Bonum Certa Men Certa

Technology: rights or responsibilities? - Part II

posted by Rianne Schestowitz on Oct 02, 2024

By Dr. Andy Farnell

Back to Part I

Outline

This thesis on technology and responsibility proceeds, albeit incoherently, through several stages. First from the very idea of "rights" and the fundamental duty of the State to protect citizens from arbitrary private power. Next to situate this in terms of "civic cybersecurity" and the growing realisation of security organisations that contemporary threats are not just cybercriminals and hostile foreign states but billionaire megalomaniacs and unruly corporate giants who have set digital technology on a dangerous trajectory. A marriage of convenience between these factions needs a swift divorce if the State is to stay on the "right side of history" in coming years.

Academia

I then move on to examine the debasement of science and (as Noam Chomsky predicted) the utter failure of Academia to rescue it (and itself) from moral dereliction. After mentioning my personal experience of academic decay in the field of computer science, and the wider cultural shift from valuing knowledge to valuing convenience which I've witnessed over 50 years, I'll conclude with a reprise of the unyielding bugle-call to "take back tech", but this time under the banner of personal and social responsibility for the future rather than our own parochial wish for gratification.

computer science

Who wants digital rights?

First let's talk about personalities and motives. We often begin computer security classes with a breakdown of the types of hacker, from the curious teenager DDOS-ing fellow gamers from their bedroom to international cybercriminals and state intelligence actors. Rarely do we extend that analysis to every corner of computer use and misuse, including developers, business founders, and the end-users themselves. That would seem an interesting exercise if we are to really understand cybersecurity and digital rights. Of all the people out there using devices for work, chatting, entertainment, where do they fit in their scheme of usage and attitudes around rights, ownership and boundaries with technology? From such a study I think we would quickly conclude that cybersecurity must concern itself with preventing the violation of rights as much as the violation of laws and technical protections.

motives

hacker

Rights?

But what are rights and how can they possibly extend to unreal electronic realms? What happens when your digital rights conflict with mine? Can there be natural rights around information? Surely well-meaning ideas like the "right to be forgotten" are impossible demands in practice, whereas the "right to repair" is almost a nonsense for the opposite reason; namely that it is a self evident natural right impeded only by the existence of egregious over-reaching "intellectual property" laws. Even if certain "technology rights" existed, what use are mere legal rights in a world where the rule of Law is continually being weakened, where arbitrary private authoritarianism is on the rise and de-facto law is determined by technical factors in far away lands or even out in space? Rights are a super complex can-o-worms, so it might be worth quickly tracing the history of rights.

violation

Modern ideas of rights really appeared in the late 1940s after the Holocaust in response to the realisation that laws alone could neither restrain nor define human conduct. That is of course something Sophocles' Antigone dug up the bones of in the Greek period. Pivotal in the 1940s was the testimony of Hermann Goering at Nuremberg, who shocked and deeply challenged established thought with his dogged insistence on the rational, legal and procedural basis of eugenics and genocide. Goering died unrepentant, satisfied that he had "served order" to the last. This resurfaced a contradiction at the heart of social contract theory that had been around since the 19th century. It upended our comfortable satisfaction with society based solely on the primacy of procedural, positivist logic.

genocide

To understand this is to grasp the oscillation between "legal" and "natural" concepts of rights which have existed in tension since humans could think. Greatly simplified, this comes from differing interpretations of social contract by Rousseau and Hobbes, differing accounts of human reason by Locke and Hume, and differing ideas about individual sovereignty arising from Mill and Bentham. One major turning point is the demise of 13th century Feudalism leading to documents like the Magna Carta that define legitimate government as having a duty to protect rights above private power interests. Again in the 18th century the United States yields and inflection in the time-line with its Declaration of Independence containing the famous words "self-evident and unalienable" with origins in Natural Law. Prior to this the British had been on a distinctly positivist trajectory into "legal rights" which generally tend toward a tyranny of those with the power to make laws.

legal

With that philosophy out of the way - if you want to see beyond the academic and philosophical takes on jurisprudence, social contract, constitutions and documents like the UDHR - then I highly recommend George Carlin's pragmatic commentary on what "rights" really mean. In practice, rights are limited by what you are prepared to defend, physically if necessary - and certainly using technical means. In other words, "rights" are as extremely political as you can get, since they ultimately concern the life of law (jurisprudence), social contract, and the right of the people to fight wars and take revolutionary action against defective social apparatus or hostile concentrations of power within society.

