Bonum Certa Men Certa

Trump's USPTO Nominee is a Supporter of Software Patents

And proponents of software patents seem pleased, as science and technology were put in the hands of people who understand neither

Trump on nukes



Summary: The US patent office is at risk (if Trump gets his way) of being dominated by law firms rather than people with a background in science and technology

THE administration of Donald Trump is becoming a threat to Alice and to the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB), both of which led to the demise of software patents in the United States. The latest step towards this was the nomination of Iancu, a person from the legal 'industry', not a technical industry. We wrote several articles about him (at least four [1, 2, 3, 4]) because we try to figure out where he stands on key issues. If he becomes USPTO Director, then his personal beliefs (probably tied to his financial interests) can become policies.



"But Iancu does have a high-profile 'industry' background... in his law firm. That too they consider to be an industry, albeit not one which produces anything but paperwork."A proponent of software patents and trolls likes Iancu. He paints him as a blank sheet/slate even though Iancu is not at all new to this area (unlike Battistelli, for instance). "He doesn’t have the high-profile industry background of some recent directors such as David Kappos or Michelle Lee," IAM wrote, "and has not been politically active like other recent post-holders Bruce Lehman, Todd Dickinson, James Rogan or Jon Dudas. What’s more, Iancu eschewed publicly campaigning for the position and has eschewed all public opportunities to outline where he stands on various key topics."

But Iancu does have a high-profile 'industry' background... in his law firm. That too they consider to be an industry, albeit not one which produces anything but paperwork. His positions are not so mysterious/cryptic at all, for he has written all sorts of things over the years, at times "showing support for software patents," (without having written a single computer program) based on this new report from Law 360. To quote what wasn't enveloped behind an impenetrable paywall:

Although he has a relatively low public profile, U.S. Patent and Trademark Office director nominee Andrei Iancu has written extensively on issues he could address during his tenure. From showing support for software patents to pushing back against criticism of the Eastern District of Texas, here are some of the views he has expressed in print.

Iancu, the managing partner of Irell & Manella LLP who was nominated Friday to lead the USPTO, has authored numerous articles in legal journals over the years.


We have reasonable doubts and legitimate reasons to worry about Iancu. Although software patents are collapsing in US courts, the USPTO continues granting a lot of them. Even Free/libre software has been targeted, as in the case of Blockchain [1, 2, 3]. What's needed at the USPTO right now is a leader who recognises and accepts Alice, hence stopping further granting of software patents.

Blockchain, based on this new report, is being poisoned yet again by a bunch of USPTO patents. To quote:

Leading cryptocurrency startup Coinbase received in mid-August a patent related to a security system for storing and distributing private keys.

The USPTO approved and published the patent on August 15, reports Econotimes.com. Entitled “Key ceremony of a security system forming part of a host computer for cryptographic transactions’, the patent lists former Coinbase engineers James Hudson and Andrew Alness as inventors, CoinDesk reported. The patent application for “key ceremony” was submitted in 2015. The startup has filed a number of patents related to security of private keys in the past.


These are clearly software patents, patent-ineligible under Alice. Why are these still being granted and when will PTAB get around to invalidating them (probably upon petitions)? ⬆

Recent Techrights' Posts

More Shutdowns at Microsoft, Hundreds of Workers Impacted Shortly
It's not the entire wave, just part of it
The World Needs Activists With Social Skills and Perseverance
An everyday activist makes life better for everybody, everywhere (not for personal gain or even credit)
 
