Bonum Certa Men Certa

EPO Censorship Rebuked by Former UK Human Rights Judge

The EPO still censors every single page in Techrights, which it also threatened using several law firms

EPO IAC
Former UK Judge at the European Court of Human Rights, Sir Paul Mahoney:
Now head of the EPO's Internal Appeals Committee



Summary: The European Patent Office (EPO) under the leadership (maladministration) of António Campinos and Benoît Battistelli is in noncompliance with international standards of law

In 2017 (warning: epo.org link) following an unrelenting stream of adverse publicity both inside the EPO and outside, Battistelli was forced by the Administrative Council to reform the EPO's internal justice system.



Since then the Internal Appeals Committee (IAC) has been headed by Sir Paul Mahoney, a distinguished British legal scholar who previously served as first President of the European Union Civil Service Tribunal (2005 to 2011) and as the UK's judge on the European Court of Human Rights from 2012 to 2016.

Somewhat belatedly the Mahoney-led IAC is getting around to dealing with the massive backlog of internal appeal cases that built up during the Battistelli era at the EPO.

It's an unenviable task that could be compared with the fifth labour of Hercules, cleaning out the large volumes of manure that have accumulated in the Augean stables of the Battistelli regime.

Augean
The IAC has the unenviable task of cleaning out the Augean stables of the Battistelli era



The role of the IAC is to issue opinions to the EPO's two appointing authorities, the President and the Administrative Council, who then take a final decision which can be appealed to the ILOAT.

"Somewhat belatedly the Mahoney-led IAC is getting around to dealing with the massive backlog of internal appeal cases that built up during the Battistelli era at the EPO."The system is far from ideal because the opinions issued by the IAC are only non-binding advisory opinions and the appointing authority is free to depart from them.

Also following a "reform" introduced by Battistelli which remains in force long after his departure, the appellant no longer receives an advance copy of the IAC's opinion when it is issued to the appointing authority as was the long-established practice prior to Battistelli. Nowadays a copy of the opinion is only provided to the appellant after the appointing authority has issued its decision.

"In a recent landmark case, the IAC issued an opinion belatedly excoriating an arbitrary and unprincipled act of censorship by Elodie Bergot which occurred almost four years ago in 2016."Strictly speaking any departure from the IAC's opinion by the appointing authority should be justified by reasons. But, hey, this is EPOnia where anything goes and where - to borrow a phrase from the ILOAT - "arbitrary, unprincipled or even irrational decision-making" was the ordre du jour under Battistelli.

Nevertheless it seems that the current EPO management under Campinos is generally more inclined to follow the opinions of the IAC than was the case under Battistelli.

In a recent landmark case, the IAC issued an opinion belatedly excoriating an arbitrary and unprincipled act of censorship by Elodie Bergot which occurred almost four years ago in 2016.

Bergot censorship
Sir Paul and his Committee were not amused by Bergot's censorship



The background to this case is that in October 2016 the EPO Central Staff Committee (CSC) tried to publish two documents relating to the internal justice system of the EPO, namely a presentation criticising the operation of the system under Battistelli's management and an open letter to the Principal Director of the Human Resources Department (Dir 4.3), Ms Elodie Bergot.

But Bergot was having none of this and - presumably with the backing of Battistelli and her hubby Gilles Requena - she spiked the publication.

Four years down the road, in a unanimous opinion the IAC has found that the Office was wrong in refusing the publication of the two documents.

"Four years down the road, in a unanimous opinion the IAC has found that the Office was wrong in refusing the publication of the two documents."The IAC confirmed that freedom of speech is part and parcel of freedom of association. Those freedoms are not absolute or unconditional and an organisation may take steps to prevent publications containing incorrect information, or statements impairing the dignity of international civil service or grossly abusing freedom of speech. However, such interferences by an organisation are subject to limits.

The IAC found it impossible to accept that two minor statistical deviations from actual official figures in the presentation objected to by Bergot were grave enough to justify the refusal to allow publication.

The IAC also confirmed that staff representatives are at liberty to criticise the EPO’s policies and actions, even sharply and robustly, as long as the language used is not injurious or defamatory. This is a perfectly legitimate manifestation of the political jousting between management and staff bodies that is part and parcel of the life of a healthy International Organisation.

