Links: OSI Finds Its Spine, 'Open' Core Called Out
- Dr. Roy Schestowitz
- 2010-07-21 16:38:08 UTC
- Modified: 2010-07-21 16:38:08 UTC
Summary: With people like Simon Phipps in its house, the OSI regains credibility
Open core, Open core, more Open core… the debate goes on and on, with Monty the latest to weigh in.
When you get down to it this is a fight over branding – which is why the issue is so important to the OSI folks (who are all about the brand). I don’t actually care that much how SugarCRM, Jahia, Alfresco et al make the software they sell to their customers. As a customer I’m asking a whole different set of questions to “is this product open source?” I want to know how good the service and support is, how good the product is, and above all, does it solve the problem I have at a price point I’m comfortable with. The license doesn’t enter into consideration.
So if that’s the case (and I believe it is), why the fighting? Because of the Open Source brand, and all the warm-and-fuzzies that procures. “Open solutions” are the flavour of the decade, and as a small ISV building a global brand, being known as Open Source is a positive marketing attribute. The only problem is that the warm-and-fuzzies implied by Open source – freedom to change supplier or improve the software, freedom to try the software before purchasing, the existence of a diverse community of people with knowledge, skills and willingness to help a user in difficulty – don’s exist in the Open Core world. The problem is that for the most part, the Open Core which you can obtain under the OSI-approved license is not that useful.
Yesterday on Twitter, I said “Open Core is annoying because the “open core” bit is pretty much useless. It doesn’t do exactly what it says on the tin.”
Recently, there has been debate in the press about "Open Core". I don't care to debate the minor points but make a simple declaration:
* "Open Core" has NOTHING to do with "Open Source". Nearly all proprietary software, at this point, has various degrees of open source-licensed source code in its core.
* "Open Core" has none of the advantages of open source to the user and is merely a proprietary software company.
* "Open Core" puts the software user at a disadvantage in the same way that all proprietary software puts the user at a disadvantage.
While their marketing guy may claim “that overall, Sugar 6 is an open source product from an open source company”, it’s hard to see how they are anything other than a proprietary software company who share some code with a related open source project. Claiming to be “an open source company” seems an unacceptable use of the open source brand to me.
Once more there is a lot of heated discussion about what constitutes a “real” open source business model – that is, one that remains true to the spirit of open source, and doesn't just use it as a trendy badge to attract customers. But such business models address only a tiny part of running a company – how it generates money. What about the many other aspects of a firm?
Imagine a world where code used by the biggest clouds is freely available to any developer, anywhere. A world where that code was a standard used to build private clouds as well as a variety of new service offers. In this world, workloads could be moved around these clouds easily – you could fire your cloud provider for bad service or lack of features, but not have to rewrite the software to do it. Imagine an open source cloud operating system that lifts IT to the next level of innovation, just as Linux drove the web to new heights.
Free whitepaper – 10 top tips for getting IT into your CMO’s good books
NASA is dropping Eucalyptus from its Nebula infrastructure cloud not only because its engineers believe the open source platform can't achieve the sort of scale they require, but also because it isn't entirely open source.
NASA chief technology officer Chris Kemp tells The Reg that as his engineers attempted to contribute additional Eucalyptus code to improve its ability to scale, they were unable to do so because some of the platform's code is open and some isn't. Their attempted contributions conflicted with code that was only available in a partially closed version of platform maintained by Eucalyptus Systems Inc., the commercial outfit run by the project's founders.
I was surprised to see that Larry Augustin had posted to his blog, since he does that pretty infrequently, so I assume all of the questioning about whether or not SugarCRM is open source is hitting close to home. Not as bad as a flawed cell phone antenna design, but I guess bad enough.
While his post is very heartfelt, it is full of misdirection about the meaning of the term “open source”. He refers to the word “open” a lot, but “open” and “open source” are two different things. Heck, one of the most popular network management product suites of all time was called OpenView, but the “open” in the name had nothing to do with open source software.
I’ve been staying out of the recent resurgence in the “open core” debate (check out the 451 Group for a summary). If these fauxpen source vendors would simply call their product “open core” versus “open source” there wouldn’t be anything to talk about, but they need to market themselves as “open source” as opposed to “just another commercial software company with a great API” to get any traction.
Recent Techrights' Posts
- Security Advisory: Debian falls for social engineering hacks
- Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
- The High Cost of Making Scepticism of Proprietary Voting Machines a "Trump" and "Conspiracy Theory" Territory
- Time to get back to paper? Or read an old paper?
- Today We Got an Early Birthday Gift
- Exciting times
- [Meme] Going Too Far to the Left Can Breed Militant Ideology
- Some people can never be appeased because they prefer not to be appeased
- FSF Expressed No Preference Regarding Presidential Candidates (Its Founder Did)
- Because he is a principled person, he does not prioritise loyalty to customers or employers (money)
-
- Gateway for News and Blogs
- In the long run, this site and its sister site (less overlap between them now) should hopefully become a popular destination for people who look for information, not chaff
- Going Even Faster
- We hope the site will be faster soon
- Psychopaths Who Reaffirm Our Work's Value
- Psychopaths and sociopaths lack empathy, so they're willing to go very far and stoop as low as they deem necessary
- [Meme] How Low Can You Go at the European Patent Office?
- Not just in terms of patent quality
- More Cuts/End to Benefits for EPO Workers (Europe's Working Conditions Incompatible With the European Patent Convention)
- "The Office is now reviving it but plans to introduce new cuts on benefits"
- Over at Tux Machines...
