Bonum Certa Men Certa

EPO Looney Tunes - Part 1: Is D-Day Approaching for Battistelli’s “Difficult Legacy”?

A four-part mini series about EBA referral G 2/19

EPO toons



"The European Patent Office is an executive organisation, it deals especially with patent applicants, as such, its view of the world may be biased. As an executive organisation, its interpretative powers are very limited. The European Patent Convention excludes computer programs, it is outside the EPO's power to change this. The exclusion of computer programs is a political question. [...] The core task of a computer is to process data. So at least the processing of data is not patentable."

--Ante Wessels, FFII



Summary: European patent justice isn't working within the premises of EPOnia; a bunch of 'show trials' may in fact turn out to be just that -- a show

THIS series about the European Patent Office (EPO) comes from someone who prefers to remain anonymous. It is a series by a guest author. This author has a lot of credibility based on a track record of high accuracy.



"EPO Looney Tunes," the author explains, is "a four-part mini-series exploring Battistelli's "difficult legacy" and the Enlarged Board of Appeal referral case G 2/19 which is scheduled for a hearing in the main EPO Isar Building today (Tuesday, 16 July 2019)."

The Enlarged Board of Appeal (EBA) is very important (a decade ago it dealt with questions like software patentability in Europe and I sent it a letter about it). There are similar things in the United States (dealing with 35 U.S.C. €§ 101 at the Office) and elsewhere in Europe, e.g. in EUIPO (previous home of António Campinos). Yesterday the following comment was left in IP Kat: "I note that I am not permitted to post obscene or defamatory comments, or to post ad hominem (or, I presume, ad feminam) attacks on members of the blog team or other posters. Moreover, the IPKat team will moderate my comments before they are published. This seems perfectly reasonable to me. What I do not understand is that the USPTO should be less privileged in this respect than the IPKat. David T. Keeling (former EUIPO Board of Appeal member, rapporteur in the SCREW YOU case, not rapporteur in the FUCKING HELL case)..."

Assuming that's really him, it's funny that he takes note of IP Kat censorship -- a subject we explored/revisited at least twice earlier this month. Notice how IP Kat quit covering the attacks on EBA a couple of years ago (after some people had left the blog and the EPO temporarily blocked the whole blog). EBA has since then complained, publicly even, about its lack of independence. Will any of that change any time soon (under Campinos)? Will the EPO change at all? Yesterday the EPO tweeted: "The EPO's success is based on the expertise of its highly skilled staff."

"The EPO already drove away all the best staff," I responded. "So now it can grant loads of fake patents and underpay the staff."

We also recently noted here that examiners are bound by the decisions (e.g. interpretations of the EPC) of the Boards of Appeal, including EBA. So it's highly crucial that independence gets restored. Without it, quality of patents will continue to suffer if not fall even further. With that in mind, here comes part 1.




Back in March of this year, JUVE reported on a case which had been referred to the Enlarged Board of Appeal, the highest judicial instance at the EPO, in a move which was said to put Battistelli's “difficult legacy” to the test.

The “difficult legacy” referred to here was the banishment of the Boards of Appeal to a new premises in Haar, an independent municipality on the outskirts of Munich.

The question as to whether oral proceedings could lawfully be held in Haar was raised by Aachen patent attorney€ Hans-Dieter Jostarndt, following objections raised by third parties during the granting procedure of EP 2 378 735.

The disputed patent relates to a technology for operating a mobile phone network and it belongs to IPCom, a well-known - some might say “notorious” - patent-holding company or “non-practicing entity”, which is a common euphemism for a patent troll.

One of the leading patent trolls in Germany, IPCom was established by the flamboyant Munich patent attorney, Bernhard Frohwitter, and it lays claim to a portfolio of over 1,200 patents, many of which were acquired from Bosch. It has been active in the business of trying to “shake-down” big telecom companies since 2008 or thereabouts.

