Bonum Certa Men Certa

IP Kat Used to Blast the EPO for Profound Lack of Justice. Now It's Just Meowing With the EPO's Management.

From watchdog to pussycat

Curious Cat



Summary: The European Patent Convention (EPC) has been turned into a Kleenex€® tissue and all that the 'Kats' (what's left of them) have to say amounts to a puff piece with some Battistelli photo op

THE largest patent office of Europe has been ruined by Benoît Battistelli. António Campinos is 'finishing the job'...



Suffice to say, Campinos was wedged or shoehorned by Battistelli into this position. It's all 'fixed'. Nepotism and cover-up. The concept of independence or oversight exists only in theory but never in practice.

"Today's EPO offers only a pretense of justice."When I was a lot younger I used to hear about the quality of examination at the European Patent Office (EPO) and how strong a background examiners came from (professors and scholars). That was before the lobby for software patents in Europe and back in the days when professors and judges such as Alain Pompidou and Ingo Kober 'ran the show'. They weren't perfect, but at least they had respect for science and the rule of law. Right about now there's a similar problem at the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO), whose Director Andrei Iancu openly mocks the law, notably 35 U.S.C. €§ 101. In our latest daily links we've included some new articles to that effect; thankfully the trends at the Federal Circuit carry on (invalidation of abstract patents) and Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) inter partes reviews (IPRs) continue unabated.

Today's EPO offers only a pretense of justice. It puts together a panel of judges for 'trials' which have become show trials and 'legal theatre'. We wrote about it earlier this month in relation to the Haar case or the "Haar question" (our coverage of this case was based on an informed source).

About a week ago the EPO quietly published (warning: epo.org link) this page. The EPO did not say anything about it in "news" or in its Twitter account; instead it made lots of noise about "green" or "social" or "ethics" (three separate puff pieces coinciding with this case). To quote:

The Enlarged Board of Appeal today issued opinion G 1/18 on the distinction between an appeal deemed not to have been filed and an inadmissible appeal, and on the consequences of this. The opinion is in response to a referral by the President of the European Patent Office (EPO). The Enlarged Board of Appeal is the highest judicial authority under the European Patent Convention (EPC).

The point of law referred by the President of the EPO was whether an appeal is to be treated as not filed or as inadmissible in cases of a failure to observe the two‑month time limit under Article 108 EPC owing to belated payment of the appeal fee and/or belated filing of notice of appeal. The appeal fee is not reimbursed if an appeal is inadmissible (Rule 103(1) EPC).

Under Article 112(1)(b) EPC, the President of the EPO may refer a point of law to the Enlarged Board of Appeal where two boards of appeal have given different decisions on it. With respect to the point of law in issue here, some boards had held that the appeal was inadmissible and that there were therefore no grounds for reimbursing the appeal fee. However, the prevailing view in the Boards' case law was rather that the appeal was deemed not to have been filed, and that - since no appeal existed - the appeal fee had been paid without a legal basis and therefore had to be refunded. The Enlarged Board was therefore called on to clarify this point of law and its consequences for the reimbursement of the appeal fee.


This is hogwash and a stunning reminder of what a joke justice at the EPO became. Just before the weekend Rose Hughes (IP Kat) mentioned the above -- an outcome we first mentioned several days ago. No other blog appears to have mentioned it (we checked) and the EPC's demise apparently interests nobody who is in the 'trade' of litigation. The EPO's management just doubles down on its unconstitutional behaviour and gross violation of the law; it refuses to even deal with the question, just as we expected/foresaw. Here is what Hughes wrote just before the weekend:

The referral related to the question of whether, where a notice of appeal is filed after expiry of the time limit for filing an appeal (Article 108 EPC), an appeal to the Boards of Appeal a) is inadmissible or b) should be deemed not to have been filed. The question was referred by outgoing EPO President Benoît Battistelli, just before the end of his term. For a full background to the case see IPKat post here.


