Bonum Certa Men Certa

Patent Trolls Update: IPVALUE, Cypress, OIN, Open Patents, Blackbird, CATO and So-called 'Efficient Infringement'

Worm-like parasites and what is being proposed for battling them

Subway platform



Summary: A roundup of recent news about patent trolls and suggestions that have been put forth for cutting off their air supply

AS our previous post explained, hardware giants are using patents in anticompetitive ways and regulatory agencies have begun paying attention. As it turns out, based on yesterday's blog post from IAM, patent trolls are ganging up against the hardware industry too. It's noteworthy because typically -- or at least traditionally -- trolls relied a great deal on software patents -- like those that even the EPO covertly granted.



"In 1 week," wrote this person the other day, "patent trolls drain $1.5B from the US economy. Tell Congress to move on patent reform..."

This figure is somewhat controversial, but without a doubt patent trolls are a burden on society and on the industry (meaning money-making corporations, which themselves can sometimes be a burden on society). Yesterday we wrote about IBM's latest ugly lobbying effort for software patents -- an effort which coincides with IBM's attacks on smaller businesses. We kindly remind readers that it was IBM that brought power or gave rise to OIN, which was initially led by a person from IBM (Rosenthal). OIN is the IBM-led 'solution’ to a lot of the problems as envisioned by IBM, I told Benjamin Henrion yesterday, after he wrote that "OIN CEO Keith Bergelt said OIN is useless against patent trolls" (mentioned in relation to FOSDEM last weekend). "They [IBM] get to continue to sue us and pretend software patents are awesome," I told Henrion. André Rebentisch (FFII) asked Henrion: "What to make out of this?"

Henrion replied by saying "it is an old quote from ssp website [the Stop Software Patents Web site]. Dr. Stefane Fermigier added: "Rightfully so. This is asymmetric warfare."

Remember that patent trolls cannot be sued. There is nothing to sue them over and large corporations now use trolls as a sort of loophole by which to harass their competitors. It further complicates the situation and serves to show just how evil the scourge of trolls has become.

The reason much of this was brought up is this FOSDEM talk, which we mentioned a few days ago. "Slides and video of our #Open #Patents talk at #FOSDEM are now available at https://fosdem.org/2017/schedule/event/open_patents/," their official account said after the talk and the event had ended.

Henrion said he was "Watching Open Patent Office talk at Fosdem, defensive publication is useless and yet another waste of energy and time..."

"Peer-To-Patent (or Peer2Patent) failed miserably," I told Henrion, "just like OIN's equivalent effort" (which didn't even last long). We never supported the method of defensive publication, which passes a lot of the burden to the victims rather than the source of abuse.

In other news, the other day Condé Nast published this article about a new and high-profile troll case. Their trolls expert wrote:

It's been barely two months since Netflix added its long-awaited download feature, and the online streaming company has already been sued over it. The plaintiff is a company few have heard of: Blackbird Technologies, a company with no products or assets other than patents. Blackbird's business is to buy up patent rights and file lawsuits over them, a business known colloquially as "patent trolling."

Blackbird was founded by two former big-firm patent attorneys, Wendy Verlander and Chris Freeman. The organization owns US Patent No. 7,174,362, which it hopes will result in payouts from a internet video companies with offline-viewing features. On Wednesday, Blackbird (who tells potential clients about being "able to litigate at reduced costs and achieve results") filed lawsuits against Netflix (PDF), Soundcloud (PDF), Vimeo, Starz, Mubi, and Studio 3 Partners, which owns the Epix TV channel. All of the companies have some type of app that allows for downloading streamable content and watching it offline.


CATO, in the same week, wrote about the TC Heartland case -- a case which is likely to seriously weaken patent trolls later this year. Here is the summary of it:

Twelve years ago Congress passed the Class Action Fairness Act of 2005, much of whose point was to curb the then-rampant practice in class actions of national forum-shopping, that is, filing a lawsuit in whichever of many possible courts around the U.S. was most favorable to the plaintiff, whether or not the state or district associated with that court had a natural link to the underlying controversy (such as being the place where the alleged misconduct occurred or where its defendant had its base of operations). But forum-shopping remains rampant and damaging in some other areas of litigation, such as product liability: thus pharmaceutical cases get taken to California and asbestos cases to Illinois and New York even if plaintiffs have never set foot in those states. And in perhaps the best-known litigation bazaar of all, a large share of patent cases (44% in 2015) are filed in the Eastern District of Texas, centered on Marshall, Texas, a rural community far from most defendants and their headquarters, and known for its exceedingly plaintiff-friendly judges and juries. The result has been a series of large verdicts even on dubious claims of infringement, coupled with enormous pressure on defendants to settle cases they would have resisted with confidence if filed in a different, randomly chosen district.