In the course of the proceedings in the case of EP 2378 735,€ Jostarndt requested that an oral hearing scheduled for 25 January should be moved to the seat of the EPO in Munich because “Haar is obviously not intended in the EPC as a place for acts and negotiations.”

The Technical Board of Appeal dealing with the case decided to refer the matter to the Enlarged Board of Appeal.

Oral proceedings are scheduled to be held in the main EPO Isar building on Tuesday, 16 July 2019.

The hearing will be public so anybody who is interested can attend.

One of the questions on the agenda is whether an EPO Appeals Board can lawfully hold oral proceedings in Haar “if the appellant objects to this site as not being in conformity with the EPC and requests that the oral proceedings be held in Munich instead?”

Despite the excitement which the case has generated inside the EPO, observers are cautioning that it may all turn out to be a bit of an anti-climax because the question about Haar’s conformity with the EPC is preceded by two other questions which concern the admissibility of the legal action itself.

Should the Enlarged Board decide that the appeal is inadmissible, then it will not need to consider the “Haar question”.

In that case, the issue of Haar’s conformity with the EPC would remain unresolved and would be likely to fester on in the background until it resurfaces in a future proceedings.

While we are waiting for the Enlarged Board to make up its mind on referral G 2/19, it seems like a good time to take a peek behind the scenes and have a closer look at the background and some of the personalities involved in the case.

The next installment will follow shortly… ⬆

Recent Techrights' Posts

The Real News About the White House (Not the 'Exclusive' Rupert Murdoch Published for It at Midnight Monday) is Complicity in NVIDIA Fraud
They need a distraction from commercial malpractice
I Tried Linux Again After 10 Years - Here's What Blew My Mind
It's like leaving your hometown as a teenager and coming back to find the weird kid from high school is now the mayor
 
