01.20.21

Suppressed Facts of the Free Software Movement and Its Community of Volunteers – Part V: How FSF Secrecy Ended Up Insulting People, Alienating Trans Developers

Posted in Free/Libre Software, FSF at 10:09 am by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

This wouldn’t have happened if no secrecy was entertained as an option

Summary: Having just uploaded this introductory video, we delve into the backstory or the real reason the FSF sank into somewhat of a crisis with the trans community almost half a decade ago

THIS post will hopefully not be misunderstood. It is by no means a criticism of individuals; it’s a bunch of constructive suggestions and some observations about what really happened several years ago at the FSF.

The FSF is the primary proponent of Free software; it is also the oldest (turning 36 years old later this year). The FSF supports the GNU Project and provides a supportive framework for it. GNU, in turn, facilitates many volunteers and developers who contribute to the cause of software freedom. Some of these developers are purely volunteers, whereas others are salaried by companies such as Red Hat (IBM).

“The FSF is the primary proponent of Free software; it is also the oldest (turning 36 years old later this year).”I myself am a proponent of the FSF and quite a few of us at Techrights (e.g. IRC) are FSF members. Some of us are trans. That’s not really the subject of debate here; instead, we deal with how secrecy can beget offence/insults.

In Historic First, Biden Picks Trans Woman, Dr. Rachel Levine, to Help Lead HHSOur general view is, technology and merits of programmers should be looked at irrespective of gender. We already see evidence of the president inaugurated today having the courage to act accordingly (article from yesterday shown to the right).

In Part I, Part II, Part III and Part IV we talked about elements of secrecy being a peril; they breed suspicion and mistrust. We generally think that secrecy is a lot more risky than beneficial. It has the potential to cause embarrassment. With transparency, for example, the tone of conversations would simply not be the same (a higher level of restraint and ‘professionalism’).

Just to be clear, we don’t advocate leaking FSF ‘secrets’. We just want to better understand past events.

As somebody recently told us, “do you know GNU removed many voices that were against RMS?” (Richard Stallman)

“…do you know GNU removed many voices that were against RMS?”
      –Anonymous
“For example,” we’ve learned, “you can probably find that Matt Lee was silently wiped from the list of GNU speakers if you look at web.archive.org or something…”

Matt Lee blocked me in Twitter after I had politely responded to an RMS-hostile tweet of his. “Matt Lee was a sysadmin and he was calling on RMS to quit the FSF on Twitter,” we’ve been told, “after he quit MIT…”

SANDERS WARREN BIDEN: Tech Before GenderLee made no ambiguities/secrets about that. I met Lee in person a very long time ago (amicable meeting), so seeing his flippant reaction (blocking me in Twitter for a polite tweet) was a little surprising. And “also,” we’ve been told, “RMS is truly out of MIT, that was a final decision, but it’s not the first time he left them…”

And “still,” we’ve been told, “whenever RMS defended [himself] from this crowd, he did so silently…”

So there was more going on behind the scenes — something many weren’t privy to or aware of.

“RMS is truly out of MIT, that was a final decision, but it’s not the first time he left them…”
      –Anonymous
The case of point, which the video alludes to, is the Rowe incident. It apparently started after
Lisa Maginnis had leaked information about inside affairs at the FSF. “Lisa Maginnis was fired [sic] over this [as] she leaked something…” (according to our source)

If secrecy is an issue, then the organisation can become more vulnerable. We saw some FSF insiders (and maybe Alex Oliva also) trying to enhance transparency, but so far we see evidence of mostly backlash against those attempting to push in that direction (increasing visibility). I mean, what good is leaking of information that only few can see? As it turns out, Maginnis didn’t just leak it for everyone to see. The intent wasn’t to damage the FSF. The nature or purpose of the leak was to highlight a concern; We were told “she leaked that the FSF, in the 2000s, rejected a transgender woman from getting a job there on the grounds that she is “ugly, and would upset the rest of the employees”” (paraphrased).

Our source said that “this was only leaked to Leah Rowe [...] and Leah Rowe went everywhere asking for John Sullivan to be banned [...] err, not banned, I mean removed” (same effect).

But “this got Lisa fired,” [sic] whereas John Sullivan is still in the FSF. “Fired” is possibly not the correct term here, but either way, the person punished probably did not deserve this. Our source inquired, “do you remember when libreboot left GNU?”

