07.16.20

The EPO’s Corruption is Like a Cancer That Has Spread to and Infected the EU as Well

Posted in Deception, Europe, Patents at 9:52 pm by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

Battistelli-Breton photo-op

Summary: With Breton inside the Commission what we’re basically seeing is the EPO cabal speaking on behalf of the EU as well, spreading falsehoods and promoting illegal, unconstitutional agenda in defiance of judges and Justices

I have never come across anything quite like this. Right in the middle of Europe — in the reputable Bavaria no less! — there’s a sort of Mediterranean ‘Mafia’ running a ‘racket’ of sorts…

How was this allowed to happen? Why is nobody putting an end to it?

“How was this allowed to happen? Why is nobody putting an end to it?”Well, behind the smokescreen of EPO-funded fluff* there’s something rather horrific and sinister going on. I, as a longtime proponent of the EU, am horrified to see the EU becoming an extender of EPO corruption. They don’t care about the law and about facts, let alone constitutions. Corruption and illegalities rage on. Having added an update to our previous post about this (with Bristows jumping in, parroting Breton), I now see Myles Jelf (Bristows) jumping in to say:

As well as the issue of the UPC’s central division, other concerns were expressed about the unitary patent and UPC system going ahead without the UK, including:

- the system will be less attractive without coverage of the UK;

- the UPC procedure includes clear features of English legal procedure, yet the only participating country with a similar procedure will be Ireland;

- the expertise of UK judges will not be available, and UK lawyers will not be able to participate;

- English still being the main language; and

- the financial implications for the remaining participating countries.

Why on Earth does the German injustice minister carry on with this Big Lie? It’s going to completely discredit the German government while quite likely having zero effect on the death of the UPC. Facts aren’t on the UPCA’s side. They just aren’t.

And now the EU as well. With Benoît Battistelli's buddy speaking for the EU/EC, it’s bound to become a total embarrassment. Look no further than all the comments in this ongoing thread. All of them.

“It’s going to completely discredit the German government while quite likely having zero effect on the death of the UPC.”Jan Van Hoey said: “Time for Boris to pull the plug and send its notification to the secretariat of the Council of the EU. That’s what Mr Tillman was suggesting in its previous interview. It is also strange to consider agreements not into force part of “Union law”…”

Benjamin Henrion has been saying something similar (it’s in our IRC logs).

MaxDrei then wrote: “Talk about deja vu. In the UK, in the run up to BREXIT, HMG flying on auto-pilot, deposited its instrument of accession to the UPCA. Now, the EU Commission, another craft flying on auto-pilot, happily announces that it would “welcome” ratification of the UPCA by Germany. Sometimes the ship, sailing on its pre-set course, is so enormous that it takes years to change course. Somebody on the bridge has first to issue an authoritative command. Those underlings who are responsible for Press Releases have no authority to do anything else but state what course the ocean-going liner is proceeding along.”

“Concerned observer” is the latest to weigh in:

Well, the only way to describe that response is that is uses carefully selected language to make statements that, whilst not strictly untrue, are highly misleading.

Most misleading of all is the statement that “participation in that system, including the Unified Patent Court Agreement, is only open to EU Member States”. The trouble with this is that termination the UK’s membership of the EU does NOT automatically terminate the UK’s participation in the UPC Agreement. Whilst Mr Tilmann has (rather dubiously, in my opinion) suggested that a notification from the UK would serve to terminate its participation in the UPCA, not even he has suggested any plausible mechanism under the Vienna Convention for AUTOMATIC termination of the UK’s participation at the end of the transitional period.

There has certainly not been any “notification” from the UK to the other Participating Member States of the UPCA. Thus, the problem with the UPCA remains that the UK will be (and, arguably, already is) a “third country” under EU law. In this sense, Mr Breton’s response simply does not address the legal issue underlying Mr Breyer’s question. Whilst extremely disappointing, this is hardly surprising … given the level of “political” support for the UPCA at the EU level.

It remains to be seen whether national courts (such as the BVerfG) will be persuaded by such misleading responses. In my experience, courts tend not to be so easily misled. Also, given that Germany is proposing to ratify the UPCA by relying upon arguments that happen to work very nicely for their legal profession (by effectively dividing between Munich and Paris cases that would have gone to London), it remains to be seen whether the other Participating Member States (such as Italy) can be persuaded that this is acceptable. Whilst various carrots and sticks will no doubt be deployed, I doubt that it will be so easy to persuade all of the PMSs.

Finally, I have my doubts about Jan’s suggestion that the UK should formally withdraw from the UPCA. Recent years have seen many highly dubious (and sometimes contradictory) legal theories wheeled out to keep the UPCA “alive”. In this respect, I have no doubt that Mr Tilmann would find some way of arguing the UK’s formal withdrawal would not prevent the UPCA from coming into force. No doubt he would also concoct some arguments for salvaging the associated Protocols (on Provisional Application and Privileges and Immunities), regardless of the fact that those explicitly call for ratification by the UK…

This is pretty much the consensus if one asks anybody except Team UPC as “more than 71.4 % of judges no longer support the UPC,” based on a recent survey from JUVE.

