Bonum Certa Men Certa

Microsoft Angers the World by Asking for a Form of Security Bailout, More Fundamental Windows Flaws Found

Screaming



Summary: Microsoft's recommendation of "Internet tax" for removing Windows botnets/zombies doesn't fly; Windows DEP (data execution prevention) is busted

EARLIER in the week we wrote about Microsoft's Charney suggesting that everyone -- UNIX and Linux users included -- should pay [1, 2] to compensate for Microsoft's own negligence [1, 2, 3]. Many people already pay for the damage collectively; for instance, if banks lose money due to zombie Windows PCs that compromise accounts, then interest rates will be lessened. These are some of the hidden costs everyone pays for Microsoft's incompetence. In Germany, it's hardly even hidden anymore.



"Microsoft's Laugh-a-Minute Show Continues," says Glyn Moody regarding Microsoft's arrogant suggestion.

Can you believe it? Microsoft's lousy programming has caused *billions* of pounds worth of damage to the global economy in terms of downtime, lost files (and probably blood pressure problems) and it has the bare-faced cheek to suggest there should be an “Internet usage tax” on *everyone* (including GNU/Linux users) to pay for the rectification of *its* mistakes? No wonder Scott Charney has the humorous and manifestly self-contradictory title of “Microsoft Corporate Vice President for Trustworthy Computing”....


Here is another response: "Taxing every citizen for Microsoft Windows problems? Are we insane?"

Just when you think you've heard everything, something new arrives. Two years ago, we heard that half a million computers are infected with malicious bots every day (a "bot" is a software program that enters your computer from the Internet or inside infected files, then runs in the background to steal your data, send spam or wreak havoc in some other way).

This is a huge problem both because we depend on digital data in too many ways to explain them here (but you may read about them in the Open Government Book) and because of environmental reasons. According to a McAfee report published in May 2009 the amount of energy used every year to transmit, process and filter spam would be enough to power 2.4 million homes, with the same Greenhouse Gas emissions as 3.1 million passenger cars.

On March 2nd, 2010, Microsoft Corporate Vice President for Trustworthy Computing Scott Charney spoke at a computer security conference about this very theme, that is how to fight the damages caused by computers infected by bots (or "malware").

According to the summary published on ComputerWorld, Mr Charney started correctly. He pointed out that, just as there are quarantine programs for people with infective diseases, the same thing should happen with people who have computers infected by malware but, for any reasons, won't fix them up as soon as possible: such people should not be allowed to go online until their computer is clean and safe.


Windows is insecure not because people are negligent; Microsoft itself is extremely negligent and there are many examples of this. "Typical Windows user patches every 5 days," says this new report from IDG (quoting Secunia).

75 Microsoft, third-party patch events each year are a burden most users can't bear, says Secunia


Here is Berend-Jan Weve finding another security problem in Windows. From SJVN:

Honest to God I don't go around trying to pick on Windows for its security problems, but the hackers keep finding new ways to break into it. And, this time, they've found a doozie. Berend-Jan Wever, aka "Skylined," a Google security software engineer has busted DEP (data execution prevention), one of the few significant security improvements Microsoft has made to Windows.

DEP, which was added to Windows back in August 2004 in XP SP2. It addressed the very common hacking technique of buffer overflows. In a buffer overflow attack, a malicious program tries to overwrite the buffer, the amount of memory a program has been allocated for running its code in. By so doing, a buffer overflow overwrites memory that may or may not have been allocated to other programs. In either case, it can then use this overwritten memory for its own purposes. Usually this means running malware or even taking over the computer itself.

[...]

Unfortunately, Wever, using a variation of a hacking technique he helped perfect called heap-spraying has busted DEP. In heap-spraying, the attack code made an educated guess at where vulnerable memory that could be used to execute unapproved programs could be found. In Wever's latest trick, the attacking code looks for clues on where to find memory that's allowed by DEP to run programs. Once armed with this information, the attack code can then successfully plant itself in the system.

While the attack code isn't ready to go for any script-kiddie, as Wever himself points out, he has given enough information on how to defeat DEP that it's only a matter of time before a competent cracker uses the code to start enabling new attacks.

[...]

In short, if you're running 32-bit Windows of any sort-XP, Vista, 7, Server 2008-you can look 'forward' to being even more vulnerable to attacks. Have I mentioned lately that I tend to do most of my desktop computing with Linux? Well, I am. This exploit opens up a new and huge hole in Windows' already vulnerable defenses.


