09.10.07

^{Gemini version available ♊︎}

Novell Attempts to Defend Moonlight, But Sinks Deeper in the Mud

Posted in GNU/Linux, Marketing, Microsoft, Mono, Novell, Patents at 10:12 pm by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

Man strikes back, hits own foot

Novell was not pleased with our understanding of Moonlight, but its rebuttal failed to impress. Worse — it only confirmed and reaffirmed most of our suspicions. It even introduced new serious issues. Here it is:

Bruce Lowry of Novell’s PR team here. You state in this piece that the only Linux Silverlight will run on is SUSE Linux Enterprise (citing, incidentally, a site called Boycott Novell, which one can surmise from its name is not objective). This isn’t correct. Using Moonlight, Silverlight will run on any Linux distro supported by Mono, which is most of the major distros. It’s true that, under the terms of our agreements with Microsoft, only SUSE Linux Enterprise will be able to bundle Moonlight into the distribution. However, users of other distributions will be able to run Silverlight on those distributions, if they so desire.

Actually, Bruce, I believe Matt was correct. Neither was he suggesting that “Linux Silverlight” would only run in SUSE Linux Enterprise, nor did we. Your assessment here only defends — rather than contradicts — what we said in the previous post on this huge problem.

Ignoring the pseudo-ad hominem attack their on our credibility (based on impulsive choice of a domain name), let’s examine your points in turn:

“Using Moonlight, Silverlight will run on any Linux distro supported by Mono”

Of course it will. It will run. It will even fly. Where does it leave patent ‘protection’, which was introduced as a requirement when the deal was signed in November 2006? Users will be able to use Mono just as a Linux users in the United States are able to play their DVDs (hint: against the law). Will they have “balance-sheet liability” that needs paying in order to access Web sites which embraced XAML?

“It’s true that, under the terms of our agreements with Microsoft, only SUSE Linux Enterprise will be able to bundle Moonlight into the distribution”

“Let the users break the law themselves,” so to speak.So now we know that Novell gets ‘special treatment’ and that Microsoft has its reasons to keep Moonlight away (matters of convenience) from ‘non-taxable’ GNU/Linux distributions. How would Novell feel if Red Hat decided that its improvements to GNOME cannot be incorporated into a packaged SUSE (SLED/S)? The whole issue of prebundling being disapproved is akin to distributions which do not contain DVD playback capabilities ‘out of the box’. Why? Legal reasons. “Let the users break the law themselves,” so to speak.

Is this patent game the type of ‘competitive advantage’ Masie (of Novell) was talking about?

Share in other sites/networks: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.

Permalink Mail Send this to a friend

ᶃ Gemini Space

Below is a Web proxy. We recommend getting a Gemini client/browser.

Black/white/grey bullet button This post is also available in Gemini over at this address (requires a Gemini client/browser to open).

✐ Cross-references

Black/white/grey bullet button Pages that cross-reference this one, if any exist, are listed below or will be listed below over time.

▢ Respond and Discuss

Black/white/grey bullet button If you liked this post, consider subscribing to the RSS feed or join us now at the IRC channels.

A Single Comment

werner said,

September 11, 2007 at 3:48 pm

According to the GPL, whom connect software with open software, makes it open, as a concludent behaviour. Independently of this, accoding to the most legislatures, who connect any good with public domain, incorporate it with this too. Thus, anybody may treat/use these programs as open and free — let process the oponents when they want.