As Usual, Late on a Friday XBox (Microsoft) Releases Evidence of Its Demise
We covered several such Friday announcements earlier this year
Gemini Links 24/10/2026: Break/Fix and OpenStreetMap
Links for the day
Links 23/10/2026: Slop "is Scaling Transnational Repression" and Infringement and DMCA Suits Against Suno/Anthropic (Plagiarism Blenders)
Links for the day
The Register MS: About 60 Mentions of "AI" in One Day Are Paid-for Spam (Sponsored Hype, Composed by the Companies Covered)
The Register MS is a dying site
Links 22/10/2026: MElon (Elon Musk) Election Interference and Perl/Raku Foundation by the Numbers
Links for the day
Techrights Audience Grew as a Function of the Intensity of Attacks on Its Existence
We try to publish fewer stories but better (not necessarily long but at least important) stories
TechRepublic is Becoming a Slopfarm
It seems like TechRepublic became LLM slop (maybe all of it, maybe only some of it for now)
Techrights is Not About GNU/Linux, Tux Machines Is
When we say "GNU/Linux" we emphasise the GNU
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XII - Lawfare to Cover Up Microsoft's Restricted Boot Calamity (Microsoft as Authority Over Linux), Garrett Wants to Talk About Penises Instead
When lawsuits become a political weapon
Without Microsoft's Monopoly (and Monopoly Rents) the Inevitable Microsoft Mass Layoffs Carry on Endlessly
Microsoft Windows is not retaining the dominance it once had
IBM's Debt Grew About $2 Billion in 3 Months
The silent layoffs still seem to impact Red Hat
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Thursday, October 22, 2026
IRC logs for Thursday, October 22, 2026
Gemini Links 22/10/2026: Solar MiniBBS, Building Major Tom, and Zig
Links for the day
Links 22/10/2026: Busan’s Celebrity Shark in Canal Again
Links for the day
Links 22/10/2026: "Software Developers Have Been Promoted Into Incompetence"
Links for the day
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XI - Losing Over a Million Pounds (Borrowed Money) to Try to Silence Critics of Restricted Boot With Microsoft-Controlled "Certificates"
Garrett is also very jealous of Daniel Pocock
Links 22/10/2026: eBay to Lay Off a Tenth of Staff (Again), Node.js and PHP Security Crises, Climate News
Links for the day
Red Hat Layoffs Still Going on This Week (Whilst IBM's Debt Grows in Spite of Mass Layoffs)
IBM is bluffing/cheating the shareholders again
IBM's Debt Continues to Increase While the Company Rapidly Shrinks
This is what a dying company looks like
Linux Kernel Needs Diversity and Diversity of Good Code, Not LLM Slop
Linux (and Linus) are kicking a can down the road
Microsoft Shrinks Every Year
Microsoft will try to spin or twist this as "efficiency"
Gemini Links 22/10/2026: Holiday Inn and Emacs
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, October 21, 2026
IRC logs for Wednesday, October 21, 2026
Techrights Was Right About a Fake Security Model Built Around Lies or Built Upon Trust in "Certificates" and "Authorities" (like Microsoft)
We have begun to amass some media reports and blog posts from technical sites
Windows Monopoly is No Longer Sustainable (the Case of Oceania)
This is why Microsoft layoffs are happening all the time
Some Downtime Possible Shortly (Router Work)
We don't use PHP in the site anymore
Mass Layoffs at Microsoft This Week and/or Next Week
Cannot pull a bunny out of some hat
With Its Future on the Line, EPO Management (Dictatorship) Resorts to Further Escalations to Fake 'Production' and Curtail Industrial Actions
It's clear that with a yearlong campaign of industrial actions - including strikes - Campinos cannot save face anymore
Gemini Links 21/10/2026: Summer Day in Tokyo (30c in Late October) and Whole Food for the Whole World
Links for the day
Links 21/10/2026: "Zelensky Took the Gloves Off This Time With Convicted Felon" and "Cellebrite iPhone Radio Zero-Day"
Links for the day
Reuters is Becoming Slop, Not a News Agency (Treat Reports From Reuters Sceptically)
In their own words
Disclosure/s Crisis at The Register MS (Promoting a Ponzi Scheme for Money)
So now they sell several schemes/scams at the same time, not limited to the slop
Links 21/10/2026: "The Tragic Death of the Republican Party" and "No War But Data Center War"
Links for the day
Internet Relay Chat Still Growing
The numbers go up, not down [...] Don't believe the doomers
Intercontinental Brigading - Part X - American Back Doors Inside Our Computers, With Transatlantic Swatting Against Critics Thrown 'Into the Mix'
"If your Windows PC's Secure Boot certificates are out of date, your system is vulnerable to malware like rootkits."
Gemini Links 21/10/2026: A Walk Through Amsterdam and Pythagorean Theorem
Links for the day
More Mass Layoffs at Microsoft Weeks From Now, Then Again Months From Now
Microsoft's crisis is not limited to XBox
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, October 20, 2026
IRC logs for Tuesday, October 20, 2026