For some of its better enhancements to security, Microsoft relies on Free software in the form of firewalls, even virus scanners.

The open source ClamAV project is often used on servers as a way to scan and secure e-mail gateways and Windows file shares. Now ClamAV is coming to the Windows desktop too, by way of the cloud.


Vista 7 is not a solution because it's not secure either. See the links below.

  1. Cybercrime Rises and Vista 7 is Already Open to Hijackers
  2. Vista 7: Broken Apart Before Arrival
  3. Department of Homeland Security 'Poisoned' by Microsoft; Vista 7 is Open to Hijackers Again
  4. Vista 7 Security “Cannot be Fixed. It's a Design Problem.”
  5. Why Vista 7 Could be the Least Secure Operating System Ever
  6. Journalists Suggest Banning Windows, Maybe Suing Microsoft Over DDoS Attacks
  7. Vista 7 Vulnerable to Latest “Critical” Flaws
  8. Vista 7 Seemingly Affected by Several More “Critical” Flaws This Month
  9. Reason #1 to Avoid Vista 7: Insecurity
  10. Vista 7 Left Hijackable Again (Almost a Monthly Recurrence)
  11. Trend Micro: Vista 7 Less Secure Than Vista
  12. Vista 7 Less Secure Than Predecessors? Remote BSoD Now Possible!

Comments

Recent Techrights' Posts

"GNU/Linux" No Longer a Pandora's Box
Cannot even make or crack a joke... when you have a target painted on your back
The "Nazi Bars"
We don't condone or condemn the label "Nazi Bar"
TV Programmes in Geminispace
Sort of like teletext except more cross-platform
Techrights' Assessment of Red Hat Layoffs in 2025 (Yes, They Happened!)
In short, Red Hat layoffs did occur this year, but even when they did the media did not mention these (and those would count as "IBM" regardless)
The GPU Bubble (GPUs Marketed by Useless Slop)
"they're selling GPUs for the sake of selling GPUs"
 
