Bonum Certa Men Certa

Ean Schuessler & Debian SPI OSI trademark disputes

posted by Roy Schestowitz on Apr 23, 2024

[Article 1 year old]

Reprinted with permission from disguised.work.

In our last blog, we looked at Bruce Perens' attempt to covertly ferret away the Open Source trademark.

Now we will look at how the community felt about that. The full thread is available in the debian-private leaks

Many people had put time and effort into creating Debian, the SPI structure, raising funds and generally creating goodwill towards these trademarks.

If Bruce Perens went into a restaurant and walked out without paying the bill we would all agree that was wrong. Therefore, how could he simply walk away with the Open Source trademark and put it into another organization?

Subject: SPI is Debian
Date: Thu, 19 Mar 1998 10:59:41 -0600
From: Ean Schuessler <ean@novare.net>
To: debian-private@lists.debian.org

This is not intended to be a flame.
I just want to try and get some things straight and on the level.
I was hoping to delay these discussions until the freeze was over and 2.0 was out. Highly visible public statements that Bruce continues to make preclude that option.
1. SPI was originally formed to service the Debian project and its donations. This was the reason for its inception. Creating SPI was a time consuming and difficult process that consumed money that was donated to the Debian project. The resulting artifact is valuable and belongs to the citizens of the Debian group.
2. In addition to its monetary value as a piece of equipment SPI is the caretaker of several valuable trademarks including: "Debian", "The Debian Penguin", "OpenSource", "Open Hardware" and others. These marks are of special value to Debian and the Open Source movement in general and a private individual or a private group of individuals has no place controlling these marks.
3. SPI has represented itself publicly as being synonymous with Debian and has taken money as Debian (http://www.debian.org/donations.html). This would seem to create a precedent for any understanding that SPI is an infrastructure belonging to Debian and answerable to Debian.
4. Posts from Ian Jackson indicated to me that the current board is a temporary "representative democracy" to rule and govern until more formal, rigid and democratic policies, checks and balances can be developed but that it's task was strictly to represent the interests of the Debian group.
5. It is true that SPI may have interests outside of the Debian packaging system. This is true mostly because everything that gets packaged by the Debian packaging system is of interest to the Debian developers and therefore to SPI. These external interests are not separate or distinct from Debian, but supplementary.
I would not be so egotistical as to speak for the Debian group at large. I will speak as a Debian user, advocate and contributor and urge those who agree or disagree to take your usual actions. Therefore, as a Debian user and participant I demand the following:
1. The SPI charter be made publicly available and any other legal documentation concerning its ownership, behavior and responsibilities that is not currently publicly available. (And I would note that its a thin bit of material indeed that is publicly available).
2. The position of the board as to whether they do or do not represent the interests of the Debian group and their responsibilities to us as representatives.
3. A promise from Bruce that he will not publicly represent the orientation, beliefs or direction of the Debian group as anything other than his own opinion effective immediately.
4. Bruce must reverse his confrontational position towards the Debian group and their work or otherwise be removed as a representative of SPI and therefore Debian.
5. A promise towards a time-line or links to developmental documents from Ian Jackson as to future plans for more rigid and democratic rules for the governing of Debian and SPI's actions.
That concludes my remarks. On a personal note I would like to say that I have had numerous enjoyable discussions with Bruce and have found him to be an interesting and charming person. I am frustrated and confused by his recent actions and feel genuinely bad that they have put me in a position to post this confrontational statement. I think that his contributions to the Debian project have been legion and that without his help we would be short of the mark we occupy today. His actions and the issues at stake with the control of the SPI organization require me to speak in good faith.
To Ian Jackson, Ian Murdock, Tim Sailer and other SPI board members I encourage you to consider my remarks carefully and take my assurance that it is the most sincere belief in cooperation and group spirit that motivates me to make this stand. To my fellow developers and participants I charge you to think carefully on these issues and make the decisions that are most compatible with the goals and intentions of Debian and the Open Source movement at large.
Respectfully if not cheerfully, E.Schuessler -- ___________________________________________________________________ Ean Schuessler As above Novare International Inc. so below *** WARNING: This signature may contain jokes.

Other Recent Techrights' Posts

What Happened to the Open Source Initiative (OSI) Elections: Leaking Information of Members (Even in 2025)
More nonsense about Hey Hi (AI), which OSI has been openwashing on Microsoft's payroll
Techrights Will Never Capitulate to Threats From Microsofters
Set aside violence against women and all sorts of other things; it's not about personal issues
The Microsoft-Led Open Source Initiative (OSI) is Hurting, It'll Try to Hurt Its Critics and Exposers Now
The OSI's chief meanwhile issues a bunch of meaningless waffle, a sort of "damage control" or "face-saving" platitudes
 
