Bonum Certa Men Certa

The "Luddite" Complex

posted by Roy Schestowitz on Nov 02, 2024,
updated Nov 02, 2024

Wooden vintage telephone

Yesterday Dr. Andy Farnell asserted that: "Devious or confused thinkers often level the accusation of "Luddite" against anyone who even mentions autonomy and negative freedoms. For them, platform normativity is a stick with which to beat others, as a cover for their own ambition, insecurity or identification. They misuse words like "compatibility" and "interoperability" to mean domination of their own standards, rather than real plurality."

Let's think for a moment what this means, in particular the "Luddite" analogy or the "being backwards" metaphor. As if some people insist on using stones and twigs to start a fire in the age of lighters and electric hobs. Half a day ago we took a phone back from repair. It's not an old phone, it's just over 12 years old. Yesterday we also bought batteries for an alarm clock from the mid-90s. I've not actually used it for over two decades (it was a gift from my grandmother), but it still works it has plenty of functionality, including calculator. It does not require recharging every day; a pair or AAA batteries can drive it for nearly a year and with rechargeable batteries it'll cost just pennies to run for a decade or so.

Old is not bad. Old is just old. We don't call a person who is 20 "old" or assert the person is obsolete. A person aged 20 is older than 10, for instance, but can likely do both mental and physical jobs a lot better. Age isn't a measure of "badness". In some cases (wine for instance), age is a measure of value. Devices that last very long (my stereo system is about 30) are likely built using robust components. They are perhaps more likely to last another decade... and another decade.

In a sense, we ought to discard or mostly reject this notion that whatever is newer (even in tech) is necessarily better. Yesterday I used my Palm PDA, which is over 20 (I bought it in 2004) to look up an account number. It did that just fine, it didn't ask me to install "the latest updates" or change SIM or whatever.

Sometimes simplest is best and sometimes "modern" is designed not with the buyers' interest in mind. Modern gadgets are often just plasticware with nice veneer, but they're not really expensive (nor are they made to last), so they're not really status symbols; they do not symbolise wealth or class.

Other Recent Techrights' Posts

Advertisers and Their Covert Impact on Publications' Output (or Writers' Topics of Choice, as Assigned or Approved by Editors)
It cannot be trivially denied that sponsorship in the form of "advertising" impacts where publishers go (or don't go, won't go)
Terrible Year for Microsoft Windows in Cyprus
down from 86% to 72% since January
 
Links 25/12/2024: Hong Kong Attacks Activists During Holidays, Xerox to Buy Lexmark
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, December 24, 2024
IRC logs for Tuesday, December 24, 2024
Gemini Links 25/12/2024: Open Source Social and No Search
Links for the day
Brittany Day Connects Windows Ransomware to "Linux" Using Microsoft LLMs (FUD Galore, Zero Effort, No Accountability)
FUD and misinformation made by Microsoft LLMs again?
Links 24/12/2024: Labour Strikes and TikTok Scrambling to Prop Up Radical Politicians That Would Protect TikTok
Links for the day
Where the Population is Controlled by Skinnerboxes Inside People's Pockets (or Purses)
A very small fraction of mobile users practise or exercise freedom/control over the skinnerbox
[Meme] Coin-Operated Publishers (Gaming the Message, Buying the Narrative)
Advertise (sponsor) to 'play'
[Meme] How to Kill Unions (Staff on Shoestring Budget Cannot Afford Lawyers)
What next for the EPO? "Gig economy"?
The EPO's Staff Union (SUEPO) Takes Legal Action to Rectify the Decrease in Wages (Lessening of Purchasing Power)
here is what the union published
Gemini Links 24/12/2024: Deedum Gemini Client Gets Colour Support, Advent of Code 2024
Links for the day
Microsoft Windows Slides to New Lows in Colombia
Now Windows is at an all-time low
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Monday, December 23, 2024
IRC logs for Monday, December 23, 2024
A Strong and Positive Closing for the Year's Last Week
In a lot of ways this year was a good one for Free software
Feels Too Warm for Christmas
Christmas is here, no snow in sight
Links 23/12/2024: 'Negative Time' and US Arms Taiwan Again
Links for the day
Links 23/12/2024: The Book of Uncommon Beings, Squirrels, and Slop Ruining Workplaces
Links for the day
Links 23/12/2024: North Korean Death Toll in Russia at ~1,100, Oligarch Who Illegally Migrated/Stayed (Musk) Shuts Down US Government
Links for the day
The World's 'Richest Country' Chooses GNU/Linux
This has gone on for quite some time
Richard Stallman on Love
Richard Stallman's personal website includes a section that lists three essays on the subject of love
Apple's LLM Slop Told Us Luigi Mangione Had Shot Himself, BetaNews Used LLMs to Talk About a Dead Linus Torvalds
They can blame it on some bot
Microsoft, Give Me LLM Slop About "Linux" and "Santa", I Need Some Fake Article...
BetaNews is basically an LLM slop site
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, December 22, 2024
IRC logs for Sunday, December 22, 2024