Bonum Certa Men Certa

In the United States, Software Patents Are Still Consistently Invalidated Under 35 U.S.C. €§ 101

No entry sign



Summary: A look at some of the latest decisions, rants, and frustration expressed by the patent microcosm over the elimination of many software patents in the United States (US)

PATENT certainty matters. Consistency across judgments matters. Predictability matters. If all those software patents perish in courts, will their holders bother asserting anymore (i.e. suing)? The patent litigation numbers are already down and they go down every year. Ever since Alice we are seeing an encouraging pattern; the US Supreme Court objects to revisiting the matter and the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (CAFC) gets more hostile towards software patents each year. This shapes so-called 'caselaw' in a favourable fashion because software patents are ebbing away.



Most of the articles and tweets we find are rants about Alice and/or promotion of software patents, courtesy of people who never developed any software in their entire lifetime. It's almost amusing to watch their agony; they try to attribute this loss to "software", but in reality people who actually develop software are pleased to see the demise of software patents.

"Challenges to patent eligibility under 35 U.S.C. €§ 101 have become so routine in patent litigation," says the patent microcosm, expressing the usual concern over Alice Corp. Pty. Ltd. v CLS Bank Int’l. To quote this new example:

Challenges to patent eligibility under 35 U.S.C. €§ 101 have become so routine in patent litigation that it is easy to overlook the opinions that seem to issue almost daily from the district courts and, less frequently, from the Federal Circuit. If one were to judge solely by the tenor of recent cert petitions filed with the Supreme Court, however, one would likely conclude that the lower courts are still fundamentally confused as to how to properly apply the Supreme Court’s two-step analysis for ineligible “abstract ideas” set forth in Alice Corp. Pty. Ltd. v. CLS Bank Int’l, 134 S. Ct. 2347 (2014). For example, an amicus brief in support of a cert petition in Recognicorp, LLC v. Nintendo, No. 17-645 (denied, Jan. 8, 2018) argues that, at least in the context of data processing patents, “[t]he lower courts and the PTO have misunderstood the Mayo-Alice test and have created indeterminate and overly restrictive patent eligibility doctrine under Section 101.” Other recent petitions in which cert was denied have taken the lower courts to task for either improperly looking beyond the claims to assess patent eligibility or, to the other extreme, looking only at the claims. This is not to mention the argument that eligibility is not a cognizable defense at all in patent litigation, an issue also denied certiorari by the Supreme Court last year.


That last sentence is correct. The US Supreme Court isn't interested in throwing a lifeline to patent lawyers. The Justices at the US Supreme Court, at least as far as patents are concerned, have been doing the right thing. That cannot be said about all sorts of other domains (copyright law for example), but recently we have been feeling like we have an 'ally' in the highest US court. The Justices often rule unanimously against the maximalists. They overturn CAFC almost every time.

Looking at the reactions from self-described advocates of software patents, we still find words such as "kill" (war narrative); it's almost as if, at least to these people, strict judges or examiners are murderers. How about this: "Cleveland Clinic's Petition for Cert. Challenging 101/Mayo Kill of Cardiovascular Disease Detection Tests..."

It's quite likely that this so-called 'kill' will actually help save lives by denying a monopoly on detection of heart problems. Here's another one: "Search Engine Optimization Patents Held Patent Ineligible under 101/Alice..."

So another one bites the dust, as usual. We aren't even skipping any of the decisions that are inconvenient to us! Alice and Mayo are having the intended effect.

It certainly sounds like Nike now uses a bogus software patent to taunt small rivals. To quote a report about a lawsuit filed last Saturday:

Sports brand Nike is being sued for patent infringement over an app that tracks users’ fitness.

US-based Personal Beasties Group (PDG) alleged that Nike infringes on US patent number 6,769,915, in a case filed at the US District Court for the Southern District of New York on Saturday, January 20.

The patent, known as the “Interactive system for personal life patterns”, covers an app developed by PDG that helps track the fitness goals and achievements of the user.


Just use 35 U.S.C. €§ 101. That might eliminate this patent altogether. Without looking at the pertinent details, it sounds like a software-only surveillance patent. Many such patents have already been invalidated; we can recall some.

There are obvious cases where €§ 101 is brought up inappropriately -- cases where Alice and Mayo are simply inapplicable. But just because the €§ 101 challenge does not pass muster doesn't necessarily mean it has been defeated; it may simply mean poor defense strategy. Consider this coverage of a district court case: (Free Stream Media Corp. v Alphonso Inc.)

