Collateral Damage in Oracle's Case Against Android

Dr. Roy Schestowitz

2012-04-17 21:00:10 UTC
Modified: 2012-04-17 21:00:10 UTC

Gates

Summary: News analysis and preparation for patent news catchup

THE lawsuits against Red Hat and Google help teach us that once someone is making money with Linux, patents come knocking on the door in pursuit of a share of the profits. As Simon Phipps recently explained, everyone loses from this practice (except lawyers). He speaks specifically about the Oracle case and it is summarised as follows:

Besides Google, biggest loser is free culture in general and open source in particular. Here's your guide to what's at stake

As a former manager at Sun (of Java fame), Phipps understands what's at stake and in the rest of this month we are going to catch up with patent news that we missed in March and April (due to personal reasons).

The new Android case kicks off and Groklaw provides detailed analysis while the less legalese-savvy press follows the lead. As Pogson puts it, "Oracle [is] is clutching at straws," for reasons we covered here before. ⬆

Comments

walterbyrd

2012-04-18 15:07:47

On the stand, Larry decided to be cute and claimed - under oath - that he did not know whether Java was a free language, or not.

I guess Larry wants the jury to believe that he may have filed the lawsuit by accident.

Dr. Roy Schestowitz

2012-04-18 15:53:45

He couldn't help it. He saw his best friend Steve Jobs crying, he had to lash out at Android. :-)

twitter

2012-04-18 17:24:47

I'm glad to see you come roaring back, Roy. The software patent issue is one you have a very good grip on and I like the way you put the news together.

