Bonum Certa Men Certa

When EPO Does Not Control and Coerce the Judges — Part III — ILOAT Judgment No. 4551

Series parts:

  1. When EPO Does Not Control and Coerce the Judges — Part I — ILOAT 134th Session: Two More Bittersweet Victories for EPO Staff
  2. When EPO Does Not Control and Coerce the Judges — Part II — ILOAT Judgment No. 4550
  3. YOU ARE HERE ☞ ILOAT Judgment No. 4551


EPO censorship
In Judgment No. 4551, the Tribunal found that "the true reason for the requirement of the prior authorisation was to exercise a prior censorship on the content of the communications."



Summary: EPO censorship of staff communications isn't compatible with the law, said a ruling one week ago, but the ruling is nearly a decade late

The ILOAT Judgment which we will look at in this part - No. 4551 - concerns a challenge by a group of three staff representatives to measures adopted by EPO management in May 2013 (!) for the purpose of preventing EPO staff representatives from sending mass e-mails to staff.



One of the complainants against these measures was Laurent Prunier, a staff representative who was viciously targeted and defamed by Benoît Battistelli and subjected to another politically-motivated disciplinary procedure by Elodie Bergot which led to his dismissal in 2016.

As noted above, the measures impugned in the case of Judgment 4551 date back to May 2013 (!).

"The Tribunal found that the restrictions imposed by the communiqué of 31 May 2013 were unlawful and breached the fundamental right to freedom of association."On 13 May 2013, Battistelli issued Communiqué No. 26 entitled “When enough is enough – the use of mass emails within the Office”. He complained that staff representatives were using mass emails increasingly, and claimed that, in many instances, these emails were polemical and factually incorrect.

Battistelli announced that he would shortly be setting up rules on mass communications and he delegated this task to his trusted "Croatian bulldog", the notorious union-buster Željko Topić.

António Campinos and Željko Topić
On 30 May 2013, Battistelli’s "Croatian bulldog", the notorious union-buster Željko Topić (r.), issued a communiqué imposing unlawful restrictions on EPO staff representatives with regard to the use of mass e-mails for communicating with staff. These oppressive measures were maintained intact by Battistelli’s successor, António Campinos (l.).



On 31 May 2013, Topić issued a communiqué decreeing that as from 3 June 2013, the sending of emails to more than fifty addressees would be restricted and that prior authorisation would be required. The communiqué noted that there was a facility for communication by the staff representation and the trade unions via dedicated intranet pages under their sole responsibility.

The Tribunal found that the restrictions imposed by the communiqué of 31 May 2013 were unlawful and breached the fundamental right to freedom of association.

According to the Tribunal’s assessment, the communiqué of 31 May 2013 was unlawful because it set out an indiscriminate limitation on the use of mass e-mails, without providing specific reasons for this measure which, moreover, was intended to apply for an indefinite time.

The EPO failed to establish that the prior authorisation was required for technical reasons, and it provided no evidence that mass emails to more than fifty addressees could jeopardise the operation of its IT systems.

"The EPO failed to establish that the prior authorisation was required for technical reasons, and it provided no evidence that mass emails to more than fifty addressees could jeopardise the operation of its IT systems."As a matter of fact, the wording of the two impugned communiqués revealed that "the true reason for the requirement of the prior authorisation was to exercise a prior censorship on the content of the communications."

The Tribunal was satisfied that the content of the mass e-mails which irritated EPO management did not exceed the limits to freedom of opinion and speech, and therefore did not justify the imposition of a requirement for prior authorisation.

"The [EPO] did not have the power to prevent or to impede communications among staff representatives and staff members only on the basis that they appeared, according to the Organisation, to be “polemical” or “factually incorrect”, or to substantiate “vindictive personal attacks”.

The EPO failed to provide evidence that the communications went beyond the bounds of legitimate, though harsh, criticism, and trespassed into the realm of gross violations of the rights of the Organisation or individuals. In the present case, the measures taken by the Organisation were disproportionate."


The Tribunal recalled that according to its case law, the ability of a body representing the staff to circulate emails to all staff members is not “a privilege”. On the contrary, such body “has a legitimate right to avail itself of this facility, unless there is good cause for restricting it” (Judgment 3156).

"The complainants were collectively awarded costs of € 900 euros."Although the Tribunal found in favour of Laurent and his co-complainants, it rejected their claim for an award of € 20,000 in moral damages for the “serious breach” of their rights since 2013.

According to the Tribunal, "the annulment of the impugned decision is in itself a sufficient remedy for any moral injury the complainants may have conceivably suffered."

The complainants were collectively awarded costs of € 900 euros.

In the concluding part of this mini-series we will look at the wider implications of ILOAT Judgments nos. 4550 and 4551 for the EPO’s notoriously dysfunctional internal justice system.