In a recent decision from the U.S. District Court Northern District of California, involving Free Stream Media Corp. v. Alphonso Inc., claims of a television system patent survived a motion to dismiss under 35 U.S.C. €§ 101.

[...]

Samba relied heavily on Enfish, LLC v. Microsoft Corp., 822 F.3d 1327 (Fed. Cir. 2016), which supports the notion that a dividing line can be drawn between patents which merely describe using a computer and/or the internet to carry out pre-existing and well-known tasks and techniques, and those that relate to the functioning of computers themselves (e.g., specific asserted improvement in computer capabilities). The former will virtually always fail under Alice unless some "inventive concept" can be found in the second step of the analysis; the latter are substantially less easily characterized as merely abstract ideas.


So Alice was attempted unsuccessfully; the case can probably be appealed/brought to CAFC. Maybe try another legal strategy this time around. We were dumbfounded to see this other new case where €§ 101 did not work. It's just hard to understand why €§ 101 was even invoked in this context (against patents on night vision):

The court denied defendant's motion to dismiss on the ground that plaintiff’s night vision patents encompassed unpatentable subject matter because the asserted claims were not directed toward an abstract idea.


Seems to make sense.

Here, by contrast, is a new district court case (VOIT) which shows software patents crushed; they are hard to get and then also defend in US courts. Alice is cited:

Patent claims directed to “buying and selling an item relating to unique subjects” were held patent-ineligible under the Alice abstract idea test and 35 USC €§ 101 in VOIT Technologies, LLC v. Del-Ton, Inc., No. 5:17-CV-259-BO, (E.D. N.C. Jan. 10, 2018). The court therefore granted a motion to dismiss under FRCP 12(b)(6). Among the interesting aspects of this case are that U.S. Patent No. 6,226,412 includes a 330 word independent claim, and that claim includes a lot of technical terminology relating to storing and processing text and image data. Neither of these things saved the claim from Alice.

The ’412 patent is directed to “secure interactive communication of text and image information between a central server computer and one or more client computers located at remote sites for the purpose of storing and retrieving files describing unique products, services or individuals.” Claim 1, reproduced at the bottom of this post, recites numerous steps for achieving this secure interactive communication relating to unique products.


No matter how hard they try to defend software patents (or abstract patents), they almost always fail. Why would they even assure clients that such patents are worth pursuing in the first place? Or such lawsuits?

Charles Bieneman, like many in his profession, looks for new ways to bamboozle software developers with advocacy of post-Alice software patents. Here is what he wrote some days ago:

Perhaps the single most useful resource summarizing the law of patent-eligibility under the Alice abstract idea test is this chart of Federal Circuit cases under 35 U.S.C. €§ 101, found on the USPTO’s very helpful web page providing guidance on analyzing claims for patent-eligible subject matter. This blog has previously covered the USPTO’s guidance on patent-eligibility; I am discussing it again to note that the afore-mentioned chart of patent-eligibility case was updated on January 4. If you are responding to – and especially if you are appealing – a rejection under the Alice abstract idea test, this chart is the place to start.

[...]

A recent post on the PatentlyO blog, quoting a PTAB decision to the effect that the USPTO is not required to provide facts supporting patent-eligibility rejections, further drives home the reality. As the Federal Circuit has explained in many cases (see, e.g. OIP Techs., Inc. v. Amazon.com, a 2015 case holding claims directed to price optimization patent-ineligible), patent-eligibility is a question of law. In practice, this means that it is like interpreting or construing claims – every adjudicator, from patent examiners up to the US Supreme Court, gets to look at it anew. Every adjudicator can apply his or her own gloss, a nightmare for patent applicants, patent owners, and potential infringers alike.


Watch how they resort to PTAB-bashing -- a subject we shall cover later in the weekend. PTAB too is enforcing €§ 101, so even patent holders that sue nobody may see their already-granted patents invalidated.

Is the following good news? "PTAB Reversed Examiner on 101 Rejection of SAP Claims for Modeling Service Endpoints of Process Based on BPMN," wrote a patent maximalist. So basically, this is not a granted patent, there is no lawsuit, and PTAB basically said OK to one single patent (for now, it can be squashed even in the lowest of patent courts later on).

