Patents Roundup: Why Software Patents Are Harmful; Status Update Re Bilski
- Dr. Roy Schestowitz
- 2009-11-11 12:37:52 UTC
- Modified: 2009-11-11 12:37:52 UTC
Summary: A lot of new links about software patents and In Re Bilski
●
Software patents have tangible costs for innovation, and for you [
via]
One thing that I find extremely frustrating about many legal scholars' and economists' approach to patents is that they make two false assumptions. The first assumption is that transaction costs are acceptable, or can be made so with some modest reforms. The second assumption is that patent litigation is reasonably "precise"; i.e., if you don't infringe on something then you'll be able to build useful technology and bring it to market relatively unhindered. As my friend's story shows, both of these assumptions are laughably false. I mean, just black-is-white, up-is-down, slavery-is-freedom, we-have-always-been-at-war-with-Eastasia false.
The end result is that our patent system encourages "land grab" behavior which could practically serve as the dictionary definition of rent-seeking. The closest analogy is to a conquistador planting a flag on a random outcropping of rock at the tip of some peninsula, and then saying "I claim all this land for Spain", and then the entire Western hemisphere allegedly becomes the property of the Spanish crown. This is a theory of property that's light-years away from any Lockean notion of mixing your labor with the land or any Smithian notion of promoting economic efficiency. And yet it's the state of the law for software patents. Your business plan can literally be to build a half-assed implementation of some straightforward idea (or, in the case of Intellectual Ventures, don't build it at all), file a patent, and subsequently sue the pants off anybody who comes anywhere near the turf you've claimed. And if they do come near your turf, regardless of how much of their own sweat and blood they put into their independent invention, the legal system's going go off under them like a land mine.
●
'Intellectual Property' a Violation of Real Property
Proprietary software advocates would probably be most concerned with money whereas ironically Free Software advocates, especially those who promote GNU General Public License (GPL), would be concerned with power.
[...]
Intellectual property is a lie, thus its enforcement by means of the copyright law is nothing more than institutionalized violation of real property rights by means of granting government enforced monopolies to authors. They are given the power to dictate how individuals who never entered any agreements with them and instead got it from someone else will use their own property (hard drives, DVD players and burners etc.).
●
BMW seeks to patent technological creative thinking?!
Yes, you read the headline correctly. BMW has filed a patent for a "Method for Systematically Identifying Technology-Based Solutions." Broken down into non-lawyer speak, BMW thinks it has identified the ways in which technology can solve problems. In other words, they want to patent the methodology behind technological problem solving.
●
Supreme Court Considers Software Patents
Those arguing that patent rights should be restricted say that "business method patents amount to a tax on Internet commerce." On the other hand, small software companies, financial services companies and others argue that their inability to protect software "cripples" the ability of smaller companies to compete.
●
Supreme Skepticism Over Bilski Claims Puts Method Patents on Shaky Ground
For the first time in almost 30 years, the U.S. Supreme Court on Monday considered the issue of what types of technology should be eligible for patent protection when it heard oral arguments in Bilski v. Kappos.
●
Justices Show Supreme Skepticism About Broad Business Model Patents
●
Bilski oral argument highlights (or rather, lowlights...)
●
Bilski’s hearing and software patents [via
Digital Majority]
At Monday’s hearing (court transcript), neither party had the objective of abolishing software patents. The Bilski case is about a business method patent, so there was Mr. Jakes arguing that business methods should be patentable, and Mr. Stewart arguing that they shouldn’t. For software to be excluded, we’re relying on the judges (to whom we wrote an amicus brief, as did many others). There’re a few worrying statements, but there’s also a lot of hope.
On the issue of business methods, the judges were very sceptical but mentioned many times that they don’t see an obvious place to draw the line. Indeed, they seemed to find Jakes’ position comical at times, and also found Stewart not going far enough and said that with his proposed interpretation, a computer could be added to any idea to make a patentable “machine”, thus also failing to exclude business method patents. There are also some worrying statements in there, like Justice Sotomayor calling the 2008 CAFC in re Bilski ruling “extreme“.
