05.13.18

Three Weeks After Oil States the Patent Microcosm Has Already ‘Buried’ the Subject and 35 U.S.C. § 101 is Under Threat

Posted in America, Deception, Patents at 11:01 pm by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

Drinking their sorrows away

Patent Lawyers' Tears

Summary: The agenda of patent trolls, who are hoping to make Oil States go away, is well served by patent lawyers, who keep bringing up far less important (and far older) cases whose outcome better suited their financial interests

WILL THE USPTO take Oil States seriously? We asked this question ‘aloud’ in our last post. It’s the sort of thing that patent extremists hope the Office will just forget already. We took note of it in previous coverage about the Oil States decision, e.g. in:

Our prediction that patent maximalists would try to bury Oil States was largely correct. It’s barely even mentioned anymore (in sites dominated by law firms, except perhaps in new IAM ‘ads’, i.e. self-promotional pieces).

“Funny timing to bring up Alice all of a sudden (4 years after the decision and just days apart from Oil States).”To put it a little more bluntly, patent maximalists are still licking their wounds over Oil States — a decision that makes PTAB stronger and patents more limited in scope/magnitude. The patent microcosm generally promotes the next PTAB threats, namely cases like Droplets v Iancu or some class action ‘stunt’. They also push the SAS case, we noted about 24 hours ago in this advertisement for a ‘stacked panel’ event. “The panel will provide an analysis of the Court’s Oil States and SAS decisions and discuss the impact of these decisions on daily patent practice,” it says. Guess who’s on this panel…

“Watchtroll went back to writing about WesternGeco yesterday. It’s old.”Going back to April 24th (around the same time as the Oil States decision), mind what Workman Nydegger’s Brad Barger wrote: “Is Alice Coming Home From Wonderland? Finally Finding Direction in the Fairy Tale of 101 Jurisprudence”

Funny timing to bring up Alice all of a sudden (4 years after the decision and just days apart from Oil States). To quote:

In its 2014 decision, Alice v. CLS Bank, the Supreme Court dramatically reshaped the application of 35 U.S.C. § 101, which defines patent eligible subject matter. Much to the chagrin of inventors and patent practitioners around the world, the Supreme Court established a poorly defined test that the courts have struggled to apply in ways that result in consistent and predictable outcomes. The muddled rules and guidance provided by the courts have resulted in similarly inconsistent and unpredictable application of the law at the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO). Strong anecdotal and statistical differences in the application of Alice could be seen across different art units, between different examiners within the same art units, and even between different panels of the Federal Circuit.

Fortunately, it appears that the USPTO is now taking concrete steps to stabilize the application of the Alice by examiners within the USPTO. Much of this change at the USPTO appears to be driven by the appointment of Director Iancu. In a recent appearance before the Senate Judiciary Committee, Director Iancu testified that the USPTO was addressing the confusion related to Alice by “work[ing] to provide more concrete tests – to the extent possible given Supreme Court precedent – that guide examiners and the public toward finding the appropriate lines to draw with respect to eligible subject matter.”

Watchtroll went back to writing about WesternGeco yesterday. It’s old. Oil States not interesting anymore?

Oil States not interesting anymore?”Around the same time the patent microcosm (people who profit from lawsuits) also brought up the Kamstrup A/S case — one that we mentioned earlier this month. To quote:

In Apator Miitors ApS v. Kamstrup A/S, No. 2017-1681 (Fed. Cir. Apr. 17, 2018), the Federal Circuit affirmed the PTAB’s conclusion that Apator failed to swear behind a prior art reference, because Apator did not sufficiently corroborate the inventor’s testimony of conception prior to the reference’s filing date.

This was an important decision that serves to reaffirm PTAB’s authority, but it barely received any coverage.

Other sites of the patent microcosm wrote about a petition/case “seeking to invalidate [...] patent in a cannabis IPR currently pending before the PTAB.” To quote:

On this point, the PTAB recently conducted a trial and heard oral arguments from a canna-patent owner and a party seeking to invalidate that patent in a cannabis IPR currently pending before the PTAB. Specifically, IPR2017-00503 (previously flagged here) involves one of GW Pharma’s patents related to treating seizures with cannabidiol (CBD), the non-psychoactive cannabinoid found in the cannabis plant. GW Pharma is a British biopharmaceutical company known for its cannabis-based products, which it protects, in part, with its large cannabis-related patent portfolio (comprising around 100 patents and published applications in the U.S. alone), many of which are directed to treating diseases with cannabis-based compounds. GW Pharma is also currently pursuing FDA approval for its cannabinol drug for treatment of seizures and is well on its way to having the first drug derived from the cannabis plant approved in the U.S.

