Bonum Certa Men Certa

EPO Staff Explains That With Phony 'Quality Audits' the EPO is "in Breach of the EPC" (European Patent Convention) and Patent Examiners Are Compelled to Act in Breach of the EPC

posted by Roy Schestowitz on Feb 09, 2024,
updated Feb 09, 2024

Crime Scene Do Not Cross

The Central Staff Committee at the EPO has a new paper. It concerns patent quality again and thus - inter alia - it concerns European software patents.

It is no secret that Benoît Battistelli and António Campinos are well aware that they illegally grant patents for the sole purpose of making and gambling with more money. There's paper trail for all this.

Yesterday the Central Staff Committee said to staff:

Dear Colleagues,

The Directorate Quality Audit consists of examiners and formalities officers. DQA samples patent applications at grant or search stage from the Patent Workbench for quality audit. The auditors perform the checks and send the outcome by email to the competent Examining Division. The outcome is sent to the Examining Division both if the audit criteria are met and if deficiencies are found.

On 11 December 2023, the three Vice-Presidents of DG1, DG4 and DG5 issued Internal Procedural Instructions updating the DQA workflow.

The newly planned involvement of “line managers” and of the “DG1 independent review panel” is particularly worrying as they have disciplinary powers, reporting authority and play a decisive role in the career advancement of the members of Examining Division under the new career system. The new workflow is hence of highly questionable legality which jeopardizes the “three-man examining divisions”.

From what we can gather, this paper of theirs is less than a day old or was published less than a day ago, disseminated through members of staff by hacking around illegal censorship by the Office (the EPO continues to not obey a court ruling successfully challenging this censorship).

Here's the publication from the EPO's own staff, presented in the form of HTML, plain text, and GemText. These people know the matter best:

Zentraler Personalausschuss
Central Staff Committee
Le Comité Central du Personnel

Munich, 08-02-2024
sc24009cp

Quality Audits

What is DQA?
The Directorate Quality Audit consists of examiners and formalities officers. DQA samples patent applications at grant or search stage from the Patent Workbench for quality audit. The auditors perform the checks and send the outcome by email to the competent Examining Division. The outcome is sent to the Examining Division both if the audit criteria are met and if deficiencies are found.

The EPO Quality Report features statistics on the grant and search audit results. The latest from 2022 show (p. 46 and 38) 76% compliance for grants (vs. 85% target) and 82.6% compliance for searches.

New DQA workflow…
On 11 December 2023, the three Vice-Presidents of DG1, DG4 and DG5 issued Internal Procedural Instructions updating the DQA workflow.

As of 1 January 2024:
− the audit report, both in grant and search audits, is sent also to the line manager of the first member of the competent Examining Division,

− in case of deficiencies, a new “audit dialogue” takes place involving also the line manager of the first member,

− if no agreement is reached DQA may review each disagreed product finding internally, either by a “simplified review” of two auditors or a “full review” additionally comprising the quality audit line manager

− if DQA maintains at least one finding after a full review, it informs a new “DG1 independent review panel” which shall issue a recommendation to the division and send a revision task to the first member “to correct the action as appropriate”.

… in breach of the EPC
Examiners are first and foremost bound to the European Patent Convention (EPC)1. The EPC defines that examination of European patent applications is the sole responsibility of Examining Divisions2. Such divisions shall consist of three technically qualified members, and can, only in exceptional cases, be enlarged by decision of the responsible Examining Division with a legally qualified member to four members3.

There is no provision for the involvement of anyone else. This de facto excludes “DQA auditors”, “line managers”, the “quality audit line manager” and the “DG1 independent review panel”. Should they be involved according to the new DQA workflow, the applicable rules on the composition of the Examining Divisions are systematically violated.4

The planned involvement of “line managers” and of the “DG1 independent review panel” is

______

1 e.g. T 0162/82, headnote; or T 0500/00, cons. 2.6.1

2 Article 18(1) EPC

3 Article 18(2) EPC

4 In fact, it is undisputed that the final decision to grant a patent or refuse a patent application remains the sole competence of the Examining Division and that neither a line manager nor anybody else can replace a member of the Examining Division when taking a decision under the EPC unless being appointed as member of the Examining Division in accordance with Article 18(2) EPC.


particularly worrying as they have disciplinary powers, reporting authority and play a decisive role in the career advancement of the members of Examining Division under the new career system5.

Moreover, the “DG1 independent review panel” is presented internally as if it were a higher legal instance for reviewing the Examining Divisions’ decisions, besides the EPO Boards of Appeal, although it has no basis in the EPC at all.

The expectations of the users of the patent system
In the course of the revision of the EPC to EPC20006, the users of the European Patent System as represented by the members of SACEPO7 unanimously supported the “retention of the three-man examining divisions”. This composition of the Examining Divisions should ensure the high quality and legal certainty of the granted patents, presuming that the Divisions’ members have the required time and independence in substance for arriving at their decisions.