Having seen that "rights" exist in a quantum state between natural and legal types we should notice that despite highfalutin international treaties and conventions this century has seen a drift away from natural rights again. The resurrection of 13th century Feudalism as technological neo-feudalism has dealt a serious blow to rights of all kinds.

The "laws of the internet", and so called "cyber-law" as a recognised branch of law, and the conceit of "cyberspace" itself as a realm or place may indeed be a grave mistake. Thinkers like William Gibson, J. P. Barlow, and Lawrence Lessig may have done us a disservice in its cultural construction. There is a very real danger of forgetting reality is simply a bunch of people individually sitting at computers and a great deal of wire connecting us all together. A natural, political or technical event may render it all a useless pile of junk in an instant.

cybersecurity

Philosophers of technology as diverse as Debord, Einstein, Ellul, Freud, Fromm, Heidegger, Kaczynski, Marcuse, Mumford and Postman have sounded alarms over the insane subtext of "the technological society" as a project to shoehorn reality into something smaller, weaker, less durable, and less flexible. Such systems and their systemantics (Gall) are the one-dimensional vanities of the systematisers Nietzche mistrusted as having "a lack of integrity".

In plainer words; the Internet, AI and-all-that, is seriously over-rated if we take a moment to sober up and consider the big picture of human evolution. We have a lot on our plate right now. An Internet is a nice utility that exists to the extent we let it, engage with it, and defend it, but as McLuhan and Postman explained it's become an ideological battlegound in itself. We're now approaching the point where, as the charm wears off, our love may rapidly turn to hate. What were rights become encumbrances. There is nothing physical, legal or effective that would stop people turning en-masse away from "online".

Fear of "missing out" no longer has a hold on people like in the 2010's. We're more circumspect of bandwaggons and hype, and realise that with technology what we're mostly missing out on is life. Such a cultural paradigm shift, a great "logging-off", could spread very rapidly across the globe, and to not recognise the possibility of such upheaval is dangerously naive. We should anticipate that vendors and bureaucrats will employ more and more aggressive means to keep people dependent on technology, and to induct children into a "techno-socialised" mindset.

missing out

For example in Finland and Estonia, which have wholly embraced the "digital state", good internet connectivity is deemed a "right". While this may seem progressive, as Mr. T. (Laurence Tureaud) put it, regarding his success as a film and TV actor; (I paraphrase) "My ancestors from Africa wore chains as slaves. Today my chains are made of gold. But I am still a slave". Eve Ensler noted how we often neglect our right to be free from technology, free from security. Be careful what you wish for as a "right".

slave

Other Recent Techrights' Posts

EFF Celebrates Microsoft Windows and Microsoft Office as "Digital Inclusion", Mocks GNU/Linux-Based ChromeOS
Yet another example/evidence that EFF has become a rotten pile of junk
 
