Bonum Certa Men Certa

Samsung to Potentially Challenge Design Patents in the US Supreme Court While Filing Patent Applications for Designs

Defensive, offensive, or just outright dumb and unnecessary? Hypocritical for sure.

Gates



Summary: Dumb patents on very dumb/trivial ideas (like gate-locking, or slide to unlock) still a subject which the higher US courts deem worthy of Supreme intervention (while Samsung itself joins the problem with new patent filings)

KOREAN giant Samsung, the market leader in the Android space, is an attractive target for patent lawsuits, even though conventionally Korean companies aren't combative patent aggressors themselves (they don't deserve the pricey defendant's treatment). There's no escaping the aggressors for Samsung, which even got attacked using EPO patents on software and designs (Samsung won as the EPO patents turned out to be bogus, i.e. erroneously granted).



"There's no escaping the aggressors for Samsung, which even got attacked using EPO patents on software and designs (Samsung won as the EPO patents turned out to be bogus, i.e. erroneously granted)."Samsung is pursuing design patents of its own now, based on the latest news, e.g. [1, 2, 3] (we found more than a dozen articles about this one) and Apple's attack on Samsung using design patents is still a subject of discussion, even 2.5 weeks after it was news. This one new blog post says: "Oral argument has not yet been scheduled, but I imagine it will be held sometime in October or November after the Court returns from its summer recess. For now, at least, it seems likely that the Court will still consist of only eight, not the full complement of nine, justices."

By extension, a lot of design patents will be considered/assessed by SCOTUS, but why were they being granted in the first place? Designs are often covered by laws other than patent law. In the context of patents it's common for callback functions, i.e. software (behaviour), to be incorporated into the static (visual i.e. plottable) design.

"In the context of patents it's common for callback functions, i.e. software (behaviour), to be incorporated into the static (visual i.e. plottable) design."As we pointed out here a long time ago, design patents are in many cases just a subclass of software patents, hence they both need to go away. MIP does not quite agree and in a very recent post about "design rights" (not quite the same as design patents) it said: "After attending the recent INTA/AIPPI conference on “Designs: Into the Future”, James Nurton summarises what there is to love about designs – and also a few reasons not to love them. On the following pages, we also look in depth at the recent Trunki decision in the UK and the pending Apple v Samsung case in the United States"

The Trunki case has been mentioned many times in our daily links. It's truly dumb and some might call it outrageous. But it's not about patents. There is hardly a connection/parable here. Either way, to conflate or interject it into the Apple v Samsung would only mislead.

Comments

Recent Techrights' Posts

Central Staff Committee on EPO Bribing Its Critics, Using a "Sharp and Abrupt Reduction, Estimated at 80% to 90%, in the Number of Refusals and Summons for Oral Proceedings in Areas Related to Software Patents"
silence would be a form of enhanced complicity, in effect endorsing both bribes and violation of the EPC
Speaking Truth to Power (More Effectively)
Behind every 'tech' giant there's some dark secret and they already seek to demonise/discredit critics/exposers
 
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Friday, September 20, 2024
IRC logs for Friday, September 20, 2024
[Meme] EPO Suckers
The EPO's president refers to himself as "the f**king president" (maybe he knows why)
Links 20/09/2024: Qualcomm Layoffs, Interest Rates Fall
Links for the day
Gemini Links 20/09/2024: 3K Run and Lagrange 1.18
Links for the day
Spam of the Day (Yes, Brittany Day Again)
They leverage LLMs for SEO purposes
Links 20/09/2024: Chinese Botnet Dismantled, More EU Shake-ups
Links for the day
Links 20/09/2024: European Commission on Microsoft Competition Abuses, More Revelations About Mass Layoffs at IBM and Microsoft
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Thursday, September 19, 2024
IRC logs for Thursday, September 19, 2024
Links 19/09/2024: UPC Illegal 'Court' and Microsoft LinkedIn Called Out for Data Misuse
Links for the day
Gemini Links 19/09/2024: Invidious Problems and Install Times
Links for the day
Links 19/09/2024: Scam ‘Funeral Streaming’ and More Microsoft TCO Tales
Links for the day
In Sweden, GNU/Linux Almost 20% of the Laptop/Desktop Market, Firefox Falls to 2%
In the US, once a browser falls below 2%, many critical sites can legally ignore it (or its users' needs) altogether
When Microsoft Pays a Lot of Money to Reddit, 'Linux' Foundation, and Countless Other Entities
As does Google
A CoC Will Destroy Your Free Software Community and Help Imposers of CoC (Like Microsoft)
Abusers like to disguise censorship (of their abuse) as "manners" or good "conduct"
IBM Likely Breaking Several Laws With Latest 'Secret' Mass Layoffs
Never sign an NDA
Gemini Links 19/09/2024: Emacs Wiki and China, IRC Chatting
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, September 18, 2024
IRC logs for Wednesday, September 18, 2024