EditorsAbout the SiteComes vs. MicrosoftUsing This Web SiteSite ArchivesCredibility IndexOOXMLOpenDocumentPatentsNovellNews DigestSite NewsRSS

01.01.13

Groups of Lawyers Will Not Solve the Patent Problem

Posted in Patents at 2:05 pm by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

Quentin Massys painting
16th century painting of a civil law notary

Summary: Scientists, engineers, programmers, technologists etc. — not government bodies — will help the rest of the public abolish government-granted monopolies

The European Commission doesn't get FRAND, or maybe it pretends not to, or perhaps it was bribed or deceived by Apple and Microsoft lobbyists. Either way, this recent event proved some malice in today’s Commission, which also ushered in the unitary patent. Glyn Moody writes on the subject:

There was – of course – disagreement on the place of FRAND, since those in the open source world know that it has none if the object is to produce a level playing-field for all to compete on equally. And for that very reason those in the world of proprietary software want FRAND baked into standards since it excludes nearly all of the key open source licences and the projects using them. It’s the perfect solution for those who are afraid to compete fairly: skew the rules so that open source is excluded, and then claim victory when it doesn’t offer solutions.

Also worth noting in the above statement from the report is the claim that “the distinction between software and hardware is increasingly artificial”. I think if we decode this, what it means is that in the old world of hardware – for example, in telecommunications or codecs – FRAND standards were common, and that’s perfectly true. But in the world of software, the key modern forums for standards such as W3C or OASIS require RF, not FRAND. So this is a crude attempt to force old-fashioned hardware approaches on modern software, because once again the convenient result is that open source is excluded.

Indeed, given the manifestly greater success of the modern approach – as demonstrated by the unprecedented rate of growth of the Internet ecosystem compared to earlier technologies – the move to implementing hardware features in software is a strong argument for making older hardware standards RF instead of FRAND; that would allow them to enjoy the same kind of accelerated deployment the software world has experienced in the last two decades.

Thus there is no “dilemma” that needs resolving, and no need for stakeholder dialogue – another code term for “opportunity for wealthy US software companies to spend huge sums lobbying for what they want in the corridors of Brussels,” since “stakeholders” never seems to include groups representing the public interest, who were similarly excluded from the ACTA negotiations until they took to the streets across Europe.

Even Kroes lost her way when it comes to patents as she gave implicit consent to FRAND [1, 2, 3]. These career politicians are typically lawyers by trade, so the poor comprehension of scientists’ desire is not surprising. See what IBM’s Kappos says to provide ammo to a lawyers’ firm after he had joined the USPTO and later announced that he would leave amid public scolding [1, 2, 3]:

USPTO Director Discusses Software “Patent Wars” By: Sheldon Mak & Anderson http://www.eyeonip.net/David Kappos, the Director of the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, recently addressed the socalled “patent wars” impacting the software industry. Although he acknowledged several concerns about patent quality, he also highlighted the importance of IP rights to the software industry. “Patent protection is every bit as well-deserved for software-implemented innovation as for the innovations that enabled man to fly, and before that for the innovations that enabled man to light the dark with electricity, and before that for the innovations that enabled the industrial revolution,” Kappos stated. However, he also acknowledged that patent protection must be “properly tailored in scope, so that programmers can write code and engineers can design devices without fear of unfounded accusations of infringement.” Kappos also debunked reports that the “patent wars” between companies like Samsung and Apple signal that the system is broken. He cited a USPTO study that found that in over 80 percent of the smartphone lawsuits, the courts have construed the software patents at issue as valid. He further noted that rejections in software patent applications taken to the USPTO appeals board are upheld at a slightly higher rate than for the office as a whole, and those few decisions appealed to the Federal Circuit are affirmed 95 percent of the time. Kappos also noted that the changes implemented under the America Invents Act should improve the quality of software patents. He specifically listed new procedures, such as post-grant opposition, inter partes review, and covered business method patents review. He also noted that additional changes are forthcoming as the USPTO completes the rollout of the AIA. “So to the commentators declaring the system is “broken” I say: give it a rest already, and give the AIA a chance to work. Give it a chance to even get started. But we’re not done. Not nearly,” Kappos stated.

We already shared some rebuttals to this. The conclusion we can reach is that too many government bodies are occupied by lawyers who represent corporations (not people) and it shows. Groups that are led by lawyers do not want to solve the problem from which they profit.

Share this post: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
  • co.mments
  • DZone
  • email
  • Google Bookmarks
  • LinkedIn
  • NewsVine
  • Print
  • Technorati
  • TwitThis
  • Facebook

If you liked this post, consider subscribing to the RSS feed or join us now at the IRC channels.

