The Free Software Foundation No Longer Interested in .NET Cloning?

Dr. Roy Schestowitz

2008-10-05 17:22:45 UTC
Modified: 2008-10-06 23:21:09 UTC

.NET Slipping through

A bad penguin -- Novell

This year's list of high-priority Free software projects excludes DotGNU, which was there before. An article from last year explained the controversy surrounding this.

The Free Software Foundation's 'High Priority' List: A Key Guidepost

[...]

# DotGNU: GNU/Linux already has a partial implementation of Microsofts .NET (AKA C#) language in the Mono Project. However, many people in free software are concerned that Mono could face patent attacks from Microsoft. Just as importantly, some view Mono with suspicion, especially since it is sponsored by Novell, Microsoft's chief partner in the community. DotGNU is an effort to provide a technical and political alternative.

AVRS2 is not hurried in jumping to conclusions. Yesterday he clarified that "it could just have fallen down because it works well (don't know) already." Dan O'Brien writes: "maybe because of Mono." Either way, it's not there anymore. Looking at readers of Linux Today, some people vehemently dislike Mono and several other people begin to understand a Mono injection vector called Moonlight, so there's no happiness.

I won't even install mono on my system. If a site is built using silverlight, it will get the same treatment from me as any site that caters to IE-only: I will not use it.

Further, says Jeff Cobb:

I agree with the above poster and the article which states that Linux will always be behind the curve WRT Mono/MS version compatibility. What I find disgusting though is the reasoning behind why we should do it: because "everyone else is doing it". Doesn't this make you glad that Linus, RMS, et al didn't share Miguels casual moral attitude?

Mono is not a wise way to proceed given things that we already know. What GNU/Linux is in danger of is ending up with a poor man's .NET (Mono) and poor man's Visual Studio (Novell's MonoDevelop). It makes it a follower, inferior and subjected, to the merciless hand of Microsoft. One person has just called this "ignorance".

i guess miguel still does not realize that linux will always be a second class citizen when it comes to M$.. if it was up to M$ linux would even be a citizen..... so the fact the you do have to WAIT for MS to throw you a bone with specs tells you that you will always be playing catchup.. and the day the M$ decides that they no longer need to satisfy any antitrust deals.. your out of luck...... MAN.. i just can;t understnad how this guy can be completely ignorant of this..

Moreover, based on an interesting recent post, those Microsoft licences are a menace.

So where does this leave us? GNOME has been encumbered with Microsoft patents. Microsoft clearly has no regard for anyone's intellectual property, albeit their own, and will stop at nothing to gain control or draw the life from new innovations in order to keep afloat their failing ideal. What can we do about it?

Abandon Microsoft entirely, abandon their attempts at 'open source' and give complete non-compliance. Through all their underhanded tricks and lies there remains one feature inherent to all capitalistic business...

This warning comes at a good time because Microsoft has doctored and begun spreading GNU/Linux-hostile licences. One reader wrote to say: "Maybe I read this wrong, but this strikes me like the scenario we were trying to warn the pro-mono folk about. As long as Microsoft is in the mix, free isn't going to be free for long." ⬆

"Value your freedom or you will lose it, teaches history. "Don't bother us with politics," respond those who don't want to learn."

--Richard Stallman

Comments

newkon

2008-10-05 17:27:26

thanks good blog and post
Needs Sunlight

2008-10-05 18:06:58

Good post and welcome back.

I hope that the FSF goes from ignoring .NET and C# to actually rousting them, and other toxic payloads, from mainstream linux distros.

Java and Python seem to be the markets MSFTers are trying to break into with their proprietary imitations.
seller_liar

2008-10-05 18:10:28

DotGNU is gplv3 .Mono is not.

But gplv3 is not the panacea box.FSF know this and dotgnu is not a priority anymore.

Thanks Roy and FSF!
bob

2008-10-05 18:20:38

I think a more likely reason is that the FSF are no longer interested in having a .Net replacement as a *high priority project*. They are still interested in providing a free .Net implementation, but now they have other more important things to worry about such as a free Skype replacement and free 3d card drivers.
joe

2008-10-05 19:13:08

Likewise, Anjuta and KDevelop are just poor man's Visual Studios too.