Of course today's 'Kats' won't bother pointing out how monumental a disaster the EPO became. "We await publication of the Enlarged Board of Appeal opinion in full," Hughes concluded. As do others, but we know who's responsible for this farce and why. It was predictable given how the panel had been constructed. Watch this comment that says: "The full decision is available here: https://www.epo.org/law-practice/case-law-appeals/eba/number.html" (warning: epo.org link)

Why did nobody among the 'Kat', who had written many articles about the exile to Haar, bother scrutinising this decision? IP Kat 'staff' (Jonathan Pratt) wrote this weekly roundup. Hughes is basically pushing Team UPC agenda like SPCs, FRAND and SEP. In Pratt's words:

Rose also commented on the question relating to SPCs for a second indication of a product that has been referred to the CJEU (C-354/19).

On the theme of SPCs, Rose further summarised the SPC manufacturing and stockpiling waiver (amending Regulation (EC) No 469/2009) that came into force on 1 July 2019. Controversially, the legislation provides a waiver not only for the manufacture of generics and biosimilars for export, but also provides a waiver for stockpiling for day-1 release following expiry of an SPC.

Finally, Rose updated us on the latest step in the FRAND/SEP saga with the UK High Court decision on the validity of Conversant's patent for 3G mobile phone technology. Mr Justice Arnold found that Conversant's patent is essential and infringed by Huawei and ZTE, but invalid for added matter: Conversant v Huawei [2019] EWHC 1687 (Pat).


The interests that nowadays drive these 'Kats' are disturbing. It used to be like a watchdog (or cat), but now it's like a litigators' lobby, very much like IAM (almost the same at times, with literal litigators as bloggers).

Hughes soon (less than two hours later) proceeded to CIPA 'ads' for "Rules of Procedure of the Board of Appeal" (which lack independence). It was entitled "Event Report: CIPA seminar on the revised Rules of Procedure of the Board of Appeal" (an 'event' mentioned here before it took place because of the sheer bias).

CIPA is a pack of patent maximalists, Battistelli allies (almost a 'collusion'), and Team UPC nuts who intentionally promote falsehoods and lie about businesses in Britain in order to extract money from these businesses (in the form of legal fees). Kluwer Patent Blog and other prominent blogs about patents have not yet said a thing about the Haar decision; why not? Are they embarrassed? Do they believe it's not worthy of a report? Why has the EPO itself kept quiet about it?

Recent Techrights' Posts

More Microsoft-Red Hat Cross-Pollination as the Company Loses a Managing Director
some people move from Microsoft to Red Hat and some do the opposite
Cloudflare Gives Us All Another Reason to Boycott Cloudflare
If Cloudflare wants to use its vast surveillance network (which is what it does as a CDN) to foist paywalls and maybe something worse (like DRM on top), then Cloudflare should be more widely rejected as a company
The Free Software Foundation (FSF) Has Un-cancelled the Best People, Just in Time for the Big 4-0
Mr. Oliva should have been there all along (since 2019)
Most "Modern" Technology Makes You Slower and Dumber
Because proprietary software makes you worse off
"What Comes After Free Software?" Wrongly Insinuates We've Reached the Goal (Prison is Not the Goal)
The oil tycoons use similar tactics against environmentalists, giving them fake "wins"
Making More Work Space
I learned the hard way that less is more in circumstances where more means distraction
MAHA is a Lie, Public Officials Never Valued Citizens' Health (They Still Value Private Businesses, Their Sponsors)
Reject demagogues
 