What Else is New

CONFIRMED: Microsoft Mass Layoffs Starting Today (July 2023 Layoffs Confirmed by the Company) (Updatedx3)

We’ve been saying for a long time today is the day; we got it right and it’s “impacting an as-yet-unknown number of employees in customer service, support, and sales.” (Just like the rumours said)
Links 10/07/2023: Wayland on OpenBSD and Slackware 15 as Daily Driver

Links for the day
'Hacker' 'News': You're 'Flagged'... for Insulting Canonical and IBM With Inconvenient Facts

'Hacker' 'News' in 2023 is still operated by corporate 'bury brigades'; facts are "hurtful", so accurate stories get removed from sight, usually within an hour or less irrespective of score/popularity/precision (it's always like this; far from the first time, no explanation provided)
According to the Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification (WARN) Web Site of Washington State, in January 2023 Only 878 Workers Were Declared Redundant, Now It's About 3,000 Already (in This One State Alone)

Based on the Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification (WARN) site of Washington, it seems very unrealistic that Microsoft fired just 10,000 staff worldwide; in one state in the United States alone the number is about 3,000 already, not even counting temps and contractors or subsidiaries such as Nuance Communications
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, July 09, 2023

IRC logs for Sunday, July 09, 2023
Graph of IBM's Debt Helps Shed Light on the Red Hat Squeeze

The media does not often talk about the debt of the dying giant. IBM’s total liabilities for the quarter ending March 31, 2023 were $111.964 billion and long term debt for the same quarter was $53.826 billion. Like many other companies, IBM is buying back its own shares, faking stability and “growth”. IBM has not been a ‘household name” or even prominent in business for nearly two decades already, so its contemporary existence is largely speculative and the company still makes a lot of its revenue by (software) patent blackmail, using patents that last 20 years.
YouTube is Becoming Television (With DRM) and Creators Just 'Get in the Way'

The Google Gulag does not pursue anything but money, which it increasingly wants to aggressively (e.g. by blackmail) pursue by grabbing control over people’s PCs (in GNU/Linux, YouTube already latches onto desktop components, maybe a one step away from “protected content” through Widevine DRM), so creators who do all the hard work are demoted and their audiences mistreated; waste no time and get away from YouTube as soon as possible
Gemini Links 10/07/2023: More on Old Computer Challenge

Links for the day
New Report: Many Microsoft Employees Are Nowadays Fake Workers, Contractors Instead of Real Staff (Not Even Counted as Layoffs After Their Disposal)

We’ve long said that the real number of Microsoft layoffs is far higher than what Microsoft and the media (parroting Microsoft’s lies) say and on top of that they don’t even count the temps (temporary workers) and the contractors (what the above articles calls “fake work“); Microsoft suffers a serious crisis which dismantles entire teams and products/disservices (GitHub had at least two waves of layoffs this year, to give one example)
[Meme] Equality at Sirius Open Source

To the credit of Sirius ‘Open Source’, both men and women in the company were defrauded for years and formal, certified payslips were lies; it might be very hard to recover the stolen money, but the perpetrators of the crime need to be arrested (the government and the police cover up for them because some people are implicated contractually)
Boycott TikTok

Bytedance’s TikTok (some spell it ByteDance) comes in two “flavours”, which are known as spinach and opium. The former is for the local (Chinese) market and makes people obedient, whereas the latter makes people destructive (to themselves and to others) overseas; why can’t the mainstream media properly convey such a simple message?
Staying Productive in the Face of Corporate or Military-Grade Trolling (Maybe Even Doxing)

The publication pace at Techrights has gone up by a lot; we're nearly reaching the record levels of 2010
The Corporate ‘Cancel Culture’ Industry — Part VIII: In Conclusion

After 2 introductory parts and 7 core parts we're finally concluding the series with a handful of points
[Meme] EPO Manager's War Against the Law

This nonsensical video means that the EPO’s corrupt administrators have lost the argument and are now stacking up straw men, demonising the people whose job is to decide who receives a patent monopoly and who does not (based on scientific merit and the European Patent Convention). It’ll be interesting to see what Staff Representatives make of the decision from ILOAT regarding the NO-Career System.
The European Patent Office's War of Disinformation Against Patent Examiners (and Mindless Promotion of Microsoft Vapourware)