Pages that cross-reference this one

What Else is New


  1. The NSA's Top (and First) PRISM Partner, Microsoft, Lies to Governments and Businesses as Office Gets Banned in China

    Developments in China reveal that security and privacy threats posed by reliance on Microsoft are so great that a ban becomes inevitable and continues to expand (Microsoft put on more and more block lists and blacklists)



  2. Microsoft's Propaganda Machine Tries to Shift Security Debate Amid Serious Catastrophes

    Observations and analysis of some recent deception in corporate news sites (like Condé Nasty), trying to pretend that Microsoft is secure, that Microsoft is pursuing security, and that FOSS and Android security or privacy are inherently poor



  3. Despite SCOTUS Ruling, Microsoft Still Extorts Companies and Product Buyers Using FAT Software Patents, Latest Victim is Canon

    Canon and Microsoft sign a patent deal which relates to patents on FAT file systems and impacts some of Canon's products, potentially Linux products as well (Canon makes drivers for Linux but does not develop products with Android or GNU/Linux just yet)



  4. Links 7/7/2014: CentOS 7 Released, Linux 3.16 RC4

    Links for the day



  5. Links 6/7/2014: Deepin 2014, Calligra 2.8.5

    Links for the day



  6. Bill Gates Pushed Out of States by Better Informed Teachers

    Bill Gates’ private (for-profit) coup against public education is being impeded by people whom it negatively affects



  7. Microsoft Struggling to Make Sales and More Future Products Axed

    The software bully which manipulates its financial reports is said to be unable to sell the latest Windows and a new Microsoft product running this version of Windows is axed before arrival



  8. Internet of Things Alliance Now Has a Mole, Microsoft

    The Internet of Things Alliance has just let the mole, Microsoft, dip its finger in the competition, as it so often does in order to derail the competition



  9. Links 6/7/2014: Korea's Domestic GNU/Linux Plans

    Links for the day



  10. Microsoft Sabotaging No-IP Rather Than Admitting Its Own Failures, Time for Class Action Seems Right as List of Affected Domains Collected

    Microsoft control over the Internet (control that should never have been granted) is used to shut down millions of legitimate services



  11. Bill Gates Deeply Corrupt Not Just in Education Sector

    Bursting the bubble or shattering the illusion that Gates is merely a misguided well-meaning person when it comes to education 'reform'



  12. Publicly-funded NHS Would Enjoy Symbiotic Relationship With Free -- as in Freedom -- Software

    Some of the latest attacks on FOSS and how these relate to the uprise of the affluent (seeking to privatise everything which is public and profit by domination over the state)



  13. Links 4/7/2014: E19 Alpha 2, KDevelop 4.7.0 Beta

    Links for the day



  14. US System Manipulated to Financially Punish Free Software

    The Yorba Foundation is denied tax exemptions while the world's biggest thief, who increases his wealth by lobbying and investing under the guise of 'charity', receives tax exemptions



  15. 'Hope' and 'Change' in Reverse: USPTO Gets Even More Extremist With New White House Appointment

    Philip Johnson, a "patent extremist", becomes the new head of the monopolies office, showing that nothing is going to improve any time soon



  16. Symptoms of Injustice: Biggest Software Patents Proponent, CAFC, Superseding Supreme Court Decisions on Patents

    A patent case in the United States gets sent from SCOTUS to CACF, showing a rather odd hierarchy of justice (top-to-bottom, back to notorious patent boosters)



  17. Links 2/7/2014: GNU/Linux up in Steam, New GCHQ Lawuit

    Links for the day



  18. Links 1/7/2014: CoreOS and Blackphone in Headlines

    Links for the day



  19. Links 30/6/2014: Linux 3.16 RC3, Many New Android Devices

    Links for the day



  20. The Internet's Own Boy: The Story of Aaron Swartz

    A film that has just been released and is a free (CC-licensed) download on Internet Archive



  21. Arguments Persist Over Whether Software Patents Died in the US Whilst European Patent Law is Quietly Assimilated to US

    Continued discussion about the meaning of the US Supreme Court (SCOTUS) ruling and what it means to programmers all around the world, not just patent lawyers who seek to monopolise and tax software development



  22. Good Nokia (Jolla) and Bad Nokia (Microsoft); or Good Derivatives and Bad Derivatives of Android Hardware

    A reminder of what Nokia has really become (a part of Microsoft) and where people should go if they pursue what Nokia would have been without the mole (Elop)



  23. Microsoft and the BSA Play Hardball, Accelerating a Much-Motivated Move to Free/Libre Software

    The alliance of proprietary software giants and software patents proponents (BSA) is seen bolstering Microsoft's war of aggression against its own 'clients'



  24. Microsoft E-mail Infrastructure a Sure Way to Lose Access to E-mail, Lose Messages, and Get Abused

    How the increased reliance of proprietary software for E-mails breeds abuse at the higher levels while hurting those who are vulnerable



  25. 'Open' Nastiness: Openwashing of OOXML in Order to Make Microsoft the Standard and Bury ODF

    Another step in the long struggle to cast proprietary as 'open', especially when it comes to Microsoft's last remaining cash cow and Facebook's core business of mass surveillance



  26. Links 28/6/2014: New Wine, Steam Update

    Links for the day



  27. Links 27/6/2014: New Mint 17 Variant, OwnCloud 7 Beta

    Links for the day



  28. Links 26/6/2014: Linux is Everywhere; A Lot of Android News

    Links for the day



  29. Links 25/6/2014: A Lot of Android News, Peppermint Five

    Links for the day



  30. Patent Lawyers Fail to Grasp That Software Ideas Rather Than Code Are Abstract and Hence Cannot Endure a Proper Court's Test

    Heaps of editorials and analyses from patent-centric firms pretend that nothing has changed after the Supreme Court abolished patents on "abstract ideas" (as opposed to working implementations)


CoPilotCo

RSS 64x64RSS Feed: subscribe to the RSS feed for regular updates

Home iconSite Wiki: You can improve this site by helping the extension of the site's content

Home iconSite Home: Background about the site and some key features in the front page

Chat iconIRC Channel: Come and chat with us in real time

CoPilotCo

Recent Posts