●
Software patent case arrives at Supreme Court
With the tech industry looking on, the Supreme Court today will explore what types of inventions should be eligible for a patent in a pivotal case that could undermine such legal protections for software.
●
Business Method Patents: Technological Change, Not Judicial Activism
The judicial activism thesis may have a superficial appeal. State Street was a highly visible and prominent pronouncement by the federal court having nationwide jurisdiction over patent cases. It may seem reasonable to attribute tremendous implications to such a famous judicial opinion. Yet the judicial activism thesis suffers from multiple glaring problems and plainly cannot account for the timing of the rise in business method patenting, which plainly began well before State Street.
●
Patent law must not stifle innovation
In a world of constantly accelerating technological change, economic prosperity depends on innovation. To support such innovation, it is vital that our patent system be well-calibrated, so that overly broad patent monopolies do not choke innovation. In the last several years, patent standards have been relaxed by the courts, which has created a patent system that hinders innovation in the software industry.
[...]
Such lawsuits can be ruinously expensive - including, for an average-size case, millions of dollars in attorneys' fees. Large software companies have developed defenses against some patent threats, including obtaining their own patents that they may use to bring countersuits if attacked. This strategy is only available to well-financed companies. Even large companies face increased litigation risks from businesses with no purpose other than exploiting patents. These businesses - called non-practicing entities, or, less politely, patent trolls - buy patents not with a view of producing products, but rather so that they can demand ransom from operating companies.
●
High Court Must Lower Bar For Patents
Due to an important federal circuit court of appeals decision last year, this type of powerful innovation may no longer be patentable. In upholding a lower court ruling, the federal circuit wrote that a business process (like online banking) must be "tied to a machine" or transform "a substance into a different state or thing" in order to qualify for patent protection. This "machine or transformation" test, as it is called, is too rigid to incite innovation.
●
An Important Patent Law Precedent Approaches
So now, shorn of all the technicalities, the Supreme Court gets a chance to say whether it means what it's always said, or whether it wants to endorse the fast and flashy round-heeled patent system we were running during the boom times. Of course, it can always do nothing at all, or make a new alternative that wasn't there before; that's what being the Supreme Court means, as any Legal Realist will tell you. But one thing is certain, that if they wind up saying anything at all, what the Justices say in this case will determine the course of patent law for a long time to come.
●
A Math Geek's Ride to the High Court in Landmark Patent Fight
The company is marketing the product even without the patent, so Warsaw was asked: Why keep fighting for it? "Our revenues are down millions of dollars because we don't have the patent" and the royalty stream that would have resulted, he said. "We have no market power. That's the essence of it. You can't protect your interests."
●
Bilski Supreme Court Preview: Finnegan Lawyer Challenging 'Machine or Transformation' Patent Test Says He's Ready
The appellate court ruled that in order for a business method to receive patent protection, it would need to either "transform [an] article to a different state or thing," or be "tied to a particular machine." The opinion sent the patent bar into an uproar, with businesses asserting that the new standard jeopardized patents on all kinds of highly valuable intellectual property, including software.
●
Supreme Court to decide: What kind of innovations get a patent?
At issue is whether US patent protection must be limited to inventions involving machines and transformative processes, or whether patent law also embraces nonphysical inventions like improved business methods and software innovations.
The case, Bilski v. Kappos, is viewed as a potential landmark in patent law. It has attracted 67 friend-of-the-court briefs from lawyers, scholars, and businesses, including Microsoft, the Biotechnology Industry Organization, Bank of America, Google, Yahoo, and L.L. Bean.
Recent Techrights' Posts
- I Tried Linux Again After 10 Years - Here's What Blew My Mind
- It's like leaving your hometown as a teenager and coming back to find the weird kid from high school is now the mayor
-
- Buy Influence "Over Dinner With The Register."