"The IAC unanimously concluded that the censorship imposed by Bergot was neither appropriate nor proportionate and that the refusal to publish both documents was tainted by illegality."The IAC took the position that it is essential for staff members to have knowledge of the various positions discussed between EPO management and the Staff Committee on matters of general interest for staff. This ensures that EPO management can be exposed to a degree of accountability to staff in relation to policy decisions affecting them.

The IAC unanimously concluded that the censorship imposed by Bergot was neither appropriate nor proportionate and that the refusal to publish both documents was tainted by illegality.

In addition, it also found aggravating circumstances in the way that the EPO handled the CSC requests, by delaying a response and then failing to respond altogether.

The IAC also had "some difficulty in understanding" the EPO when it raised a receivability objection with no serious arguments at the appeal stage.

"So after almost four years of waiting the CSC has had a small taste of justice."The good news is that the new President of the Office, António Campinos, has decided to follow the opinion of the IAC. As a result, the CSC is finally allowed to publish the documents from October 2016 on the EPO Intranet!

So after almost four years of waiting the CSC has had a small taste of justice.

But what is even more remarkable about this case, is that the person responsible for trampling on the CSC's fundamental right to freedom of speech still remains in her position.

Back in June 2018, the ILOAT found Bergot guilty of masterminding a witch-hunt conducted against two SUEPO officials, one of whom was unlawfully dismissed from his position and the other who was unlawfully downgraded.

Bergot mugshot
Fit for purpose as head of the EPO's HR department?
Some think not... but Madame Bergot still enjoys António's support



To her officially documented record as a union-basher, Bergot can now add the distinction of an official rebuke for unlawful acts of censorship.

Campinos Battistelli
Why does Campinos continue to protect Bergot?



It's a mystery how someone with such an egregious track record of trampling on the fundamental rights of staff can be allowed to remain in a senior managerial post at an international organisation like the EPO.

"It's a mystery how someone with such an egregious track record of trampling on the fundamental rights of staff can be allowed to remain in a senior managerial post at an international organisation like the EPO."What many people at the EPO are wondering is why Campinos is still protecting Bergot whose "fitness for purpose" as a principal director of the EPO's human resources department is clearly open to question. Some suspect that it is part of a secret unwritten deal with his predecessor Battistelli.

Over to you on that one, António... anything to say?

Or has the cat got your tongue?

Recent Techrights' Posts

Removing the Tumour From IRC
looking back
Windows Sinking Below 13% Market Share in the Island of Jamaica
Microsoft's decline continues and will mostly likely continue indefinitely in Jamaica and its neighbours
Women in Free Software (FOSS) Need Action, Not Mere Words
the men who are loudest about women's rights are some of the very worst offenders
Embrace, Extend, Extinguish Minecraft
These folks should check out Minetest
Techrights Statement on Men Who Viciously Attack Women in Free Software
history shows women will win
 
