Raw: SUEPO Connected the Unitary Patent (UPC) to Abuses at the European Patent Office
- Dr. Roy Schestowitz
- 2017-12-25 06:22:36 UTC
- Modified: 2017-12-25 06:22:36 UTC
Summary: SUEPO's letter to the boss of Jesper Kongstad, a protector of Benoît Battistelli who allegedly got sacked a few years later
Mr Henrik Sass Larsen
Minister of Business and Growth in Denmark
Danish Ministry of Business and Growth - Erhvervs- og Vækstministeriet,
Slotsholmsgade 10-12, 1216 København K
min@evm.dk
Unitary Patent and European Patent Organisation - Your duty to safeguard the fundamental rights of EPO staff
Dear Mr Sass Larsen,
We are writing to you as the Central Chairs of the Staff Union of the European Patent Office (SUEPO). Around 50% of the 7000 staff members of the European Patent Office are members of our Union.
At a time when Denmark is facing an important referendum on whether or not to join the Community Patent Court, it is important to ensure that no relevant factors that could potentially prove damaging are disregarded.
The Kingdom of Denmark is a member of the European Patent Organisation, whose supervisory body is the Administrative Council (AC) of the EPO. The current AC Chairman is the Danish representative, Mr Jesper Kongstad who is also concurrently Director General of the Danish Patent Office (DKPTO). As head of the Ministry of Growth and Business, all of Mr Kongstad’s actions fall ultimately under your responsibility.
There are well-reasoned concerns that suggest that the EPO is flouting established and internationally recognized principles of labour law. SUEPO has brought these concerns to the attention of the Administrative Council and Chair in a letter dated 3 March 2013 entitled “Social Democracy - Mr Battistelli's reform of the Staff Representation”. You will find a copy attached to this letter.
As executive President of the EPO, Mr Benoît Battistelli (FR) has adopted a dubious management style that may be characterized by authoritarianism and a complete disrespect for rights that are assuredly fundamental rights within a democratic country like Denmark. To give you just a few of many examples:
- Mr Battistelli has severely limited the right to strike: it is contingent on his accepting the grounds for striking and eventually approving the request to strike, all before he will then allow any industrial action to take place
- Freedom of speech is severely curtailed; staff who voice dissent are punished.
- Any staff member can be subject to an investigation by a newly created internal police force; they can neither keep silent nor be assisted by legal counsel.
- Access to independent justice is both limited and very ineffective.
All these unilaterally enforced changes have led to the worst social conflict at the EPO in its 40 years of existence. There is no indication of any improvement in the situation on the horizon - on the contrary, it seems the situation will only get worse. Not only are these changes one-sided, they risk emasculating the checks and balances in place to moderate EPO governance. We fear that in the medium term there will be heavy costs to pay in terms of the health and welfare of staff: such a regime will lead to stress, burnout or something worse. In the long term, legal inadequacies could pose problems of liability for the organisation itself, and for the Member States that fail to ensure that EPO employees enjoy the same fundamental rights as all other citizens of Europe.
Moreover, as a minister in a genuinely social-democratic government of a country that has a long-standing reputation for transparent governance, you should be concerned about the opacity of any available information concerning the EPO. The salary and terms of service of Mr Battistelli (in contrast to those of his predecessor) are kept secret. His accountability to the Administrative Council, and therefore the Member States, is limited. The perceived impartiality of one of the Auditors who, in theory, should work on behalf of the Administrative Council, might be questioned when the successful candidate happens to have been the closest associate of Mr Battistelli during his tenure at the French Patent Office (INPI). Indeed, Mr Battistelli has appointed to several key positions within the EPO a number of former associates from INPI, far exceeding the normal level of representation for France (please see http://suepo.org/public/su14062cp.pdf).
All of these changes have happened under the eyes of the Danish delegation and the Chairmanship of Mr Kongstad, both of whom have always supported Mr Battistelli.
Taking all the above information into consideration, we would ask you to take a position on your duty to safeguard the fundamental rights of EPO staff and brief your delegation and Mr Kongstad before the next AC meeting accordingly.