“With Benoît Battistelli’s buddy speaking for the EU/EC, it’s bound to become a total embarrassment.”A scholar has written to us about this, seeking to participate by expressing concerns about the campaign of Team UPC.

“Hi Roy,” said the message, noting “that the matter is urgent as many sources confirm that Germany can ratify UPCA and they will try to push it through rather than risk a renegotiation.”

Regarding getting people involved in this: “In the constitutional law quarters, academics are more independent and open minded, especially those specialising in human rights, but they do not understand patent law at all.

“A lot of it can be traced back to the EPO and failure to regulate the EPO (or have effective oversight) basically dooms many institutions around it, including ILO.”“There is a recent feedback initiative from the Commission on the future of IP. [...] As things stand at present, the matter is a bit urgent and if Germany does not manage to have its way, the UPC legislative package must re-open [...] The moment is critical. [...] we need to get politicians to re-open the negotiations on the UPC and UPCA. [...] at the same time, we need to get politicians to re-open the negotiations on the UPC and UPCA.”

Keep an eye on this space. There might be further formal action quite soon. We cannot specify the details just yet, but Team UPC is vaguely aware. It’s truly a shame that all this corruption has touched the German government and the EU; the aftermath or the consequence will simply erode public confidence in these institutions. A lot of it can be traced back to the EPO and failure to regulate the EPO (or have effective oversight) basically dooms many institutions around it, including ILO.
____
* The latest nonsense comes from Watchtroll (“IPWatchdog”), e.g. “‘Not a Field of Giants’: Trends in 3D Printing Tech Include Key Contributions from US,” and Machinery that bases its ‘reporting’ on “European intellectual property firm, Withers & Rogers.” It’s an EPO parrot; to quote: “Highlighting the UK’s position as a European hub for innovation in 3D printing, the report revealed the city of Derby at number seven in a ranking of 15 major European innovation centres for AM technologies, with Munich, Barcelona and Zurich taking the top positions.” They’re reusing these talking points, extracted from the EPO’s own ‘script’. Real journalism is dead/dying.

Share in other sites/networks: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Reddit
  • email

This post is also available in Gemini over at:

gemini://gemini.techrights.org/2020/07/16/epo-cancer-inside-eu/

If you liked this post, consider subscribing to the RSS feed or join us now at the IRC channels.

Pages that cross-reference this one

What Else is New


  1. Links 22/4/2021: virt-viewer 10.0, PipeWire 0.3.26, LibreELEC (Matrix) 10.0 Beta 2

    Links for the day



  2. Links 22/4/2021: Ubuntu Release, KDE Gear 21.04, GNU/Linux on MacBooks

    Links for the day



  3. GNU/Linux Turns 38 This Year, But the (Partly) Microsoft-Led Linux Foundation Wants You to Think It's Only 30 and a Good Friend of Microsoft

    What the Linux Foundation calls “Linux” (as its PR staff members refer to it in their new press release) is 38 years old, not 30. “Open Source” as a term did not formally exist yet, so this latest waffle makes no sense at all (the press release keeps mentioning a term that’s designed to attack and replace the original). But it’s part of a broader pattern of deception, attacking software freedom and pretending GNU never existed. Did money corrupt everything and is it too late to salvage truth, let alone freedom?



  4. Richard Stallman on Paid Smear Campaigns

    Dr. Richard Stallman on people who lie about him online (4 years after the older campaign of hate and distortion and half a decade before the current one, coordinated by groups funded by monopolies that dislike GPL)



  5. Links 22/4/2021: Grafana Goes for AGPLv3, Godot 3.3 Released, Mesa 21.0.3 Available

    Links for the day



  6. IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, April 21, 2021

    IRC logs for Wednesday, April 21, 2021



  7. Behind the Curtains of Cheap and Cheesy PR the EPO is a Machine of Oppression (Against Its Very Own Staff), Tribunal to Rule on Strike Busting

    The laughable regime of Campinos is a naked emperor with nothing but diplomatic immunity (almost not a single member of staff trusts the President) and the PR strategic front is becoming worse than pathetic; it's like the place is run by infantile career-climbing sociopaths with no qualifications, trying to weaponise a sea of money against staff, inquisitive media, and states (by bribing them or hiring lawyers to intimidate/bankrupt them); while the EPO still swims in money its reputation drowns too quickly to ever resurface, recover



  8. Links 21/4/2021: University of Minnesota Blacklisted Over Defects, Red Hat Satellite 6.9 is Out

    Links for the day



  9. Links 21/4/2021: VirtualBox 6.1.20, GCC 11.1 Release Candidate, Nginx 1.20.0

    Links for the day



  10. IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, April 20, 2021

    IRC logs for Tuesday, April 20, 2021



  11. Some People Who Asked to Be Removed From the Slanderous Hate Letter Against the FSF Are Still Being Denied Removal (But Not All)

    I am aware of some people (evidence is in the public domain for all to see) who asked to be removed from the hate list; their requests have not yet been processed, or simply denied. Maybe they should ask again. There are silent and selective changes.



