Bonum Certa Men Certa

Understanding Thierry Breton: Moral Responsibility for “a Capitalism That Kills”?

Overview





Understanding Thierry Breton



Further parts pending review and research




Breton at France Télécom
Moral responsibility for “a capitalism that kills”?



Summary: "...France Télécom which had previously been defined by an ethos of public service, by egalitarian working conditions and by a sense of universal mission, had now been transformed into a "cash machine” whose sole purpose was to generate shareholder value on international financial markets."

French telecommunications had a long and illustrious history as a state enterprise. Since 1889 the state telecommunications company was administered directly by a government ministry in Paris which had its budget fixed by the French National Assembly.



Employees of France Télécom enjoyed job security and guaranteed income as state employees, or “fonctionnaires”, but were part of a hierarchical, paternalistic, and tightly regulated structure that offered restricted opportunities for career advancement.

At first, the privatisation of France Télécom was hailed by free market enthusiasts as a showpiece of economic liberalization which had surpassed all other French companies in the scale and speed of its transformation from a state-owned enterprise to a global economic player.

French politicians like to cite France Télécom as a flagship for privatization which demonstrated the methods that could be used to privatize other companies stifled by the yoke of state ownership.

"...France Télécom which had previously been defined by an ethos of public service, by egalitarian working conditions and by a sense of universal mission, had now been transformed into a "cash machine” whose sole purpose was to generate shareholder value on international financial markets."However, in the eyes of some critics, France Télécom which had previously been defined by an ethos of public service, by egalitarian working conditions and by a sense of universal mission, had now been transformed into a "cash machine” whose sole purpose was to generate shareholder value on international financial markets.

In her article entitled "A Capitalism That Kills: Workplace Suicides at France Télécom" (2014), Sarah Waters, Professor of French Studies at the University of Leeds, takes the view that France Télécom's situation represents a microcosm of the broad economic changes that transformed the French economy since the early 1980s.

These economic transformations which involved processes of privatization, economic liberalization, and deregulation were characterised by a shift from an economic model rooted in industrial production to a model of finance capitalism driven by exogenous financial indicators.

This is a new economic "paradigm" in which profits are derived from financial exchanges rather than material production. The worker is no longer an essential factor of production but is reduced to a mere “cost factor” and thus becomes an impediment to profitability.

"This is a new economic "paradigm" in which profits are derived from financial exchanges rather than material production."Under this model France Télécom was increasingly driven by financial imperatives that determined how the company was to be run at every level, from the shop floor to senior management.

With the increased privatisation of its shares, the company was obliged to comply with performance indicators put in place by financial analysts in order to measure the company's share price on international markets.

France Télécom managers increasingly substituted a coherent internally-defined economic and technological strategy with short-term financial indicators to measure workplace performance.

At the same time, France Télécom's increasing indebtedness as a result of its vast acquisitions meant that making short-term financial returns became the single and all-pervasive goal of management, to the detriment of every other human consideration.

Didier Lombard cartoon
Didier Lombard protests at the injustice of being branded "the CEO with 60 suicides over 3 years" which overlooks his achievements as "the CEO of the 4 billion annual dividend!"



The new course was set by the ruthless “cost-killer” Thierry Breton when he became CEO in 2002. He defined his primary task as the restoration of the company's financial health ("santé financière") through the reimbursement of € 15 billion euros in 2003 and renegotiation of company debt to 50 billion euro over three years.

"France Télécom managers increasingly substituted a coherent internally-defined economic and technological strategy with short-term financial indicators to measure workplace performance."A company once governed by a vision of the "common good" became increasingly subjugated to a single overarching goal: "la finance".

The "suicide wave" which occurred under the stewardship of his successor, Didier Lombard, took place after Breton had departed to take up his new position as Minister for the Economy in 2005.

However, some commentators take the view that by laying the foundations for the toxic management culture which ran riot under Lombard and by acting as one of the main cheerleaders for the new economic paradigm, the swashbuckling “ultra-liberal musketeer” Breton shares a moral culpability for the tragedy known as "l'affaire France Télécom ".

Yannick Jadot
According to French MEP Yannick Jadot, cost-killer Thierry Breton bears "moral responsibility" for the France Télécom "suicide disaster".



This view was recently expressed by the French MEP Yannick Jadot who commented on Breton's nomination as the French candidate for EU Commissioner in the following terms:

"The "suicide wave" which occurred under the stewardship of his successor, Didier Lombard, took place after Breton had departed to take up his new position as Minister for the Economy in 2005.""The questions raised by Mr Breton’s career are indeed numerous. He also has a moral responsibility regarding the ‘suicide disaster’, which affected employees at France Télécom.”

In the next part we will look at the events which led to Breton entering the world of politics as Minister for the Economy under President Jacques Chirac in February 2005.

