Bonum Certa Men Certa

My Response to the Enlarged Board of Appeal

FURTHER TO this previous post, I have just submitted my answers to the Enlarged Board of Appeal [PDF] regarding software patents. Here it is as text and as LATEX.

Enlarged Board of Appeal European Patent Office Erhardtstrasse 27 80331 Munich, Germany

To whom it may concern in the Enlarged Board of Appeal,

I hereby submit my answers to the questions about case G3/08. As a computer scientist in Europe, the subject matters to me personally; in particular, the effect of this matter reaches Free/Open Source software. It is increasingly used and developed in Europe, whose legislation in the area affects progress.

The questions are phrased in such a way that they almost entrap the answerer, so replies address entire blocks of questions. I shall address the questions raised by the EPO, in turn.

QUESTION 1: CAN A COMPUTER PROGRAM ONLY BE EXCLUDED AS A COMPUTER PROGRAM AS SUCH IF IT IS EXPLICITLY CLAIMED AS A COMPUTER PROGRAM?

I fear that permitting such loopholes to exist leads to the actual permission of software patents. To quote Marshall Phelps from Microsoft, ``[The EPO] can’t distinguish between hardware and software so the patents get issued anyway." By allowing ambiguity, the EPO essentially leaves the door open to software patents, in which case the policy becomes moot.

QUESTION 2: (A) CAN A CLAIM IN THE AREA OF COMPUTER PROGRAMS AVOID EXCLUSION UNDER ART. 52(2)(C) AND (3) MERELY BY EXPLICITLY MENTIONING THE USE OF A COMPUTER OR A COMPUTER-READABLE DATA STORAGE MEDIUM? (B) IF QUESTION 2 (A) IS ANSWERED IN THE NEGATIVE, IS A FURTHER TECHNICAL EFFECT NECESSARY TO AVOID EXCLUSION, SAID EFFECT GOING BEYOND THOSE EFFECTS INHERENT IN THE USE OF A COMPUTER OR DATA STORAGE MEDIUM TO RESPECTIVELY EXECUTE OR STORE A COMPUTER PROGRAM?

This suggests that a separation between hardware and software is possible despite the fact that one requires another in order to operate. There is no program which is separable from hardware because without execution it exists only in the minds of people, much like poetry. Any software patent is able to characterise itself with the combination of hardware that it interacts with, so it is irrelevant whether or not hardware is mentioned in a patent application. If the inventor was to construct a novel physical entity, its physical attributes -- not mere zeroes and ones that pass through it -- may merit a patent.

QUESTION 3: (A) MUST A CLAIMED FEATURE CAUSE A TECHNICAL EFFECT ON A PHYSICAL ENTITY IN THE REAL WORLD IN ORDER TO CONTRIBUTE TO THE TECHNICAL CHARACTER OF THE CLAIM? (B) IF QUESTION 3 (A) IS ANSWERED IN THE POSITIVE, IS IT SUFFICIENT THAT THE PHYSICAL ENTITY BE AN UNSPECIFIED COMPUTER? (C) IF QUESTION 3 (A) IS ANSWERED IN THE NEGATIVE, CAN FEATURES CONTRIBUTE TO THE TECHNICAL CHARACTER OF THE CLAIM IF THE ONLY EFFECTS TO WHICH THEY CONTRIBUTE ARE INDEPENDENT OF ANY PARTICULAR HARDWARE THAT MAY BE USED?

Hardware responds to signals that it is capable of interpreting and reacts in a predefined physical fashion. For example, a hard drive uses a physical process to produce output upon receiving a known signal. As such, any process described in algorithms may effect a physical device in one form or another, but its role in the process is as abstract as one's thoughts. To suggest that software changes the form of something physical is to suggest that one's mere thoughts can lead to muscular motion and thus be considered an invention. Once the ownership of one's ideas -- as expressed in broad terms -- becomes possible, copyrights can be rendered moot and instead block any expression of ideas -- be it an algorithm, a musical note, or the assembly of pertinent facts/parts -- which is what every invention really is about. There needs to be a physical device which is new and unique. Without innovation in physical terms, patentability becomes not only absurd but dangerous too. In Re Bilski is an example of broadening the scope of patents too far.

QUESTION 4: (A) DOES THE ACTIVITY OF PROGRAMMING A COMPUTER NECESSARILY INVOLVE TECHNICAL CONSIDERATIONS? (B) IF QUESTION 4 (A) IS ANSWERED IN THE POSITIVE, DO ALL FEATURES RESULTING FROM PROGRAMMING THUS CONTRIBUTE TO THE TECHNICAL CHARACTER OF A CLAIM? (C) IF QUESTION 4 (A) IS ANSWERED IN THE NEGATIVE, CAN FEATURES RESULTING FROM PROGRAMMING CONTRIBUTE TO THE TECHNICAL CHARACTER OF A CLAIM ONLY WHEN THEY CONTRIBUTE TO A FURTHER TECHNICAL EFFECT WHEN THE PROGRAM IS EXECUTED?