This is one of those cases where PTAB gets involved in disputes over patents on drugs, not software. We tend to focus on PTAB cases which involve Alice/§ 101.

“We tend to focus on PTAB cases which involve Alice/§ 101.”Speaking of § 101, on May 8th an interesting docket report came out from XpertUniverse, Inc. v Cisco Systems, Inc.

This is extraordinary especially because the Supreme Court (in Alice) changed patenting criteria in the US — serving to annul pretty much all software patents — but a jury relied on a very old ruling to deny justice:

The court granted plaintiff’s motion for summary judgment that defendant’s challenge under 35 U.S.C. § 101 was barred by collateral estoppel because a jury found the patent-in-suit valid in the parties’ prior action.

They’re alluding to 2012: “There is no evidence that a Section 101 defense was completely unavailable to [defendant] under the framework set out in [Mayo Collaborative Servs. v. Prometheus Labs., Inc., 132 S. Ct. 1282 (2012)], or that such a challenge would have been futile prior to Alice.”

“Speaking to people in the jury in technical terms won’t help; it often just confuses them and it makes it easier for lawyers to manipulate them.”This is why we oppose patent trials by juries, who are typically nontechnical and incapable of grasping the underlying claims in patents. Jury trials are OK for particular things that everyday newspapers cover (e.g. petty crime), but patents? Speaking to people in the jury in technical terms won’t help; it often just confuses them and it makes it easier for lawyers to manipulate them.

To say more on § 101, Gary Cohen, Mark Nowotarski and Trent Ostler did some propaganda on it half a week ago. We don’t want to delve into every single sentence and paragraph (in effect amplifying them), so we’ll just say that when Watchtroll uses terms like “Surviving Alice” it is basically perpetuating the bogus narrative that people with bogus patents that they often use to scam people into paying ‘protection’ money are actually the victims, trying to merely “survive” in court. It’s them who file the lawsuits!

Share in other sites/networks: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Reddit
  • email

This post is also available in Gemini over at:

gemini://gemini.techrights.org/2018/05/13/oil-states-scotus-decoy/

If you liked this post, consider subscribing to the RSS feed or join us now at the IRC channels.

Pages that cross-reference this one

What Else is New


  1. Links 25/2/2021: RHEL for Open-Source Infrastructure, GNOME 40 Beta, LXPanel 0.10.1

    Links for the day



  2. IBM and Qt Don't Understand Free Software and They Now Impose Terms and Conditions on Who Qualifies for Use of Free Software Free of Charge

    IBM and Qt Don't Understand Free Software and They Now Impose Terms and Conditions on Who Qualifies for Use of Free Software Free of Charge



  3. Techrights Gemini Capsule, Now With Over 35,000 Pages and Files

    Blog posts combined with static (plain text) files are now 36,000+ in number, just for Gemini protocol alone; that number keeps growing as our conversion proceeds and evolves (our software will be released under terms of the AGPLv3)



  4. Eventually, or Hopefully, Many People Will Come Back to What the Web Used to Be (Or Web Alternatives More Like the 'Old' Web)

    With RSS feeds making a comeback and a resurgence of personal blogs we can take back the Web from a cabal of tech/Internet giants and social control media, censored, curated and spied on by oligarchy



  5. If Wikipedia is Controlled by Corporations and Mobs, It Needs to Be 'Cancelled'

    Facts have never truly mattered in social control media sites; it certainly seems as though Wikipedia now suffers the very same issue/deficit, allowing oligarchs and their companies to define what goes on in the world and which people Wikipedia should regard as persona non grata



  6. GNU/Linux Reaffirms Its Status as the Universal and Inter-planetary Operating System

    The operating system made for and by scientists (not business sharks and marketing cults) is winning the battle, and not only in this planet



  7. IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, February 24, 2021

    IRC logs for Wednesday, February 24, 2021



  8. Links 25/2/2021: Kali Linux 2021.1, Wine Launcher 1.4.46, and Google's Security Posing

    Links for the day



  9. Links 24/2/2021: MariaDB 10.5.9, Krita 4.4.3 Beta, and Debuginfod Server for Debian

    Links for the day



  10. Self-Host Your Videos, Take Full Advantage of HTML5 and Video Attributes

    For self-hosting of videos over the World Wide Web (Gemini too can handle videos; its clients/browsers can, for example, link video files/URLs to external media players) it's worth reviewing the full set of features made available by the standards because a lot can be accomplished without JavaScript and without unnecessary bloat/complexity



  11. Trying Out NoiseTorch to Reduce Background Sound/Noise in GNU/Linux

    An introduction to noisetorch (or NoiseTorch), an application that helps create virtual microphones/devices with reduced background noise



