Bonum Certa Men Certa

The Council of Europe Slams the EPO as Political Pressure Grows for EPO Management to Obey the Law

An emergency

Summary: Battistelli et al. come under yet more fire as politicians -- many of whom from Battistelli's home country -- become better informed of the EPO's management fiasco, abuses, and scandals

We have just been sent a copy [PDF] of the written declaration sponsored by Pierre-Yves Le Borgn' (mentioned here before) and signed by 82 members of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe. Rollbacks of fundamental rights at the European Patent Office are clearly not being tolerated. Here is the declaration as HTML:

Doc. 13836

25 June 2015

Rollback of fundamental rights at the European Patent Office

Written declaration No. 596

This written declaration commits only those who have signed it On 17 February 2015, the Hague Court of Appeal condemned the European Patent Office (EPO), arguing that its internal dispute settlement system led to a rollback of fundamental rights enshrined in the European Convention of Human Rights and the European Social Charter. The Court considered that the EPO could not invoke its immunity when a trade union is deprived of any means to challenge violations of the personnel's rights, for want of any legal remedy before the International Labour Organisation Administrative Tribunal or via any other internal procedure.

An international organisation cannot become a place of lesser law, sheltered by its jurisdictional immunity. Restraining the right of association, reducing the right to go on strike, preventing the personnel from being entitled to collective bargaining, depriving all organisations from any effective remedy and failing to carry out a court decision are all unacceptable developments. We call on the 38 member States of the EPO, all members of the Council of Europe, to bring this situation to an end and urge the EPO's management to comply with the decision of the Hague Court of Appeal.

Signed (see overleaf)

Doc. 13836 Written declaration


LE BORGN' Pierre-Yves, France, SOC AGRAMUNT Pedro, Spain, EPP/CD ALAVEZ RUIZ Aleida, Mexico ALLAIN Brigitte, France, SOC ANDERSON Donald, United Kingdom, SOC ANDREOLI Paride, San Marino, SOC BARILARO Christian, Monaco, ALDE BENTON Joe, United Kingdom, SOC BIES Philippe, France, SOC BÄ°LGEHAN Gülsün, Turkey, SOC BLONDIN Maryvonne, France, SOC BOCKEL Jean-Marie, France, EPP/CD BONET PEROT Sílvia Eloïsa, Andorra, SOC CANTU SEGOVIA Eloy, Mexico CHAOUKI Khalid, Italy, SOC CHRISTOFFERSEN Lise, Norway, SOC CILEVIÄŒS Boriss, Latvia, SOC CORSINI Paolo, Italy, SOC CROZON Pascale, France, SOC DAVIES Geraint, United Kingdom, SOC DÍAZ TEJERA Arcadio, Spain, SOC DOKLE Namik, Albania, SOC DURRIEU Josette, France, SOC FLEGO Gvozden Srećko, Croatia, SOC FLYNN Paul, United Kingdom, SOC FOURNIER Bernard, France, EPP/CD FRESKO-ROLFO Béatrice, Monaco, EPP/CD GABÁNIOVÁ Darina, Slovak Republic, SOC GIOVAGNOLI Gerardo, San Marino, SOC GOSSELIN-FLEURY Geneviève, France, SOC GROSS Andreas, Switzerland, SOC GUNNARSSON Jonas, Sweden, SOC GUTIÉRREZ Antonio, Spain, SOC GUZENINA Maria, Finland, SOC HAGEBAKKEN Tore, Norway, SOC HAIDER Monica, Sweden, SOC HARANGOZÓ Gábor, Hungary, SOC HEINRICH Gabriela, Germany, SOC IORDACHE Florin, Romania, SOC IWIŃSKI Tadeusz, Poland, SOC JANSSON Eva-Lena, Sweden, SOC JURATOVIC Josip, Germany, SOC KARLSSON Niklas, Sweden, SOC KOX Tiny, Netherlands, UEL LE DÉAUT Jean-Yves, France, SOC LESKAJ Valentina, Albania, SOC LONCLE François, France, SOC LUND Jacob, Denmark, SOC MAHOUX Philippe, Belgium, SOC MAIJ Marit, Netherlands, SOC MARKOVIĆ Milica, Bosnia and Herzegovina, SOC MARTINEL Martine, France, SOC