Gemini Links 16/06/2024: Hand Held Maneuvering Unit and Hugo Static Files
Links for the day
[Meme] The Free(dom) Software Engineer in European Elections
“When the debate is lost, slander becomes the tool of the loser.”
Vista 11 Was 'Leaked' Exactly 3 Years Ago and This One Picture Says It All
how 'well' Vista 11 has done
A Smokescreen for Brad Smith
Maybe the key point was to say "Linux is not secure either" or "Windows and Linux are equally vulnerable", so don't bother dumping Microsoft
Links 15/06/2024: Microsoft's Intellectual Ventures Attacks Kubernetes With Software Patents, More Layoff Waves
Links for the day
Gemini Links 15/06/2024: On Lagrange and on YouTube Getting Worse
Links for the day
Edward Brocklesby: hacker received advance notice of zero-day vulnerabilities in MH and NMH email software
Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
[Meme] Code Liberates Kids
Matthias Kirschner: I can't code, but I can write a book
In Armenia, Bing is Measured at 0.6%, About Ten Times Less Than Yandex
Bing will probably get mothballed in the coming years
[Meme] A Pack and Pact (Collusion Against Computer Users)
They never really cared about users, no more than drug dealers care about drug users...
GNU/Linux in Azerbaijan: From ~0.1% to 7%
Azerbaijan is around the same size as Portugal
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Friday, June 14, 2024
IRC logs for Friday, June 14, 2024
[Meme] People Who Cannot Find Gainful Employment Because of Their Poor Behaviour Online (Not the People Who Merely Call Them Out on It)
Imagine trying to become a lecturer while talking like this in public
You Too Would Get Nervous
countries where Windows is down to 2%
[Meme] The Two Phases (and Faces) of Microsofters
Microsofters: stalk IRC, then troll IRC
The 'Nobody Reads Techrights Anyway' Crowd
Send In the Clowns
Books in the Making
I intend to spend a considerable amount of time explaining what my family and I were subjected to for the 'crime' of promoting/covering Free software
Microsoft is Still Losing Malta
And GNU/Linux is doing well on laptops and desktops
Tux Machines: Third Party Impending
There will be more next week
Links 14/06/2024: Microsoft Layoffs in the News Again, East-West Conflict/Tensions Update
Links for the day
Links 14/06/2024: Comments on the Death of Email and Lagrange Commentary
Links for the day
Dutch Government Appoints Microsofters to Combat "OSS Fetishism"
What corruption looks like
Microsoft's Collapse in Africa and Shutdown of Entire 'Development Centre'
Unlike what Microsoft claimed in face-saving statements
[Meme] Not Your Typical IRC Troll and Harasser
I say, let's punch nazis...
GNU/Linux's Journey in Qatar: From 0.1% to Over 3%
Windows is no longer an important contender there
Secret Contracts and Corpses
The media pretends it's just some generic "IT" issue, but it is not
Bing Has Run Out of Time and Microsoft Might Dismantle It (Save a Financial Miracle)
How much more of investors' money is Microsoft willing to throw in the trash?
Statement on Antisemitism in Our IRC Network and in Social Control Media
In an ideal world nobody would have to be banned from IRC
Gemini Links 14/06/2024: Ads vs. Content, Why Aliases Are Har
Links for the day
Vista 11 Has Fallen in Switzerland, a Country That is More Microsoft Friendly Than Most of Europe
GNU/Linux rose to its highest level there in almost half a decade
Microsoft is Dying in Africa
Based on the Central African Republic, which "is around the same size as France"
[Meme] Microsoft in Africa
Are you telling me Windows is now down to 1% 'market share' in some countries?
Management of the European Patent Office Misleads Staff on Views of the Office's Staff Committee
The EPO as a workplace very rapidly deteriorates
[Meme] Newer is Worse
"They say those are New Ways of Working (NWoW); New does not mean better, it is worse"
Microsoft Needs to be Banned From Contracts, Including Government Contracts, Not Just for Security Failings But for Criminal Negligence, Corruption, and Fatal Cover-ups
How many deaths will it take for Microsoft to face real, effective scrutiny rather than kid gloves treatment?
Links 14/06/2024: Violence, Famines, and Montana Has More Cows Than People
Links for the day
Microsoft Telecom Layoffs, Facebook Layoffs in Africa: A Month After Microsoft's Mass Layoffs in Lagos (Nigeria) Facebook/Meta Does the Same and Microsoft is Now Retreating and Quitting an Entire Sector! (Affirmed Networks and Metaswitch)
Disasters in the making for GAFAM. Money down the drain.
Papua New Guinea: GNU/Linux Growing, Windows Down Below 15%
it seems indisputable there's headway and momentum
"Planets" Cannot Replace Social Control Media, They're Very Much Akin to It (Censorship Hubs, Gatekeepers)
Don't be subjected to gaslighting; make your own OPML file
Topics That Truly Irritate and Consistently Infuriate the Microsofters (Whenever We Cover These)
Censoring uncomfortable information is a difficult activity that has its limits, even in Reddit
Honduras: Vista 11 Down, GNU/Linux Up
Valve sees GNU/Linux as bigger than Apple's MacOS
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Thursday, June 13, 2024
IRC logs for Thursday, June 13, 2024
LibrePlanet 2024 and the Lost Video/Audio of Talks
After the event was over someone informed us that due to technical issues they had lost (or failed to acquire) recordings of the talks
Choosing Between Options to Outsource to Evades the Best Solution (Self-Hosting)
Most users don't need this sort of complexity
IBM Layoffs at Kyndryl
This can soon spill over to Red Hat
Turkmenistan: GNU/Linux Leaps Past 5% This Month?
This is how statCounter sees it
Watch This Space
what matters most is not the volume or quantity of publications but their underlying depth and quality