If specialised knowledge is required to write a particular program, i.e. series of commands, then it is likely to involve computer-independent knowledge such as mathematics or physics. To acquire a monopoly on areas of science where nature's rules cannot be refuted should require the inventor to seek a patent in his/her particular field, not the field of software engineering. The question begs to insinuate that scientists deserve protection for their hard work, but rarely does this work have anything to do with computers; software is just where these ideas happen to be applied, although they could equally well be applied using pen and paper.

On a separate note, in order for Europe to preserve and promote autonomy, the rejection of software patents is encouraged. This gives tremendous advantage to those are are ably programming without the burden of lawsuits, filing of papers, and studying of too many papers. It gives European programmers the upper hand. The field of software is highly complex and there are many intersections in implementations of different ideas. It is not practically possible to ensure that one program does not `collide' with another at a binary level and since composers of software are able to program without anything but a computer (and distribution likewise, thanks to the Internet), to impose unnecessary limits is virtually to forbid many the art of programming, turning it into a scarcely-explored field possessed and controlled by a small number of privileged classes with portfolios that represent monopolies on mathematics. This imperils both the economy and the value of innovation; history teaches that most brilliant software technologies are conceived by a small group of enthusiasts, and not with a patent application.

Yours sincerely, Roy Schestowitz Manchester, England


If you reside in Europe, please send your answers as well before the deadline is due. The address to mail answers to is Dg3registry_eba@epo.org. ⬆

Logo - stop software patents

Comments

Recent Techrights' Posts

An American and South Korean Cartel Artificially Inflating the Prices You Pay for Computers (or Any Service That Relies on Computers, I.e. Almost Everything)
As long as the principal tenant of the White House is a white-collar criminal we can expect only cover-up and participation, not a crackdown
The EPO Still on Strike. 141 Tickets Opened Regarding Lack of Toilet Paper (or Similar).
Yesterday staff representatives at the EPO in The Hague (LSCTH] spoke of a meeting which took place a month ago
The Real News About the White House (Not the 'Exclusive' Rupert Murdoch Published for It at Midnight Monday) is Complicity in NVIDIA Fraud
They need a distraction from commercial malpractice
I Tried Linux Again After 10 Years - Here's What Blew My Mind
It's like leaving your hometown as a teenager and coming back to find the weird kid from high school is now the mayor
 