_________ 1. SOC: Socialist Group EPP/CD: Group of the European People's Party ALDE: Alliance of Liberals and Democrats for Europe EC: European Conservatives Group UEL: Group of the Unified European Left NR: Representatives not belonging to a Political Group

Doc. 13836 Written declaration

MAURY PASQUIER Liliane, Switzerland, SOC MEALE Alan, United Kingdom, SOC MESTERHÁZY Attila, Hungary, SOC MULIĆ Melita, Croatia, SOC NACHTMANNOVÁ Oľga, Slovak Republic, SOC NEGUTA Andrei, Republic of Moldova, SOC NICOLETTI Michele, Italy, SOC OBRADOVIĆ Žarko, Serbia, SOC OHLSSON Carina, Sweden, SOC PÂSLARU Florin Costin, Romania, SOC PETRÁK Ľubomir, Slovak Republic, SOC QUÉRÉ Catherine, France, SOC RAWERT Mechthild, Germany, SOC ROCHEBLOINE François, France, EPP/CD RODRÍGUEZ Soraya, Spain, SOC ROSEIRA Maria de Belém, Portugal, SOC ROUQUET René, France, SOC SÁEZ Àlex, Spain, SOC SCHENNACH Stefan, Austria, SOC SCHMIDT Frithjof, Germany, SOC SCHWABE Frank, Germany, SOC SEKULIĆ Predrag, Montenegro, SOC SIMENSEN KÃ¥re, Norway, SOC STRIK Tineke, Netherlands, SOC SUTTER Petra, De, Belgium, SOC TAKTAKISHVILI Chiora, Georgia, ALDE TOMLINSON John E., United Kingdom, SOC VÄ–SAITÄ– Birutė, Lithuania, SOC VORUZ Eric, Switzerland, SOC VRIES Klaas, de, Netherlands, SOC VUÄŒKOVIĆ Nataša, Serbia, SOC XUCLÀ Jordi, Spain, ALDE

_____________________________ Total = 82

The latest item on IP Kat beat us to it. Merpel writes: "Altogether more than 100 parliamentarians from 32 countries have now expressed their anxieties and concerns regarding the persistent erosion of fundamental rights experienced by EPO staff over the past year and a half at the hands of the current regime, which presumably still enjoys the substantial support of the Administrative Council which has notional control of the organisation."

Merpel also found this political intervention in the European Parliament:

The European Patent Office (EPO) was set up forty years ago. It currently employs about seven thousand highly qualified people, most of whom work at its offices in Germany (Munich) and the Netherlands (Ryswick). In 2014 alone, it received 274 000 patent applications from companies all over the world. Its budget of EUR 2 000 million makes it the second largest European institution after the Commission.

There have been a huge number of complaints about the EPO. Cases of staff suffering from depression (including four suicides since 2012), a climate of intimidation caused by the creation of an internal investigation unit, and restrictions on the right to strike have been reported by the trade union, SUEPO, which is now banned from EPO premises. Among other things, the union is complaining about management’s plan to lower the cost of registering patents at the price of employees' health.

Is the Commission aware of this situation and what is being done to investigate it? Also, what are the grounds for the immunity granted to the European Patent Office, which allegedly derives from the fact that it is extraterritorial, thus making it impossible for any legal action to be taken to protect workers' rights?

Over at IP Kat there are some interesting comments from what appears to be EPO staff. The first:

During this time in a Galaxy far away ....

The Administrative Council just extended for 3 years VP5 (Raimund Lutz) the man who finds everything perfectly legal (when national courts and parliamentaries don't)...


VP1 (who will be 70 at the end of his mandate whereas max. pension age at EPO is 67....


Battistelli starts his new mandate with secret salarial conditions ...


the AC did not bother to comment on the on-going spying on staff reps/unionists nor on public spying

All is fine in Eponia !!

Second comment speaks of betrayal:

Many years ago I gave a promise to the Office, and with it to the general public of Europe, that I would examine patents and only grant those with a high probability of validity as far as I could establish. In return for this the office made a promise to look after me. We had an agreement, which I considered to be binding. I have kept my promise so far and I intend to keep my promise. Unfortunately this is not made easier by the fact the some people in the Office have decided to withdraw the promise made by the office to me by changing the whole substance of my working conditions without my agreement. If I am to keep my promise, this must be tolerated, however, since there is no functioning legal system which will tell them to stop, so I have no defence. None the less, I intend to keep my promise, since I believe, and all the evidence I've seen confirms, that valid patents are important for the general public and the whole patent system. It would be really nice if someone could persuade the office to revert to keeping it's promise. I do hope these initiatives are a step along the way.