  12. How the Big Banks and OIN Can Whitewash Software Patents and Do Nothing Concrete About Patent Trolls

    Response to the puff piece entitled "How the Big Banks and OIN Can Lock Out Patent Trolls with Enabled Publications"



  13. IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, February 23, 2021

    IRC logs for Tuesday, February 23, 2021



  14. How to Set Up a Gemini Server of Your Own, Even on a Simple Single-Board Computer

    Using Agate to start one's own Gemini capsule (self-hosted) is a lot simpler than one might be inclined to believe; this is a detailed HOWTO, hoping to encourage more people to join Gemini space, which is fast-growing and free of garbage



  15. Links 23/2/2021: Tails 4.16, Libinput 1.17, Fwupd 1.5.7, Firefox 86, NeoChat 1.1

    Links for the day



  16. The Word Master is Not Problematic in Most Contexts and Its Origin Hasn't a Connection to Slavery

    Slavery is to the word "master" mostly disconnected; it might, however, be closely connected in the minds of racists or the agenda of highly racist corporations (profiting from racism) that look for ways to distract from their racism



  17. On Misapplication, Misuse, Overuse and Abuse of Words (to Suit False Narratives)

    It is looking like the word "abuse" has been extended to basically mean all sorts of things including the act of actually exposing real abuse



  18. The Administrative Council Needs to Fix the EPO While It's Still Possible

    EPO staff and former staff (pensioners) aren't happy and the it's the responsibility of the Administrative Council to do something before it's too late (the reputation of the Office is already severely harmed and it's unable/unwilling to recruit suitable and qualified people, both as examiners and managers, respectively)



  19. 'These Questions Remain Unanswered': Campinos Became Battistelli Just Halfway Through His Term

    The Central Staff Committee of the EPO highlights the grim situation or the deadlock reached after totally dysfunctional Office management somehow managed to kill off channels of communication, in effect going back to where things were back in 2018 under Battistelli



  20. 'The One Percent': Salary Adjustment Procedure (SAP) Supported Only by 1% of EPO Staff

    Out of 2,237 EPO workers who expressed their position on the SAP, which in essence lowers their salary, only 31 expressed support for it (that's 1.385%)



  21. IRC Proceedings: Monday, February 22, 2021

    IRC logs for Monday, February 22, 2021



  22. DDOS Attacks and Decentralisation

    Our server, which is shared among sites, has been under persistent distributed denial of service (DDOS) attacks almost every day in recent weeks, culminating in much worse attacks last night, but we're not too worried anymore



  23. Links 23/2/2021: Gemini (and Gopher) on the Rise Again, Systemd 248 Reaches RC1

    Links for the day



  24. On the Terms Master, Main and Abuse

    Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock



  25. Microsoft Inside — Part IV: Microsoft Everywhere, Looking to Poach Developers, Not Disclosing What It Really Wants

    As it turns out, just about everyone looking to recruit for a Microsoft-connected project/company (working on Raspberry Pi, Ubuntu etc.) near Microsoft is 'former' Microsoft, but people who are being approached aren't being told so, at least not upfront; those are very familiar and old tactics, which merit a word of caution to all



  26. Microsoft: We Ain't Done Until Raspberry Pi Won't Run (Anything But Our Proprietary Software With 'Telemetry' Surveillance)

    The ongoing series which we started yesterday and still publish today (about Microsoft recruiters) shows that Microsoft has rather toxic ambitions and the general idea is to infect everything with Microsoft, even the things that compete against Microsoft



  27. Controlling the Conduct of Large Corporations (and Monopolies) Would Help Tackle Disproportionate and Asymmetric Power Structures

    A "CoC" (Code of Conduct) is often crafted or drafted with good intentions; but with enforcement put in the wrong hands it is a tool of corporate oppression instead of protection of people's dignity



  28. Another Reason to Boycott Microsoft/GitHub: The War on Reverse-Engineering

    The high-profile fan-made reverse-engineering efforts are being proactively censored by Microsoft on behalf of another company (without as much as due process), reaffirming the problematic nature of GitHub, a monopoly that represses Free software developers



  29. Links 22/2/2021: Lots More About Linux on Mars, Release of 4MLinux 35.2

    Links for the day



  30. Microsoft Inside — Part III: Microsoft Finds Out That Free Software Developers Don't Want to Work for Microsoft on Microsoft Platforms

    The attempts to poach high-profile Free software and GNU/Linux developers aren't succeeding, especially once it turns out who's really behind those attempts (they don't give it away upfront)


RSS 64x64RSS Feed: subscribe to the RSS feed for regular updates

Home iconSite Wiki: You can improve this site by helping the extension of the site's content

Home iconSite Home: Background about the site and some key features in the front page

Chat iconIRC Channel: Come and chat with us in real time

Recent Posts