Under the title “Examiner’s Wars” the EPO now insults its own productive workers, looking to harm their image and their reputation instead of actually fixing the EPO crisis, including all the corruption at the top
Links 09/07/2023: GNU/Linux Client Side Usage Growing, Linux 6.5 Release Candidate Out

Links for the day
Gemini Links 09/07/2023: Mutt and Updated Thoughts on Gemini

Links for the day
Surge in Microsoft Traffic Suggests There's Hearsay -- Maybe Panic -- About the July 2023 Layoffs

There’s Microsoft gossip or rumours regarding an impending big wave of layoffs; the source of these rumours is 100% external to us (independent) and pro-Microsoft media chaff seems to be proactive 'damage control'
Microsoft 'Research' (PR and Marketing) Already Preparing Us for Layoffs Excuse?

Yesterday we gave several examples of new Microsoft chaff in the media, insinuating that Microsoft was in fact hiring and that "Hey Hi" (AI) is replacing workers and we really ought to celebrate this; the examples above are just hours old (and it’s Sunday!)
[Meme] Warming Up With Excuses for Mass Layoffs at Microsoft?

They already warm up with the excuses, or so it might seem ("it's NOT layoffs, it's HEY HI!"). Preparatory PR? “In January,” it says, “just days after Microsoft announced plans to lay off 10,000 employees as part of broader cost-cutting measures, the company also confirmed it was making a “multibillion dollar” investment into OpenAI, the company behind ChatGPT.” Yes, this decoy and misdirection went nowhere (they lost inertia, lost market share, and lost lots of money on it as well, deepening the already-massive debt)
[Meme] IBM and Canonical Respecting Your Freedom

When GNU/Linux vendors misunderstand consent and disrespect the community (volunteers) it's probably time to jog on
Linux Mint Was Right About Snaps and It Should Make LMDE the Default (Better Yet, Base It on Devuan)

The direction taken by Canonical in recent months has upset a lot of people, and rightly so; we kindly remind people that alternatives exist and Linux Mint already explores some of them
Techrights Was Right About Microsoft's Chatbots Hype

There are now many press articles mentioning the rapid demise of chatbots (by usage) but almost nobody mentions the many layoffs in Bing (lots this year) and erosion of excitement, along with market share
Links 09/07/2023: GNOME Web Canary is Back

Links for the day
Gemini Links 09/07/2023: Hard to Trust Red Hat Now

Links for the day
Microsoft Panic as GNU/Linux Market Share in the United States is Rising Well Above 3% (or 7% If One Counts ChromeOS)

This month’s data from statCounter (OpenDocument version with chart) gives reasons for optimism; based on what we’re seeing this weekend, there are consequences for GNU/Linux usage surging in the world's most populous nations and Microsoft is panicking
Canonical and IBM Are Turning Ubuntu and Fedora Into Microsoft Windows, Time to Adopt Real Community Distros

IBM, with its notorious army of aggressive lawyers and mountains of software patents, is trying to make RHEL proprietary and render Fedora ‘spyware’ (they know it’ll put off existing and potential users; later they can claim “reduced demand” for it and mothball the whole thing, rebranding it as “CentOS” after they had already fired Fedora management and then abandoned OpenSource.com and OpenOffice.org/LibreOffice); Canonical keeps up with evil by doing some of its own and they don't compete with Microsoft, so we can trust neither of them
37,000 Blog Posts, IRC Treat, and Positive Reader Feedback

After nearly 17 years we’ve crossed the 37,000 blog posts milestone; we can probably hit 40,000 within a year or less and today we’ve replaced the IRC widget (it hasn’t worked for anyone since December; there’s no plan to fix it)
IRC Proceedings: Saturday, July 08, 2023

IRC logs for Saturday, July 08, 2023
China is Moving Away From Microsoft Windows (as Promised Years Ago)

Microsoft propagandists have long attempted to curb China's move to GNU/Linux. Those propagandists are nowhere to be seen anymore (gone inactive).