IBM and OSI Said opensource.net Would Replace opensource.com, But It Has Been Dead for 1.5 Years and the Person Who Had Made Promises Left OSI
Over a year ago he left
Red Hat and IBM Meet Targets (of Pushing People Out)
now there are claims of security breach inside IBM, but no press reports related to that
Gemini Links 17/11/2026: Reading Clocks and StreetComplete
Links for the day
Buy Influence "Over Dinner With The Register."
The Register MS is the facilitator or 'pimp'
While the Slop Industry Wobbles The Register MS Bags Tens of Thousands of Pounds to Publish Propaganda With "AI" 23 Times in It
The Register MS is selling its reputation away
Links 16/11/2026: Microsoft Increases Indian Clown Computing Prices by 15%, Meta Fined $887 Million in Italy
Links for the day
Gemini Links 16/11/2026: Container Gardening, Laughing at an LLM, "EU 72-Hour Guidelines Through a Lawyer's Eyes"
Links for the day
Links 16/11/2026: Data Centers (White Elephants) as Tax Evasion Scam/Ploy, Social Control Media Harms Boomers, "Microsoft Outage Hindered Ticket Issuance in Greece"
Links for the day
The Register MS Seems to Have Moved to 'The Cloud' (WeWork) After Shutting Down the Office
The Register MS will have a hard time explaining why it so passionately participated in the "hey hi" pyramid scheme
Holiday Plans (We Need More IBM Whistleblowers)
in particular with possession of material in relation to PIPs, NDAs, and silent RAs
After Microsoft Outage GNU/Linux Usage Leaps to 9% in the UK (Where Public Services Were Notoriously Overdependent on Microsoft Disservices)
in the UK we are extremely dependent on Microsoft stuff in the NHS, courts, law firms, police etc.
Richard Stallman Was Right About the Corruption of the Term "Artificial intelligence"
This will do severe damage to the administration which participated in the scam
The Dictatorship Already Working to Distract From NVIDIA Corruption and Slop Bubble Reaching Its Limits
Circular financing is simply a form of financial fraud
IBM Selling Itself, Piecewise, to Raise Money (to Pay Salaries)
IBM is a zombie waiting to inhale one last time (last breath)
"Allies" of Disgraced NVIDIA CEO Aren't About Morality, They're Just Covering Up Their Own Backs (and Loans)
The next stage is examining the false accounting (fraud basically)
No Outage Since 2023
I did host from home between 2020 and 2023
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXXII - Back Doors and Kill Switches From Microsoft Are Objectively Undesirable
"I dual-boot Omarchy and Windows. Be careful updating your BIOS. Mine made Omarchy unbootable."
Gemini Links 16/11/2026: Enjoyable Coding, Social Control Media Considered Harmful, and Recursive Rectangular Subdivision
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, November 15, 2026
IRC logs for Sunday, November 15, 2026
Cusp of Collapse
NVIDIA Corp (NASDAQ: NVDA) is set to open in the red tomorrow
Getting Fed Up Not Only With Microsoft But Also Windows
This morning we wrote about North America
Layoffs and Silent Layoffs (e.g. PIPs) as a "Break" From IBM
If the press doesn't report it, then it never happened, right?
Microsoft XBox at 25 and All-Time Low
XBox will be "officially" dead (not the brand) when sales fall below some threshold and then production is halted, sort of like Apple's Vision Pro
Links 15/11/2026: Microsoft Already Emitting Chaff to Distract From Its Catastrophe, Jensen Huang Deemed Just 'Fall Guy' Amid Collapse of the Pyramid Scheme
Links for the day
Gemini Links 15/11/2026: CD Players Live on and Self-Hosting from Home Fallacy
Links for the day
When Short is Way Too Short (Superficiality, Lowering of Entropy)
Demonstrating how truly worthless social control media was all along
Techrights Hates Slop Bots
They benefit nobody
The Economy is Fine! (If Only for China!)
The future is slop! If not, then it's China's fault! It's "sabotaging" the "Western hey hi" in this "hey hi arms race!"
"IT" as "Musical Chairs" (on the Deck of The Titanic)
Each generation will get worse for "IT"
Salesforce in Trouble, Debt Nearly Quadrupled in 9 Months
Salesforce is perishing in a deep pool of debt
"Microsoft is Next IBM"
The words of a Microsoft insider and responses to that
IRC is Decentralised
Bye, Microsoft Teams/Skype
Links 15/11/2026: Murdoch's "WSJ Buries Stephen Miller's Racism" and "America Has Entered a New Age of Propaganda"
Links for the day
In the UK, GNU/Linux Usage Soared During Microsoft Downtime
since the massive outage GNU/Linux usage soared to over 10%
Google Slop About Richard Stallman Shows Stallman Was Right, LLMs are BS Generators
Google slop is the "new Google"
Spouse of Garrett Needs to Get "Several Firearms" to Feel Safe Amid Divorce (Garrett Has a "Girlfriend" Now)
Seems like Isis and my wife have a lot in common when it comes to Garrett
Vista 11 is Small
Can Microsoft survive the fall of Windows?
Six Richard Stallman and FSF Talks This Month (FSF Staff at Ohio State University)
Dr. Stallman's talks in Ecuador are well timed because of the collapse of the LLMs (slop) pyramid scheme
NVIDIA's Crisis Has Only Just began
NVIDIA Corp (NASDAQ: NVDA) is set to open in the red tomorrow
IBM Has Destroyed Red Hat and Hashicorp, Insiders Say It's the Usual From IBM:
Bluewashing is a death wave
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Saturday, November 14, 2026
IRC logs for Saturday, November 14, 2026
Techrights Was Right About Slop Destroying Development Communities and Projects
Slop does not improve your project. It kills the community. Without community, what is left? A 'botfarm'?
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXXI - Harassment Law and "Things Are Unfairly Asymmetric" (Exploring the Boundaries of Death Threats and Various Threats From America)
the sort of "technofascism" that our country must learn to confront rather than facilitate
Gemini Links 15/11/2026: "The Bastards Can Never Win" and "The Last Low-Tech Generation"
Links for the day