A patent troll from Dominion Harbor responded with: "A good day, but a little sad that this is what we're reduced to celebrating..."

It's actually somewhat hilarious.

The maximalist then responded: "So true. I bit more good news with the PTAB reversing an examiner on 101 in an SAP application. This does not happen very often."

In other words, PTAB very often rejects patents that examiners decided to accept.

In a sense, anyone can sense the frustration there. They really struggle to find any "good news" (for them).

Here comes €§ 103 to invalidate a Microsoft patent (well, application that nearly got granted). "PTAB Reversed Examiner on 101/Alice Rejection of Microsoft Patent Application but Affirmed Examiner on 103 Rejection," he wrote.

Then came more PTAB bashing from a person connected to the above patent troll (Dominion Harbor). "Patent practitioners BEWARE," he shouted, then taking note of someone who lost a rehearing at PTAB (on €§ 101). Here's another rant (with ALL CAPS) about €§ 101 invalidations ("crazy rejections under €§101 continue," he later added). Here's another ALL CAPS and a rant about PTAB invalidation. He said that "the definition of the "abstract" idea takes up almost a whole paragraph" as if the length of that somehow voids the decision.

The above are just some among many tweets that highlight the tough time trolls and law firms are having (they're connected to each other). €§ 101 in particular drives them crazy. Then there's also €§ 102, which was mentioned in another context 5 days ago.

Rule 130 declarations are the mechanism by which applicants can invoke many of the prior art exceptions embodied in the AIA version of 35 USC €§ 102(b)...


So we've seen how €§ 101, €§ 102 and €§ 103 generally raise the bar, if not at the patent office, then at PTAB or the courts. No wonder the number of lawsuits in the US has nosedived. In Texas it fell by more than half. ⬆

Recent Techrights' Posts

When Short is Way Too Short (Superficiality, Lowering of Entropy)
Demonstrating how truly worthless social control media was all along
 
