ING was quick off the mark to place its seal of approval on Breton's appointment
Following initial approval by the screening committee of MEPs on 14 November 2019, Thierry Breton's appointment as the new EU Commissioner for the Internal Market was finally confirmed at a plenary session of the European Parliament held on 27 November 2019.
Breton's appointment as a member of the new EU Commission was confirmed on 27 November 2019
"So how did he return to the political arena after an absence of over 10 years and ended up as the EU Commissioner for the Internal Market?"The sole opposition to Breton's appointment in the European Parliament came from MEPs of the European United Left/Nordic Green Left bloc (GUE/NGL) who expressed concerns about his conflicts of interest. The MEPs who criticised his appointment took the position that he should not be placed in charge of a portfolio that has significant areas of overlap with his previous private sector activities as CEO of the French multinational Atos.
In an earlier part of this series, it was explained how Breton previously pursued a brief but eventful political career as Chirac's entrepreneurial "joker" in Bercy between 2005 and 2007. So how did he return to the political arena after an absence of over 10 years and ended up as the EU Commissioner for the Internal Market? To understand this, it's necessary to take another look at domestic politics in France and the rise of Breton's current political sponsor, Emmanuel Macron.
To the uninformed Breton and Macron seem like improbable political bedfellows.
"To the uninformed Breton and Macron seem like improbable political bedfellows."The former CEO at France Télécom served his political apprenticeship in the ranks of the centre-right UMP under the guiding hand of Jacques Chirac, a convicted felon, who received a two year suspended sentence in 2011 for "longstanding and reiterated practices" of illegal party financing during his time mayor of Paris from 1977 to 1995.
According to media reports, Chirac was involved in channeling about € 2.2 million from the City of Paris to pay for at least 21 people who were employed in fake jobs on the city payroll while actually engaged in national party politics as he prepared to run for the presidency.
Breton was the "teacher's pet" of his mentor Jacques Chirac
The youthful Sarkozy attending a tennis tournament
together with Papa Chirac and daughter Claude (1985)
François Hollande - nicknamed “Flanby” after Nestlé's wobbly caramel pudding
Macron with his patron and mentor François Hollande
Ex-banker Macron reinvents himself as a new "centrist" demagogue
Ãâ°narques to a man - with the exception of Sarkozy.
"With the exception of Nicolas Sarkozy, all Presidents of the postwar Fifth Republic have been graduates of the grandes écoles..."Staring with Valéry Giscard d'Estaing who succeeded Georges Pompidou -- and once again with the exception of Sarkozy -- the office of President has been occupied since 1974 by an Ãâ°narque, as the graduates of the Ãâ°cole Nationale d'Administration (ENA) are known.
The ENA was created in 1945 by French President, Charles de Gaulle, and the principal author of the French Constitution, Michel Debré, as part of a plan for the reform of the civil service in postwar France. The implementation of this plan was, to a large extent, entrusted to the Stalinist Maurice Thorez, leader of the French Communist Party (PCF) who served as Deputy Prime Minister from 1946 to 1947.
France's ENA - a Stalinist-inspired finishing school for the technocratic elite
Sarkozy (UMP), Hollande (Socialist) flanking Macron ("Centrist"): "Gentlemen, if we continue walking in this direction I am confident that we will arrive at a revolving door in due course…"
"The formation at the ENA leads to the forging of incestuous bonds between future political, administrative and business leaders, and these are reinforced as the Ãâ°narques circulate between these spheres of activity in the course of their careers thanks to the ubiquitous revolving doors linking the public and private sectors."As Alain Madelin, Minister for Industry under Jacques Chirac, once put it: "Ireland has the IRA, Spain the ETA, Italy the Mafia, and France has the ENA."
An illustrative example of the extreme fluidity of political boundaries in France can be found in the case of Bernard Tapie, businessman, occasional actor, singer, TV host and convicted corruptionist.
Tapie is associated with the Radical Party of the Left, a close ally of the main centre-left Socialist Party, and he briefly served as Minister for Urban Affairs under the Socialist President François Mitterand from December 1992 to March 1993.
"This kind of shenanigans is par for the course in the Machiavellian world of French politics."However, during the 2007 presidential election, Tapie switched his political allegiance to UMP candidate Sarkozy. Tapie's ideological U-turn was attributed to "tax issues" which Sarkozy reportedly promised to resolve if he were elected. Detail which subsequently emerged in court during the trial which led to the conviction of Christine Lagarde in 2016, indicate that Sarkozy kept his promise to Tapie.
This kind of shenanigans is par for the course in the Machiavellian world of French politics.
So when the new "centrist" movement set up by the Ãâ°narque Macron started to gain traction in 2016, various figures from different regions of the party political spectrum emerged from the wings to hitch their horses to his bandwagon as it started rolling across the French political landscape.
A new political "star" is born… the unstoppable rise of Emmanuel Macron
"Nice" to see you, to see you "Nice"...
Emmanuel and Nicolas bromancing at an official celebration in Nice (14 July 2017)
"The hardware is awesome, all we need now is someone to take care of the software…"
"How about getting Benoît to do the job? I have heard the most wonderful stories about his achievements at the EPO."
Emmanuel and "the Donald" at the White House in April 2018
Thierry promoting his own proprietary brand of French "Bull" in the USA
After a hard day's networking, time to grab a nosebag at the White House…
"Breton's prominent role in Macron's entourage during the US state visit in April 2018 is indicative of his privileged position in the French President's "inner circle"."When Sylvie Goulard, Macron's initial nominee for EU Commissioner, came a cropper after an intense grilling before the European Parliament in October of this year it was no real surprise to those in the know when the French President turned to his trusted friend, Atos CEO Thierry Breton, to help him out of a hole.
Initial speculation that Breton's nomination might meet the same fate as that of Madame Goulard turned out to be unfounded and his place in the new EU Commission has now been officially rubber-stamped.
In the next part we will examine some high-level connections to the world of international finance which Macron and Breton have in common. ⬆