Bonum Certa Men Certa

Message to LibrePlanet (From Ukraine) 'Censored' But Not Ignored

Ukraine flag: FSF says 'We respond. But quietly.'



Summary: Free as in free speech; but not for everyone...

In past years we learned that certain Free/Libre software developers had been banned from GNU and LibrePlanet mailing lists. To make matters worse, bans in the GNU domain (as a whole) meant that they were unable to reach pertinent people, including Richard Stallman, who pioneered and championed the movement.



"The response, which was amicable, was sent by the Campaigns Manager of the Free Software Foundation (FSF).""Mail sent by a Ukrainian advocate from shelter to libreplanet-discuss@libreplanet.org," we've learned, "is censored but gets private response." The Ukrainian name is redacted for privacy reasons.

The response, which was amicable, was sent by the Campaigns Manager of the Free Software Foundation (FSF). It it a day old:



GNU on UkraineДата: 2 бер. 2022 р., 23:29 Від: gregf@fsf.org Кому: [redacted] Тема: Your question

> Hi, [redacted]: > >> Hello there! > > First of all, we hope you're safe. > >> My name is , I am the leader of the NGO "Ukrainian >> Liberation" which aims to share info and promote FOSS here in >> Ukraine in any possible way. Sorry for some terrible mistakes -- >> there's a war going on in [redacted] my country, and we haven't slept plenty of >> time, so it's kinda difficult to stay focused enough to speak good >> English. >> >> I just wanted to ask you, guys, why RMS is not speaking on >> LibrePlanet this year? It's the first time in history, if I am not >> mistaken. So I would like to know, what's going on. > > As the organizers of LibrePlanet I think we can help answer your > question directly instead of passing it onto the community > libreplanet-discuss list, which wouldn't be able to give you any > information beyond what you already know. > > LibrePlanet doesn't have a standard speaker list, and the selection > procedure is done anonymously by a committee. We usually offer the > president of the FSF a slot to speak in every year, but beyond that we > do not have any "reserved" slots. We also can't give out information > on who did or didn't submit for a talk. We apply this policy uniformly > across all of our speakers, and can't make any exceptions in order to > preserve speaker privacy. > > However, it's probably worth pointing out that if you look at past > schedules, you'll find it is not the first time that RMS didn't speak. > He didn't speak as recently as 2020, but did talk in 2021. With him > being a member of our board and the Chief GNUisance, we *can* inform > that we work closely with RMS. > > Also, thanks for expressing your interest in seeing a talk by him. > Even though we can't have the same people speaking every year, we do > try to take note of speakers people want to see. > > On another note, would you be able to give us more information about > the your Ukranian NGO? We'd be interested in hearing more about it, > especially where it pertains to free software. > > Hope this helps, and hope you keep safe. > > Best, > -Greg > > -- > Greg Farough // Campaigns Manager > Free Software Foundation > > Join the FSF and help us defend software freedom: https://my.fsf.org



There's absolutely nothing wrong with this response, but why remove/block the message from public viewing? Maybe they try hard to keep politics off these mailing lists, which is sort of understandable, but the question asked wasn't a political one. It's just a suppressed question.

Recent Techrights' Posts

Corporate Media: Blame the People Who Enter the Abandoned IBM Buildings, Not IBM for Abandoning Workers in Pursuit of IT Sweatshops
When the media spreads falsehoods stocks can go up (a lot higher), but at whose expense and how long for?
 
The Cyber Show Explains How Slop and Promotion of Slop is About Taking Control Away From Computer Users
"On making a trustworthy machine"
Keeping Available the Site at All Times
Informal arrangements and crowdfunding keep our work available despite resistance (including from people who break the law)
What If "Era of AI" and "AI Revolution" (Fake News) Never Happened?
So how much longer before the bust (or bubble-burst)?
GNU/Linux Approaches 5% in Australia
5% by year's end?
How We Do Techrights (and What's Changing Next Week)
Many former news sites no longer yield much non-meaningless news (not anymore); there's a gap to be filled
Europe/EU is Moving Towards Independence, Fast to Adopt Free Software
More and more states (governments, public sector) in Germany are dumping Microsoft
GNU/Linux Grows at the Expense of Windows
People who want to get work done already left Windows
Tux Machines Growing as a Volunteers-Run Site
Historically the site did not have many original stories, but this changed as the audience grew and the site gained more recognition
Links 12/07/2026: European Commission Versus ‘Addictive Design’, "Google Loses Final Appeal Over $4.7 Billion EU Android Antitrust Fine"
Links for the day
GNU/Linux Market Share Increases Some More Today, statCounter Measures It at 7.3%
Will more such thresholds and records be broken?
Gemini Links 12/07/2026: Studying Languages and 2026 Old Computer Challenge (OCC)
Links for the day
EPO "Cocaine Communication Manager" - Part XIII - At the EPO, Cocaine Addicts and Their Friends Are "Protected Class"
What does that tell us about the EPO?
Increasing Output by Focusing on Originals
It's probably more important to carry on with these than it is to keep abreast of non-crucial news
Amid Strikes and Industrial Actions, Young Professionals at the European Patent Office (EPO) Kept on 'Short Leash', According to the Local Staff Committee The Hague
Issues affecting Young Professionals
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Saturday, July 11, 2026
IRC logs for Saturday, July 11, 2026
Blogs May be Making a Comeback (They're Not Fediverse, They Are Joined by RSS Feeds)
Don't fake expansion where none existed
ChromeOS and GNU/Linux in the United Kingdom Reach 11%
the UK shows signs of digital maturity
Canonical is Selling Microsoft, It Pays The Register MS to Sell Microsoft
It's all about money to them. And they call this journalism.
When Red Hat's HR Becomes the Same as IBM's HR (Bluewashing)
Red Hat keeps sacking very experienced engineers and adding temporary interns
GNU/Linux Growing in East Asia
Assuming this is more or less accurate, we could use a plausible explanation
SUEPO Munich Report on the Recent EPO Demonstration and Rolling Strikes That Continue to Grow
"increasing registrations for the 'rolling strikes' running until autumn"
Over a Week After Microsoft Discontinued Some XBox Models It Apparently Exits Some Markets Altogether
We seem to be witnessing the end of XBox
Gemini Links 11/07/2026: Old Computer challenge, Poems, Antenna, and More
Links for the day
Links 11/07/2026: "Trademark wars of Influencer Culture", Xinuos Uses Copyrights Versus UNIX
Links for the day
North America: GNU/Linux Measured at 10%
To better understand what contributes to the gains
Following Corrections and Adjustments statCounter Sees GNU/Linux at 7.1%, an All-Time High
There is a lot of layoffs at Microsoft this month
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Friday, July 10, 2026
IRC logs for Friday, July 10, 2026
Links 11/07/2026: Wednesday-Saturday News Catch-up
Links for the day
Prioritising High-Importance News
In order to fully catch up with news we'll not publish many new articles until next week
The Register MS: "AI" More Than 80 Times in One Article. But It's Not an Article, It's Sponsored Keyword-stuffed Page.
The Register MS is being paid to actively promoted this scheme
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Thursday, July 09, 2026
IRC logs for Thursday, July 09, 2026
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, July 08, 2026
IRC logs for Wednesday, July 08, 2026