Recent Techrights' Posts

In defence of JD Vance, death of Pope Francis
Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
Three Years in Prison for Disney Employee’s ‘Menu Hacking’: The Economic Fallout of Digital Menus
Reprinted with permission from Ryan Farmer
Approaching 10,000 Articles/Pages Since Going Static
Trying to silence or derail the site was always a dumb strategy
Microsoft is Shedding Off Loads of Staff and That Can be Dangerous Too
Working for Microsoft is a choice; nobody forces you to do it
Richard Stallman and the Unix Philosophy
When asked about systemd people must remember that RMS speaks as an active Board member of the FSF and also the founder of the FSF
 
Links 26/04/2025: General Assassinated in the Town of Balashikha, US Promoting Seafloor Mining
Links for the day
Links 26/04/2025: Facebook Layoffs Again, Remembering What's Real, and Say No to Mass Surveillance
Links for the day
Links 26/04/2025: NOAA Budget Cuts and "Dog Days Ahead"
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Friday, April 25, 2025
IRC logs for Friday, April 25, 2025
Links 25/04/2025: Slop Fatigue and Patent Judges Flocking to Fake, Unconstitutional and Illegal Kangaroo Court (UPC, Captured 'Justice')
Links for the day
Gemini Links 25/04/2025: Night Manager and Devuan in Hosting
Links for the day
Windows Falls to New Lows in Nicaragua, Now Below a Quarter (It Used to be Almost 100%)
Another all-time low for Windows
The Cost (to Linux) of LLM Slop
Slop 'artists' like Fagioli are far from harmless
Links 25/04/2025: Ubisoft Spyware, Hegseth Fails at Tech on Every Level
Links for the day
Gemini Links 25/04/2025: Food Forest Update and Facebook Destroying the Net
Links for the day
Get Rid of Back Doors, Don't Obsess Over Bounties and Other Corporate PR Stunts (or Needless Reboot Rituals)
Security as a term has mostly lost its meaning due to repeated misuse for many years
Serial Sloppers Are Killing the Web (They Probably Don't Care, Either)
Slop is a disease on the Web
Streaming Apps Are “Investor Fraud” That Kills the Planet
Reprinted with permission from Ryan Farmer
Things Get Increasingly Nasty at Microsoft Ahead of the Fake Results and May's Mass Layoffs Wave
They try to get people to 'resign' so that they won't count as layoffs and the company's 'wellbeing' will seem better
IBM's Debt Ballooned by 8.5 Billion Dollars in Just 3 Months!
Hallmark of a company in a state of disarray, trying to spend its way out of trouble
Big Trouble in GNOME
even GNOME people admit the CoC went wrong
Slopping the Trough: Disney Plus Loses Billions and the Decline of Physical Media in America
Reprinted with permission from Ryan Farmer
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Thursday, April 24, 2025
IRC logs for Thursday, April 24, 2025
Links 24/04/2025: GAFAM Problems and No Peace (or Ceasefire) in Sight
Links for the day
Slopfarms on the Web Almost Always Generate Anti-Linux FUD When They Produce "Linux" Output
Welcome to the dying Web
Richard Stallman's Oxford Talk Has Just Ended, Here Are Some Photos
he might hop over to another European country
Gemini Links 24/04/2025: Birthday and Good Work of Academia in Esotericism
Links for the day
Links 24/04/2025: EU fines Apple and Facebook, Another Microsoft GitHub Security Blunder
Links for the day
New Article Explains How the GPL Came About and WordPress Having Copyleft Obligations
Having been involved in the WordPress development community since almost the beginning, I know why it chose the GPL and how it restricts abuse by Automattic
IBM Gained Almost 6 Billion Dollars in "Goodwill" Value in Just 3 Months, According to IBM
Congrats to the management!
In Belarus, Yandex is Now Measured as 50 Times More 'Popular' (by Usage) Than Microsoft
Yandex continues to gain, whereas Bing cannot even register at 1%. Last month it was registered or measured at a measly 0.65%.
IBM Cannot Lie to Shareholders Anymore
"I would not be surprised if we see a layoff every quarter this year."
Dr Richard Stallman (RMS) Gives Talk in Oxford University in 4 Hours
If you live nearby, go there (it's free as in gratis)
Using a Law Firm's Licence to Exercise Politics Through Frivolous SLAPPs and Nastygrams (to Silence People, Remove Pages, Demand Fake or Forced 'Apologies')
Things must be getting really bad when lawyers act for raving antisemites
We're Working to Make Full-Site Search Available
This site has over 1,000 'wiki' pages, many thousands of documents, several thousands of videos, and about 50,000 blog posts or articles. We need to make them easier to find/navigate.
Links 24/04/2025: IBM Loses Many Contracts, Intel to Lay Off Over 20% (Not Counting Those Who Leave 'Voluntarily')
Links for the day
Richard Stallman Can Explain to Oxford Artificial Intelligence Society Why LLM Slop is Not Artificial Intelligence and Why It Hurts Society
another 'crop' of LLM slop that damages GNU/Linux and facts
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, April 23, 2025
IRC logs for Wednesday, April 23, 2025