Microsoft Wants Music DRM Renaissance

Dr. Roy Schestowitz

2009-01-25 01:28:45 UTC
Modified: 2009-01-25 01:28:45 UTC

Broken CD
Defective, by design, by Microsoft

"We've had DRM in Windows for years. The most common format of music on an iPod is "stolen"."

--Steve Ballmer, Microsoft CEO

QUITE A FEW ARTICLES about this have been circulating, so it's probably worth bringing up the core of the news:

Microsoft yesterday unveiled its MSN Mobile Music service - and a surprise return to digital rights management (DRM).

As expected, there is some strong critique already:

While this is just a relatively small service offered only in the UK, it's the perfect example of why Microsoft can't get it right when it comes to competing with Apple's iTunes Music Store. The key to success is offering a consistent user experience, with one single store. It doesn't make sense to have each national Microsoft branch to start its own music service, with independent pricing and restrictive DRM schemes. Microsoft is laying off 5000 people, and looking for other means to cut costs?

I say, quit this pointless music store before it's even open, and because of this saving, maybe a few more folk can keep their jobs. I'd say, get your priorities straight.

Microsoft seems somewhat out of touch because, as pointed out here, music DRM is on its way to the grave.

Last week's agreement between Apple and the major record companies to eliminate DRM (copy protection) in iTunes songs marks the effective end of DRM for recorded music. The major online music stores are now all DRM-free, and CDs still lack DRM, so consumers who acquire music will now expect it without DRM. That's a sensible result, given the incompatibility and other problems caused by DRM, and it's a good sign that the record companies are ready to retreat from DRM and get on with the job of reinventing themselves for the digital world.

In the movie world, DRM for stored content may also be in trouble. On DVDs, the CSS DRM scheme has long been a dead letter, technologically speaking. The Blu-ray scheme is better, but if Blu-ray doesn't catch on, this doesn't matter.

Why is Microsoft so desperate to have DRM? Platform lock-in is likely to be among the causes. But that's another story which we'll revisit in the future. Comes vs Microsoft exhibits, for example, show that Bill Gates intended to also use "security as a lock-in." ⬆

"We've been very focused on producing a DRM system. [...] We think DRM is important"

--Robbie Bach, Microsoft President

"DRM is the future."

--Steve Ballmer, Microsoft CEO

Comments

Renan

2009-01-25 02:21:52

As always, Microsoft brings a bad idea back from the deathbed.

Until all companies agree to completely GIVE UP on any and all forms of DRM, I will keep "stealing" music (since breaking DRM is a crime, in any case I would be an "intellectual property thief", whatever that means).
aeshna23

2009-01-25 03:27:32

It's not just MSN Mobile Music. It's also Windows 7. I've been using Windows 7 recently to understand the ways of the enemy. In fact, I'm using now. Even given my dislike for Microsoft, I was shocked to find out that the Rip Music settings under Windows Media Player include "Copy Protect Music"--an option that only inconveniences the customer. And the atrocious Windows Media Center pushes that option. I don't think I'm paranoid to believe that the only reason to introduce such a customer unfriendly feature is to make it mandatory.

What I think gets lost in conversations about Windows 7 is one key fact: even if Windows 7 were to be the perfect OS from the Microsoft perspective and all the hardwire drivers and eye candy worked perfectly, Windows 7 would still be bad deal for the customer.
The Mad Hatter

2009-01-25 03:31:01

Microsoft doesn't understand who their customer is, and that's a problem. The end user, who is their true customer, has no interest in DRM. Rather than DRM being a feature, it's a dis-incentive to use Windows.
Mike Brown

2009-01-25 04:56:13

The question and answer session in the PcPro article is proof positive - just in case anybody needed any more - that Microsoft's nose dive into the compost is all but assured. I mean, just read this!:

Q: If I buy these songs on your service - and they're locked to my phone - what happens when I upgrade my phone in six months' time?

A: Well, I think you know the answer to that.

Q: Can you really expect people to buy music that's locked to a device they upgrade every 12 to 18 months?

A: I didn't realise phones were churning that quickly in the marketplace these days

In short, not only does Microsoft's DRM tie the music that you've just paid for to your mobile phone. When you upgrade that phone - at the end of your contract, for example - you'll have to put your hand in your pocket *again* if you want to carry on listening to that music!

Just how stupid do they think people are?
Roy Schestowitz

2009-01-25 09:07:26

Microsoft doesn't understand who their customer is, and that's a problem.

They actually treat OEMs and Hollywood as their customers. Users just don't have much choice. These are not the customers.

About 80% of the Windows licences are sold to OEMs, not the users. They are being tied to PCs.
amd-linux

2009-01-25 09:53:35

"They actually treat OEMs and Hollywood as their customers. Users just don’t have much choice. These are not the customers."

And forcing the crap that results from this down their customers' throats will (or already has, in the case of Vista) in a boycott of consumers - sooner or later, everybody, incl. John Doe knows that the Windows flag sticker on a PC stands for something bad.

I love to see how they pull themselves apart in slow motion. How incredibly stupid can a CEO be? How incredible stupid can shareholders be that tolerate a CEO like Ballmer who so obviously lost touch to the real world like Comical Ali? ( http://www.welovetheiraqiinformationminister.com/ in case you forgot who he was).