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, November 18, 2025
IRC logs for Tuesday, November 18, 2025
We Don't Keep Logs
Not for any considerable length of time
Wall Street Journal is Publishing Puff Pieces About Quantum
For IBM [...] a lot of articles about "AI" are basically a form of spam
Is the Lid Being Shut on Top of LLM Slop?
It sort of "feels" like slop is becoming passé
Celebrating Digital Sovereignty
Digital Sovereignty is connected very closely to the concept of Software Freedom
Your Web Site is Connected to the Net and the Server is Powered On, But Cloudflare Takes It All Down
Anything outsourced means that yet another party can get things wrong, resulting in problems for everyone else "in the chain"
The Register's Latest Slop Spam, Another Paid-for Article to Inflate the Bubble
Remember when celebrities advertised FTX?
Quite a Few Red Hat Layoffs These Days (or Departures)
Remember that if there are Red Hat Layoffs, they won't be called "Red Hat Layoffs" but instead be "IBM RAs" or some thing to that effect
Today is an Excellent Day To Remind People to Dump Clownflare (Cloudflare)
If people think that Clownflare (Cloudflare) will improve uptime and make access better (it sure makes accessibility far worse), remind them of all the times this clown show goes wrong, taking down with it a lot of the Web
Links 18/11/2025: Asbestos Fears, Delays for GAFAM Undersea Cable
Links for the day
Links 18/11/2025: "Bitcoin Showing Signs of Severe Collapse" and CEOs of GAFAM Finally Speak About a Slop Bubble
Links for the day
Apparent Red Hat Layoffs in "AI" (Supposedly a Strategic Area for IBM)
What is going on there?
Gemini Protocol as a Growing Source of Audience (Mostly Technical People)
Clients for Gemini Protocol are available for almost every platform imaginable
EPO Change May be Afoot, Keep Pushing and Hold Those Feet to the Fire
Backlash is brewing and societal trends reinforce backlash right now
Links 18/11/2025: CISA Advisories, Climate, "U.S. Layoffs Surge and Blaming AI is Part of the Smokescreen"
Links for the day
Gemini Links 18/11/2025: "Block Them All", Annex, Signed Commits, and "Cryptography of the Internet"
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Monday, November 17, 2025
IRC logs for Monday, November 17, 2025
Right Under the Nose of Mainstream Media
That the media fails to cover the matter mostly speaks volumes about the media
Formalities Officers at the EPO Face Uncertain Future, Administration Gets Asked About That
They're being too polite (perhaps) to people whose agenda is detrimental not just to the EPO but also the EPC
Spanish Focus Coming Soon and Maturity of Site Search
We'll soon be focusing on Spain
Slopwatch: LLM Slopfarms Seem to be Slowing Down Somewhat
LLM addiction is a very unhealthy addiction
Thailand: Windows Down Sharply, Microsoft Loses Share to GNU/Linux
the Thai economy is strategic and relatively important in the region
EPO General Consultative Committee (GCC) Agenda: Reduction of Staff's Salaries (Compared to Inflation)
knocking salaries down some more
Gaming Journalist and Guru Jason Schreier Says Microsoft is Indeed Behaving Like It Exits the Console Market
Remember that many shops no longer sell or stock XBox
Links 17/11/2025: ‘Agentic OS’ Backlash and Facebook ('Meta') Loses Yann Le Cun
Links for the day
Gemini Links 17/11/2025: Technology's Harm in Schools, 3D Printer Blurb
Links for the day
Coming Soon: EPO Trip in Spain
António Campinos being 'Marcosed'
Links 17/11/2025: "You Don't Need Animations" and Blocking Copyright-Infringing Sites Inevitably Goes Wrong
Links for the day
The Register MS: Slop is "FOMO" (Fear of Missing Out), FOMO is Funding Us
even former management (Editor in Chief of The Register MS) admitted to me it was aware of this issue
What's 4Chan and Why It's So Problematic
Incels and losers converge around online echo chambers
Difficult to Win Arguments When the Simple Facts Are Not on One's Side
Starting arguments over things when you know the facts (unlike money!) aren't on your side is a dumb move that can only ever result in severe loss of credibility
Python is Attempting an Outreach to African-Americans, Microsoft Lunduke Has a Problem With That
Did he manage to brainwash himself into this ideology wherein bigotry is in fact tolerance, inclusion, equity?
Tribalism Injures Projects
In Free software communities, there are many species and "breeds". Some developers are happy to work with everyone else based upon technical merit
IBM is Googlebombing Its Way Out of Trouble and Criticism
IBM is a dying giant
No, There is Nothing Impressive About Slop Plagiarism-Enabled, Computer-Generated Images in Your Web Site...
When people use slop they do not broadcast an embrace of innovation; they merely signal they're lazy, unethical, and unscrupulous
After Denial (of the Issues) Comes Censorship
Every critic of the status quo is "racist" and every criticism is "racism"
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, November 16, 2025
IRC logs for Sunday, November 16, 2025
Intel, Facing Mass Layoffs (Including Many Key Engineers Who Work on Linux Kernel), is Pushing for Slop Inside Linux
replacing proper, well-tested code (and documentation thereof) with slop
More People Want to Quit Windows (Vista 10 is "End of Life"), Restricted Boot (UEFI) Makes That Harder
It's widely agreed (a consensus) that Restricted Boot is a bad thing for GNU/Linux
IRCNow Helped Techrights
If you want to gain more independence or "sovereignty" over your communications and need help setting things up (no prior experience setting up/configuring IRC), go to IRCNow
How We Managed to Make IRC Inclusive and Free Speech-Tolerant Without Banning People
People in IRC seldom agree on everything, more so if politics are aired and especially in the wrong context/s
UEFI 'Restricted Boot' Will Usher in Rootkits Into Linux
Those of us who understand and value what it means to truly own our devices should definitely be alarmed by these trends
Plan for European Patent Office (EPO) Coverage This Month, Next Month, and Next Year
How much longer can European politicians ignore all this corruption?
Germany-Based Focus Online is Apparently Covering Up Cocaine Use at Europe's Second-Largest Institution, the European Patent Office
More contact details for the German press - Focus online
opensource.net Dead Since Middle of Summer, opensource.org (OSI) Still Leaderless
At the moment the brand "Open Source" is misused so heavily that we have considered adding a new category to our Daily Links, focusing a lot less on "Open" and more on software freedom as a concept
Photos From Richard Stallman's Talk in Argentina Earlier Today (Remote Talk)
Dr. Stallman's talk went ahead