Bonum Certa Men Certa

Microsoft Dismisses Being Subjected to GPL, Uses Novell as a Proxy

In the following new coverage, Microsoft claims to be exempted from the GPL. This contradicts a few other arguments.

Microsoft is not convinced that distribution of SUSE vouchers makes the company subject to GPL requirements. Richard Wilder, a patent lawyer for the Association of Competitive Technology (an organization partially funded by Microsoft), argues that Microsoft isn't subject to the GPL because the company isn't literally distributing Linux or any other piece of GPL-licensed software. Speaking to the Seattle Post-Intelligencer, Wilder said, "[Microsoft is] not distributing Linux. They're providing somebody access to a service, but they're not providing copies of Linux on a disk, and they're not providing somebody access to Linux for the purpose of download, and so they're not engaged in any distribution."


So, where would Microsoft be if it were not for Novell? The true situation is yet to be understood as there are two sides to every argument. There is some further discussion about the GPL in the second part of a recent interview with Eben Moglen and, given that he knows the licence better than most, he is quite likely to be correct.

The following article explains why Microsoft has entered the deal and what this means to Novell.

Microsoft seemed satisfied in the past to wage the battle against Linux through its SCO Group proxy, but SCO’s lawsuit against IBM — claiming IBM contributed SCO intellectual property to Linux — has been slowly circling the drain for some time. With Windows Vista sales hardly taking flight, and Microsoft’s next-generation server operating system — Longhorn — still not ready for prime time, it seems that Chief Executive Officer Steve Ballmer decided it was time to unleash the lawyers to buy the Redmondians some time. [Note: this is a point which we stressed before]

Meanwhile, Novell may start selling a lot more SuSE Linux, because Novell and Microsoft’s software patent agreement shields the distribution against Redmond’s wrath. But that agreement hasn’t won Novell a lot of friends. The free-software community has risen up to protest Novell’s moves, urging people to dump SuSE. And many open-source license-holders are considering relicensing key libraries to the Limited GNU Public License to exclude SuSE from using them.


In other news, Novell has just got itself a contract in California.

San Diego Students Learn on Linux Desktops From Novell

[...]

San Diego Unified School District is the second-largest school district in California, serving more than 130,000 students, 100,000 of whom are in grades three through 12 and are targeted by the Always-On Learning Initiative.


For a change, neither Microsoft nor "intellectual property" are mentioned in the press release.

Recent Techrights' Posts

There Are Still Many Debian Developers (Alternative to IBM)
Some Debian Developers are on Microsoft's payroll
Apple's Last Leader Died After He Had Been Sacked by Apple
Cult-like worship leads to dictatorships, not redemption from dictatorships
 