People should just use GNU/Emacs for development, who needs GUI clicking IDEs? GNU/Emacs + gdb is so much more powerful than anything Microsoft has and only newbs need a clicky interface.
Roy Schestowitz

2008-10-05 19:30:20

Likewise, Anjuta and KDevelop are just poor man’s Visual Studios too.

The end product is very different though. You can't really compare Eclipse/Beans to Visual Studio, which is "write once, run... well, on Microsoft Windows."

I personally use Kate or nedit for development.
Dan O'Brian

2008-10-05 20:32:03

Visual Studio is no more "write once, run only on Microsoft Windows" than Eclipse is "write once, run only on Solaris" or KDevelop/Anjuta are "write once, run only on Linux".

I'm not sure whether to laugh or cry at your ignorance.
Dan O'Brian

2008-10-06 01:04:37

It should be pointed out that any patents that affect Mono also affect DotGNU, regardless of what license DotGNU chooses.GPLv3 does not protect DotGNU users from any patents that the DotGNU developers do not have rights to.
Roy Schestowitz

2008-10-06 06:42:57

Visual Studio is no more “write once, run only on Microsoft Windows” than Eclipse is “write once, run only on Solaris” or KDevelop/Anjuta are “write once, run only on Linux”.

I was referring to programming languages and platform-specific 'extensions'.
DanielHedblom

2008-10-06 13:20:36

The only party that has something to gain from a GNU implementation of dotnet is Microsoft who can claim its cross-platform when its really not. If it was, how come Moonlight sucks so horribly?
Dan O'Brian

2008-10-06 14:40:24

I've actually been using Moonlight to view some sites. It works rather well. What is so sucky about it? Have you even used it? I highly doubt you have.
Roy Schestowitz

2008-10-06 14:56:45

It's not about practicality alone. You're ignoring the fact that it's seen as an unacceptable legal risk.