However, the new DQA workflow obviously undermines these principles and user expectations. The “DG1 independent review panel” even has the power to send a decision back to the entrusted examiner of the competent Examining Division for “correcting” the decision “as appropriate” taking into account the panel’s recommendation without disclosing any interference to the public8.

Twenty years after the EPC2000 reform, major users of the EPO patent system currently ask that the EPO focuses on substantive quality of patents by giving the necessary time to Examining Divisions 9 . These users never asked for new processes of highly questionable legality which jeopardize the “three-man examining divisions”.

Conclusion
The President and DG5 would be well advised to reassess the legal situation and to make the respective legal opinions on the DQA workflow available.

The users of the patent system and the public deserve to be transparently informed of the EPO’s new processes. In the past, we have already requested the President to publish the respective internal EPO guidelines10 on the work in the Divisions. Now, we request that the new DQA workflow is also published and submitted to SACEPO for consultation.

In case of questions or comments concerning the work in the Examining Divisions and the DQA workflow, please contact your Staff Representation.

The Central Staff Committee

____

5 A career system based primarily on incentives for examiners to achieve ever increasing productivity targets to allegedly guarantee the financial stability of the office.

6 see CA/PL 2/99, item I.A.

7 Standing Advisory Committee before the European Patent Office, “a group of 180 engaged, active and vocal user representatives from all over the world”, see also the SACEPO website

8 Only the names of the members of the competent Examining Division continue to be displayed to the public on the decision to grant without any trace in the public part of the examination file. This violates the findings of the Boards of Appeal that the person signing a communication or decision takes unconditional responsibility for its content. (OJ EPO SE 2/2021, p. 37, T 989/19)

9 “50 years EPC: The EPO ignoring the skilled person”, CSC paper (sc24001cp), 19-01-2024 “50 years EPC: The EPO ignoring the skilled person”, CSC paper (sc24001cp), 19-01-2024

10 see CSC letter sc20184cl (not published)

As we are going to show in a later article, the atmosphere at the Office is again deteriorating, along with quality and compliance. The EPO is basically operating outside the rule of law while relying on crooked kangaroo (and evidently anti-European) courts to let the matter be... and persist. This has become a serious reputation problem for the EU, which is only belatedly catching up with the problem of patents on seeds/plants.

Unless the EU wakes up and gets this matter under control, all this corruption will continue to spill over. This is really terrible for Europe.

Other Recent Techrights' Posts

Windows in Åland Islands: From 100% to Less Than Half
Åland Islands lost the sense of urgency to move to GNU/Linux
Not Just Slow News But Also Late News (Julian Assange Landing in Thailand)
Why did AP take so long (nearly a week) to release these?
[Meme] Smart Alec Poettering
How many Microsofters can the Debian Project withstand?
Getting Rid of Microsoft Does Not Go Far Enough
Microsoft already has many problems. One day Microsoft won't exist anymore. But that does not guarantee users' freedom.
Alyssa Rosenzweig's LibrePlanet Talk About Freeing the Apple GPU
Alyssa Rosenzweig is the graphics witch behind the reverse-engineered drivers for the Apple GPU. She previously led Panfrost, the free drivers for Arm Mali GPUs powering devices like the Pinebook Pro. She graduated in 2023 with a Computer Science degree from the University of Toronto and now writes free software full-time.
Links 30/06/2024: LLMs Under Fire and Dictatorship of the Old
Links for the day
[Meme] Walking Outside the Guardrails of the Walled Gardens Built by Monopolies
So-called "advertiser-unfriendly" material was never a problem for Wikileaks
 