Richard Stallman on Patents
uploaded a day ago by Aleksandar Popovic
Recommended New Article From Dr. Andy Farnell and Some Site Miscellany
Andy says he and his daughter successfully avoid GAFAM
Links 20/03/2025: Executions in China and Crackdowns on Science in the US
Links for the day
Gemini Links 20/03/2025: Ubuntu Shafting Common Sense and Blocking of Bots of the Net
Links for the day
Links 20/03/2025: IBM Layoffs (Thousands Reportedly Laid Off) and Lots More Corruption in the White House
Links for the day
Apple is Still an Enemy of Open Standards and Software Freedom
Apple did not get any more benign
Gemini Links 20/03/2025: Wanting the Future Back and "Society That Lost Focus"
Links for the day
Fake Articles About GNOME
betanews again
Richard Stallman's Personal Site Says He's Looking for More Opportunities to Speak in Europe
He does not charge people for the talk
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, March 19, 2025
IRC logs for Wednesday, March 19, 2025
Debian Pregnancy Cluster, when I stopped using IRC
Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
Mass Layoffs at IBM Confirmed
Thousands believed to have been laid off
Slopwatch: linuxsecurity.com, cybersecuritynews.com, gbhackers.com, and techmonitor.ai (Fake 'Articles' About "Linux")
Almost all of them (75%) show up in Google News
Is Ubuntu Compromised? Push Away From GNU and GPL Led by Army Officers.
Perhaps people should ask Canonical what the thinking behind it was...
Gemini Links 19/03/2025: go-gopherproxy and 'Small Web' as Self-expression
Links for the day
Links 19/03/2025: Attention's Cost and Media Still Besieged by Dictatorships
Links for the day
Phoronix Seems to be Trying to Kill Discussion About "Asahi Lina" and the Anti-Torvalds Brigade
Our informed guess is that by reporting this news Phoronix got caught up in flamewars that divide and fracture the community
Claiming to Love What You Reject or Seek to Totally Own, Control
The Russia analogy is political
LinuxTechLab Became Just LLM Slop and SPAM
Another dead (former "Linux") site
The Rust Song
It's about control
Facts on the Case Already Disclosed by US Authorities
NGOs in the UK (several keep abreast of this, judging every recent move) are truly unimpressed
The Times Group (and The Times of India) Basically Died Again
This time a death by LLM slop/plagiarism
The Death of The Economic Times (India Times): LLM Slop Presented as 'Articles', Containing Errors and Revisionism
They'd be better off shutting down operations with some dignity than resort to bots giving the false impression (illusion) of authorship
In Belgium, Android is Finally Measured as Bigger Than Windows
In Belgium, the lobbying capital of Microsoft, it wasn't easy to get there
"Rust People" Are a Threat to BSD Too (the Licence Isn't the Main Issue, Nor is the Proprietary Microsoft Hosting)
BSDs aren't written in Rust, so BSD developers should buckle up
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, March 18, 2025
IRC logs for Tuesday, March 18, 2025
Sami Tikkanen Explains Rust Language and Its Goals
"Sompi" (the nickname of Sami Tikkanen) has weighed in
Links 19/03/2025: Gardening Season and the Web Without an Audience
Links for the day
Mauritius: Windows at All-Time Low, Down From 96% to 17%
Put in simple terms, people choose to connect from the "phone" (running Linux), not some laptop running Windows
Many IBM Layoffs Reported Today in Europe and North America
there's definitely a lot going on today
The GNU Manifesto is 40. Here's the Original Print (1985).
Some unpleasant people want to replace GNU with Microsoft-controlled (GitHub) Rust copycats
Unixmen Seems to Have Died After Turning Into a Slopfarm and Spamfarm, Is LinuxSecurity.com Next?
Better to not publish anything at all than to resort to fake garbage.
What Happened to the Open Source Initiative (OSI) Elections: More People Begin to Speak Out
Kuhn set another bonfire ablaze
Links 18/03/2025: ‘Meritless’ Defamation Suit Thrown Out, InterDigital Software Patents Headed for the Bin Too
Links for the day
These Strange Web Statistics From The Bahamas Show Windows Falling From 93% to Less Than 5%
There are about half a million there
Gemini Links 18/03/2025: Weather and Resisting "MAGA"
Links for the day
Links 18/03/2025: New Apple Blunders and Windows Disliked by Users
Links for the day
Once Again 'Losing Track' of Who the Clients Are, The Serial Harasser and Strangler from Microsoft
Timing is everything
2025 Rumours of IBM Layoffs in Marketing Likely True, Online Powwow Drops More Clues
Expect over 10,000 layoffs this year (at IBM alone)
Android (With Linux) Rises to Record Highs in Hong Kong and in Macao
Looking quite bad for Microsoft
Distractions. Distractions Everywhere.
distracting from the real solution
EPO Concerns About the Education and Childcare Allowance Reform (ECAR) and School Liaison Officer (SLO)
The public deserves to know as it impacts thousands of families
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Monday, March 17, 2025
IRC logs for Monday, March 17, 2025