This is the kind of thing which is likely to seriously impede further trolling, along with abolition of software patents (already happening in the US).

Sites that are funded by patent trolls don't wish to see that coming to fruition. Yesterday, for example, IAM used propaganda terms of the trolls right there in the headline ("efficient infringement", not even with scare quotes like they did some days ago). This was said in relation to Korea ( "Korean IP office boss vows crackdown on efficient infringement, but don't hold your breath") and it is worth reminding ourselves that in Korea they disallow software patents and authorities recently went after Microsoft, for essentially 'trolling' Korean giants. Maximalists like IAM are upset.

Recent Techrights' Posts

There's Nothing "Funny" About Attacking Free Speech and Software Freedom
persistent focus on the principal issues is very important
GNU/Linux Adoption in Africa, a Passageway Towards Freedom From Neo-Colonialism
Digi(tal)-Colonialism and/or Techolonialism are a thing. Can Africa flee the trap?
 
Links 06/12/2023: Many More December Layoffs
Links for the day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, December 05, 2023
IRC logs for Tuesday, December 05, 2023
PipeWire 1.0: Linux audio comes of age
Once upon a time, serious audio users like musicians and audio engineers had real trouble with Linux
This is How 'Linux' Foundation Presents Linux to the World
Right now it even picks Windows over Linux in some cases
Links 05/12/2023: Microsoft's Chatbot as Health Hazard
Links for the day
Professor Eben Moglen Explained How Software Patent Threats Had Changed Around 2014 (Alice Case) and What Would Happen Till 2025
clip aged reasonably well
CNN Contributes to Demolition of the Open Web
Reprinted with permission from Ryan Farmer
Eben Moglen on Encryption and Anonymity
The alternate net we need, and how we can build it ourselves
Yet More Microsofters Inside the Board of Mozilla (Which Has Just Outsourced Firefox Development to Microsoft's Proprietary Prison)
Do you want a browser controlled (and spied on) by such a company?
IRC Proceedings: Monday, December 04, 2023
IRC logs for Monday, December 04, 2023
GNU/Linux Now Exceeds 3.6% Market Share on Desktops/Laptops, According to statCounter
things have changed for Windows in China
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news
Links 05/12/2023: Debt Brake in Germany and Layoffs at Condé Nast (Reddit, Wired, Ars Technica and More)
Links for the day
[Meme] Social Control Media Giants Shaping Debates on BSDs and GNU/Linux
listening to random people in Social Control Media
Reddit (Condé Nast), Which Has Another Round of Layoffs This Month, Incited People Against GNU/Linux Users (Divide and Rule, It's 2003 All Over Again!)
Does somebody (perhaps a third party) fan the flames?
Who Will Hold the Open Source Initiative (OSI) Accountable for Taking Bribes From Microsoft and Selling Out to Enable/Endorse Massive Copyright Infringement?
it does Microsoft advocacy
Using Gemini to Moan About Linux and Spread .NET
Toxic, acidic post in Gemini
Web Monopolist, Google, 'Pulls a Microsoft' by Hijacking/Overriding the Name of Competitor and Alternative to the Web
Gulag 'hijacking' 'Gemini'
Links 04/12/2023: Mass Layoffs at Spotify (Debt, Losses, Bubble) Once Again
Links for the day
ChatGPT Hype/Vapourware (and 'Bing') Has Failed, Google Maintains Dominance in Search
a growing mountain of debt and crises
[Meme] Every Real Paralegal Knows This
how copyright law works
Forging IRC Logs and Impersonating Professors: the Lengths to Which Anti-Free Software Militants Would Go
Impersonating people in IRC, too
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, December 03, 2023
IRC logs for Sunday, December 03, 2023
GNU/Linux Popularity Surging, So Why Did MakeUseOf Quit Covering It About 10 Days Ago?
It's particularly sad because some of the best articles about GNU/Linux came from that site, both technical articles and advocacy-centric pieces
Links 04/12/2023: COVID-19 Data Misused Again, Anti-Consumerism Activism
Links for the day