Gemini Links 21/04/2026: Drinking, Gardening, and Politics
Links for the day
SLAPP Censorship - Part 53 Out of 200: The Lying Solicitor of Alex Graveley Left Brett Wilson LLP Only Days or Few Weeks After the Garrett Trial (Attended by Almost Their Entire Office/Team)
They kept trying to get us to settle
Financial Misery: The Failures of the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) to Regulate Have Cost Many Thousands of Brits Over 50 Million Dollars (Stolen, Embezzled, Defrauded)
There's plenty of revolving doors-like activity
Sense of Panic at Microsoft, the Slop (for "Entertainment") in Windows is Backfiring
We'll probably find out soon
The Register MS Has Just Published Another SPAM 'Article' for Slop Grifters. It Says "AI" 33 Times!
The Register MS is not a good publisher
Microsoft Lunduke Never Liked Free Speech
Microsoft Lunduke does not speak truth to power. He farts words to 4Chan "bros"
"Linux" Sites That Knock Themselves Out by 'Pivoting' to LLM Slop
People don't need like 100 "Linux" sites to follow, only a handful that they can truly trust
The European Patent Office (EPO) Needs More Scrutiny, Contact Your Officials Tonight or Tomorrow
The European Patent Office (EPO) or the European Patent Organisation (also EPO) are disgracing Europe and the European Union (EU)
Slop in "AI" Clothing is Such a Miserable Failure That IBM is Allegedly Firing Entire Teams That Do Slop (the Media Didn't Report This; It Said the Opposite!)
Gaslighting, lying media that engages in deceit will not outlast this bubble
Huge Microsoft Layoffs Coming Shortly (With Financial Report)
There will be lost of slop layoffs. Be ready. It's a bubble.
The Corrupt Lecture the Non-Corrupt - Part III - "Ethics" Explained by Unethical People, Lots of Buzzwords Included
Imagine being the person (or PR agency) that wrote this with a straight face, possibly commissioned by some frequent cocaine user who runs the Office
Gemini Links 21/04/2026: Dystemia, Protocol Group Chat Gone Wrong, and More
Links for the day
Links 21/04/2026: Drunken Kash Patel Sues The Atlantic for Reporting, California Accuses Amazon of Price-Fixing
Links for the day
EPO Cocainegate Escalates - Part III - Connected Families - The Cocaine User Luis Berenguer and António Campinos
not just bromance between Luis and António
FOSS Linux (fosslinux.com) Has Become a Slopfarm
Slopfarming is the last incarnation of sites that die or are dead
Gemini Links 21/04/2026: NeoVim, GeminiMDB, and Another New Gemini Client (Called Titan II)
Links for the day
Links 21/04/2026: Internet Shutdowns, Bluesky Crippled by DDoS Attack
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Monday, April 20, 2026
IRC logs for Monday, April 20, 2026
3,400 Gemini Capsules Accessible and Known to Lupa, A Geminispace Crawler
We're about to exceed 3,400 some time soon
When and Why I Quit Writing "Classical" GNU/Linux Advocacy Articles
I'd love to write more about why GNU/Linux is great [...] We always try to cover unique issues and break stories (exclusives)
IBM Had Mass Layoffs Every Month This Year (Including at HashiCorp, Confluent, and Red Hat), 'Results' Due in 2 Days' Time
IBM's "media partners" seem to be engaging (propaganda and puff piece) ahead of the serenade to Wall Street
Dr. Andy Farnell on Privacy Failings and Shallow Media Coverage
Bad media paves the way for failed societies
Gemini Links 20/04/2026: Fahrenheit 451, Small Web Advocacy, and Offgrid Holdout
Links for the day
Debian Has a New Project Leader (DPL)
We plan to upgrade Debian some time this month
This Morning The Register MS Published SPAM With "AI" 36 Times in It. This is What The Register MS is Paid to Publish.
It's selling out to Ponzi schemers
Links 20/04/2026: Chatbots Motivate Manslaughter, GAFAM’s ‘Tobacco Moment’
Links for the day
Throwing Rocks in Houses of Glass
Lots of "virtue-signalling" against ICE
The Corrupt Lecture the Non-Corrupt - Part II - It's About Politics, Not Science
Tomorrow we'll discuss what the cocaine proponents (or apologists) deem to be "ethics"
SLAPP Censorship - Part 52 Out of 200: Phil Golding Appointed Bar Standards Board (BSB) Chief, Misogyny Must End
How many rules will they "bend" or even breach?
Links 20/04/2026: Brave Origin Nightly, Scuttling USAID Gives 'Soft Power' to China, and White House Gives Money to Russia (Through Oil Sales)
Links for the day
EPO Cocainegate Escalates - Part II - "Cocaine Communication Manager" Luis Berenguer is Back Without Punishment
Latest on Luis Berenguer
Gemini Links 20/04/2026: "I Hate Computers" and "Why I de-Googled"
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, April 19, 2026
IRC logs for Sunday, April 19, 2026
If You're Against War, Why Would You Pay IBM Red Hat?
Red Hat's largest clients aren't geeks; they're militaries
Uplifting Mood in Manchester
Looking behind - and ahead - after a day of relaxation
SLAPP Censorship - Part 51 Out of 200: On Perjury and What It Means to Take Third-Party Funding to Attack Reporter and His Family (in Another Continent)
threats of prison sent to my wife
The Corrupt Lecture the Non-Corrupt - Part I - EPO Management Talks About "Ethics" While Cocaine Users Run the Office
Let's start with the basics
EPO Cocainegate Escalates - Part I - Cocaine Abuse in Family of Campinos (President’s Office)
at the EPO's management you can do illegal drugs and still represent Europe's second-largest institution
Gemini Links 19/04/2026: Big Brother and the Telescreen, Syncing Gemini Capsule With a Makefile
Links for the day
Links 19/04/2026: Introducing “Fighting Fascism” Podcast and Kyiv Mass Shooting
Links for the day
Links 19/04/2026: Mass Layoffs at GAFAM Again (10% Laid Off), Azure Capacity Problems (Enshittification)
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Saturday, April 18, 2026
IRC logs for Saturday, April 18, 2026