- The Register MS is the facilitator or 'pimp'
- While the Slop Industry Wobbles The Register MS Bags Tens of Thousands of Pounds to Publish Propaganda With "AI" 23 Times in It
- The Register MS is selling its reputation away
- The Real News About the White House (Not the 'Exclusive' Rupert Murdoch Published for It at Midnight Monday) is Complicity in NVIDIA Fraud
- They need a distraction from commercial malpractice
- Links 16/11/2026: Microsoft Increases Indian Clown Computing Prices by 15%, Meta Fined $887 Million in Italy
- Links for the day
- Gemini Links 16/11/2026: Container Gardening, Laughing at an LLM, "EU 72-Hour Guidelines Through a Lawyer's Eyes"
- Links for the day
- Links 16/11/2026: Data Centers (White Elephants) as Tax Evasion Scam/Ploy, Social Control Media Harms Boomers, "Microsoft Outage Hindered Ticket Issuance in Greece"
- Links for the day
- The Register MS Seems to Have Moved to 'The Cloud' (WeWork) After Shutting Down the Office
- The Register MS will have a hard time explaining why it so passionately participated in the "hey hi" pyramid scheme
- Holiday Plans (We Need More IBM Whistleblowers)
- in particular with possession of material in relation to PIPs, NDAs, and silent RAs
- After Microsoft Outage GNU/Linux Usage Leaps to 9% in the UK (Where Public Services Were Notoriously Overdependent on Microsoft Disservices)
- in the UK we are extremely dependent on Microsoft stuff in the NHS, courts, law firms, police etc.
- Richard Stallman Was Right About the Corruption of the Term "Artificial intelligence"
- This will do severe damage to the administration which participated in the scam
- The Dictatorship Already Working to Distract From NVIDIA Corruption and Slop Bubble Reaching Its Limits
- Circular financing is simply a form of financial fraud
- IBM Selling Itself, Piecewise, to Raise Money (to Pay Salaries)
- IBM is a zombie waiting to inhale one last time (last breath)
- "Allies" of Disgraced NVIDIA CEO Aren't About Morality, They're Just Covering Up Their Own Backs (and Loans)
- The next stage is examining the false accounting (fraud basically)
- No Outage Since 2023
- I did host from home between 2020 and 2023
- Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXXII - Back Doors and Kill Switches From Microsoft Are Objectively Undesirable
- "I dual-boot Omarchy and Windows. Be careful updating your BIOS. Mine made Omarchy unbootable."
- Gemini Links 16/11/2026: Enjoyable Coding, Social Control Media Considered Harmful, and Recursive Rectangular Subdivision
- Links for the day
- Over at Tux Machines...
- GNU/Linux news for the past day
- IRC Proceedings: Sunday, November 15, 2026
- IRC logs for Sunday, November 15, 2026
- Cusp of Collapse
- NVIDIA Corp (NASDAQ: NVDA) is set to open in the red tomorrow
- Getting Fed Up Not Only With Microsoft But Also Windows
- This morning we wrote about North America
- Layoffs and Silent Layoffs (e.g. PIPs) as a "Break" From IBM
- If the press doesn't report it, then it never happened, right?
- Microsoft XBox at 25 and All-Time Low
- XBox will be "officially" dead (not the brand) when sales fall below some threshold and then production is halted, sort of like Apple's Vision Pro
- Links 15/11/2026: Microsoft Already Emitting Chaff to Distract From Its Catastrophe, Jensen Huang Deemed Just 'Fall Guy' Amid Collapse of the Pyramid Scheme
- Links for the day
- Gemini Links 15/11/2026: CD Players Live on and Self-Hosting from Home Fallacy
- Links for the day
- When Short is Way Too Short (Superficiality, Lowering of Entropy)
- Demonstrating how truly worthless social control media was all along
- Techrights Hates Slop Bots
- They benefit nobody
- The Economy is Fine! (If Only for China!)
- The future is slop! If not, then it's China's fault! It's "sabotaging" the "Western hey hi" in this "hey hi arms race!"
