Bonum Certa Men Certa

The Quality of European Patents is Nosediving and Those Who Can Put an End to It (Appeal Boards) Are Controlled by Fear of Battistelli

The boards still lack independence from the rogue regime that Battistelli has nurtured and expanded

Metal pieces



Summary: The EPO is broken beyond repair, as even parts of the Organisation that should in principle be capable of supervising the Office are reduced to subservient elements of 'King' Battistelli

THE quality of patents at the EPO declined sharply. Many insiders say so; they would know, wouldn't they? They are, after all, those under pressure to work faster and more sloppily, often granting or rejecting patents based on a more superficial examination.



"It's a lot better when an application or a patent is found ineligible/invalid early on, albeit that kind of trajectory is becoming rare as workload grows and the appeal boards are further marginalised, threatened, understaffed, and even illegally suspended."Watch this new press release (found today). A company "on Wednesday had received so-called Intention to Grant from European Patent Office (EPO) regarding the company's patent application for Europe" (and beyond, as EPO covers not only Europe).

Is this what "Early Certainty" (i.e. superficial examination) might look like? Or "legal certainty on pending applications," as the EPO euphemistically calls it? Here is yet another example of patents in this week's press releases [1, 2, 3]. "The EPO upheld a decision that found the patent to be invalid," it says. It's not unusual for European patents (EPs) to be found invalid some time down the line these days. Each time a patent is granted in error the outcome would be innocent people (defendants, the public etc.) being punished. It's unjust. It's a lot better when an application or a patent is found ineligible/invalid early on, albeit that kind of trajectory is becoming rare as workload grows and the appeal boards are further marginalised, threatened, understaffed, and even illegally suspended.

Yesterday, on the 1st of February, Matthew Fletcher from Abel & Imray wrote about the Enlarged Board of Appeal and his colleague Paul Brady wrote about the Enlarged Board's recent case, which IP Kat mentioned as well (as the referral got published). To quote the detailed analysis from Abel & Imray:

Has The EPO's Enlarged Board Detoxified "Poisonous Divisionals"?



In G 1/15, the EPO's Enlarged Board of Appeal was asked to clarify the position regarding the entitlement to "partial priority". A key issue was whether it is necessary for subject matter to be defined as alternatives in a claim in order for the claim to be entitled to multiple priority dates.

While the full decision in G1/15 is not yet out, the Enlarged Board has issued an order to the effect that the only aspect that needs to be considered is whether the subject matter claimed is disclosed in a priority document. This possibly more liberal approach to partial priority may be good news for many applicants.


"Under the EPC," IP Kat wrote, "entitlement to partial priority may not be refused for a claim encompassing alternative subject-matter by virtue of one or more generic expressions or otherwise (generic "OR"-claim) provided that said alternative subject-matter has been disclosed for the first time, directly, or at least implicitly, unambiguously and in an enabling manner in the priority document. No other substantive conditions or limitations apply in this respect."

"We are growingly pessimistic about patent quality at the EPO and so are stakeholders of the EPO, based on a new survey."What we are basically seeing here is lenience being expanded/broadened, thanks perhaps to boards that are under growing pressure from Battistelli and his thugs not to "interfere" with "production" (i.e. devaluation of patents for artificial growth).

We are growingly pessimistic about patent quality at the EPO and so are stakeholders of the EPO, based on a new survey. They want Battistelli out, but Battistelli is guarded by a Chinchilla of a person (who is otherwise supposed to boss him). Chinchilla Man of the Administrative Council actually played a role, at Battistelli's behest, in trying to get a judge fired. It serves to show just how crooked the whole Organisation has become.

Recent Techrights' Posts

Open Source Initiative (OSI) is Microsoft, It Presents Microsoft-Controlled Projects Like They're Everything That Exists in the World
They're not assessing the real data, they keep track only of projects foolish enough to choose slavery under Microsoft
Links 08/12/2023: Cyber Resilience Act in EU and Denmark Embracing 'Blasphemy Law'
Links for the day
Linus Torvalds Cannot Easily 'Offend' Companies Anymore, But Weeks Ago He Explained Why (Linux Support and Hardware Documentation Has Significantly Improved)
new clip
Links 08/12/2023: Tidal and Simplilearn Layoffs
Links for the day
IRC Proceedings: Thursday, December 07, 2023
IRC logs for Thursday, December 07, 2023
[Video] The Media Facilitates Microsoft's Abuse, Bribes, and Growing Threats to National Security
The failure of the media to properly and independently explain what's happening will continue to doom the media
[Video] The Next Ten Years of Techrights in a World With Changing Threats and Technological Landscapes (or Trends That Are Buzzwords/Cargo Cults)
The video of today talks about the site's (and capsule's plan) for the future
Wikipedia is Vandalism, Brought to You by Microsoft and Bill Gates
Reprinted with permission from Ryan Farmer
Lennart Poettering and Fellow Microsofters Turn GNU/Linux Into Windows, Expect Poor Reliability With systemd-bsod
turning Linux into Microsoft Windows
The Effort to Silence (Squash) GNU/Linux Advocates and Press Coverage
If nobody even mentions it anymore, does it still exist?
Links 07/12/2023: Climate Events Occupied by Their Enemy, Workers Going on Strike
Links for the day
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, December 06, 2023
IRC logs for Wednesday, December 06, 2023
A Googlebombing Campaign Targeting "Gemini" Takes on E-mail, Too
Google can do Googlebombing too (the term is even named after it)
[Video] Microsoft Without a So-called 'Common Carrier' (Windows Monoculture)
Windows Has Fallen
[Video] To Combat Efforts to Cancel or Kill the Career (and Reputation) of the People Who Made GNU/Linux We Must Rally the Community
nobody speaks better for projects and for licences than their own founders
Rumour: Major Finance Layoffs at Microsoft Next Week
If the rumour is true, we'll be hearing barely anything from the mainstream media next week
Links 07/12/2023: More EPO Patents Squashed, More Pfizer COVID-19 Vaccine "Glitches" Found
Links for the day
Still Not 'Canceled'
Ted Ts'o, Jan Kara, Linus Torvalds last month
Google is Googlebombing the Term "Gemini"
Could Google not pick a name that's already "taken"?
Links 06/12/2023: Bitcoin Rebound, China Downgraded by American Firm, Yahoo! Layoffs Again
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news
Shooting the Messenger Using Bribes and Secrecy Bonds
We seem to live in a world where accountability for the rich and well-connected barely exists anymore
The Myth of an Aging (or Dying) GNU/Linux Leadership
Self-fulfilling prophecies as a tactic?
Links 06/12/2023: Many More December Layoffs
Links for the day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, December 05, 2023
IRC logs for Tuesday, December 05, 2023
PipeWire 1.0: Linux audio comes of age
Once upon a time, serious audio users like musicians and audio engineers had real trouble with Linux
This is How 'Linux' Foundation Presents Linux to the World
Right now it even picks Windows over Linux in some cases