  12. Overt Abuse and Mischaracterisations by Bully de Blanc

    The campaign to ruin the FSF and silence its founder, Richard M. Stallman (RMS), goes months prior to the hate letter set up by Bully de Blanc, her boss, and the Microsoft-sponsored OSI; they just attack the licence (GPL/copyleft) and they try to redefine things for the corporations which fund them



  13. According to StatCounter, This Month GNU/Linux Market Share on Desktops/Laptops Exceeded 2% (Based on Sites They Monitor)

    StatCounter does not monitor everything and not every machine connects to the Web, but in relative terms, based on the chart above, no doubt GNU/Linux continues growing relative to other operating systems (chart plotted based on the latest raw data, rendered in LibreOffice Calc)



  14. At the EPO, Lawlessness Has Become “a New Normal”

    Without as much as a real consultation with those who are impacted (by the EPO's gross infringements) the management of the EPO rushes ahead again, enjoying zero oversight, no legal review, and no accountability or scrutiny of any kind



  15. Links 20/4/2021: Tails 4.18 and Mark Surman in Mozilla's Board of Directors

    Links for the day



  16. Microsoft as a Censorship Machine Working to Undermine Free Software and Code Sharing (Also Sharing in General)

    Microsoft is, as usual, a tool of destruction rather than creation; it seems to be better at ruining things and censoring things, notably things that compete against Microsoft or pose a threat to Microsoft's business model (and close partners, such as RIAA)



  17. Phoronix Needs to Exercise Caution and Stay Vigilant/Careful of Microsoft

    Taking note or lessons from the blunder of Raspberry Pi (back in February), Phoronix should be careful of Microsoft 'freebies' as they're never free and there are strings attached, destined to alienate longtime supporters



  18. IRC Proceedings: Monday, April 19, 2021

    IRC logs for Monday, April 19, 2021



  19. Links 20/4/2021: EasyOS Dunfell 2.7.1, Phoronix Takes Microsoft 'Freebies', Microsoft Trying to Steal Credit for Linux on Mars

    Links for the day



  20. Richard Stallman on How UPC is a Trojan Horse for Software Patents in Europe

    Dr. Richard Stallman, the Free Software Foundation's founder, offers his analysis of the Unitary Patent (or UPC) and what it means for software patents in Europe now that the EPO increases its influence over continental law



  21. Technology Can Make Life Worse, Even in the Public Sector, Not Just the Private Sector

    There are growing concerns — increasingly justified concerns as a matter of fact — that customer service is universally going away and “COVID” has become the impenetrable shield or a cover in the face of facts, laws, and basic rights



  22. Links 19/4/2021: LibreSSL 3.3.2, OpenSSH 8.6, Firefox 88

    Links for the day



  23. Time to Move to Gemini, Wherever/Whenever Possible, as the World Wide Web is a Burden on Everybody

    A 30-minute rant about what the Web has become and the promise of gemini:// (designed to simplify everything, enable self-hosting, preserve privacy, and empower communities rather than military-connected monopolies)



  24. The Number of Signatures in the Anti-FSF Petition is Decreasing, Not Increasing

    A reader has notified Techrights that belatedly, perhaps where people’s job is at risk (we’ve heard of stories and situations wherein the employer’s view and a worker’s view diverge), the GNOME Foundation/OSI did in fact remove some people from the hate letter they had set up for their monopolistic sponsors. We do, however, still see some names in there of people who asked to be removed, so it must be a very selective process. They don’t want to lose face, so they must have made it very difficult to revoke one’s name. Exceptional circumstances? We have checked to confirm, based on the available archives, and indeed that number decreased since 10 days ago, whereas 6,415 people have thus far signed the support letter (it's still growing), so we’ve just re-plotted the chart.



  25. IRC Proceedings: Sunday, April 18, 2021

    IRC logs for Sunday, April 18, 2021



  26. How Many People Developed GNU (Maybe Hundreds) in the 1980s

    Dr. Richard Stallman, the Free Software Foundation's founder, explains how code was managed and contributed in the early days of GNU



  27. Links 19/4/2021: Linux 5.12 RC8, GNU Poke 1.2, EndeavourOS 2021.04

    Links for the day



  28. Proprietary Software (BT Hub) Has Ruined My Whole Day

    While we did have some plans to publish long articles, those plans were curtailed or at least delayed due to the fact our sole device at home not to be controlled by us (a so-called 'Smart' Hub from BT) decided to break itself and by doing so bring productivity to a standstill (that firmware update, silently installed without notice or any form of consent, managed to screw with the local network)



  29. IRC Proceedings: Saturday, April 17, 2021

    IRC logs for Saturday, April 17, 2021



  30. Tolerating the Intolerant and Lacking Tolerance for Opposing Views

    The person who shouted...


RSS 64x64RSS Feed: subscribe to the RSS feed for regular updates

Home iconSite Wiki: You can improve this site by helping the extension of the site's content

Home iconSite Home: Background about the site and some key features in the front page

Chat iconIRC Channel: Come and chat with us in real time

Recent Posts