Gemini Links 17/11/2026: Super Power, Knowember, Writing in Shorthand, Cooking over a Woodstove, Decoupling Code and Content
Links for the day
Links 17/11/2026: California Sues Slop Peddlers and Nvidia Was Already in Trouble Before the Jensen Huang Mess
Links for the day
NVIDIA Corp Was Grossly Overvalued, Lost 36.06% of Alleged "Market Value" in 5-6 Weeks
NVIDIA has many of "obligations" (to pay), not money
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Monday, November 16, 2026
IRC logs for Monday, November 16, 2026
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXXIII - An Attack on the Dignity of Reporters and Their Family Members (by Proxy/Attack Dogs)
The Microsofters seem to be super-upset that I uncovered Microsoft fraud
IBM and OSI Said opensource.net Would Replace opensource.com, But It Has Been Dead for 1.5 Years and the Person Who Had Made Promises Left OSI
Over a year ago he left
Red Hat and IBM Meet Targets (of Pushing People Out)
now there are claims of security breach inside IBM, but no press reports related to that
Gemini Links 17/11/2026: Reading Clocks and StreetComplete
Links for the day
Buy Influence "Over Dinner With The Register."
The Register MS is the facilitator or 'pimp'
While the Slop Industry Wobbles The Register MS Bags Tens of Thousands of Pounds to Publish Propaganda With "AI" 23 Times in It
The Register MS is selling its reputation away
Links 16/11/2026: Microsoft Increases Indian Clown Computing Prices by 15%, Meta Fined $887 Million in Italy
Links for the day
Gemini Links 16/11/2026: Container Gardening, Laughing at an LLM, "EU 72-Hour Guidelines Through a Lawyer's Eyes"
Links for the day
Links 16/11/2026: Data Centers (White Elephants) as Tax Evasion Scam/Ploy, Social Control Media Harms Boomers, "Microsoft Outage Hindered Ticket Issuance in Greece"
Links for the day
The Register MS Seems to Have Moved to 'The Cloud' (WeWork) After Shutting Down the Office
The Register MS will have a hard time explaining why it so passionately participated in the "hey hi" pyramid scheme
Holiday Plans (We Need More IBM Whistleblowers)
in particular with possession of material in relation to PIPs, NDAs, and silent RAs
After Microsoft Outage GNU/Linux Usage Leaps to 9% in the UK (Where Public Services Were Notoriously Overdependent on Microsoft Disservices)
in the UK we are extremely dependent on Microsoft stuff in the NHS, courts, law firms, police etc.
Richard Stallman Was Right About the Corruption of the Term "Artificial intelligence"
This will do severe damage to the administration which participated in the scam
The Dictatorship Already Working to Distract From NVIDIA Corruption and Slop Bubble Reaching Its Limits
Circular financing is simply a form of financial fraud
IBM Selling Itself, Piecewise, to Raise Money (to Pay Salaries)
IBM is a zombie waiting to inhale one last time (last breath)
"Allies" of Disgraced NVIDIA CEO Aren't About Morality, They're Just Covering Up Their Own Backs (and Loans)
The next stage is examining the false accounting (fraud basically)
No Outage Since 2023
I did host from home between 2020 and 2023
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXXII - Back Doors and Kill Switches From Microsoft Are Objectively Undesirable
"I dual-boot Omarchy and Windows. Be careful updating your BIOS. Mine made Omarchy unbootable."
Gemini Links 16/11/2026: Enjoyable Coding, Social Control Media Considered Harmful, and Recursive Rectangular Subdivision
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, November 15, 2026
IRC logs for Sunday, November 15, 2026
Cusp of Collapse
NVIDIA Corp (NASDAQ: NVDA) is set to open in the red tomorrow
Getting Fed Up Not Only With Microsoft But Also Windows
This morning we wrote about North America
Layoffs and Silent Layoffs (e.g. PIPs) as a "Break" From IBM
If the press doesn't report it, then it never happened, right?
Microsoft XBox at 25 and All-Time Low
XBox will be "officially" dead (not the brand) when sales fall below some threshold and then production is halted, sort of like Apple's Vision Pro
Links 15/11/2026: Microsoft Already Emitting Chaff to Distract From Its Catastrophe, Jensen Huang Deemed Just 'Fall Guy' Amid Collapse of the Pyramid Scheme
Links for the day
Gemini Links 15/11/2026: CD Players Live on and Self-Hosting from Home Fallacy
Links for the day
When Short is Way Too Short (Superficiality, Lowering of Entropy)
Demonstrating how truly worthless social control media was all along
Techrights Hates Slop Bots
They benefit nobody
The Economy is Fine! (If Only for China!)
The future is slop! If not, then it's China's fault! It's "sabotaging" the "Western hey hi" in this "hey hi arms race!"
"IT" as "Musical Chairs" (on the Deck of The Titanic)
Each generation will get worse for "IT"
Salesforce in Trouble, Debt Nearly Quadrupled in 9 Months
Salesforce is perishing in a deep pool of debt
"Microsoft is Next IBM"
The words of a Microsoft insider and responses to that
IRC is Decentralised
Bye, Microsoft Teams/Skype
Links 15/11/2026: Murdoch's "WSJ Buries Stephen Miller's Racism" and "America Has Entered a New Age of Propaganda"
Links for the day
In the UK, GNU/Linux Usage Soared During Microsoft Downtime
since the massive outage GNU/Linux usage soared to over 10%
Google Slop About Richard Stallman Shows Stallman Was Right, LLMs are BS Generators
Google slop is the "new Google"
Spouse of Garrett Needs to Get "Several Firearms" to Feel Safe Amid Divorce (Garrett Has a "Girlfriend" Now)
Seems like Isis and my wife have a lot in common when it comes to Garrett
Vista 11 is Small
Can Microsoft survive the fall of Windows?
Six Richard Stallman and FSF Talks This Month (FSF Staff at Ohio State University)
Dr. Stallman's talks in Ecuador are well timed because of the collapse of the LLMs (slop) pyramid scheme
NVIDIA's Crisis Has Only Just began
NVIDIA Corp (NASDAQ: NVDA) is set to open in the red tomorrow
IBM Has Destroyed Red Hat and Hashicorp, Insiders Say It's the Usual From IBM:
Bluewashing is a death wave
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Saturday, November 14, 2026
IRC logs for Saturday, November 14, 2026
Techrights Was Right About Slop Destroying Development Communities and Projects
Slop does not improve your project. It kills the community. Without community, what is left? A 'botfarm'?
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXXI - Harassment Law and "Things Are Unfairly Asymmetric" (Exploring the Boundaries of Death Threats and Various Threats From America)
the sort of "technofascism" that our country must learn to confront rather than facilitate
Gemini Links 15/11/2026: "The Bastards Can Never Win" and "The Last Low-Tech Generation"
Links for the day