Links 16/11/2026: Data Centers (White Elephants) as Tax Evasion Scam/Ploy, Social Control Media Harms Boomers, "Microsoft Outage Hindered Ticket Issuance in Greece"
Links for the day
The Register MS Seems to Have Moved to 'The Cloud' (WeWork) After Shutting Down the Office
The Register MS will have a hard time explaining why it so passionately participated in the "hey hi" pyramid scheme
Holiday Plans (We Need More IBM Whistleblowers)
in particular with possession of material in relation to PIPs, NDAs, and silent RAs
After Microsoft Outage GNU/Linux Usage Leaps to 9% in the UK (Where Public Services Were Notoriously Overdependent on Microsoft Disservices)
in the UK we are extremely dependent on Microsoft stuff in the NHS, courts, law firms, police etc.
Richard Stallman Was Right About the Corruption of the Term "Artificial intelligence"
This will do severe damage to the administration which participated in the scam
The Dictatorship Already Working to Distract From NVIDIA Corruption and Slop Bubble Reaching Its Limits
Circular financing is simply a form of financial fraud
IBM Selling Itself, Piecewise, to Raise Money (to Pay Salaries)
IBM is a zombie waiting to inhale one last time (last breath)
"Allies" of Disgraced NVIDIA CEO Aren't About Morality, They're Just Covering Up Their Own Backs (and Loans)
The next stage is examining the false accounting (fraud basically)
No Outage Since 2023
I did host from home between 2020 and 2023
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXXII - Back Doors and Kill Switches From Microsoft Are Objectively Undesirable
"I dual-boot Omarchy and Windows. Be careful updating your BIOS. Mine made Omarchy unbootable."
Gemini Links 16/11/2026: Enjoyable Coding, Social Control Media Considered Harmful, and Recursive Rectangular Subdivision
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, November 15, 2026
IRC logs for Sunday, November 15, 2026
Cusp of Collapse
NVIDIA Corp (NASDAQ: NVDA) is set to open in the red tomorrow
Getting Fed Up Not Only With Microsoft But Also Windows
This morning we wrote about North America
Layoffs and Silent Layoffs (e.g. PIPs) as a "Break" From IBM
If the press doesn't report it, then it never happened, right?
Microsoft XBox at 25 and All-Time Low
XBox will be "officially" dead (not the brand) when sales fall below some threshold and then production is halted, sort of like Apple's Vision Pro
Links 15/11/2026: Microsoft Already Emitting Chaff to Distract From Its Catastrophe, Jensen Huang Deemed Just 'Fall Guy' Amid Collapse of the Pyramid Scheme
Links for the day
Gemini Links 15/11/2026: CD Players Live on and Self-Hosting from Home Fallacy
Links for the day
Techrights Hates Slop Bots
They benefit nobody
The Economy is Fine! (If Only for China!)
The future is slop! If not, then it's China's fault! It's "sabotaging" the "Western hey hi" in this "hey hi arms race!"
"IT" as "Musical Chairs" (on the Deck of The Titanic)
Each generation will get worse for "IT"
Salesforce in Trouble, Debt Nearly Quadrupled in 9 Months
Salesforce is perishing in a deep pool of debt
"Microsoft is Next IBM"
The words of a Microsoft insider and responses to that
IRC is Decentralised
Bye, Microsoft Teams/Skype
Links 15/11/2026: Murdoch's "WSJ Buries Stephen Miller's Racism" and "America Has Entered a New Age of Propaganda"
Links for the day
In the UK, GNU/Linux Usage Soared During Microsoft Downtime
since the massive outage GNU/Linux usage soared to over 10%
Google Slop About Richard Stallman Shows Stallman Was Right, LLMs are BS Generators
Google slop is the "new Google"
Spouse of Garrett Needs to Get "Several Firearms" to Feel Safe Amid Divorce (Garrett Has a "Girlfriend" Now)
Seems like Isis and my wife have a lot in common when it comes to Garrett
Vista 11 is Small
Can Microsoft survive the fall of Windows?
Six Richard Stallman and FSF Talks This Month (FSF Staff at Ohio State University)
Dr. Stallman's talks in Ecuador are well timed because of the collapse of the LLMs (slop) pyramid scheme
NVIDIA's Crisis Has Only Just began
NVIDIA Corp (NASDAQ: NVDA) is set to open in the red tomorrow
IBM Has Destroyed Red Hat and Hashicorp, Insiders Say It's the Usual From IBM:
Bluewashing is a death wave
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Saturday, November 14, 2026
IRC logs for Saturday, November 14, 2026
Techrights Was Right About Slop Destroying Development Communities and Projects
Slop does not improve your project. It kills the community. Without community, what is left? A 'botfarm'?
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXXI - Harassment Law and "Things Are Unfairly Asymmetric" (Exploring the Boundaries of Death Threats and Various Threats From America)
the sort of "technofascism" that our country must learn to confront rather than facilitate
Gemini Links 15/11/2026: "The Bastards Can Never Win" and "The Last Low-Tech Generation"
Links for the day
Links 14/11/2026: Wuhan Corruption and "Aid Isn’t Reaching Ebola’s Epicenter"
Links for the day
Rahul Kumar Has Turned tecadmin.net Into a Slopfarm That Promotes Slop and Microsoft (as Usual)
Slop promoting slop - a death knell of once-active "Linux" sites
Large-Scale Layoffs - Not Just PIPs - at Red Hat and IBM This Month
Mainstream media has quit covering mass layoffs
Links 14/11/2026: "The Claude Delusion" and "The Microsoft Outage is a Warning for the World"
Links for the day
Ethics in Perspective, Free Software and Morality
top clients of Jeffrey Epstein are one happy family
Richard Stallman (RMS) at Universidad Central del Ecuador (Guayaquil), Cuenca, Campus Sur Universidad Politecnica Salesiana (Quito), and Ohio State University
Long live the message and mission of RMS
They Paid Workers in 'Shares' (That Lost Almost Half Their Value in One Month)
Welcome back 1999 or 2007
The Register MS Made Millions of Pounds by Participating in the Slop Hype Campaign (It's Still Doing It), Now It Admits That It's Just a Bubble
the slop frenzy played a role in the Microsoft meltdown
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXX - Pyramid Schemes (Planned Plunder) and Canceled/Botched Surgeries Aren't "Funny", They Cause Serious Harm and Distress
We were right about Microsoft
Links 14/11/2026: "OpenAI Is Sustaining Enormous Losses" and Slop "Loses the Popular Vote"
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Friday, November 13, 2026
IRC logs for Friday, November 13, 2026
Gemini Links 14/11/2026: Code of Conduct, Back to Gemini, and Gemlog to Inbox
Links for the day