- GNU/Linux news for the past day
- IRC Proceedings: Thursday, November 07, 2024
- IRC logs for Thursday, November 07, 2024
- Gemini Links 08/11/2024: US Election, RetroChallenge 2024, and More
- Links for the day
- [Meme] Questioning Proprietary Software? Not OK...
- A disaster long in the making
- Links 07/11/2024: HTTP/3, Health Research, and Punditry
- Links for the day
- Gemini Links 07/11/2024: On Writing Publicly and Record Player Table
- Links for the day
- Open Source Security Foundation (OpenSSF) Hosted SOSS as Microsoft Propaganda Platform With Microsoft Front Group OSI
- They essentially promote what they're attacking under false pretences [...] OSI is deeply corrupt. It's more toxic than arsenic.
- Anti-Linux FUD, Now in LLM Form, Thanks to Brittany Day
- They attack Linux with chatbots
- [Meme] When You Discredit People Who Discredit Secret Code
- proprietary systems with hundreds of millions of transistors (and hundreds of millions of lines of code)
- Links 07/11/2024: Online Manipulation in Social Control Media, Election Deniers, and More
- Links for the day
- Gemini Links 07/11/2024: emacs-guix and File Hoarding
- Links for the day
- [Meme] Election Day at the European Patent Office
- Less than 60 minutes left to cast your vote
- Staff Union of the European Patent Office (SUEPO) Election Ending Today
- In one hour
- [Meme] When the Patent Office Does Illegal Things and Staff Speaks Out
- many leaks received today
- Apple's Debt Has Skyrocketed While Gimmicks Like Vision Pro Failed
- In Apple's case, the debt is almost double the "Cash on Hand", which isn't even cash
- A President Trump is Excellent News to Microsoft
- His racist policies gave lots of contracts to Microsoft
- Who Next on the Linux Foundation's 'Kill List'?
- Remember that only about 2% of the "Linux" Foundation's budget goes to Linux
- Links 07/11/2024: Facebook Scams, Journalists on Strike
- Links for the day
- Over at Tux Machines...
- GNU/Linux news for the past day
- IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, November 06, 2024
- IRC logs for Wednesday, November 06, 2024
- Microsoft-Connected Publishers Want Us to Think That Linux is Some Sort of a Virus and a "Backdoor"
- "The problem is with windows and the attack vector is via Windows"
- We've Made it to 18! Here's to Another 18!
- Going on for another 18 years means until some time at the end of 2042
- Links 07/11/2024: Political Angst and Laptop Issues
- Links for the day
- Even LKML Subjected to Slop/SPAM by Guardian Digital, Inc (linuxsecurity.com)
- They're really awful
- Links 06/11/2024: BPF in RFC 9669, More Facebook Fines for Privacy Abuses
- Links for the day
- Gemini Links 06/11/2024: Political Shock and Hermaic Encouragement
- Links for the day
- Planet Debian Allows Politics (But It Depends on Your Opinions and Debian's Big Sponsors)
- Planet Debian is OK with politics... as long as all your political opinions are the "correct" ones and you add cute animals
- What Makes RMS Such an Attractive Target ('Discreditisation' Campaigns)
- Don't be so easily fooled
- The Biggest OEMs or Vendors of GNU/Linux Stopped Competing With Microsoft (Which Pays Them to Promote Windows, Too)
- Where are the competition authorities (or regulators for that matter)?
- Let's Encrypt Falls to a New Low of Only 0.6% of Gemini Capsules Known to Lupa
- In Gemini Protocol, certificates for encryption are required, but centralised Certificate Authorities (CAs) aren't needed
- Computer-Generator Crap Flooding the Web, the Latest Example About "Linux"
- Here's today's example
- Links 06/11/2024: Election Disinformation and Legal Actions
- Links for the day
- Gemini Links 06/11/2024: Stargazing and Death on Hallowe'en
- Links for the day
- Would You Trust a Liar?
- Why lie about the authorship?
- Mass Layoffs at Mozilla Announced During US Elections
- Maybe nobody will notice?
- [Meme] Announcing "Results" Before Everyone Even "Played"
- There is a "tech" angle to otherwise political news
- US Polls Close in One Minute (Social Control Media Does Not Care, Will Not Wait)
- US election results will be known in about 2 days
- Concentration and Centralisation Versus Aggregation or Syndication
- KDE has a history of burying old sites
- Social Control Media, Even Hours Before Polls Have Closed
- Has social control media controlled by CPC (TikTok) and the Trumpmobile guy (Musk's "X") done enough to convince people not to even vote (based on presumptive "results", presented a long time before all polls have closed)?
- Over at Tux Machines...
- GNU/Linux news for the past day
- IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, November 05, 2024
- IRC logs for Tuesday, November 05, 2024
- Wayland Pains in Community-Led Distros of GNU/Linux
- Few people and companies use Wayland; there's hardly any technical or practical reason to choose it
- IBM Still Conflating Microsoft With 'Security'
- As a meme
- Sanctions Cause Fragmentation in Software
- some Chinese Linux developers are already subjected to restrictions similar to Russians'
- Web Failing With Slop, Even in 'Linux' Sites (LLM Spam)
- Add SEO prompting to the mix and the Web becomes a pool of slop, not knowledge
- [Meme] State of the World Wide Web and Online Journalism
- Technically a failure (DRM) and cannot even get basic things right
- Trump's signature policy, building a wall, copied from Irish-Australian student politician
- Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
- Linus Torvalds' self-deprecating LKML CoC mail linked to Hitler's first writing: Gemlich letter
- Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
- [Meme] Turning 18 in One Day
- just one more day