Johannes Åsgård on Making the Raspberry Pi More Free With librerpi
Johannes (also known as dolphinana)
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, June 30, 2024
IRC logs for Sunday, June 30, 2024
200 This Week
Monday started with 40 articles/pages and this is #200
Press Complicity and Public Apathy All Along Enabled 14 Years of Illegal, Arbitrary Detention and Coercion Into Plea Bargain of Julian Assange on Brink of Death
They basically blackmailed him into letting the US 'win' the argument
At the End Journalism a Crime (If It Involves Accessing or Gaining Access to Documents Marked "Confidential" or "Classified" by Those Looking to Hide Their Misconduct/Crimes)
At least in the US, especially where the imperialism is at stake
Links 30/06/2024: Tensions in Korea and Japan, Criminalisation of Sleeping Outdoors
Links for the day
100% Slop/Spam From linuxsecurity.com
This is the kind of stuff that's killing the Web faster
Gemini Links 30/06/2024: Murdoch and Ideal OS
Links for the day
In the First 6 Months of 2024 Thailand Moved to GNU/Linux, Not to Windows Vista 11
maybe users moved from Vista 10 and 11 to GNU/Linux, seeing where Microsoft was heading with forced hardware "upgrades"
Eko K. A. Owen, New Outreach and Communications Coordinator for the FSF
Nice to see many new additions to the FSF's team
Microsoft Has Slaves and Enablers, Not Partners
Obligatory meme too
Tobias Platen Covered Freedom-To-Play Games in LibrePlanet 2024
Freedom-To-Play games using Taler
[Meme] Opening a 'Webapp' With 'Only' 4 GB of RAM
Until 2020 none of my PCs ever had more than 2 GB of RAM
Destination 'Five Percent'
We reckon GNU/Linux can break the 5% barrier some time by the end of this year, even without counting Chromebooks
A Crisis of Online Journalism
Almost a week ago a journalist was forced to plead guilty for an act of journalism
Germany One of Many Countries Where Microsoft's Bing Lost Market Share After All That LLM Nonsense (Bing Chat and Further Rebrands/Renames)
openai.com traffic plunged 60% last month
Microsoft’s Latest Antitrust Scrutiny
4 new stories
Microsoft Layoffs, Mass Plagiarism, and More
outrage included
GNU/Linux Climbed 0.25% This Month (in statCounter)
Around midday on Tuesday we'll start seeing preliminary data for July
Ilya Gulko Introduces Pollyanna
"Pollyanna is a web framework that makes it easy to create your own libre social space, such as a social network or blog."
'FSFE': Underage Labour, GAFAM Fronting, and Identity Theft to Undermine the FSF's Current Fundraiser
looking to raise funds at the same time as the FSF
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Saturday, June 29, 2024
IRC logs for Saturday, June 29, 2024
Links 29/06/2024: Astronauts at Risk, Ukraine Updates
Links for the day
Fedora and Red Hat Leftovers
mostly redhat.com
Microsoft is Now Googlebombing or Spamming 'Open Source' and 'Linux' to Promote Proprietary Surveillance, Azure
Notice the title and the image, what's being promoted etc.
Seychelles: GNU/Linux Doing OK
Seychelles cannot be considered poor
This War Crime Footage, Nothing Political Per Se, Is What They Made Julian Assange Plead Guilty To (War Criminals Not Convicted, Only Those Who Expose Them)
Wikileaks' Julian Assange: Exposing the US Military Crimes
Gemini Protocol Isn't Even Remotely "Dead"
"Lupa knows of 505,000 (half a million!) working Gemini URLs at present, up from about 425,000 this time last year"
About 10 New Free Software Foundation (FSF) Members Per Day
The total changed from 46 to 47 while typing the article
20 Years Passed, Let's Go Even Faster Now
We are hoping to bring more original stories
Vista 11 Adoption Unusually Low in Germany and It's Going Down, Not Up
This is not happening only in Germany
Kevin Korte on Computers Being Allowed to Make Decisions Based on Cryptic Algorithms and Proprietary/Secret Data
It uses buzzwords where none are needed
[Meme] Garbage In, Garbage Out (linuxsecurity.com)
It is neither Linux nor security, just chatbot-generated slop
Microsoft-Invaded CISA Spreads Anti-Free Software FUD (as If Proprietary Software Has No Memory Safety Issues), Brittany Day Uses Chatbots to Amplify and Permutate the Microsoft FUD
linuxsecurity.com became an anti-Linux spam site
Microsoft Laying Off Staff in an Act of Retaliation and Union-Busting
retaliatory layoffs at Microsoft
Gemini Links 29/06/2024: Content Drowning in 'Goo' and LLM Slop
Links for the day
Windows Lost Almost 92% Market Share in Egypt
From over 99% to just over 7%
In Ecuador, GNU/Linux Adoption Surged From Under 1% to Over 4% in About 3 Years
Not even counting Chromebooks
LibrePlanet: Cultivating Backups (of Recordings)
an appeal to recover some of these talks
Microsoft/Windows Machines Are Turned Off (or Windows Deleted/Decommissioned) in Web Servers, as the "Market Share" Collapse Continues
Taking full history into account, this is a decrease of over 90% in some cases
Corwin Brust Hosting Freedom: A Behind-the-scenes Tour With the GNU Savannah Hackers
"the "smiling faces" behind it."
Android at 90% or More in Chad
Windows below 2%
David Wilson: Cultivating a Welcoming Free Software Community That Lasts
"a feeling of shared ownership for all users."
Julian Assange Might Continue Wikileaks, But Certainly Not Yet (Recovery Time Needed)
And probably at a symbolic capacity only
Bringing in 12 Santas and Taking 13 Out (Old Interview With Julian Assange)
Julian Assange's life inside the Ecuadorian embassy
Neil Plotnick on GNU/Linux in the High School Classroom
uploaded to the LibrePlanet instance of MediaGoblin
Asia Appears to be Fastest to Adopt GNU/Linux
the home of a considerable majority of the world's population
Alexandre Oliva's LibrePlanet 2024 Talk About "Software Enshittification"
in spite of technical difficulties encountered while recording
What They Used to Do With Mono They Now Do With Systemd (Lower and Deeper Down Than Userspace)
Now we have a project started primarily by Red Hat (and managed by Microsoft GitHub, which is proprietary) being managed by Microsoft and primarily serving Microsoft and IBM
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Friday, June 28, 2024
IRC logs for Friday, June 28, 2024