GNU/Linux Measured at All-Time High in Sweden: Can 'influencers' have played a role
GNU/Linux Becoming More Universal: It seems likely the end of Vista 10 coinciding with a sharp rise in memory prices (and now energy prices) will benefit GNU/Linux and therefore give us more to write about
Can Economies Like the American One Hang On?: The coming weeks will be "interesting" unless wars end
The "Pale Blue Dot" Moment Had Returned: To many people, the "bitter-sweet" observation of how small we are
Saudi Arabia Does Not Rely Much on Microsoft/Windows: Putting aside politics, this is good for Free software
Almost 12 Years of Exposing Corruption in Europe's Second-Largest Institution: The "unready" President is now an abandoned President
Easter Moon Mission and Its Reminder of IBM's Demise: A lot of NASA operations now rely on GNU/Linux
When Power is Scarce and GNU/Linux Has Power: In Cuba, GNU/Linux has long enjoyed high adoption rates
Don't Totally Dismiss the 'Survivalists': 'Survivalists' or similar terms are used to describe a particular mindset of people who prepare for some really awful scenarios
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Thursday, April 02, 2026: IRC logs for Thursday, April 02, 2026
A Much Better Use of Fuel Than Slop: Something positive for a change
Hoping for Peace: There are still many things to be enjoyed, including nature and kind people
Gemini Links 03/04/2026: "Slide Rule Triple Multiplication" and End of "Picture Pages": Links for the day
Rumours of Microsoft Layoffs This Season: Just how much trouble is Microsoft in at this point?
SLAPP Censorship - Part 31 Out of 200: Speaking About 20+ Years of Alleged Harassment/Defamation and High-Profile 'Targets' of Garrett: attempts were made to settle (in effect end the case) by the person who started the case almost half a dozen times along the way
In Asia, Windows is in Its Teens (Below 20%): On a global scale, Windows is down to about 26%
Low Morale at IBM and Perception of Destructive Management: IBM is going nowhere, fast
Gemini Links 02/04/2026: Super Mario Galaxy Movie and New Antenna Instance: Links for the day
It Seems Like Google News Cracked Down on (Omitted, Delisted) a Lot of Slopfarms: There's no justification/point in spending so much energy just to plagiarise things poorly
Steam Survey for Last Month Says 5.33% Use GNU/Linux: big leap for GNU/Linux
Links 02/04/2026: Science News, Energy Scarcity, Oil Sold in Yuan: Links for the day
Links 02/04/2026: Apple Turns 50, Efforts To Ban VPNs: Links for the day
Gemini Links 02/04/2026: Kubernetes With FreeBSD, OFFLFIRSOCH, and Great Circle Distance: Links for the day
Dr. Andy Farnell on Microsoft Silencing or Deplatforming Opposition in the UK and Elsewhere: Microsoft as a king or a kind of "religion" one cannot question
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, April 01, 2026: IRC logs for Wednesday, April 01, 2026
SLAPP Censorship - Part 30 Out of 200: The Time We Reported Abuse to Greater Manchester Police (GMP) and It Was Escalated to Its Cybercrime Unit: he started trolling and harassing me for criticising his employers' monopolistic and users-hostile agenda
'Modern' Cars Not a Rosy Industry: The current "modern" cars already have a shelf life similar to that of many toothpastes
Wrongthink Detector and Filter in "Think About the Children" Clothing: It is not about "age verification", it's a Trojan horse for social control
IBM Facilities Now Deemed Legitimate (Military) Target, Along With GAFAM Bases: Does IBM have any defences in place to protect against "downtime by explosions"?
What Happens When Some Large News Sites Turn to Slop and Spew Out Nonsense: LLM slop makes such grotesque mistakes abundant
Hardly Seeing Slopfarms Today, Even in Google News: Google's adventures with slop increased its debt significantly
Links 01/04/2026: Quantum Hype (Turing and Google), "US Fuel Prices Surge Past $4 a Gallon": Links for the day
Gemini Links 01/04/2026: "Sacred Week of Cycling" and Zenity for Scripts: Links for the day
Losing Debian: Sruthi Chandran election flop: Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
French judgment: parasitisme by FSFE & Matthias Kirschner (CO23.002709): Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
Microsoft Uses April Fools to 'Joke' About Inserting "Age Verification" (Surveillance) Into Linux: MinceR says the "lkml [message/page] one is April Fools or at least they're trying to pass it off as April Fools [however] the [GitHub] one was archived on the 8th and yesterday, so that probably isn't..."
IBM "Headcount Reductions" by Early Retirement and Death: The tragedy at IBM started 33 years ago on the first of April
Red Hat: Latin-1 character set under threat from Bishop Michael Martin, North Carolina: Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
Links 01/04/2026: Microsoft GitHub Now Pushing Ads Into People's Code/Commits, Earth Overshoot Day Draws Nearer: Links for the day
What IBM and EPO Workers Have in Common: European Media Not Covering Very Major News (Press Became Dysfunctional): Are IBM operatives working to scuttle the process of investigative journalism?
Free Speech in the United Kingdom When "Chilling Effect" is Increasingly Prevalent: If politicians cannot even use a term like "parasitic behaviour", then where do we as a society end up?
Oracle Lays Off Because of Debt and Commercial Issues, Not Slop: Like Scam Altman, Larry Ellison hangs around Cheeto King because he could use some bailouts in the form of government contracts or phony money with an incredible name like "Stargate"
The Real Reason Many Sites and Forums Shun Microsoft Lunduke: When forums say that they banned Microsoft Lunduke or don't want him mentioned it's probably because they are familiar with the "stench" that follows him around
Gemini Links 01/04/2026: Hallucinations, Stitching, and Type Systems: Links for the day
Lots of Layoffs at IBM, "Media Blackout" About Mass Layoffs at IBM's HashiCorp and Confluent Last Month: IBM is a dying company circling down the drain while manipulating or paying the media to pretend everything is fine
Microsoft Under Investigation by the UK's Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) for Abusive Tactics: What's noteworthy is that this is "set to begin in May"
Sounds Like Red Hat (IBM) Layoffs in Slop Clothing: This is an IBM policy. They try to justify staff cuts.
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, March 31, 2026: IRC logs for Tuesday, March 31, 2026

The Free Software Foundation No Longer Interested in .NET Cloning?

The Free Software Foundation's 'High Priority' List: A Key Guidepost

Comments

Recent Techrights' Posts