- "IT" as "Musical Chairs" (on the Deck of The Titanic)
- Each generation will get worse for "IT"
- Salesforce in Trouble, Debt Nearly Quadrupled in 9 Months
- Salesforce is perishing in a deep pool of debt
- "Microsoft is Next IBM"
- The words of a Microsoft insider and responses to that
- IRC is Decentralised
- Bye, Microsoft Teams/Skype
- Links 15/11/2026: Murdoch's "WSJ Buries Stephen Miller's Racism" and "America Has Entered a New Age of Propaganda"
- Links for the day
- In the UK, GNU/Linux Usage Soared During Microsoft Downtime
- since the massive outage GNU/Linux usage soared to over 10%
- Google Slop About Richard Stallman Shows Stallman Was Right, LLMs are BS Generators
- Google slop is the "new Google"
- Spouse of Garrett Needs to Get "Several Firearms" to Feel Safe Amid Divorce (Garrett Has a "Girlfriend" Now)
- Seems like Isis and my wife have a lot in common when it comes to Garrett
- Vista 11 is Small
- Can Microsoft survive the fall of Windows?
- Six Richard Stallman and FSF Talks This Month (FSF Staff at Ohio State University)
- Dr. Stallman's talks in Ecuador are well timed because of the collapse of the LLMs (slop) pyramid scheme
- NVIDIA's Crisis Has Only Just began
- NVIDIA Corp (NASDAQ: NVDA) is set to open in the red tomorrow
- IBM Has Destroyed Red Hat and Hashicorp, Insiders Say It's the Usual From IBM:
- Bluewashing is a death wave
- Over at Tux Machines...
- GNU/Linux news for the past day
- IRC Proceedings: Saturday, November 14, 2026
- IRC logs for Saturday, November 14, 2026
- Techrights Was Right About Slop Destroying Development Communities and Projects
- Slop does not improve your project. It kills the community. Without community, what is left? A 'botfarm'?
- Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXXI - Harassment Law and "Things Are Unfairly Asymmetric" (Exploring the Boundaries of Death Threats and Various Threats From America)
- the sort of "technofascism" that our country must learn to confront rather than facilitate
- Gemini Links 15/11/2026: "The Bastards Can Never Win" and "The Last Low-Tech Generation"
- Links for the day
- Links 14/11/2026: Wuhan Corruption and "Aid Isn’t Reaching Ebola’s Epicenter"
- Links for the day
- Rahul Kumar Has Turned tecadmin.net Into a Slopfarm That Promotes Slop and Microsoft (as Usual)
- Slop promoting slop - a death knell of once-active "Linux" sites
- Large-Scale Layoffs - Not Just PIPs - at Red Hat and IBM This Month
- Mainstream media has quit covering mass layoffs
- Links 14/11/2026: "The Claude Delusion" and "The Microsoft Outage is a Warning for the World"
- Links for the day
- Ethics in Perspective, Free Software and Morality
- top clients of Jeffrey Epstein are one happy family
- Richard Stallman (RMS) at Universidad Central del Ecuador (Guayaquil), Cuenca, Campus Sur Universidad Politecnica Salesiana (Quito), and Ohio State University
- Long live the message and mission of RMS
- They Paid Workers in 'Shares' (That Lost Almost Half Their Value in One Month)
- Welcome back 1999 or 2007
- The Register MS Made Millions of Pounds by Participating in the Slop Hype Campaign (It's Still Doing It), Now It Admits That It's Just a Bubble
- the slop frenzy played a role in the Microsoft meltdown
- Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXX - Pyramid Schemes (Planned Plunder) and Canceled/Botched Surgeries Aren't "Funny", They Cause Serious Harm and Distress
- We were right about Microsoft
- Links 14/11/2026: "OpenAI Is Sustaining Enormous Losses" and Slop "Loses the Popular Vote"
- Links for the day
- Over at Tux Machines...
- GNU/Linux news for the past day
- IRC Proceedings: Friday, November 13, 2026
- IRC logs for Friday, November 13, 2026
- Gemini Links 14/11/2026: Code of Conduct, Back to Gemini, and Gemlog to Inbox
- Links for the day