Mongolian
Links for the day