Yours sincerely,
[Omitted]
Recent Techrights' Posts
- SLAPP Censorship - Part 32 Out of 200: Garrett Made Spurious Requests (Later Withdrawn) the Same Week Someone He Later Spoke to by E-mail Sent Threats to Our Webhost
- The "plot thickens" because there's a multi-party tag-team act, as confirmed by Garrett after he had sworn on the Bible
- GNU/Linux Measured at All-Time High in Sweden
- Can 'influencers' have played a role
-
- SLAPP Censorship - Part 33 Out of 200: Garrett Sued by My Wife and I, Then His Microsoft Acquaintance Files Another Lawsuit and Our Webhost Receives Legal Threats Too
- Today we also show how our solicitor Mark Lewis responded to it
- Good Friday, Leaving IBM for Good
- Even on holidays
- Links 03/04/2026: Rejection of More Software Patents and Social Control Media in Several Continents
- Links for the day
- Malware in Proprietary Software - Latest Additions by Rob Musial
- Original published yesterday in gnu.org
- Visual Evidence/Documentation of IBM Dying Like the Dinosaurs
- IBM has many of these giant white elephants lying around, with some getting demolished
- Links 03/04/2026: USPTO’s Latest Greenwashing and Internet Blackouts Impact Journalists in War Zones
- Links for the day
- IBM is a Dying Company, Nowadays It Kills Red Hat With Slop
- when your last day is a national holiday in IBM's country
- "Independence Drives" and Community-Run Sites
- Independence in reporting is a much-valued trait
- When Charlatans Are Only Good at Losing Money and Storytelling (e.g. About Investment in Them)
- Wait till a a barrel of oil costs $300
- What Apple Fans Are Missing
- Apple is a bad company
- The "Pale Blue Dot" Moment Had Returned
- To many people, the "bitter-sweet" observation of how small we are
- Saudi Arabia Does Not Rely Much on Microsoft/Windows
- Putting aside politics, this is good for Free software
- Almost 12 Years of Exposing Corruption in Europe's Second-Largest Institution
- The "unready" President is now an abandoned President
- Easter Moon Mission and Its Reminder of IBM's Demise
- A lot of NASA operations now rely on GNU/Linux
- When Power is Scarce and GNU/Linux Has Power
- In Cuba, GNU/Linux has long enjoyed high adoption rates
- Don't Totally Dismiss the 'Survivalists'
- 'Survivalists' or similar terms are used to describe a particular mindset of people who prepare for some really awful scenarios
- Over at Tux Machines...
- GNU/Linux news for the past day
- IRC Proceedings: Thursday, April 02, 2026
- IRC logs for Thursday, April 02, 2026
- A Much Better Use of Fuel Than Slop
- Something positive for a change
- Hoping for Peace
- There are still many things to be enjoyed, including nature and kind people
- Gemini Links 03/04/2026: "Slide Rule Triple Multiplication" and End of "Picture Pages"
- Links for the day
- Rumours of Microsoft Layoffs This Season
- Just how much trouble is Microsoft in at this point?
- SLAPP Censorship - Part 31 Out of 200: Speaking About 20+ Years of Alleged Harassment/Defamation and High-Profile 'Targets' of Garrett
- attempts were made to settle (in effect end the case) by the person who started the case almost half a dozen times along the way
- In Asia, Windows is in Its Teens (Below 20%)
- On a global scale, Windows is down to about 26%
- GNU/Linux Becoming More Universal
- It seems likely the end of Vista 10 coinciding with a sharp rise in memory prices (and now energy prices) will benefit GNU/Linux and therefore give us more to write about
- Low Morale at IBM and Perception of Destructive Management
- IBM is going nowhere, fast
- Gemini Links 02/04/2026: Super Mario Galaxy Movie and New Antenna Instance
- Links for the day
- It Seems Like Google News Cracked Down on (Omitted, Delisted) a Lot of Slopfarms
- There's no justification/point in spending so much energy just to plagiarise things poorly
- Can Economies Like the American One Hang On?
