Moonlight is Not Silverlight, Silverlight is Not Flash

Dr. Roy Schestowitz

2008-01-24 03:28:59 UTC
Modified: 2008-01-24 03:35:14 UTC

Just some quick points worthy of clarification: Moonlight is not Silverlight. Microsoft does not support GNU/Linux as far as Silverlight is concerned. Novell merely plays catch-up trying to implement something which Microsoft refuses to make available for GNU/Linux. There is no promise of full compatibility and future support. There are also limitations being imposed on distribution and a burden of software of patents. The scenario is similar to that which involves OOXML because Novell gives perceived support which Microsoft then uses to market its technology to developers (calling it "cross-platform").

Enter standards. Decentralised control. Choice!

“Silverlight is not standardised and it is not recommended by the W3C, either.”Enter the binary Web again. Silverlight is not standardised and it is not recommended by the W3C, either. It's a case against W3C in the sense that it renders the W3C's work obsolete. Microsoft has total control over Silverlight. Microsoft can (and will) change it any time it wishes to suit other business goals such as O/S competition, application integration (e.g. Microsoft's Web design tools), Web services (Live), advertising (MSN), etc. That, and primarily that, is why Flash can be trusted more than Silverlight. Do not allow people to draw a comparison between Flash and Silverlight because Adobe is neither interested in discriminating against operating systems, nor has it got a history that demonstrates this.

Judge Jackson once recommended separating the company into an operating system unit which is wholly independent from another that handles applications. Neelie Kroes pondered spilling the company last year as well. Silverlight is another fine reminder of the use of applications (and the World Wide Web) to mutually support an operating system and other frameworks that serve as common carriers.

The only thing more worrying than Silverlight is people's lack of awareness of Silverlight's danger to the Web, to GNU/Linux users, to search engines that compete against Microsoft, to digital preservation and many other things. ⬆

Comments

Silverfish

2008-01-24 06:37:47

Don't let the wolverine explode a cloud of silverfish (Silverlight) into you.

The 'wolverine' and 'cloud of silverfish' is a reference lifted from a Bill Hicks skit. Check YouTube and watch his stuff, his pro-freedom talks and anti-corporate rants are prophetic.
Tim B.

2008-01-25 06:40:56

" Do not allow people to draw a comparison between Flash and Silverlight because Adobe is neither interested in discriminating against operating systems, nor has it got a history that demonstrates this."

Shockwave says hi.
Spaulding Smails

2008-01-25 08:16:58

Is silverlight active-x 2.0? If so, I'm not sure I even want moonlight on my desktop.
martin

2008-01-25 10:14:10

just refuse the now optional install of silverlight on any windows machine. once it becomes 'security' relevant we must find a way to block it permanently.
Guy Thomas

2008-03-05 12:50:08

This article is bang on the money - I couldn't have said it better myself. Ethical web developers unite and boycott Silvershite now!
CoolGuy

2008-03-05 17:31:53

http://java.dzone.com/news/farewell-j-jvm

Sun wants to remove J from JVM. Can you realize the implication for this.

They are going directly against .NET - head on !!

Bring it on !!
butter

2008-07-12 08:37:56

what is the compariosn between thesse 2 ?? adobe and silverfish??
Thomas Hansen

2008-12-04 12:07:03

Beautifully written. Though why not adopt my naming convention for it; "ActiveX2.0"...? ;)

SLAPP Censorship - Part 103 Out of 200: Telling People What They Know and Don't Know About Death Threats They Receive: patronising letters sent on behalf of the Serial Strangler from Microsoft
Links 10/06/2026: More Microsoft Layoffs, Sweden to "Ban Mobile Phones in Schools": Links for the day
European Patent Office (EPO) Series: The Centre (in Portugal) Falls Apart…: Luís Montenegro became embroiled in a conflict-of-interest controversy
IBM Lost About 18% of Its "Market Value" This Month: In IBM's case, a lot of the latest "pump" was Arvind's "quantum" hype/fantasy
Gemini Links 10/06/2026: Signal to Noise, Cancer, and Permacomputing: Links for the day
Communities and "Prosumers.": today's meetup will be about community
Gemini and Gopher Links 10/06/2026: Roasting, Changes, and Harms of Slop: Links for the day
IBM Genies in the Bottle: for ordinary people working who at at IBM, it's not hard to see that IBM is floundering
Microsoft Azure Shrinking With More Mass Layoffs: "Reports suggest the layoffs will impact close to 200 out of 400 workers, who are set to cease employment at Azure on July 6"
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, June 09, 2026: IRC logs for Tuesday, June 09, 2026
European Patent Office (EPO) Series: The Centre-Right "Social Democratic Party" in Portugal: Quite an achievement for a former Maoist radical and aspiring champion of the Portuguese proletariat to be invited to join Goldman Sachs
SLAPP Censorship - Part 102 Out of 200: Maybe One Day Whistleblowers From Brett Wilson LLP Will Tell Us What Really Happened: Maybe one day some former staff of Brett Wilson LLP will also approach us to blow the whistle
What LibreOffice and TDF Get Right About Document Formats (and What They Get Wrong): OOXML is a phantom - it is something nobody implements, not even Microsoft!
Gemini Links 09/06/2026: "The Mist of the Lands Between", Board Game Concept: Links for the day
2026: The Year Slop Companies "Made an Exit" (Threw in the Towel Over to Wall Street): Remember 2026 as the year two major slop companies (which we won't name) sought an IPO
Links 09/06/2026: NSO Group still cracking, "FOI tribunal throws out £14k costs claim against journalist Barnie Choudhury": Links for the day
Links 09/06/2026: "Smartphones Broke Dating" and "EU Open Source Strategy": Links for the day
Cannot Speak About IBM Wrongdoing or Jobs Being Sent Overseas (Lower Salaries): IBM has long attacked the media, the whistleblowers, and even online forums
European Patent Office (EPO) Series: The CIA-Funded Centre-Left in Portugal: In the political turmoil which followed the fall of the old regime, the communists seemed to be acquiring a dominant position and there was a very real risk that Portugal could end up aligned with the Eastern Bloc if they were not stopped
This Coming Friday: Richard Stallman (RMS)
Yesterday Afternoon The Register MS Published a Fake Article That Says "AI" 31 Times Because It Got Paid to Do This: What will happen when all those loans for slop (Ponzi scheme) stop and companies' marketing budgets - which include media bribes for hype campaigns - are no more?
Extraordinary General Meeting of Staff Union of the European Patent Office Ahead of Intensifying Strikes: We will, in the meantime, run a series about EPO corruption, which is now connected to corruption in Portugal and to corruption inside the EU
Several Slopfarms That Target "Linux" Seem to Have Died: Or perished severely
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Monday, June 08, 2026: IRC logs for Monday, June 08, 2026
Gemini Links 09/06/2026: Tanana River, Cassette Beasts, and Emacs: Links for the day

Moonlight is Not Silverlight, Silverlight is Not Flash

Comments

Recent Techrights' Posts