[Meme] How to Keep Granting Hundreds of Thousands of Fake Patents (Without Upsetting Anybody in Politics and Media)
This is very Kremlin-like
EPO Examiners to Adopt Resolution Condemning EPO Management for Breaking the Law in Order to Grant Many Illegal Software Patents
Europe's second-largest institution (EPO) is a law-breaking institution hiding behind the veil of "law"
[Meme] Sup, Nazi?
"Come back, one year"
Calling "Nazi" and "Right Wing" Everyone Who Does Not Agree With You (Even Leftists Whose Views on Some Issues Slightly Differ From Yours)
Oil money has become exceptionally notorious for takeover of online platforms and institutions/NGOs (using them to incite society inwards, not upwards)
EFF Losing the Plot
Like the Linux Foundation and OSI, the EFF has succumbed to corporate influence and is derailing itself (along with its original mission)
Links 05/10/2024: Patents Being Squashed, EFF Insists on Children's Access to Porn
Links for the day
Gemini Links 05/10/2024: Multitudinous Agreeable Futures and Misfin Mail
Links for the day
Links 05/10/2024: Amazon Culling 14,000 Managers, About 160 People Resign From Automattic
Links for the day
Microsoft Moles in Nerdearla, Openwashing and Whitewashing Microsoft With Its Latest Ponzi Scheme and Storytelling
Also GPL violations en masse
The Danger of Outsourcing Your Platform to Social Control Media and Getting "Information" There
Stella is probably not aware of what she has just done
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Friday, October 04, 2024
IRC logs for Friday, October 04, 2024
Links 05/10/2024: Shift to ARM, Microsoft XBox Crisis
Links for the day
[Meme] Who to Trust on Privacy... (Not Someone Who Boasts About Breaking Into Devices Without Authorisation)
You're not even a computer scientist...
When It Comes to Encryption, The Web (as in World Wide Web) Isn't Secure and Uses Weak Ciphers About as Often as Every Day, Even in 2024
Gemini Protocol does not
The GPL Does Not Prohibit Use of Code for Death
Windows kills even more people, but in other ways
Journalism in Europe on Life Support
Assange articulated some of the ordeals he went through
[Video] Stella Assange and Thórhildur Sunna Ævarsdóttir on Protecting Journalists Who Expose Injustice
Stella (the wife) says her husband received an invitation from the committee (PACE) while he still undergoes recovery
[Video] Thórhildur Sunna Ævarsdóttir (Iceland, SOC) Explains That Julian Assange Was Punished for Exposing Crimes (Instead of the Criminals Getting Published)
Thórhildur Sunna Ævarsdóttir speaks out...
Links 04/10/2024: Health, Asia, and Censorship
Links for the day
Links 04/10/2024: Ingrid's Back and Creative Mornings
Links for the day
[Video] The Council of Europe's Parliamentary Assembly on Julian Assange
The Council of Europe's Parliamentary Assembly has voted to confirm that Julian Assange was held as a political prisoner
Links 04/10/2024: Telegram Issues Deepen, Texas Sues TikTok
Links for the day
"The Council of Europe's Parliamentary Assembly has voted to confirm that Julian Assange was held as a political prisoner."
This stuff should not have been in Twitter (X)
Intercontinental Ballistic Missiles (ICBMs) Do Not Run Windows
The projects that deal with ICBMs are extremely unlikely to involve Microsoft
"Microsoft is asking for a handout... yet again"
Just over a month after the last bailout fell through the cracks
One Step Closer to the End of Microsoft's XBox
XBox sales are down over 50% in the past year
GNU/Linux Flaring Up in ASEAN
We said we'd not post statCounter for a few months
Gemini Links 04/10/2024: Asteroid City and Retro Gaming
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Thursday, October 03, 2024
IRC logs for Thursday, October 03, 2024
Resting Time
we deserve a short break - even if only for tomorrow
Wikileaks Revelations About the History of IBM and Its Role in the Cold War
IBM is still an ICBM company (to this very date)
Revisiting Julian Assange's Excellent Talk, His First Talk Since 2019 (Tactful and Almost Invulnerable to 'Cheap Shots')
Assange need not be politically-correct or self-censor
Windows Kills More Than Most Wars (But the Media Casually Ignores the Death Toll of Microsoft)
The bottom line is, many people are dying, they die due to Microsoft, and the media fails us by not informing us and failing to even name the principal culprit
Mozilla is GAFAM, HTTPS is Monopolies
Firefox used to boast that it would make the Web more accessible. Today's Mozilla is rowing in the opposite direction.
Gemini Links 03/10/2024: RetroChallenge and Change of Online Habits
Links for the day
Links 03/10/2024: Quantum Computer Vapourware (as Usual) and Samsung Layoffs
Links for the day
Links 03/10/2024: "Hey Hi" Scandals and Copyright/Trademark Disputes
Links for the day
Invidious Seems to be Nearing 'End of Life' After Repeated Crackdowns by Google/Alphabet/YouTube
To Free software users, YouTube ought to become a "no-no"
Links 03/10/2024: Climate Issues and Tensions in East Asia
Links for the day
Like a Marketing Department of Microsoft, Canonical Sells Back Doors and Surveillance as "Confidential" and "Hey Hi" (AI)
Notice how Canonical has made no statement critical of Microsoft for years
Gemini Links 03/10/2024: Frozen Tofu and SGI O2
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, October 02, 2024
IRC logs for Wednesday, October 02, 2024