Recent Techrights' Posts

Incompetent Patent Office (EPO) Trying to Blame Examiners (Whom It Orders to Illegally Grant European Patents)
full communication, accompanied by flowcharts
Microsoft: Break Competition Laws (Endless Antitrust Violations), Lie to Regulators, Then Send Secret Bribes
who's gonna hold them accountable for the lying?
Links 14/10/2024: One Year Since Activision Blizzard Demolition 'Officially' Began and Amazon Corporate Layoffs Accelerate
Links for the day
[Meme] No Choice, No Reuse, No Effect
Let people throw away tens of billions of batteries each year and charge them too much for this 'convenience'?
 
The Free Software Foundation Asks Nathaniel Cohen to Make Music for It using Free Software (SuperCollider)
uploaded a week ago by the Free Software Foundation
Wishing Well to LibrePlanet, Including Its Volunteers
Framatube hosts the LibrePlanet videos using PeerTube
4 Years Since We Started a Plain Text Edition of Techrights (Then Adopted IPFS and Gemini Protocol)
The earliest text editions of this site are dated late October 2020
Even in Richer Countries, Where Many People Can Afford Laptops, Windows Has Become Second to Android
Android has long been bigger than Windows in poor countries were fewer people have a "desktop" (or laptop)
On IBM Layoffs at North Carolina Where Red Hat is Headquartered
Layoffs at "IBM fall through the disclosure cracks"
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, October 15, 2024
IRC logs for Tuesday, October 15, 2024
Perfectl is Not New, It's Not News About Linux, Outdated Apache RocketMQ is Not Linux, and the Real News Should be Back Doors Like Windows and CALEA Blunder
Another theme to be debunked
[Meme] Dr. Richard M. Stallman (RMS) Not Cancelled, But They Keep Trying...
The Microsofters are evidently still angry that he gives public talks around the world
"IBM Has Trimmed Its Workforce by 8,000 People"
How can a company legally lay off 8,000 people without saying anything?
Links 16/10/2024: OpenBSD 7.6 on the StarFive VisionFive2, Netnews Specs
Links for the day
IBM Driving Workers Crazy (Maybe It Wants Them to Just Resign, No Severance)
"This whole concept of silent layoffs that are expected to last through the end of November is driving me crazy."
Links 15/10/2024: GAFAM Returning the Menace of Nuclear Reactors, More Press Crises Reports
Links for the day
linuxbsdos.com (Linux BSD OS) Has Gone Astray, It's All About Windows, Not GNU/Linux or BSD OS
The transition could be seen a week or two ago. It gets worse every day.
[Meme] Nepotism Breeds Incompetence
When a corrupt cabal takes over what was supposed to be an institution concerned with science
Links 15/10/2024: Fentanylware (TikTok) Under Fire, Espionage Wars Reported
Links for the day
Gemini Links 15/10/2024: Magic of Radio and Misfin-Server 0.5.9
Links for the day
Markets Without Fair Competition and Effective Regulation
There are many examples where a lack of true choice encourages cartels
IBM Bribery Scandal in China
IBM has a long history of bribery and other crimes
XBox Turmoil Continues, Head of XBox Game Studios Resigns After Less Than One Year
There are many signs that XBox is dying - something that many sites have predicted for a while
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Monday, October 14, 2024
IRC logs for Monday, October 14, 2024
Disputing the Achievements of IBM's CEO, Who Already Terminated Many Jobs at Red Hat (Which He Had Allegedly Suggested Buying)
Buying a company to gut it within about a year?
Gemini Links 14/10/2024: Dabbling in GemText, Unit Testing
Links for the day
Links 14/10/2024: Keeping Multiple Blogs, Wrestling With Misinformation
Links for the day
[Meme] Class of Microsoft
"Everything started with Microsoft DOS!"
History Education and Rejecting Creation Myths
The creator of Linux isn't the creator of GNU/Linux
Microsoft's GitHub is Losing Traffic, Based on an Extensive Web Survey, and Its Future is Uncertain
Remember that Microsoft keeps close to its chest the operations and finances of GitHub (because it's embarrassing!)
How to Follow Our Updates About EPO (or Everything Else for That Matter)
follow us via RSS feeds
EPO Administration: Wait Several Months or Until Next Year for Clarifications
"After the intranet announcements of 18 September and 27 September and recent emails from CIGNA concerning opting into the VECOZO network, colleagues have been contacting us with queries and requests for guidance."
[Meme] Shoestring Budget With Record Profits (Because Hundreds of Thousands of Fake European Patents Get Granted)
Record profits? EPO staff does not benefit!
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, October 13, 2024
IRC logs for Sunday, October 13, 2024
Unrest at the European Patent Office as School Costs Eat Away the Income
"Letter to the administration on the Education Allowance - DISDH - German School"
Gemini Links 13/10/2024: ArcMenu, Emacs decide-mode, Midnight Pub Mass-Deletion Option
Links for the day