- The coming weeks will be "interesting" unless wars end
- Steam Survey for Last Month Says 5.33% Use GNU/Linux
- big leap for GNU/Linux
- Links 02/04/2026: Science News, Energy Scarcity, Oil Sold in Yuan
- Links for the day
- Links 02/04/2026: Apple Turns 50, Efforts To Ban VPNs
- Links for the day
- Gemini Links 02/04/2026: Kubernetes With FreeBSD, OFFLFIRSOCH, and Great Circle Distance
- Links for the day
- Dr. Andy Farnell on Microsoft Silencing or Deplatforming Opposition in the UK and Elsewhere
- Microsoft as a king or a kind of "religion" one cannot question
- Over at Tux Machines...
- GNU/Linux news for the past day
- IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, April 01, 2026
- IRC logs for Wednesday, April 01, 2026
- SLAPP Censorship - Part 30 Out of 200: The Time We Reported Abuse to Greater Manchester Police (GMP) and It Was Escalated to Its Cybercrime Unit
- he started trolling and harassing me for criticising his employers' monopolistic and users-hostile agenda
- 'Modern' Cars Not a Rosy Industry
- The current "modern" cars already have a shelf life similar to that of many toothpastes
- Wrongthink Detector and Filter in "Think About the Children" Clothing
- It is not about "age verification", it's a Trojan horse for social control
- IBM Facilities Now Deemed Legitimate (Military) Target, Along With GAFAM Bases
- Does IBM have any defences in place to protect against "downtime by explosions"?
- What Happens When Some Large News Sites Turn to Slop and Spew Out Nonsense
- LLM slop makes such grotesque mistakes abundant
- Hardly Seeing Slopfarms Today, Even in Google News
- Google's adventures with slop increased its debt significantly
- Links 01/04/2026: Quantum Hype (Turing and Google), "US Fuel Prices Surge Past $4 a Gallon"
- Links for the day
- Gemini Links 01/04/2026: "Sacred Week of Cycling" and Zenity for Scripts
- Links for the day
- Losing Debian: Sruthi Chandran election flop
- Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
- French judgment: parasitisme by FSFE & Matthias Kirschner (CO23.002709)
- Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
- Microsoft Uses April Fools to 'Joke' About Inserting "Age Verification" (Surveillance) Into Linux
- MinceR says the "lkml [message/page] one is April Fools or at least they're trying to pass it off as April Fools [however] the [GitHub] one was archived on the 8th and yesterday, so that probably isn't..."
- IBM "Headcount Reductions" by Early Retirement and Death
- The tragedy at IBM started 33 years ago on the first of April
- Red Hat: Latin-1 character set under threat from Bishop Michael Martin, North Carolina
- Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
- Links 01/04/2026: Microsoft GitHub Now Pushing Ads Into People's Code/Commits, Earth Overshoot Day Draws Nearer
- Links for the day
- What IBM and EPO Workers Have in Common: European Media Not Covering Very Major News (Press Became Dysfunctional)
- Are IBM operatives working to scuttle the process of investigative journalism?
- Free Speech in the United Kingdom When "Chilling Effect" is Increasingly Prevalent
- If politicians cannot even use a term like "parasitic behaviour", then where do we as a society end up?
- Oracle Lays Off Because of Debt and Commercial Issues, Not Slop
- Like Scam Altman, Larry Ellison hangs around Cheeto King because he could use some bailouts in the form of government contracts or phony money with an incredible name like "Stargate"
- The Real Reason Many Sites and Forums Shun Microsoft Lunduke
- When forums say that they banned Microsoft Lunduke or don't want him mentioned it's probably because they are familiar with the "stench" that follows him around
- Gemini Links 01/04/2026: Hallucinations, Stitching, and Type Systems
- Links for the day
- Lots of Layoffs at IBM, "Media Blackout" About Mass Layoffs at IBM's HashiCorp and Confluent Last Month
- IBM is a dying company circling down the drain while manipulating or paying the media to pretend everything is fine
- Microsoft Under Investigation by the UK's Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) for Abusive Tactics
- What's noteworthy is that this is "set to begin in May"
- Sounds Like Red Hat (IBM) Layoffs in Slop Clothing
- This is an IBM policy. They try to justify staff cuts.
- Over at Tux Machines...
- GNU/Linux news for the past day
- IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, March 31, 2026
- IRC logs for Tuesday, March 31, 2026