“…she leaked that the FSF, in the 2000s, rejected a transgender woman from getting a job there on the grounds that she is “ugly, and would upset the rest of the employees” (paraphrased).”
      –Anonymous
Well, it came back. But much damage had been done prior to that. Our source noted that “the transgender woman that was rejected in the 2000s was Julia Longtin [...] a great mistake on the part of the FSF [sic] she would have done a great job…”

Some pages in the FSF’s directory list Julia Longtin as “Maintainer.”

Maginnis is no longer in the FSF, so we can say out loud (publicly) what we know (subjected to creative obfuscation that hides the sources).

And just to “clarify,” as the source told us, “Leah Rowe asked for John Sullivan to be removed, but I have found no evidence he was involved in the rejection of Julia Longtin [...] in fact, it seems to have been someone else, who has since left the FSF more than a decade ago…”

There’s reason to believe that it’s no longer an issue because, according to our source, Rowe is still involved, unlike those whom she accused; “she also accused two people of transphobia,” we were told, “who have also since left the FSF (both staffers)…”

“…she also accused two people of transphobia, who have also since left the FSF (both staffers)…”
      –Anonymous
“Lisa Maginnis was fired [sic] in 2016-ish or 2017″ and her blog posts for the FSF stopped at around that time. Maybe a monumental loss. Maybe transparency would averted that loss.

We’ve asked around about Maginnis and about the Julia Longtin incident. Some of that is rather old news and suppressed news.

“I do not have any insider information about that incident,” one person told us. “I tried to talk to Lisa after the incident, but couldn’t ever reach her again. The only contacts I had for her were the FSF email address, that no longer worked, and her IRC nick, that seems to have gone unused from then on. We’d had good rapport during LibrePlanet before that, and I was disappointed I couldn’t offer her any support at that time.”

That’s quite outdated. “I tried to talk to Leah Rowe about it back then,” this person recalled, “but she didn’t seem to be very happy that I was “investigating” the matter.”

In a sense, in order to better understand Rowe’s grievances it helps to know what actually happened. Nobody will be punished for merely talking.

“I tried to talk to Lisa after the incident, but couldn’t ever reach her again.”
      –Anonymous
“I talked to Richard Stallman,” one person told us, “and he told me something to the effect that he trusted Lisa hadn’t been wronged by FSF management. Nothing much different from his public statements on the matter at the time. So I don’t really know anything about what happened, other than what transpired to the public at large back then.”

We think that the key point is, someone said something rather offensive internally. This would be a lot less likely had there been more transparency and much of that old crisis would have been avoided.

Share in other sites/networks: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Reddit
  • email

This post is also available in Gemini over at:

gemini://gemini.techrights.org/2021/01/20/fsf-secrecy/

If you liked this post, consider subscribing to the RSS feed or join us now at the IRC channels.

Pages that cross-reference this one

What Else is New


  1. Links 6/3/2021: Linux 5.12 RC2 and OpenSUSE Tumbleweed Woes

    Links for the day



  2. IRC Proceedings: Friday, March 05, 2021

    IRC logs for Friday, March 05, 2021



  3. Links 5/3/2021: Qubes OS 4.0.4 Release and Wine's Project Leader is Open to Wayland

    Links for the day



  4. How To Deal With Your Raspberry Spy -- Part II: Introduction

    Following Part I, published a few hours ago, let's examine what happened from a technical perspective and what can be done about it technically



  5. How To Deal With Your Raspberry Spy -- Part I: Acknowledgements

    March 2, 2021 blog post series from a guest author; for some background, see blog posts from Microsoft in the official blog of Raspberry Pi and our response to these



  6. German Decision on Unitary Patent/UPC Will Take Years (and It Doesn't Matter Because the Whole Thing is Dead Already)

    Kluwer Patent Blog's Dr. Bausch explains why the UPC is pretty much doomed, as it cannot be ratified any time soon and probably will never be ratified either (for a multitude of reasons, including Brexit)



  7. Techrights in Australia (IPFS and Gemini)

    Allies in Australia will help Techrights serve material from another server; we're still bettering ourselves for an era of oppressive World Wide Web



  8. Professional Troll Matthew Garrett Spreads Libel, Defamation and Slander About the Free Software Community to Entertain Microsoft and Friends

    After months of parking in our IRC channels to provoke and troll people (and try to collect 'dirt' from responses) the professional troll Matthew Garrett has been for many years shows his true colours again