There are many more anonymous comments in there. The management of the EPO seems to have become besieged by an increasingly informed workforce, Parliament, and public. This can't end well for Battistelli. His time is running out.

Recent Techrights' Posts

Lookout, It's Outlook
Outlook is all about the sharing!
Updated A Month Ago: Richard Stallman on Software Patents as Obstacles to Software Development
very recent update
Is BlueMail a Client of ZDNet Now?
Let's examine what BlueMail does to promote itself
OpenBSD Says That Even on Linux, Wayland Still Has a Number of Rough Edges (But IBM Wants to Make X Extinct)
IBM tries to impose unready software on users
The 'Smart' Attack on Power Grid Neutrality (or the Wet Dream of Tiered Pricing for Power, Essentially Punishing Poorer Households for Exercising Freedom Like Richer Households)
The dishonest marketing people tell us the age of disservice and discrimination is all about "smart" and "Hey Hi" (AI) as in algorithms akin to traffic-shaping in the context of network neutrality
Links 29/11/2023: VMware Layoffs and Too Many Microsofters Going Inside Google
Links for the day
Just What LINUX.COM Needed After Over a Month of Inactivity: SPAM SPAM SPAM (Linux Brand as a Spamfarm)
It's not even about Linux
Microsoft “Discriminated Based on Sexuality”
Relevant, as they love lecturing us on "diversity" and "inclusion"...
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, November 28, 2023
IRC logs for Tuesday, November 28, 2023
Media Cannot Tell the Difference Between Microsoft and Iran
a platform with back doors
Links 28/11/2023: New Zealand's Big Tobacco Pivot and Google Mass-Deleting Accounts
Links for the day
Justice is Still the Main Goal
The skulduggery seems to implicate not only Microsoft
[Teaser] Next Week's Part in the Series About Anti-Free Software Militants
an effort to 'cancel' us and spy on us
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
Professor Eben Moglen on How Social Control Media Metabolises Humans and Constraints Freedom of Thought
Nothing of value would be lost if all these data-harvesting giants (profiling people) vanished overnight
IRC Proceedings: Monday, November 27, 2023
IRC logs for Monday, November 27, 2023
When Microsoft Blocks Your Access to Free Software
"Linux is a cancer that attaches itself in an intellectual property sense to everything it touches." [Chicago Sun-Times]
Techrights Statement on 'Cancel Culture' Going Out of Control
relates to a discussion we had in IRC last night
Stuff People Write About Linux
revisionist pieces
Links 28/11/2023: Rosy Crow 1.4.3 and Google Drive Data Loss
Links for the day
Links 27/11/2023: Australian Wants Tech Companies Under Grip
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news
Links 27/11/2023: Underwater Data Centres and Gemini, BSD Style!
Links for the day
[Meme] Leaning Towards the Big Corporate CoC
Or leaning to "the green" (money)
Software Freedom Conservancy Inc in 2022: Almost Half a Million Bucks for Three People Who Attack Richard Stallman and Defame Linus Torvalds
Follow the money
[Meme] Identity Theft and Forgery
Coming soon...
Microsoft Has Less Than 1,000 Mail (MX) Servers Left, It's Virtually Dead in That Area (0.19% of the Market)
Exim at 254,000 servers, Postfix at 150,774, Microsoft down to 824
The Web is Dying, Sites Must Evolve or Die Too
Nowadays when things become "Web-based" it sometimes means more hostile and less open than before
Still Growing, Still Getting Faster
Articles got considerably longer too (on average)
In India, the One Percent is Microsoft and Mozilla
India is where a lot of software innovations and development happen, so this kind of matters a lot
Feeding False Information Using Sockpuppet Accounts and Imposters
online militants try every trick in the book, even illegal stuff
What News Industry???
Marketing, spam, and chatbots
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, November 26, 2023
IRC logs for Sunday, November 26, 2023
The Software Freedom Law Center's Eben Moglen Explains That We Already Had Free Software Almost Everywhere Before (Half a Century Ago)
how code was shared in the 1970s and 80s