Science is Under Attack
Oligarchy prefers a dumbed-down population
Someone Expiring Certificates on the Day of the 9/11 Attacks is Not Someone I Would Want Controlling My PC (or Deciding What's Authorised for Booting)
"social justice warriors"
The Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) Has Reportedly Failed People With Wrong Advice
At the moment the SRA has a PR blunder
The Man Suing Brett Wilson LLP and Gervase de Wilde (5RB)
Now he's probably using the (almost) 200,000 pounds he's supposed to receive to sue Brett Wilson LLP and former colleagues/partners
Slopwatch: A World Wide Web That's Rotting for Companies That Won't Even Exist in a Few Years
some of the junk Google News is promoting
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, September 23, 2025
IRC logs for Tuesday, September 23, 2025
Links 24/09/2025: Qt Creator 18 Beta, Microsoft Cannot Bail Out "ChatGPT" Anymore, China and US Intensify Censorship
Links for the day
Gemini Links 24/09/2025: Gemlogs and Politics
Links for the day
Links 23/09/2025: Japan Limits Uses of Skinnerboxes ('Smartphones') With Toxic "Apps", Fentanylware (TikTok) Tapped by "MAGAts"
Links for the day
Brett Wilson LLP Has Just Been Sued (by Their Own Clients!)
Vladimir and Alla Yanpolsky sued Brett Wilson LLP in BL-2025-001167 at the end of last week
The Complaint About Brett Wilson LLP - Part II - UK SLAPPs for Americans, SLAPPs for Profit
Brett Wilson LLP has a track record of this kind
Mayday: Optus emergency calling crisis
Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
Links 23/09/2025: Massive Data Breach, Slop Versus Productivity, and Vista 11 Update Breaks Things Again
Links for the day
Code of Censorship
Extortion is peace
Free Software Foundation (FSF) Has a New Press Kit for the Weekend After Next Weekend (40th Anniversary)
miles better than social [sic] media [sic] quips, moderated by narcissists and oil tycoons.
Microsoft Had Two Waves of Mass Layoffs This Month (That We Know of) and It'll Get Worse for Microsoft Soon
Will the axe fall again by month's end?
Gemini Links 23/09/2025: Happy Equinox, Photronic Arts, and Perception Cognition
Links for the day
Lessons We've Learned After 17 Years of American Hosting
GAFAM is "all-in" with the "Trump agenda"
Back to Normal Now, We Plan to Do More In-Depth Series (or Multi-part Stories)
Articles (or series thereof) that contain philosophy are important to us
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Monday, September 22, 2025
IRC logs for Monday, September 22, 2025
Microsoft Media is Panicking Amid Mass Layoffs Every Month, H-1B Fees, and "Seattle’s Tech Scene in Trouble"
In "late stage Microsoft", copyleft becomes proprietary
The Next Wave of IBM/Red Hat Layoffs Being Discussed Already
Red Hat is sort of disappearing the way Tivoli did
New Techrights Turns 2
Today starts the third year of the SSG-based Techrights
What Scares Them the Most is Independent News Sites That They Cannot Control and Censor
Wikileaks was a good example of this
If You Don't Control Your Online Platform, Then Someone Else is Controlling You
be (or become) independent
Oracle Started This Year With Slop. Then It Stopped.
Passing fads are like this
Distros That Run on PCs Made 20 Years Ago and Don't Use Systemd
Betas for now
The Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) Has a Policy on Racism and Sexism
In then future we'll show the misogyny and racial slurs
The Complaint About Brett Wilson LLP - Part I - Abusing British Women on Behalf of American Men Who Abuse American Women
Transparency is important to us, so we've decided to make this series
Slopwatch: Google News and the Evident Slopfarm Infestation
This is what people get about Linux when they query Google for Linux
Links 22/09/2025: Murdochs Might Join Fentanylware (TikTok) 'Investors' (Masters), United Kingdom Recognises Palestinian Statehood
Links for the day
Gemini Links 22/09/2025: Esperanto Music History and Apps For Android
Links for the day
Links 22/09/2025: More American 'Censorship' (Retaliation for Journalism), Cheeto "Might Be Losing His Race Against Time"
Links for the day
The Blob Slop
Give me more words, give me some text
The 50-Pound Note Experiment and the "War on Cash"
Britain is actually seeing a rebound in cash payments, and it's not a temporary phenomenon
Slopwatch: Blaming the Victims for Microsoft's Failures and Plagiarising Phoronix
That's what Google has been reduced to: slop and slopfarms
Links 22/09/2025: Breaches, Windows TCO, and Arrests
Links for the day
Gemini Links 22/09/2025: Rabbit Hole and DeGoogling Fairphone
Links for the day
Links 22/09/2025: Russian War Planes Invade NATO Airspace While Dihydroxyacetone Man Escalates Attack on Free Speech Because of Critics
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, September 21, 2025
IRC logs for Sunday, September 21, 2025