  9. Links 5/3/2021: Linux 5.12-rc2 Imminent, Linux Lite 5.4 RC1 in Review

    Links for the day



  10. IRC Proceedings: Thursday, March 04, 2021

    IRC logs for Thursday, March 04, 2021



  11. Links 4/3/2021: LibreOffice 7.1.1, Cockpit 239, Many Stable Kernel Releases

    Links for the day



  12. Links 4/3/2021: Pardus 19.5 is Out and Free Software Foundation Gets Consulting Grant

    Links for the day



  13. IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, March 03, 2021

    IRC logs for Wednesday, March 03, 2021



  14. The Free Software Foundation Should Re-add Richard Stallman to the Board

    Dr. Richard Stallman is missed by many who perceive him to have been wrongly treated; putting Stallman back in the Board (at the very least) would help the image of the Free Software Foundation more than the newly-announced work with Community Consulting Teams of Boston



  15. Free Software Calling

    Fewer people are willing to "put up with the shit" given by so-called 'Big Tech', seeing that it's mostly about social control rather than enablement or emancipation



  16. Meme: EPO Management Totally Gets 'Tehc'

    The bestest patent office in the whole wide world is besting the “hey hi” (AI) cutting edge; don't worry about exam and certification integrity



  17. The EPO's Software Blunders Are Inevitable Outcome of Technically Clueless Management Which Grants Illegal Patents on Software

    The "clusterfuck" which the EPO has become is negatively affecting not only EPO staff but also stakeholders, who sink into depression and sometimes anger, even fury, at great expense to their health; this is how institutions die (for a quick but short money grab, a culmination of corruption which piggybacks half a century of goodwill gestures)



  18. Links 3/3/2021: OpenSUSE Leap 15.3 Beta, GNU Denemo 2.5, and NomadBSD 1.4

    Links for the day



  19. What Free Software Organisations Can Learn From Australia's Rape Crisis

    Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock



  20. Microsoft Weaponises (and Further Spreads) Racism to Distract From Its Own Incompetence (and 'Five Eyes' Collusion for Back Door Access)

    Racist Microsoft is at it again; we're meant to think that China is evil for doing exactly what the United States has been doing but more importantly we're told not to blame Microsoft for shoddy code and back doors (classic blame-shifting tactics and overt distortion of facts, as we saw in the wake of SolarWinds backdoors)



  21. GNU/Linux News Sites Need to Promote Software Freedom, Not Binary and Proprietary Blobs Merely Compiled for GNU/Linux

    There has been lots of proprietary fluff in GNU/Linux 'news' sites so far this week; it merits an explanation or clarification, e.g. why we should generally reject proprietary stuff and instead promote Free/libre alternatives



  22. Links 3/3/2021: OpenSSH 8.5 and Absolute64 20210302 Released

    Links for the day



  23. IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, March 02, 2021

    IRC logs for Tuesday, March 02, 2021



  24. Links 3/3/2021: IPFire 2.25 Core Update 154, Red Hat Satellite 6.8.4, Kiwi TCMS 10.0

    Links for the day



  25. Links 2/3/2021: KDE Plasma 5.21.2, Qt 6.1 Beta, Refund of Pre-installed Windows

    Links for the day



  26. 'GatoKeeper'/IP Kat (AstraZeneca) Still Suppressing and Censoring the Public Views or Internal EPO Talks About EPO Corruption

    The suppression of comments critical of the EPO‘s administration (especially corruption scandals surrounding António Campinos and Benoît Battistelli) is a real problem; those ought not be a taboo subject in comments (where bloggers used to speak about those issues openly and regularly)



  27. Pocock on Removing Cognitive Bias Around Consent

    Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock



  28. IRC Proceedings: Monday, March 01, 2021

    IRC logs for Monday, March 01, 2021



  29. Links 2/3/2021: Maui 1.2.1, RSS Guard 3.9.0

    Links for the day



  30. ZDNet Really Hates Golang (Maybe Because Microsoft Does)

    The Golang programming language seems to be the target of intense FUD campaigns from sites connected to Microsoft, so it’s likely a bit of a Nemesis/endgame to Microsoft monoculture (unlike Rust, which Microsoft has already pocketed and is actively besieging to promote Microsoft monopoly and hardware monoculture)


RSS 64x64RSS Feed: subscribe to the RSS feed for regular updates

Home iconSite Wiki: You can improve this site by helping the extension of the site's content

Home iconSite Home: Background about the site and some key features in the front page

Chat iconIRC Channel: Come and chat with us in real time

Recent Posts