Well, folks, please lean back, watch, relax and pass along the popcorn.
amd-linux

2009-01-25 09:58:32

And just to snafu Ballmer's sunday even more:

http://www.osor.eu/news/it-venice-region-settles-on-open-source-and-open-standards

" The Veneto Region, around the Italian city of Venice, has decided to move to open source software and open standards, the Italian Internet news site Zeus reports. "
Roy Schestowitz

2009-01-25 10:31:12

And just to snafu Ballmer’s sunday

I'm still preparing a post about mass-closure of services/products from Microsoft. The 'media' is asleep... and too bust doing 'damage control' for Microsoft.
David Gerard

2009-01-25 14:55:46

And after all my hard work!

I suspect they did a terrible deal with the record labels (who don't like the idea of being locked into Microsoft any more than they're enjoying being locked into Apple) and that's why the MSN UK guy knows he's selling a complete turd and is past the point of despair.

The only way they could have made it worse would have been to use the Zune branding.

ps: typing this from Shiretoko (Firefox 3.1 nightlies) in Windows 7. It runs surprisingly well in a 512MB VirtualBox ... if I have nothing else running on the host system. Uses power like nobody's business, though. And, of course, it's very pretty.
The Mad Hatter

2009-01-25 15:54:02

Yes, they did a deal with the labels, because Microsoft thinks that the labels are their customer. End users will vote with their wallets on this, and Microsoft will not like the results.
David Gerard

2009-01-25 16:05:10

I just tried playing a DivX AVI from a network share (a ripped DVD) in VLC, and got my first-ever Windows 7 blue screen! Yay!
Roy Schestowitz

2009-01-25 16:09:57

Just don't play MP3s. You might lose the files.

http://lifehacker.com/5131478/windows-7-beta-patch-fixes-mp3-bug
David Gerard

2009-01-25 16:25:25

At least they warn about the MP3 one very loudly in the release notes!
Roy Schestowitz

2009-01-25 16:28:59

Yes, they sure warn about MP3s. Watch the quote at the top.

Steve Ballmer warned the world that "The most common format of music on an iPod is “stolen”."

Was he talking about .WAV? ;-)

SLAPP Censorship - Part 103 Out of 200: Telling People What They Know and Don't Know About Death Threats They Receive: patronising letters sent on behalf of the Serial Strangler from Microsoft
Links 10/06/2026: More Microsoft Layoffs, Sweden to "Ban Mobile Phones in Schools": Links for the day
European Patent Office (EPO) Series: The Centre (in Portugal) Falls Apart…: Luís Montenegro became embroiled in a conflict-of-interest controversy
IBM Lost About 18% of Its "Market Value" This Month: In IBM's case, a lot of the latest "pump" was Arvind's "quantum" hype/fantasy
Gemini Links 10/06/2026: Signal to Noise, Cancer, and Permacomputing: Links for the day
Communities and "Prosumers.": today's meetup will be about community
Gemini and Gopher Links 10/06/2026: Roasting, Changes, and Harms of Slop: Links for the day
IBM Genies in the Bottle: for ordinary people working who at at IBM, it's not hard to see that IBM is floundering
Microsoft Azure Shrinking With More Mass Layoffs: "Reports suggest the layoffs will impact close to 200 out of 400 workers, who are set to cease employment at Azure on July 6"
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, June 09, 2026: IRC logs for Tuesday, June 09, 2026
European Patent Office (EPO) Series: The Centre-Right "Social Democratic Party" in Portugal: Quite an achievement for a former Maoist radical and aspiring champion of the Portuguese proletariat to be invited to join Goldman Sachs
SLAPP Censorship - Part 102 Out of 200: Maybe One Day Whistleblowers From Brett Wilson LLP Will Tell Us What Really Happened: Maybe one day some former staff of Brett Wilson LLP will also approach us to blow the whistle
What LibreOffice and TDF Get Right About Document Formats (and What They Get Wrong): OOXML is a phantom - it is something nobody implements, not even Microsoft!
Gemini Links 09/06/2026: "The Mist of the Lands Between", Board Game Concept: Links for the day
2026: The Year Slop Companies "Made an Exit" (Threw in the Towel Over to Wall Street): Remember 2026 as the year two major slop companies (which we won't name) sought an IPO
Links 09/06/2026: NSO Group still cracking, "FOI tribunal throws out £14k costs claim against journalist Barnie Choudhury": Links for the day
Links 09/06/2026: "Smartphones Broke Dating" and "EU Open Source Strategy": Links for the day
Cannot Speak About IBM Wrongdoing or Jobs Being Sent Overseas (Lower Salaries): IBM has long attacked the media, the whistleblowers, and even online forums
European Patent Office (EPO) Series: The CIA-Funded Centre-Left in Portugal: In the political turmoil which followed the fall of the old regime, the communists seemed to be acquiring a dominant position and there was a very real risk that Portugal could end up aligned with the Eastern Bloc if they were not stopped
This Coming Friday: Richard Stallman (RMS)
Yesterday Afternoon The Register MS Published a Fake Article That Says "AI" 31 Times Because It Got Paid to Do This: What will happen when all those loans for slop (Ponzi scheme) stop and companies' marketing budgets - which include media bribes for hype campaigns - are no more?
Extraordinary General Meeting of Staff Union of the European Patent Office Ahead of Intensifying Strikes: We will, in the meantime, run a series about EPO corruption, which is now connected to corruption in Portugal and to corruption inside the EU
Several Slopfarms That Target "Linux" Seem to Have Died: Or perished severely
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Monday, June 08, 2026: IRC logs for Monday, June 08, 2026
Gemini Links 09/06/2026: Tanana River, Cassette Beasts, and Emacs: Links for the day

Microsoft Wants Music DRM Renaissance

Comments

Recent Techrights' Posts