Many People Have Said That They "Leave" IBM in Recent Days (Ahead of Mass Layoffs): So the real extent of layoffs is greater than what's publicly stated (there are silent layoffs) [...] Whatever IBM says about the scope, scale, or magnitude of the "RAs", it doesn't tell the full story
Techrights Will Contact German Media About the EPO's Substance Abuse: This scandal won't "go to waste"
Search @ Techrights: Almost There Now (Maybe an Anniversary Gift): Just to be very clear, search would not be unprecedented at Techrights
The Rumour Was True, Mass Layoffs at IBM Today: How widespread the layoffs are (or how they're disguised, e.g. PIPs) is hard to assess
"All truths are easy to understand once they are discovered; the point is to discover them." -Galileo Galilei: This site is educational
Why I'm Always Proud of the Site I've Devoted My Life to: As a graffiti around the corner from our home says, "be a better person"
Standing Up or Standing for What's True But Inconvenient: Bad actors need to be called out
Media Coverage Regarding IBM is Vapourware and LLM Slop: With slop images, too
statCounter Says GNU/Linux Rose to 4% in the Russian Federation: Adoption of Vista 11 has been embarrassingly weak
Corruption is Not a Joke: we'll try to limit our use of humour to avoid misunderstandings or misinterpretations
The Slopfarm WebProNews is Overwhelming "linux" Results in Google News: Google News is slop
The Fall of IBM: What Happened?: Just like the EPO continues riding some old reputation acquired in the 1970s IBM relies on old myths like, "nobody gets fired for buying IBM."
IBM's CEO Already Has the Excuse for the Latest Wave of Mass Layoffs: Only days ago the CEO told a bunch of nonsense
Links 04/11/2025: Conflicts, Politics, and IPv6 at Home: Links for the day
Gemini Links 04/11/2025: Entering WiFi Passwords and Programming Rambles: Links for the day
Arch Linux Seems Like the New Debian: Arch users (btw!) are growing in relative and absolute share
Analytics From US Government Affirm a Trend: Microsoft's "Market Share" in Search is Falling: the data set is large
Holding Institutions Such as the EPO Accountable Through Public Information: Speaking truth to power is never easy
EPO Staff Losing Holidays, as Usual, as the Office Increases Profits by Illegally Granting Invalid Patents While Reducing Salaries: How much more can the staff endure and generally tolerate?
Free Software Does Not Always Speak for Itself, It Needs Advocates: Legal matters that relate to sharing of code will be discussed
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Monday, November 03, 2025: IRC logs for Monday, November 03, 2025
The Register MS Continues Looking for Money in Promotion of the "AI" Ponzi Scheme: That The Register MS participates in this deceit rather than tackle/debunk it says a lot about The Register MS
IBM Layoffs in "Software", This Likely Impacts Red Hat as Well: Many people say "software" people are impacted
Escaping Proprietary Software, Not Just Escaping Microsoft: To take control of your life adopt GNU/Linux
A Lot of Fake News About Microsoft Headcount (Also: Microsoft's Debt Rose by About 24 Billion Dollars in Past 12 Months): If you see some headline about Microsoft's CEO making claims about hirings, look away
Techrights Turns 19 in Three Days: It would be nice to meet for a chat
Akira Urushibata on How Grokipedia Fails to Work: The Grokipedia article gives the wrong character for the "Ko" on "Koan"
Links 03/11/2025: Data Breaches, Wars, and Digital Censorship: Links for the day
Gemini Links 03/11/2025: Poetry, Old Androids and Small Shells: Links for the day
Links 03/11/2025: Internet Anniversary: Links for the day
Two Years of Uptime: Reboots are seldom involuntary
Richard Stallman is Giving Another Talk in Less Than a Fortnight: in two weeks' time (13 days from now)
Windows Falls Below 20% in the UK: Many people choose to leave Windows altogether
Microsoft's Search Business Falls to Lowest Point in 2 Years, Based on statCounter: what can Microsoft sell other than shares in Microsoft?
Evidence Regarding Layoffs at Red Hat: Seems like IBM layoffs
Microsoft: Our "Goodwill" Value Grew More Than Tenfold Since 2011: Hallmark of pseudo-economics
GNU/Linux as a Boarding Pass: being mostly analogue is still feasible
Links 03/11/2025: Lack of Trust in LLMs and Windows TCO at Jaguar: Links for the day
Gemini Links 03/11/2025: Books in October and Change: Links for the day
Mozilla Firefox Won't Survive and Many Sites Don't Work With It (Compatibility Abandoned): The Web has become monocultural
Debian is Non-Free: Devuan might be worth looking into
Slopwatch: Brian Fagioli and LinuxSecurity: This is a real problem and most certainly a big problem because when people try to find real information about security and GNU/Linux they instead read "word salads" made by bots
Four Reasons to Party With Us in Four Days, Celebrating the Four Freedoms: Today we expect to be back to a more-or-less regular publication pace
Links 03/11/2025: The "Smartphone Panopticon" and Belarus' Hybrid Attacks on EU Intensify: Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, November 02, 2025: IRC logs for Sunday, November 02, 2025
Microsoft's Debt Has Skyrocketed by More Than 15 Billion Dollars in 6 Months or 8.2 Billion Dollars in the Past 3 Months Alone: The corporate media intentionally disregards - or merely turns a blind eye to - such data
Rumour: IBM Layoffs in Canada Starting Tomorrow: "RA (IBM's term for layoffs) Coming to Canada this week (Nov 3rd)"
Debunking False/Misleading Statements Made or Told to the High Court: People who try to cheat the system by gaslighting judges will end up discrediting themselves
Fear, Uncertainty, Doubt (FUD) by LLM Slop: The Web has become such a sordid mess that this FUD made by bots is what Google News deems to be "the news"
This Month's Analytics Show Vista 11 Down, GNU/Linux Up: After pulling the plug on Vista 10 we see losses - not gains - for Vista 11
Almost Fully Caught Up: The EPO series will continue very soon, maybe tomorrow or on Tuesday
Links 02/11/2025: Another Halloween Bust and MAGA Regime Says Public Universities Should No Longer Hire 'Foreign' Employees: Links for the day
The Long-Coveted Milestone of 3,200 Active Gemini Capsules: Despite being away some days last week, about 50,000 Gemini requests were served each day, on average
Five More Days Till Techrights Party: We'll have many more batches of Daily Links as we catch up with a 'backlog' of news
Links 02/11/2025: More Nuclear Escalations and "Anti-Cybercrime Laws Are Being Weaponized to Repress Journalism": Links for the day
Gemini Links 02/11/2025: "The Pragmatic Programmer", Perl New Features and Foostats: Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Saturday, November 01, 2025: IRC logs for Saturday, November 01, 2025

Collateral Damage in Oracle's Case Against Android

Comments

Recent Techrights' Posts